Blackpool Manor Dinner: D4! FRUITS WITH CHAMPAGNE

FOS: Dedicated those who can't get enough Mafia action. Ongoing Games located here!

Moderator: Community Team

Forum rules
Please read the Community Guidelines before posting.
User avatar
SoN!c
Posts: 1124
Joined: Tue May 11, 2021 10:23 am

Re: Blackpool Manor Dinner: D4! FRUITS WITH CHAMPAGNE

Post by SoN!c »

It's a knife's edge cliffhanger!! Who is speaking the truth - who is not?? And with 4 town vs 2 circle all 4 town votes need to land on the right target anyways or game over for House! No room for any f*ck up! :?
User avatar
Zulu Warrior
Posts: 19
Joined: Fri Feb 03, 2023 1:17 pm
Gender: Male
Location: United Kingdom

Re: Blackpool Manor Dinner: D4! FRUITS WITH CHAMPAGNE

Post by Zulu Warrior »

Brilliant, Annieh, great result. We all now know that Ragian is circle.

Since you mentioned revisiting Bunnie's suspicions about me, and now seeing hjelp wondering about me too, and with the Doctor already gone and only 6 of us left, I might as well put my cards on the table (not my poker ones; they are terrible lol) :-). So House doesn't waste any time doubting me: I am the HOUSE TRACKER. I kept this to myself until I should reveal it without being murdered if I did reveal.

Last night, I tracked HottBunnie, as I was very suspicious of her, and she visited Annieh. This explains why Annieh survived last night. Bunnie must have used her Doctor medicine bag to save Annieh right before HottBunnie was murdered!!! :-(. (Earlier in the game, I also tracked Ragian on a night he stayed home.)

That means we have Annieh (Archivist), Charle (Heir), and me (Tracker) all confirmed House, and Ragian caught red-handed as Circle. Once we vote out Ragian today, that narrows the very last Circle member down to just hjelp or Katyssis, and I can track one of them tonight :-).

As Charle said, I'm happy to hear what Ragian has to say before we rush the final hammer, so I'm putting my vote down now while leaving room for everyone else to weigh in :-)

VOTE RAGIAN
User avatar
SoN!c
Posts: 1124
Joined: Tue May 11, 2021 10:23 am

Re: Blackpool Manor Dinner: D4! FRUITS WITH CHAMPAGNE

Post by SoN!c »

official vote count

Ragian: 2 by Annieh and Zulu


D4 - FRUITS WITH CHAMPAGNE ends MONDAY six o'clock ENGLAND DINNER TIME! (unless extra time is requested by majority of the dinner guests)

(That's 19.00 Denmark time)

With 6 alive it takes 4 to LYNCH!!

Ragian is already at L-2!
User avatar
annieh
Posts: 4
Joined: Mon Jul 28, 2014 12:36 pm
Gender: Female

Re: Blackpool Manor Dinner: D4! FRUITS WITH CHAMPAGNE

Post by annieh »

Zulu, are you saying your card said you are the house "tracker" on it?

Other option would be is it had a title with more murder mystery dinner flavor like Usher or Heir or Archivist.
User avatar
Zulu Warrior
Posts: 19
Joined: Fri Feb 03, 2023 1:17 pm
Gender: Male
Location: United Kingdom

Re: Blackpool Manor Dinner: D4! FRUITS WITH CHAMPAGNE

Post by Zulu Warrior »

Hi Annieh, thanks for adding to my confusion with this game :-). I found a card in my pocket that said, "You are the house tracker". It lets me follow one player each night to see who they visit. If you haven't seen this title before, perhaps it's a new one, or Sonic realises just how stupid I am and is making things simple for me?
User avatar
Ragian
Posts: 123
Joined: Wed Apr 15, 2009 7:39 am

Re: Blackpool Manor Dinner: D4! FRUITS WITH CHAMPAGNE

Post by Ragian »

Well, this is all need and dandy. Let's unravel it before we're throwing the game. I'm sorry to have to acknowledge Loose here, but the Annie-Zulu tandem is pulling another fast one. I for one thought that it was unnecessarily convoluted for Annie as Circle to throw Devante under the bus, but here we are. There are a fair few things that do not add up.

