Charle wrote:My take of what happened last night is as follows:
First we are all in agreement we have the following setup:
2 x Vampires
2 x Wolves
9 x Town (Traf is dead, so 8 x Town left).
It seems that a Vampire killed Traf. Then another creature (Wolf) entered, had a fight with each other, Dev entered the room and the Wolf damaged Dev's protective Vest whereafter both creatures ran away.
Kong came up and said that Strike and EW are town, so Kong might be town aligned as well.
Just one question to both Dev and Kong, why on earth do both of you claim so early in the game? Scum will now know what both of your PR's are and that you have a protective vest Dev.
So if all the above is true, we have:
Confirmed Town:
1. Strike
2. EW
3. Kong
4. Dev
The Rest:
5. DDS
6. pmc
7. Vot
8. Loose
9. Fusi
10. Ragian
11. Pixar
12. Charle
If we lynch anybody from 5 to 12 above, we have a 50% chance to hit scum and after that the masons even have a better chance at night. This is if Kong and Dev were telling the truth though.
I'm happy enough to go with the above 5-12 being candidates for lynching D2, for now.
Me and PMC, and Town (if I'm Town) do have a problem we have to get round if 5-12 are the candidates though.
In the last game I was assessing and reassessing PMC a lot a lot a lot.
I think PMC was probably doing the same assessing with me because he had to persuade me he was town.
I think I absolutely understand why PMC would make the early assessment that I was scum in this game.
I think it is a genuine assessment on PMCs part, and actually, I'm currently putting PMC as town because of my reading of PMC and because his early reading of me as scum is both consistent with PMC towniness, and in honesty what I might be doing too if Loose Canon was another player.
So there is something that needs careful navigation here - IF I'm town.
The second most likely player to be town to me currently is Vot - but I don't have a history of good reads on Vot - just wouldn't be able to vote for him on anything I've seen so far.
Of the players who posted suspicions early I'm most suspicious of Rag.
I think he posted early suspicions on a number of players, which sort of gives him an I told you so, yes I thought that too line of self justification/defence to use later on when a suspicion wagon starts on one of his "suspects".
Re DDS, Fusi, Pix, Charl, I haven't seen anything to go on re any of them yet - so if there is something someone else has seen and thinks is suss please point it out.
For now I'm just going to hold on reitterating my FOS on Rag, would ideally not want to vote this early D2.
