Soaps Role Madness 2! Day 3

[Extreme Ways]

6 alive.
Town decides Charle lives.
Loose shoots someone -> 5 alive.

Loose shoots Max + Max = scum -> turbolynch ragian, me and Dev confirmed (Dev less confirmed than I am by virtue of investigation protection existing)
Loose shoots Max + Max = town -> someone will be confirmed town, alongside Dev.

Town decides Charle dies, this is all with 4 alive. Charle might be scum, but if he's town we autolose if Max is also town

So yeah, bummer. If I had noticed that Kong was likely to get hammered I wouldve changed my night action, of course, but if I didnt submit any in time my "self-confirming" role wouldnt have triggered.

[Extreme Ways]

EW town
Dev town
Loose town
Charle ??
Max probscum
Rag likely scum

Killing Charle is bad if Dev is protected from investigations or if scum has a redirect.

Killing Charle is decent if the above but a roleblock instead of a redirect, because we still start the day on 5 regardless of Charle's alignment

[Extreme Ways]

I personally find it unlikely that town would get 3 kill potential.

Me
Loose
Charle
along with 2 protectives
Kong
Rag????

[Charle]

Thinking of it now, if there are 2 scum and a 3rd party, I am dead as scum would want to kill me before i can use my ability tomorrow night. Maybe a small chance to live if there are only 2 scum.

[Extreme Ways]

Well in either case a legacy would be useful if you're town and dying.

[DirtyDishSoap]

I'm extending this another 24 hours since no one seems to get the hint that they can vote and night action.

[Extreme Ways]

I'm extending this another 24 hours since no one seems to get the hint that they can vote and night action.

help

[DirtyDishSoap]

Charle was voted GUILTY!

Here comes EW with the steel chair!


HE'S A FAMILY MAN! B'GAWD! But wait?
It's revealed that Charle was a scummy Hooker (RB)

Its now day 3!
With 5 alive in takes 3 for majority!

[Devante]

Well Done. What role is the scummy hooker (RB)? I was having a hard time finding it.

And what roles do we have claimed so far. EW prosecutor, Max Oracle, Rag protective and Loose investigative, do I have that right?

[Loose Canon]

No Dev, I've claimed Jack

I'm not going to say what if anything I did last night.

I will follow whatever EW suggests I do today.

And EW I will take your advice on what I should do in the night;
So please consider the following;

1. If I have both Protective and Kill abilities still available - what will you want me to do?
2. If I only still have Protect ability still available what will you want me to do?
3. If I only still have Kill ability still available what will you want me to do?

Doesn't have to be answered now and if you don't answer at all I will use my own judgement (assuming I'm not lynched)

[Devante]

I'll have a couple questions for you Loose but gonna wait a couple days since others not involved posting yet. Would like to here from the other 3 first

[Loose Canon]

Ok Dev but I may only answer what Ew asks me.
Let's see what others post and what you ask.
(If it's to do with misreading and misplaying re Kong - I plead guilty)

[Extreme Ways]

Well Done. What role is the scummy hooker (RB)? I was having a hard time finding it.

And what roles do we have claimed so far. EW prosecutor, Max Oracle, Rag protective and Loose investigative, do I have that right?

the role is called Hooker, it's a roleblocker.

I dont believe Rag's claim much, but game-optimal is likely to kill Max -> Rag. Depends on who Max targeted as well.

If you have kill option available, I wouldnt use it. We lynch someone today, we go to 4 in the night. Scum kills someone, we go to 3. Scum should only be able to kill one of us Loose, so we always have a confirmed townie in the f3. If Rag claims he can self-protect, so should you. Even on a mislynch, I believe if it's just you and the scum alive you kill each other and it's a tie.

My hope is that Max actually targeted someone useful so we can test his claim and you can shoot a guilty verdict.

@Dev, would it be beneficial for you to spill your role-secrets now?

[Devante]

Think it might be but not yet. I expect to see some comments and night info from Rag and Max here otherwise it's a clear vote road for me at this point.

How come there was no night kill last night? Does the prosecution affect that

[Ragian]

Well, that was easy. It doesn't matter if we lynch Max or me given that Dev, EW, and Loose are town. I'll vote Max today, but I'll let Dev ask his questions first.

[Loose Canon]

If I was Town Oracle I think the correct play on Day 2 would have been to say nothing Day2.
Logic from a town oracle perspective would be I'm still a vote on towns side, and I can use my Oracle powers on who I think is most useful to Night 2.
Whether Night 1 I used my powers on someone who is dead, is likely town or suspected scum, whatever I say will focus discussion on whether to lynch me or not, and lead discussion away from other candidates. Nothing I can say will have much relevance.

Now Day 3 if I was Town Oracle I think I might as well say who I used my powers on Night 2.
Its probably the correct play for me to be lynched at this point - at least let town know who they will find out about when they lynch me.
Then they can fine tune their strategy around me as town being lynched and who my oracle powers will reveal.

Over to you Max...

[Loose Canon]

Is noone else puzzled or worried about the apparent lack of firepower weve seen from mafia if there is only 1 mafia left?

Although I do imagine Charle was a high class hooker.

[Devante]

Yes I am Loose. Given this seems to be go too smoothly I’m definitely concerned. What did everyone do last night. loose you said you’ll hold for now. Ew don’t think you had any actions you could do. Rag what did you do?

[Devante]

Take your time....

[Ragian]

It's the weekend, dude. Don't get your knickers in a twist.

N1, I protected EW because I had no specific feeling for who was town, so I protected whoever I believed I would want to get rid of if I were scum.

N2, I protected Loose. Should be self explanatory.

[Devante]

Alright in that case I'll get into what I did. I am the tracker. Last night I tracked Rag who did visit Loose. Loose unless you use protection last night and it was used up then what Rag says is true. If you did use protection then he tried to kill you. Otherwise he did protect. Ok short of a 3p in play I think it's time we vote Max at this point unless anyone has anything to add at this point

[Ragian]

Didn't EW's trial action prevent night kill?

Also, let's say that Loose did use protection. If, say, Max tried to kill Loose, you'd mistake my protection of Loose for his attempt. So, yeah, if Loose did something other than self protect, you can clear me, but you cannot condemn me 100% (though Occam's razor would suggest that I'm guilty).

[Extreme Ways]

Alright in that case I'll get into what I did. I am the tracker. Last night I tracked Rag who did visit Loose. Loose unless you use protection last night and it was used up then what Rag says is true. If you did use protection then he tried to kill you. Otherwise he did protect. Ok short of a 3p in play I think it's time we vote Max at this point unless anyone has anything to add at this point

How about other nights?

[Ragian]

Uhh, good shout. Whom did you track N1?

[Devante]

Tried to track Fusi but was told my target was killed. Think that's why DDS little comment on Fusi announcement guess quite a few had interest in him N1