1) The very carefully laid out reason with research and what not to choose to investigate Devante versus the laissez-faire choice of Homer because he would be "too distracting". How convenient that you investigated a dead guy. And that you had no intention of saying so D3 because you knew that it would add ammunition to Loose saying that you're full of it. Here's what happened. You had to write in homer because you didn't want any of the remaining players to have an air of innocence about them. Especially now that Charle had already been lynched and proven town. If you had said that Katy, hjelp, or myself was town, it would be an uphill battle.

2) How on earth did you not investigate Loose N2? Everyone was doubting Loose due to the D1 and especially D2 shenanigans. It makes absolutely ZERO sense for you - as a town cop (or House Archivist if you will) - NOT to do away with the inevitable pitchforks that were being sharpened in honour of Loose. You chose Homer over Loose because Homer would be too confusing? No way, you needed Loose to die without too much fuzz and without having to commit yourself to an investigation. Charle was already, understandably, out for Loose's blood after D1, and after D2 several others, myself included, were questioning him. An investigation of Loose could've dismantled all of this.

3) The open guiding of Zulu. Don't you guys have day chat since you felt the need to direct Zulu in the game thread? I do appreciate you sticking to the rules and not discussing the game outside of the thread. That's sportswomanship of the finest quality. I'll give you that. And it's nice to see that Zulu has become your trusted warrior by steaming in only a few posts after Charle advises caution to put me at L-2. It's not difficult to see who's in cahoots. You have shown your hand and I fear it is premature.

4) Saying that I as scum prefer the kill that goes through is absolutely true. So let's have a looksee at the ones murdered: Homer and Hottbunnie. I mean...Homer is one of the best and most experienced players here. Why on earth do you think that constitutes a safe kill? If Circle, I would've gone for Katy, Zulu, or, perhaps, Charle. Never Homer. If a town power role doesn't know what to do, they usually end up targeting good players.

5) Town tracker...eh? No fancy name for that? Oh well, I guess that's possible. However, you entire post, Zulu, reeks. First, there's the whistling and the "don't-look-here" ambiance, and then the one result. You tracked the dead doctor to the one claiming that I'm Circle. Well, well, well...could it be more convenient? Why did you track HottBunnie? What was your reasoning? Whom did you track the other nights?

See, what I think has happened is as follows: Devante hit up Annie as the Secretary. Good choice. I even mentioned early doors that I would've probably chosen her. N1, they recruited Zulu who happened to be the Archivist and thus he lost that power. I never thought they would actively kill off Devante, but I guess all of his farming tendencies got him too occupado for the game and it's better to sacrifice someone in order to coast for the rest of the game than it is to do nothing and wait for the storm to appear. And, may I say so, if you pull this off and win by sacrificing your Patron, I will be the first one to applaud you <3

A final thing that I want done, but I have to go to work now, is that I want to look at the VCs. I feel that my voting is more beneficial to town than Annie's. And I think Zulu's voting has just followed Annie's like a good, little warrior.
Image
User avatar
Ragian
Posts: 123
Joined: Wed Apr 15, 2009 7:39 am

Re: Blackpool Manor Dinner: D4! FRUITS WITH CHAMPAGNE

Post by Ragian »

LOL. Annie's even directing Zulu in the posts above mine? I hadn't even seen :lol:
Image
User avatar
Ragian
Posts: 123
Joined: Wed Apr 15, 2009 7:39 am

Re: Blackpool Manor Dinner: D4! FRUITS WITH CHAMPAGNE

Post by Ragian »

I'll vote Annie to place my vote for fear that I might get lynched before getting back. Yes, it's endgame, but I want the record to show that I was right with my voting (almost) throughout the game. Sorry, Charle.

*pours whisky on ground for Loose*

You were right, big boy. MVDP (most important dead player).
Image
User avatar
Charle
SoC Training Instructor
SoC Training Instructor
Posts: 1825
Joined: Fri Mar 05, 2010 9:11 am
Gender: Male
Location: South Africa

Re: Blackpool Manor Dinner: D4! FRUITS WITH CHAMPAGNE

Post by Charle »

This dinner is starting to become interesting!

