Moderator: Community Team
the problem is that it is written "At two Circle members, you alone may invite ..." - the case written as "If two Circle members, you alone may invite ..." then I agree with youhomer_jay wrote: Mon Oct 26, 2026 2:16 ami don't read it this way at all. i read it as "if there are two circle members, it's you who can invite. not the other member."hjelp wrote: Sun Oct 25, 2026 4:03 pmAn invitation was accepted.SoN!c wrote: Sun Oct 18, 2026 3:59 am The aperitif moment is over!
...
As the game needs 2 Circle members at the start and KongMing got souped... Kong, by default, died as House.
Some of you have received new cards to reshuffle the Kong Soup situation.
Two circle members needed from the start - and kong by default, died as House - and still is around bringing food. What does that mean?
Case I: One circle member The Patron . Patron card reads - "At two Circle members, you alone may invite ..." - If only one circle member from the start The Patron can't invite.
since an invitation was accepted => The Patron invited => two Circle members => Case I is false.
if the power of the patron was to only be able to invite at 2, and only kill at 3, then that pretty much ends the game if we get the circle down to just the patron. i don't think the patron would be left powerless
Loose Canon wrote: Sun Oct 25, 2026 4:32 pm All you/we know about Kong is Kong isn't Patron.
If you are suspicious of Devante you have given no reasons - weak Hjelp
This doesn't make sense...Charle wrote: Sat Oct 24, 2026 5:12 am this also is a bit strange to me, i must say. the only reason i am not voting hjelp now is that the odds of being the bad guy twice in a row is a bit far fetched?

Ragian you made a susbstantive post 20 oct at 2.17amRagian wrote: Tue Oct 20, 2026 10:50 amThat's very convoluted. Only you know what your pronoun referred to. It could be the TV thingie or the old game. That's what confused me. I read it as if you were saying that if scum in the old game, you had to survive, which could either mean a) that you don't get that game, b) you're being a liar, or c) that I was confused by it. I'm happy to hear that you didn't write it like that to confuse me deliberately. However, I will ask you to phrase things unequivocally. Pronouns are bad if misunderstood. And yes, you could definitely argue that I'm a thickie thickie dumb dumb for thinking that you were referring to the game rather than the TV series, but I can't know if what I read is deliberately misleading me or an accident.Loose Canon wrote: Tue Oct 20, 2026 4:22 am
The where it differs I said was in the TV show only the surviving players either win or lose - here if you are eliminated you still win or lose if your faction wins or loses.
I don't think you think I phrased it deliberately convoluted to confuse you.
Also, what have I, indirectly, said that I think is Homer? The discussion about whom I'd chose as a N0 target...or recruit? I have in no way said that. You're assuming that. I have very clearly said that I won't partake in that discussion before Homer brings his thoughts to the table first. But now, he's gone on to say that he doesn't want to discuss. As far as I understood him.
Loose, I feel like I'm decent at reading people. I'll give you that. However, I have already skipped several of hjelp's posts because it does my head in. Hence I feel that I'm too thick for this type of game (and I feel that I was bullied into playing by Charle's big, beautiful, pleading eyes), so don't you dare say that I know that I'm not too dumb when I feel that I am. Borderline gaslighting. Gas-Loosing.
---
Annie, did you just tell me off?
FP'ed by HB
And there was something in this post from bunny (and to an extent what precede it) that persuaded me bunny wasnt currently circleHottBunnie wrote: Sun Oct 18, 2026 5:07 pm OK, thanks for your insight loose but that’s incorrect. Since this is a new game, one thing I’m wondering is how vanilla is it? And I can’t be the only one thinking this. It would be great to hear from some other voices, though as well. And for the new people in a game like this, some people might have powers that give them an advantage during the night phase. Additionally, there should be some consideration as to whether the Circle has Powers or not.
and Zulu what we do now is basically try to accuse each other of being the circle. And we can vote at any time on who we think is circle. Right now mostly we’re just putting out suspicions. As the game goes on sonic will give us a vote count occasionally. It might help to read the previous mafia game or at least portions of it to give you an idea. I believe it takes six votes right now to get someone out.
