Pokemon Mafia *FINALLY OVER*

spinwizard · Post by **spinwizard** » Sun Jun 17, 2007 4:32 am

Skittles! wrote:
spinwizard wrote:well more like SCUM!!!
You do know Fircoal always says Pancake is scum?

yep

diddle · Post by **diddle** » Sun Jun 17, 2007 4:48 am

spinwizard wrote:
Skittles! wrote:
spinwizard wrote:well more like SCUM!!!
You do know Fircoal always says Pancake is scum?
yep

he normally is scum though

nagerous · Post by **nagerous** » Sun Jun 17, 2007 5:02 am

spinwizard wrote:Ok then, everyone vote - pancakemix

I am the cop and i investigated him, he is scum

vote pancake

nagerous · Post by **nagerous** » Sun Jun 17, 2007 5:03 am

by the way theres a couple on the player list that will need to be replaced...

avron and alexwales strike me as most necessary, they've been replaced in the other games.

onbekende · Post by **onbekende** » Sun Jun 17, 2007 5:08 am

can someone link me to a pics of said cop, I know pokemons a bit, but not he new stuff

nagerous · Post by **nagerous** » Sun Jun 17, 2007 5:11 am

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feraligatr heres a link about said pokemon, I didn't get much of a cop vibe but the roles have appeared quite random compared to the pokemon so far.

max is gr8 · Post by **max is gr8** » Sun Jun 17, 2007 5:20 am

Well theres 2 things that might happen today we lynch pancake and he's town

Then we lynch spinwizard he could be a paranoid cop.

OR we lynch spinwizard if he's a cop we lynch pancake.

OR we lynch pancake and hes scum spinwizard will be killed at night

OR we lynch neither and if spinwizard is killed and is a cop we lynch pancake the next day.

Either way we end up with little/no lead.

as if spinwizard is a cop he should know that he shouldn't claim so early and should get a few more nights to give him an idea of his sanity.

Either was

FOS: spinwizard and pancake

The1exile · Post by **The1exile** » Sun Jun 17, 2007 5:22 am

vote PCM

Spin, if you're wrong, that's your arse on the line.

max is gr8 · Post by **max is gr8** » Sun Jun 17, 2007 5:25 am

also I fogot to mention in your PM spin does it mention your sanity?

Do not state you sanity if it does once some n00b on MS sent me a PM that told me I was paranoid

diddle · Post by **diddle** » Sun Jun 17, 2007 5:25 am

max is gr8 wrote:Well theres 2 things that might happen today we lynch pancake and he's town

Then we lynch spinwizard he could be a paranoid cop.

OR we lynch spinwizard if he's a cop we lynch pancake.
OR we lynch pancake and hes scum spinwizard will be killed at night

OR we lynch neither and if spinwizard is killed and is a cop we lynch pancake the next day.

Either way we end up with little/no lead.

as if spinwizard is a cop he should know that he shouldn't claim so early and should get a few more nights to give him an idea of his sanity.

Either was

FOS: spinwizard and pancake

that sounds most likely

diddle · Post by **diddle** » Sun Jun 17, 2007 5:26 am

diddle wrote:
max is gr8 wrote:Well theres 2 things that might happen today we lynch pancake and he's town

Then we lynch spinwizard he could be a paranoid cop.

OR we lynch spinwizard if he's a cop we lynch pancake.
OR we lynch pancake and hes scum spinwizard will be killed at night

OR we lynch neither and if spinwizard is killed and is a cop we lynch pancake the next day.

Either way we end up with little/no lead.

as if spinwizard is a cop he should know that he shouldn't claim so early and should get a few more nights to give him an idea of his sanity.

Either was

FOS: spinwizard and pancake
that sounds most likely

either way max is right, we're not gonna get very far

Steel Panzer · Post by **Steel Panzer** » Sun Jun 17, 2007 5:51 am

anyway the both will get killed so : vote pancake

freezie · Post by **freezie** » Sun Jun 17, 2007 6:04 am

Alright, 2 things occurs to me right now:

1) Spin, weren't you the one that told me back on claiming cop too early in another game?

2) Vote: PCM Let's see what happens here.

max is gr8 · Post by **max is gr8** » Sun Jun 17, 2007 6:13 am

Freezie Isn't that basically what I said.

And also. spinwizard something just struck me.