Ragian, I must admit you have raised some interesting points, and I appreciate you taking the time to explain your position. I am not going to dismiss your defence simply because Annie has accused you.

We made that mistake with Loose, and we should try to not make it again.

But I also have some questions for Zulu.

@Zulu, you have now claimed to be the House Tracker, which is quite an important revelation at this stage.
Could you please tell us exactly whom you tracked on each night, and what results you received? You mentioned Ragian staying home and Bunny visiting Annie, but I would like to understand the complete sequence of each night starting with N1.

You also concluded that Bunny saved Annie. How do you know Annie was actually targeted for a kill? Surely seeing Bunny visit Annie does not necessarily prove that?

And another interesting question Annie raised: was your role actually called "House Tracker" on your card? The other roles seem to have names associated with the dinner theme.

@Annie, I still find your investigation of Ragian compelling, but I think we need to consider all the information before deciding. We still have time.

@Ragian, your theory that Annie and Zulu are working together is interesting, but it would mean that Circle deliberately sacrificed Devante, their Patron. That seems an enormous risk to take so early in the game. What evidence do you have beyond your suspicions? We could say that they planned this to try and make Annie confirmed House and then she would take Zulu in.

And finally, @Hjelp and @Katy, I would really like to hear your thoughts on these latest developments and please do not rush in a lynch before we discussed this.

We have six players left, two of whom are Circle. Sonic has made it very clear that we cannot afford another mistake.

I am keeping my vote in my pocket until we have heard the answers.

Let's make sure we get this one right.
User avatar
SoN!c
Posts: 1124
Joined: Tue May 11, 2021 10:23 am

Re: Blackpool Manor Dinner: D4! FRUITS WITH CHAMPAGNE

Post by SoN!c »

official vote count

Ragian: 2 by Annieh and Zulu
Annieh: 1 by Ragian


D4 - FRUITS WITH CHAMPAGNE ends MONDAY six o'clock ENGLAND DINNER TIME! (unless extra time is requested by majority of the dinner guests)

(That's 19.00 Denmark time)

With 6 alive it takes 4 to LYNCH!!

PS: A MISLYNCH TODAY = CIRCLE WINS!
User avatar
Ragian
Posts: 123
Joined: Wed Apr 15, 2009 7:39 am

Re: Blackpool Manor Dinner: D4! FRUITS WITH CHAMPAGNE

Post by Ragian »

Damn, I'm at L-2. Better claim: I'm House Applicant. Quick lunch break comment.

@Charle, the thing about it is that I have no evidence. I am not in a position to put forward evidence other than that which is in the thread for everyone to read. The thing about mafia games is that at some point you have to rely on what people have done and contrast it to what people have said. That's what I think I'm capable of. To be honest, I was quite vocal in the beginning saying that a) I didn't think it necessary for Circle to sacrifice anyone that early, and b) while I think she's defo capable, I wouldn't have thought that Annie was comfortable doing that. Then she pointed her lying fingers at me and here we are. D2 when she pointed her finger at Devante, it seemed implausible that that was a hoax. D4 with all the points that I've raised in my post above, it now seems very likely (I know it to be true because I know that I'm town, but I have no solid evidence to fight for me) that Annie did indeed pull that move. And Zulu for that matter. I can only speculate on the reasons, but perhaps it was preemptive given Devante's play D1 and the fact that he was away a lot. He didn't even fight the accusations.

All I ask you to do, Charle, is look at what Annie has said and done throughout the game (especially not investigating Loose) and contrast it with her voting pattern. Afterwards, do the same with me. Compare the two.

I'm back tonight.
Image
User avatar
Zulu Warrior
Posts: 19
Joined: Fri Feb 03, 2023 1:17 pm
Gender: Male
Location: United Kingdom

Re: Blackpool Manor Dinner: D4! FRUITS WITH CHAMPAGNE

Post by Zulu Warrior »

Great post, Charle, and I'll try to satisfy your curiosity in my role. To be honest, and especially since you asked for my full tracking log, I am a novice, and this is my first-ever game; I didn't really grasp the significance of my House Tracker role at the start. I was so confused trying to understand the game that I nearly dropped out early on, and I didn't properly use or keep track of my power on the first couple of nights.