Truly a pity my efforts have gone so unappreciated. Pearls before swine, as they say. Alas.SoN!c wrote: Wed Oct 14, 2026 9:01 pm Somebody spotted the Menu on the table:
Loose Canon mumbled “Mulligatawny? That’s not a full English. Where’s the black pudding? The bacon? The fried bread?”
Kongming3 studied the card a moment longer than the others.
“Very nice. But which course is the one where we lynch someone? Because if it’s after the Lafite, I’m voting for whoever’s still sober.”
Ragian, still nowhere near the table, called from somewhere down the drive.
“Don’t you all get drunk before I arrive. And someone spell ‘Mulligatawny’ correctly or I shall leave.”
Too funny!Loose Canon wrote: Mon Oct 26, 2026 2:11 pm (I really wanted to ask kong what he thought about the empire state building btw)

hjelp wrote: Mon Oct 26, 2026 2:24 pm I think Horbunnie have asked and waiting for input from others. I'm waiting as well. That's why I wrote that Hotbunnie is a pawn.
thank youLoose Canon wrote: Mon Oct 26, 2026 3:14 am (FP means fast posted - for the benefit of Katy and Zulu)
...still suspicious of kong...annieh wrote: Mon Oct 26, 2026 1:11 pmTruly a pity my efforts have gone so unappreciated. Pearls before swine, as they say. Alas.SoN!c wrote: Wed Oct 14, 2026 9:01 pm Somebody spotted the Menu on the table:
Loose Canon mumbled “Mulligatawny? That’s not a full English. Where’s the black pudding? The bacon? The fried bread?”
Kongming3 studied the card a moment longer than the others.
“Very nice. But which course is the one where we lynch someone? Because if it’s after the Lafite, I’m voting for whoever’s still sober.”
Ragian, still nowhere near the table, called from somewhere down the drive.
“Don’t you all get drunk before I arrive. And someone spell ‘Mulligatawny’ correctly or I shall leave.”
However, I shall not be discouraged! Allow me to share my next theory.
Is it possible there are so many "Cha" items because the patron couldn't help but leave his signature on the menu?
What do you think Kingm? Or you Kong? Zulu Warrior? Katyssis? Thoughts?
if it was "you may invite at two circle members" then it would mean the circle can't invite at one. i still think it's specifying who is the one with the power to invite. not limiting when that power can be used.hjelp wrote: Mon Oct 26, 2026 5:41 am @ homer
the problem is that it is written "At two Circle members, you alone may invite ..." - the case written as "If two Circle members, you alone may invite ..." then I agree with you
he's really funneling the attention in two directions, and very clearly at that. he may be wrong. he may be misleading. but he's not pushing attention too many waysCharle wrote: Mon Oct 26, 2026 3:52 am At the moment we can only speculate, we don't really have anything to work with. However, it seems to me that Loose is now trying to get the attention to too many directions. @Loose, you are so misleading and you know it.
Unvote
Vote Loosey Goosey
i like seeing the game master saying the same thing i said earlier. nothing will be this obvious.SoN!c wrote: Mon Oct 26, 2026 1:50 pm PS: Annieh’s theory (what i make of the 'cha') - or anybody'z theory that the repeated “Cha-” words (Chardonnay, Château, Champagne) are a deliberate signature left by the Patron suggesting this points toward Charle (Charles), whose name starts with “Cha,” as if he couldn’t resist leaving a personal mark on the menu: if it was this obvious then please, never join my games again!
THIS! this clue matters. clearly "propper" isn't a typo. but now that raises the question.. wtf is a propper. we touched on this earlier, but moved off it. it can't be a mistake that sonic brings this back up again.SoN!c wrote: Mon Oct 26, 2026 1:50 pm These are propper mystery games that only proper social deduction can solve!