Soaps Role Madness 2! Day 2

[kongming3]

Neither did I.

[Votanic]

Ugh...
So scum killed Fusi the Cop! because, ...why?
Fusi hardly posted Day 1, and nothing substantial...

I guess he was chosen either randomly or because he has a semi-deserved 'good player' rep...
...or else Scum had some kinda Day 1 intel PR.

[Charle]

i learned nothing

LOL!! Me too

[Charle]

Somebody probably should have some info, we cannot just have D2 be an extension of D1. I do not understand Fusi kill, as Vot also said, he hardly participated here.

[Ragian]

There could be several reasons for a Fusi kill. It probably falls under the blind luck going for someone who wasn't likely to be protected (I guess in role madness games, there are protective roles). Or scum could've gone for someone else and we have a rogue vig that shot the town cop. All of this, however, is conjecture.

@Max, what did you do last night with your oracle powers?

[Loose Canon]

I know one player who on the basis of my night action was less likely/unlikely to have carried out the kill on Fusi.
Thats all I'm saying for now though.

[Ragian]

And if your night action involves someone who seemingly has nothing to do with the death of Fusi, you should keep it to yourself lest you out an important role.

[Loose Canon]

I'm not sure on that rag, could be useful for town to know who, then when I die the strength or not of the evidence gets revealed.

So I was thinking of revealing late today?

Up for debate + whether I should have said what I have so far or not?
- still very much learning.

[Extreme Ways]

I'm not sure on that rag, could be useful for town to know who, then when I die the strength or not of the evidence gets revealed.

So I was thinking of revealing late today?

Up for debate + whether I should have said what I have so far or not?
- still very much learning.

you can reveal without actually revealing, by it influencing your reads.

It's good to be able to exclude someone from carrying out the kill, but we're likely looking at 2 scum and maybe a 3p (though only 1 kill), so it isn't a hard clear. And a hard clear generally just means they get killed overnight.

Fwiw I think you shouldnt have said that in general because it outs you as an investigative role which is usually slightly higher on the priority list of killing.

[Extreme Ways]

Also Loose feels genuine and if I'm wrong on that, consider me completely fooled by Loose this game.

[Ragian]

What is the upside?

Let's say you reveal that X visited Y. Scum will learn two important things from that: 1) X thinks that Y has acted weirdly enough to be checked (one way or another), or X thinks that Y has acted town (or is in general deemed a strong player) enough to deserve protection. 2) X has an outgoing action that can be tampered with or similar.

Moreover, both X and/or Y can be scum doing something not related to killing. You revealing your info will give any scum in that mix town cred.

I'm against you revealing it...

FP'ed by EW. Will read now.