What I do remember is tracking HottBunnie early on when she stayed home, which makes sense since her Doctor role has been revealed. I also tracked Ragian on a night when he stayed home. Once I finally got the hang of things, I tracked HottBunnie again last night, because she had put a vote on me earlier and I found her sudden switch to Loose Canon suspicious. I saw her visit to Annieh.

Since I had no idea Bunnie was the Doctor until her card was revealed this morning, I just guessed she must have used her protection on Annieh when I saw she visited her last night, and Charle is right that Circle could have just targeted Bunnie directly.

As I answered Annieh just above Ragian's post, the card in my pocket just informed me that I was House Tracker, probably because SoN!c wanted to keep things simple for me in my first game?

Remember Annieh's evidence: "DEV + RAGS 4EVA" carved into the wall!

Also, my post, including Annieh (Archivist), Charle (Heir), and me (Tracker) all confirmed House, and Ragian caught red-handed as Circle. Once we vote out Ragian today, that narrows the very last Circle member down to just hjelp or Katyssis, and I can track one of them tonight :-).

As for Ragian's theory that Annieh and I are Circle who sacrificed our own Patron on Day 2 just to fake an Archivist claim... nobody would throw away their only recruiter on Day 2 like that? This is Ragian on the defensive, and he has panic posted above?

My vote stays right where it is on Ragian.
User avatar
Charle
SoC Training Instructor
SoC Training Instructor
Posts: 1825
Joined: Fri Mar 05, 2010 9:11 am
Gender: Male
Location: South Africa

Re: Blackpool Manor Dinner: D4! FRUITS WITH CHAMPAGNE

Post by Charle »

Please guys, NO MORE VOTES for now!

Sonic has made it absolutely clear that a mislynch today means Circle wins. We have one chance to get this right, and I don't want us to repeat what happened with Loose.

At the moment, it appears to come down to Annie versus Ragian. One of them is lying, and I must say, whoever it is has played a damn good game!

But Zulu, your latest post has raised a few more questions for me.

You claim to be the House Tracker, yet you cannot remember exactly whom you tracked on which nights. Surely you had to submit your targets to Sonic? Wouldn't you be able to check your messages and give us the actual sequence?

You mentioned tracking Bunny early in the game and finding that she stayed home. Why did you choose Bunny in the first place? And which night was that?

You also tracked Ragian and found that he stayed home. Again, which night was that, and why did you choose him?

Then you tracked Bunny again on the night she was murdered and apparently saw her visit Annie.

I understand that Bunny could potentially have performed her night action before being killed, depending on the order in which Sonic resolves actions. But that brings me to another question.

If Bunny visited Annie, how does that establish that Annie was attacked or saved? It doesn't, does it?

And something else concerns me. You keep referring to yourself and Annie as confirmed House. But surely neither of you is confirmed simply because you have claimed a power role?

Please don't misunderstand me, Zulu. I am not accusing you of being Circle at this stage. I am simply trying to establish whether your claims stand up to scrutiny.

Annie, I still find your investigation of Ragian compelling, but Ragian has raised some valid questions that we cannot ignore.

Ragian, I would also like to see the voting analysis you promised. I have been looking at the voting patterns myself, and there are some interesting things there.

Hjelp and Katy, please weigh in as well.

We have time to discuss this properly, and we absolutely cannot afford to get it wrong.

My vote stays in my pocket until I am satisfied we have identified the right person.
User avatar
hjelp
Posts: 339
Joined: Thu Oct 06, 2011 2:50 pm

Re: Blackpool Manor Dinner: D4! FRUITS WITH CHAMPAGNE

Post by hjelp »

Since I use quotes to rely on what is posted and use them to draw conclusions of wht info can tell me - I have gathered Zulu'z claim Tracker
Zulu Warrior wrote: Tue Nov 17, 2026 12:35 pm ...
So House doesn't waste any time doubting me: I am the HOUSE TRACKER. I kept this to myself until I should reveal it without being murdered if I did reveal.
Last night, I tracked HottBunnie, as I was very suspicious of her, and she visited Annieh. This explains why Annieh survived last night. Bunnie must have used her Doctor medicine bag to save Annieh right before HottBunnie was murdered!!! :-(. (Earlier in the game, I also tracked Ragian on a night he stayed home.)

