Blackpool Manor Dinner: Kong Mulligatawny Ming soup - first course (D1)

[Loose Canon]

so a woman and a man's hands are raised, so we are looking for a man and a woman here?

And because of this rather insightful (not) contribution

And since you've had time to respond with a comeback but haven't;

I posted then 10 minutes later Charle you posted

"Why is homer so quiet?

FP'd by Loose"

So I'll remind you the Why is line doesn't take 10 minutes to type - indicating you were thinking of something more cute to post - but then thought better of it fearing a janitor moment you deleted and just left the Why is...?

And actually the point on Homer isn't really that good because from what I can see he challenged by earlier suspicions of Hot X Buns and since whether House or Circle has actually got his head in the game as to what tactics House should be applying. I happen to now disagree with him about not lynching on a tactical level but his head is in the game as if house.

[SoN!c]

The Patron was chosen at random. The Secretary was not. The Secretary is the Patron’s deliberate first choice — the person the Patron trusted enough, or found useful enough..., to bring into the Circle on Night 0, before anyone else at the table knew the game had properly begun... Look at the two images with that in mind. Be observative!

The dinner-table scene is not a group portrait of random guests. It is the moment the first course was served and the Circle’s initial arrangement became visible to anyone paying "proper" attention. Including a reshuffle!

The raised hands in the second picture are not a high-five, an allergy complaint, or whatever. It's a "propper clue"..It must be?

Then..the menu card is the second "proper clue". It is not flavour... It is the formal structure of the evening.. Four courses. Four dinner moments. Like somebody here already mathematically calculated or computed..how long the dinner could go on before the inevitable (/ɪnˈɛvɪtəb(ə)) end is reached..?

Anyways, The clocks are still proper stopped at seven o'clock.

The questions are still properly yours..

The big question is : Who already knew the person across from them before the first ladle fell??

(Looking at who is not looking at the soup or the person who is not looking at the person who is amusingly talking at the dinner but already has his own agenda laid out)

I say "old chaps, and utmost venerable ladies", you have not asked the right question(s) yet..

Because; Some are listening more than they are speaking..

Because, Some are watching the others watching their (the heir?) soup. Because A careless question would be noticed..??

Because; Some are careful not to point too early.. I wonder who? The secretary perhaps?

Because; Some know that a loud hand now might reach the wrong person, it might reach their master, only known only as "The Patron"..? Is this the biggest clue?

Do some hands stay below the cloth for now..or do they appear "elsewear" - "hands off style" pun intended ??





The mulligatawny must be splendid!

[Loose Canon]

Ok i am house and want to remain house and i have a zero success rate as mafia so dont doubt me for this and dont recruit me for this, and dont ignore the evidence on charle for this.

The 2 p in propper and the clock stopped on 7 can i think be solved if there are 2 patrons and the late patron hasnt recruited their secretary yet, meaning that after night 2 there cannot be more than 7 in house.

So if we currently have PS P and 9 house and lynch the first P. Night 1 the S kills and the second P recruits or kills meaning we have only 7 in house D2

If we currently have PS P and 9 house and lynch the second P. Night one the PS kill or recruit meaning we have 8 house going into D2. Best case we lynch the P day 2. The S then kills N2 meaning we go into D3 only 7 house.

Above are best case scenarios for house therefore i say imperative is to lynch and lynch the most likely P who currently is i say Charle (based on social deduction with some evidence from everything i can deduce)

[hjelp]

So then Dev and kong and ?? the third lay at the table then --- it can be Hotbunnie since very soft hmm indeed wary regarding what I wrote. No one paid attention and grabbed the noation further so Hotbunnie switch target to Dev, was it deliberately to obscure the wawing hand situation?

[hjelp]

Anyhow, the wawing lady and the waving Dev in the second photo session - that sat next to in the photo sessions is now missing in the last photo. -- Followed the secretary/Butler to begin the intrigue N1. So, let's see if she will return before the N1.

[hjelp]

the clock stopped is the 7 needed to lynch if we are twelve playing the game ( and we are if two new added players) - as far as I understand

@ Loose Canon

[hjelp]

so Dev is the Patron, but we don't have to guess the Patron yet since lynching the secretary means that the Circle is down to two and no kill N1 - and if it turns out that Dev can flip Patron then I suggest we lynch Dev d2.

[Loose Canon]

I dont know hjelp.
I dont know if what i last posted stands up to mathematical rigour or not.
I think if there are pictoral clues i might take sonics gun off him and blow my own brains out.

Social deduction says to me charle, so i'll revert to that

[Loose Canon]

Actually kong really needs to speak because hes a clever guy and a superb player who as not currently a patron should be able to give an honestish assessment of the state of play

[Loose Canon]

Rubbish cook though

[hjelp]

I dont know hjelp.
I dont know if what i last posted stands up to mathematical rigour or not.
I think if there are pictoral clues i might take sonics gun off him and blow my own brains out.

Social deduction says to me charle, so i'll revert to that

I wrote what I deduced from the photo sessions

[hjelp]

[Loose Canon]

Visual clues as to players identities in roles would not be to my taste.
Nor would written mod supplied clues come to that.

[SoN!c]

Visual clues as to players identities in roles would not be to my taste.
Nor would written mod supplied clues come to that.

There are little clues hidden in the pictures but no clues that would identify who House is looking for.

As stated; Only social deduction can do that!

Annieh did noticed all the clues about the second picture but made the wrong conclusion..

The pictures are mainly for flavor to set the atmosphere