Greatest bands of all-time

[DAZMCFC]

Greatest, not best, so don't say "x is better than y". Which band's music you like more shouldn't affect your choices.

Here's what I'm thinking about putting on the poll:

Beatles
Queen
Led Zeppelin
Pink Floyd
Hendrix
Rolling Stones
The Who
AC/DC
Van Halen
U2 (please don't let them win)
Metallica
Other




Should I replace any on the list?

get rid of Queen, Van Halen, U2 and Metallica.

replace with The Doors, The Smiths, Nirvanna and The Pixies.

[jonesthecurl]

Even queen are better than The Smiths.
Feck, Justin Diaper is better than The Smiths.

[Quirk]

You should specify "greatest rock band" or add bands from other genres.

I would add Black Sabbath and Rush to the list even though Zeppelin is the greatest.

[Quirk]

Even queen are better than The Smiths.
Feck, Justin Diaper is bette than The Smiths.

Settle down, Jonesy.

[jonesthecurl]

I saw The Smiths live.
I stand by my comments.
No, Morrissey, I'm not ignoring you! please don't get any closer!

[Aradhus]

Even queen are better than The Smiths.
Feck, Justin Diaper is better than The Smiths.

aww, why did you ruin it. Why did you make the post that broke the jones is always right, always funny, is always always, rule.

For Jonesy, from Morrissey

[jonesthecurl]

luckily, I still don't have sound on my computer.

[Victor Sullivan]

MUTATO MUZIKA

[Pedronicus]

UH, The Doors..

Maybe. But personally I think the bands on the list edge them out. Depends on how much more support you get.

your list includes
AC/DC
Van Halen
&
Metallica

and this threesome of heavy metal and shite rock edge out the doors? your musical taste is as shit as it gets.
you want the doors and radiohead on the list and dump
AC/DC
Van Halen
Metallica

[muy_thaiguy]

UH, The Doors..

Maybe. But personally I think the bands on the list edge them out. Depends on how much more support you get.

your list includes
AC/DC
Van Halen
&
Metallica

and this threesome of heavy metal and shite rock edge out the doors? your musical taste is as shit as it gets.
you want the doors and radiohead on the list and dump
AC/DC
Van Halen
Metallica

Pedro has deeply saddened the Gods of Rock with this post.