That means we have Annieh (Archivist), Charle (Heir), and me (Tracker) all confirmed House, and Ragian caught red-handed as Circle. Once we vote out Ragian today, that narrows the very last Circle member down to just hjelp or Katyssis, and I can track one of them tonight :-).
...

VOTE RAGIAN
Zulu Warrior wrote: Tue Nov 17, 2026 9:03 pm Hi Annieh, thanks for adding to my confusion with this game :-). I found a card in my pocket that said, "You are the house tracker". It lets me follow one player each night to see who they visit. If you haven't seen this title before, perhaps it's a new one, or Sonic realises just how stupid I am and is making things simple for me?
Zulu Warrior wrote: Wed Nov 18, 2026 6:09 am ---
What I do remember is tracking HottBunnie early on when she stayed home, which makes sense since her Doctor role has been revealed. I also tracked Ragian on a night when he stayed home. Once I finally got the hang of things, I tracked HottBunnie again last night, because she had put a vote on me earlier and I found her sudden switch to Loose Canon suspicious. I saw her visit to Annieh.

Since I had no idea Bunnie was the Doctor until her card was revealed this morning, I just guessed she must have used her protection on annieh when I saw she visited her last night, and Charle is right that Circle could have just targeted Bunnie directly.
..
N1 Zulu tracked HottBunnie stayed home and no kill- N2 homer killed and tracked Ragian stayed home - N3 docktor killled and tracked HottBunnie to annieh.
My concern is the Doctor was killed - then the report would have been - no result ? since killed at home before the move to annieh - or if the kill was perforem at the spot annieh, the result would have been annieh. Further, Zulu said "This explains why Annieh survived last night. Bunnie must have used her Doctor medicine bag to save Annieh right before HottBunnie was murdered!!!" and "and Ragian caught red-handed as Circle" -
How can annieh be saved by the Doctor medicine bag and HottBuniie also got murdered ? - The Circle has one kill each night as we know of so far - They can't target annieh and HottBunnie both.

-- Zulul, how do you now that annieh was saved N3 and that also Hottbunnie was killed at the spot Annieh - if so it means that the Circle has target two kills, which they don't - according to SoN!c. - or is it that you target annieh and waited for a visitor and killed the visitor (if House) which then is HottBunnie? It make sense if you target annieh N2 and N3 and waiting for a visitor House to kill. It's possibel since N2 Ragian home and N3 HottBunnie at annieh. - we know that a dealt card is lost if recruited but we don't know if there will be setup powers after recruitment to the Circle, as far as I understand. It is a bit far-fetched but it's an explanation of your posts and claim.
-- Zulu, how do you know that Ragian was caught red handed?

I will be back later regarding what Ragion posted. I have to deal with the snow outside now.
User avatar
hjelp
Posts: 339
Joined: Thu Oct 06, 2011 2:50 pm

Re: Blackpool Manor Dinner: D4! FRUITS WITH CHAMPAGNE

Post by hjelp »

I meant that it contradicts Ragian home N2 but it's safe for you to say so--
I'm not saying that this will clear Ragian house.
User avatar
annieh
Posts: 4
Joined: Mon Jul 28, 2014 12:36 pm
Gender: Female

Re: Blackpool Manor Dinner: D4! FRUITS WITH CHAMPAGNE

Post by annieh »

My logic is easily understood and consistent.
First, I don't pick anyone too talkative because they generated their own clues. This game that's basically Bunnie, Loose, maybe hjelp. If you have a problem with that take it up with mafia wiki.