If you claim so early on in the game you put one of our vital roles at jeopardy this is not the way to play mafia. If we where on day 3 I'ld understand.

Now I don't think we should lynch either of the 2 without consideration. If spinwizard is telling the truth and he is cop he will be killed tonight by mafia or SK.

If PCM is mafia and he is lynched the mafia will obviously kill spinwizard

If we lynch neither. If the mafia kill spinwizard then then give us a reason to lynch PCM and if they kill PCM then we have another investigation to go on.

I say
HOS: Spinwizard

I think he is the scummiest out of the 2.

FOS: PCM

but we do not have a strong enough lead to lynch either of them.

So what shoud we do

nagerous · Post by **nagerous** » Sun Jun 17, 2007 6:16 am

no max because if spinwizard is telling the truth and pancake is mafia, then the doc will protect him and mafia won't be able to night-kill.

freezie · Post by **freezie** » Sun Jun 17, 2007 6:16 am

Unvote

Right now we're far from the deadline anyway...

And yes Max, it's basicly what you said. But we also have a doc in this game ( Nurse 'I dont remember her name but has a million twins?' ) I hope, so our cop is defended for now.

The problem is if we have a mafia cop out there, they could root out the doc twice as fast.

spinwizard · Post by **spinwizard** » Sun Jun 17, 2007 6:36 am

OK, this is my big post.

Bits in blue ane my inputs

max is gr8 wrote:Well theres 2 things that might happen today we lynch pancake and he's town
Then we try to work out my sanity

Then we lynch spinwizard he could be a paranoid cop.
Then it clears pancake

OR we lynch spinwizard if he's a cop we lynch pancake.
But why lynch your cop? U NOOB!
OR we lynch pancake and hes scum spinwizard will be killed at night
Doctor
OR we lynch neither and if spinwizard is killed and is a cop we lynch pancake the next day.
Doctor But why not kill PCM
Either way we end up with little/no lead.
WHAT THE HELL, YOU HAVE A LEAD, I INVESTIGATED PCM!
as if spinwizard is a cop he should know that he shouldn't claim so early
But as we have a doc why not just share my results now? and should get a few more nights to give him an idea of his sanity.
Or we lynch pcm and we learn my sanety straight away!
Either was

FOS: spinwizard and pancake

BUT WHY FOS ME!

max is gr8 wrote:also I fogot to mention in your PM spin does it mention your sanity?
Of corse it doesn't!

Do not state you sanity if it does once some n00b on MS sent me a PM that told me I was paranoid
What does this mean, i don't understand

diddle wrote:
max is gr8 wrote:Well theres 2 things that might happen today we lynch pancake and he's town

Then we lynch spinwizard he could be a paranoid cop.

OR we lynch spinwizard if he's a cop we lynch pancake.

Both of your bolded options suggest lynching me, if i was mafia why would i claim cop on day 2 with no pressure on me
OR we lynch pancake and hes scum spinwizard will be killed at night

OR we lynch neither and if spinwizard is killed and is a cop we lynch pancake the next day.

Either way we end up with little/no lead.

as if spinwizard is a cop he should know that he shouldn't claim so early and should get a few more nights to give him an idea of his sanity.

Either was

FOS: spinwizard and pancake
that sounds most likely

If PCM is scum we lynch you and max!

diddle wrote:
diddle wrote:
max is gr8 wrote:Well theres 2 things that might happen today we lynch pancake and he's town

Then we lynch spinwizard he could be a paranoid cop.

OR we lynch spinwizard if he's a cop we lynch pancake.
OR we lynch pancake and hes scum spinwizard will be killed at night

OR we lynch neither and if spinwizard is killed and is a cop we lynch pancake the next day.

Either way we end up with little/no lead.

as if spinwizard is a cop he should know that he shouldn't claim so early and should get a few more nights to give him an idea of his sanity.

Either was

FOS: spinwizard and pancake
that sounds most likely
either way max is right, we're not gonna get very far
Yet again, supporting your scum buddy
But what if i am sane and then the doc protects me!

freezie wrote:Alright, 2 things occurs to me right now:

1) Spin, weren't you the one that told me back on claiming cop too early in another game?
Nope

2) Vote: PCM Let's see what happens here.
Thanks

Max is dumb wrote:Freezie Isn't that basically what I said.