Answering the big question of the upcoming day was the big idea. The big questions:
Day 1 Are Bunnie's suspicions on Dev a waste of time?
Day 2 (given that loose went crazy on Devante's behalf) Was homer off the vote because he is circle or can homer be my voice of reason?
Day 3 Is ragian contributing less than he is able to because he is busy? Did he devise the homer hit? Can ragian be my trusted voice of reason?

The only "Guiding of Zulu" was when I asked for more details on the dance, which I never got. My HEY ZULU post included no extra details and I think is appropriate when he can forget this game is going on. The stakes were that we wanted unanimous house. Don't pretend that it was leading in any direction or out of line considering how the posts pile up. I had big news and I used big font. Next game, big font for mods only, fine!

On homer as a safe or not safe target. Killing the patsy is not a novice play. I'll have to find the quote but I recall you already telling Bunnie that it's the exact sort of thing you'd do, only that you hadn't. Which was a bad argument before you changed it alltogether.

I do agree that Zulu's most recent post has major issues. I don't think sonic gave a card that says tracker. It would be Coat Check Guy or something. The tracking choices are weird and not fully accounted for

And rags, go ahead and look at the vote counts. Tell me how much you find when we know every circle member got in on the Devante vote.

How about you search your posting record and come back with a contribution that gives us more than, "oh wow anybody else think this (bad) theory is interesting?" Or, "ew, clues? No thank you."

I caught you because every time I looked for cleverness, I found simplistic and dismissive arguments.
User avatar
annieh
Posts: 4
Joined: Mon Jul 28, 2014 12:36 pm
Gender: Female

Re: Blackpool Manor Dinner: D3 - LAFITE GRAND CRU WITH A FINE ROAST BIRD!

Post by annieh »

Ragian wrote: Fri Nov 13, 2026 2:28 am
Charle wrote: Thu Nov 12, 2026 3:50 am I also have 3 questions:

@Loose: Why should we believe Annieh deliberately sacrificed the original Patron rather than accept the simpler explanation that she is a genuine Archivist? Do you maybe have any evidence beyond the wording of her posts. She rightfully identified Devante, so do you think they would plan that for us to believe she is town?

@Katy: Why did you vote Annieh, and why did you withdraw that vote just after?

@Annie: Did you investigate anyone on Night 2, and do you have a result you can safely share?

FP'd by Sonic and that is the reason I can vote today.
Charle's best input so far. Good to have you back, Charle <3 I feel that the overwhelming amount of evidence against Loose is just too much. The Charle blunder (and yes, I mainly hold you accountable for that. I wanted hjelp D1); The going against an uncountered cop result that gave us the Patron both before and after. The thinking that "she paraphrased something weirdly" is better evidence than a guilty verdict that delivers the Patron. THE PATRON. And now Loose wants hjelp to claim...I mean...

@Annie, we should definitely look for Circle, and we should use the entirety of today, but to be honest, I feel iffy trying to pinpoint anyone. I mean, even hjelp has distanced himself from Loose. He would've been my number one guess. I don't think it's HB. It's not Charle, you, or me (I just have no evidence other than my play to prove this), and it could be Katy or Zulu. I just have absolutely no evidence on them.
annieh wrote: Thu Nov 12, 2026 7:49 am
Ragian wrote: Wed Nov 11, 2026 9:48 am Unimportant point: Why is everyone discounting Charle? Wasn't his vote just gone D2?
On Ragian's unimportant note- who told Ragian Charle would get his vote back? If it was written somewhere, I missed it.
Experience with loss of vote from other games. Unless he's a tree stump, which he hasn't claimed.

---

Uhh, new developments as I read on. Annie seems to be on the fence by looking for mod clues. Here we go again...

Decent post from Zulu.

Aww, and suss from Bunnie calling me clever. That's nice. I'll take that any day of the week. She's right about the kill, though. When reading the scene, I though, "Yeah, that's probably whom I'd have chosen, too." She's also incriminating herself in that, though, given that she can offer up the thoughts.

---

Alright, Annie, I'm here. Went to see Kneecap yesterday. Good concert. I'm kinda hung over, but mainly from lack of sleep. Getting old sucks. And as I stated before, I don't really read the multitude of mod posts. I think there's enough fluff in the game as it is.
Long quote to get to the bold. And I'm not formatting for double quotes, point 4 of Ragian's first rebuttal to my accusation today says he'd choose anyone but homer.