And also. spinwizard something just struck me.
Oh god

If you claim so early on in the game you put one of our vital roles at jeopardy this is not the way to play mafia. If we where on day 3 I'ld understand.
Day 2 and how am i putting myself in danger

Now I don't think we should lynch either of the 2 without consideration. If spinwizard is telling the truth and he is cop he will be killed tonight by mafia or SK.
Doctor u NOOB

If PCM is mafia and he is lynched the mafia will obviously kill spinwizard
DOCTOR U NOOB
If we lynch neither. If the mafia kill spinwizard then then give us a reason to lynch PCM and if they kill PCM then we have another investigation to go on.
U just want me killed don't u!
I say
HOS: Spinwizard

I think he is the scummiest out of the 2.
How the hell do u work this 1 out!
FOS: PCM

but we do not have a strong enough lead to lynch either of them.
I'm the bloody cop!

So what shoud we do
LYNCH PCM

nagerous wrote:no max because if spinwizard is telling the truth and pancake is mafia, then the doc will protect him and mafia won't be able to night-kill.

Someone who has a brain!

freezie wrote:Unvote

Right now we're far from the deadline anyway...

And yes Max, it's basicly what you said. But we also have a doc in this game ( Nurse 'I dont remember her name but has a million twins?' ) I hope, so our cop is defended for now.
Why unvote, we have a doc to protect me if i am right
The problem is if we have a mafia cop out there, they could root out the doc twice as fast.

What does that have to do with anything!

So basicly I say we lynch PCM and if he is scum we vig/ lynch Max and diddle, I AM the cop so by listening to me we could make a major breakthrough, and face it we need it. Hope you enjoy my post, it is my longest ever.

Vote PCM
FOS- Max and Diddle

max is gr8 · Post by **max is gr8** » Sun Jun 17, 2007 6:36 am

But mafia will now know not to target a certain person which makes it easier for them to find the other power roles. I'll give you a brief reason why cops shouldn't claim

A) If there are 20 people in the game and 3 cops there are 4 mafia
so

They can target 16 people and a cop claims. then they can target 15 people and they start with the people/person the cop cleared so lets say it was day 2.
Mafia get rid of a cleared person.
Day the people lynch a member of the mafia
so they can attack 15 people but they won't attack the cop so 14.
14, 2 are cops, there will be 1 doc so

The chances of them killing a cop or doc is 3/14

Whereas if a cop claims late in the game day 5 in a 30 player game

5 lynches = 25
5 NK = 20

The 5 people is a greater proportion cleared or Proof of them being mafia.
the mafia will not be able to kill the cleared people quick enough and they will get rooted out

spinwizard · Post by **spinwizard** » Sun Jun 17, 2007 6:39 am

You are taliking the biggest load of crap ever!

Welcome to my blacklist, not that i am around for much longer

Skittles! · Post by **Skittles!** » Sun Jun 17, 2007 6:47 am

Hm, very good points.
But I'm staying with my vote on PCM.

Steel Panzer · Post by **Steel Panzer** » Sun Jun 17, 2007 7:01 am

votecount pls

The1exile · Post by **The1exile** » Sun Jun 17, 2007 7:07 am

max is gr8 wrote:So what shoud we do

FOS you. Are you deliberately trying to protect your scum buddy because no-one would be that stupid?

Spin could be mafia trying to take down a power role of PCM, or PCM could actually be scum, or spin might be a paranoid/insane cop. Either way we have leads for the next few days depending on what PCM is.

I think you're trying to lynch the cop. Bad move.

If PCM shows as scum (or even just as a vanilla townie) then I am going after you tomorrow.

max is gr8 · Post by **max is gr8** » Sun Jun 17, 2007 8:04 am

No-one would be so stupid to claim this early either.

And if he comes out as vanilla townie why would you try to lynch me.
That would prove my innocence

This early in the game if you get a SCUM
then you don't vote the person or announce it (unless your about to be lynched)
You wait til tommorow if you get an innocent then your either insane or sane
If you get another scum carry on until theirs proof of sanity.

Colaalone · Post by **Colaalone** » Sun Jun 17, 2007 8:43 am

VOTE: PCM, scum is scum. And now with all this conflict of interests here, we have some things to look into tomorrow depending on the alignment that PCM.

pancakemix · Post by **pancakemix** » Sun Jun 17, 2007 8:47 am

Spin must have a messed up sanity, because every time I read my role is says I'm not scum.