As they say, lynch all liars.
User avatar
Zulu Warrior
Posts: 19
Joined: Fri Feb 03, 2023 1:17 pm
Gender: Male
Location: United Kingdom

Re: Blackpool Manor Dinner: D4! FRUITS WITH CHAMPAGNE

Post by Zulu Warrior »

Yes, fair points from both of you. Let me try to clear up my clumsy beginner's phrasing so I don't confuse anyone further. (Especially myself!!) :-).

1. I have been checking all my PMs to SoN!c and why I picked those targets. To be completely honest, I accidentally deleted some of my earlier PMs while getting used to the forum, which is why I couldn't double-check the exact timestamps earlier. From what I still have in my sent box, I can tell you this;

Night 1: I picked HB completely at random just to test out how my Tracker power worked, and she stayed home. I really didn't know what that meant.

Night 2: I tracked Ragian, again just picking someone that I wasn't sure about to see what happened. He stayed home, which totally confused me at the time, and I did wonder if I was doing something wrong or not. However, after much thought and reading streams of posts, I think it still fits fine if the other Circle member carried out the kill on Homer that night?

Last Night (Night 3): I was a bit more confident that I wasn't doing too much wrong other than tracking a player who stayed at home. I tracked HottBunnie again because she had voted for me on Day 3, and I was convinced she was Circle. I found her sudden switch to Loose Canon suspicious, and I saw her visit Annieh. This convinced me that HB was Circle, until the shocking announcement that HB had been murdered and not Annieh. I was totally confused then :-(.

2. I then thought long and hard about how and why HB visited Annieh on the night she died. Remember what Sonic explained yesterday: "the Doctor had to name their protection target before night fell". I assume that HB had already PM'd SoN!c and locked in her visit to Annieh before night started, and Circle must have targeted HB directly with their one kill. I hope that makes sense? When I said 'saved Annieh' earlier, I was literally just guessing before I thought it through. Charle is completely right that seeing a visit doesn't prove Annieh was attacked. Another beginner's mistake!

3. When I said Ragian was caught red-handed, that was because of Annieh's Archivist result on Ragian, combined with Annieh catching Devante on Day 2 and Sonic's write-up about Charle's Heir role. Obviously, I only know for 100% certain that I am House, so I shouldn't have used the word 'confirmed' so loosely. Again, a beginner's mistake, and sorry for the confusion.

I am more than happy to hold off on any more votes while Ragian posts his voting analysis and Katyssis weighs in. I definitely don't want us rushing another mislynch, either. Please let me know if you have any other questions you would like me to answer to clarify what I have stated. I really was convinced HB was Circle, so it just goes to show how cunning the Circle players are. I am totally convinced Ragin is, obviously, because I have cast my vote, but everything points to him, and he has no substance to his house claim.
User avatar
hjelp
Posts: 339
Joined: Thu Oct 06, 2011 2:50 pm

Re: Blackpool Manor Dinner: D4! FRUITS WITH CHAMPAGNE

Post by hjelp »

Zulu Warrior wrote: Wed Nov 18, 2026 10:04 am ...
I tracked HottBunnie again because she had voted for me on Day 3, and I was convinced she was Circle. I found her sudden switch to Loose Canon suspicious, and I saw her visit Annieh. This convinced me that HB was Circle, until the shocking announcement that HB had been murdered and not Annieh. I was totally confused then :-(.
...
So
you saw Hottbunnie visited Annie and you were convinced that HottBunnie was Circle - prior the announcement ?
and you found it supicios that HottBunnie changed vote to Loose Canon - but you also voted on Loose Canon.
Why dindn't that made HottBunnie less suspicious in your thinking?
User avatar
hjelp
Posts: 339
Joined: Thu Oct 06, 2011 2:50 pm

Re: Blackpool Manor Dinner: D4! FRUITS WITH CHAMPAGNE

Post by hjelp »

now I will read what Ragian posted and wait for input from Katyssis
User avatar
hjelp
Posts: 339
Joined: Thu Oct 06, 2011 2:50 pm

Re: Blackpool Manor Dinner: D4! FRUITS WITH CHAMPAGNE

Post by hjelp »

btw-Zulu - the only way you can conclude that you saw Hottbunnie visited Annie and you were convinced that HottBunnie was Circle - prior the announcement --- is if - you tracked HottBunnie to annieh N2 - I think
User avatar
SoN!c
Posts: 1124
Joined: Tue May 11, 2021 10:23 am

Re: Blackpool Manor Dinner: D4! FRUITS WITH CHAMPAGNE

Post by SoN!c »

Charles imagined Loose Canon’s ghost appeared in the empty chair where he sat before, still clutching the half-eaten blackpool sausage, face purple with residual hangry rage.

Charles’s imagination had excellent production values.

In his mind Loose his spectral performance was peak post-lynch form: half a goose, full volume, zero chill.

Then Loose canon's ghost (in Charle's day dream) opened his mouth, pointed at absolutely nothing in the middle of the room, and screamed at full volume for a solid eight seconds:

“AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA—”

“There. That clears the chest. AND I TOLD YOU IT WAS NOT THE CHAIR!.”

"NOW REMEMBER A MISLYNCH TODAY AND WE LOOSE.. A MISLYNCH TOMORROW AND WE LOOSE! IT'S 2 CIRCLE VS 4 TOWN. TOMORROW, IF WE HAVE ONE CIRCLE CATCH TODAY IT'S STILL 1 CIRCLE VS 3 TOWN. TRY TO FIGURE IT OUT TODAY!"

He vanished in a puff of black-pudding smoke yelling "a fine goose makes a fine roast bird mylooooo*!"....all with peak residual etiquette: clear the spectral chest, correct the record on the chair, deliver the MYLO math with perfect volume! Because the numbers hold: 2 Circle / 4 Town is the classic trap—one wrong lynch today and the night kill (by the wolves) equalizes! ^


*MYLO (Mislynch and Lose) is a core endgame state in Mafia werewolves social deduction games.

Charle"s awakened from his day-dinner dream and realised: "WE ARE IN MYLO ENDGAME!"

Charle took a careful sip of champagne, stared at the empty chair where Loose sat before, and muttered, “Noted. Do not lynch the chair. Do not lynch the nothing. Make sure you lynch. And for the love of the fine game bird, do not mislynch today.”
User avatar
Zulu Warrior
Posts: 19
Joined: Fri Feb 03, 2023 1:17 pm
Gender: Male
Location: United Kingdom

Re: Blackpool Manor Dinner: D4! FRUITS WITH CHAMPAGNE

Post by Zulu Warrior »

Good questions, hjelp and easy for me to explain to explain. :-).

1. Why HB's switch looked suspicious to me: HB had just voted for me and pressured me to claim my role, and then within minutes she suddenly did a complete U-turn onto Loose Canon. By contrast, I held off voting Loose Canon until much later, only after SoN!c posted the actual House Applicant card.

2. Why I thought HB was Circle before the reveal: Remember SoN!c posted the first death scene ('She was already gone... follow-up scene coming') before naming who had died! Knowing HB had visited Annieh last night, I assumed in that gap between SoN!c's posts that Annieh was the one killed and HB had done it. Then SoN!c's follow-up post shocked me by revealing it was actually HB who died.
User avatar
hjelp
Posts: 339
Joined: Thu Oct 06, 2011 2:50 pm

Re: Blackpool Manor Dinner: N3!

Post by hjelp »

SoN!c wrote: Tue Nov 17, 2026 4:58 am In the twilight between N3 and D4 a body was found. The wound was clean and deliberate. A knife. She was already gone..

On the floor beside her lay her card, the seal broken only by the blood that had reached it.

Six remain. Majority to lynch is now four.

It is still night. The next evening has not yet begun..

(follow-up scene coming)
Zulu -is it this you refer to?
So by that you have placed annieh and HottBunnie both at the very same spot HottBunnie was killed ?
Post Reply

Return to “Mafia Games”