MAFIA DISCUSSION THREAD

dominationnation · Post by **dominationnation** » Mon Jun 11, 2007 8:31 pm

hey I got an idea for a mafia game but I cant mod and will be leaving in about a week so I will put it out there for some other mod to grab/have everyone tell me how stupid I am and find so many loopholes that they are force to blacklist me from all mafia games for being so inceredibly stupid.

So this is how it works. It would have to be a VERY large game. It would start with everyone being townie except for a few people that are all cult recruters for different cults. NO one knows that their are no mafia and only cults. Every first cult recruit gets a special power. It can be anything. A kill every night, a investsigation. i dont know. be creative. So town wins if they lynch all the cult recruiters. Cult win when they over power the town and when they have the largest cult. So blast away

PS. if it is as bad as I suspect it might be someone might want to move this to flame wars...

jnd94 · Post by **jnd94** » Mon Jun 11, 2007 8:39 pm

dominationnation wrote:hey I got an idea for a mafia game but I cant mod and will be leaving in about a week so I will put it out there for some other mod to grab/have everyone tell me how stupid I am and find so many loopholes that they are force to blacklist me from all mafia games for being so inceredibly stupid.

So this is how it works. It would have to be a VERY large game. It would start with everyone being townie except for a few people that are all cult recruters for different cults. NO one knows that their are no mafia and only cults. Every first cult recruit gets a special power. It can be anything. A kill every night, a investsigation. i dont know. be creative. So town wins if they lynch all the cult recruiters. Cult win when they over power the town and when they have the largest cult. So blast away

PS. if it is as bad as I suspect it might be someone might want to move this to flame wars...

now we do

Well, I also came up with a good idea for a series of small games. Old kid stories, such as 3 little pigs, and Little red riding hood, etc. i can probably a few 10 player games, where it shows the other side of the story. Such as the 3 pigs as mafia, the wolf is the vig, etc.. just ideas though.

Fircoal · Post by **Fircoal** » Mon Jun 11, 2007 8:40 pm

dominationnation wrote:hey I got an idea for a mafia game but I cant mod and will be leaving in about a week so I will put it out there for some other mod to grab/have everyone tell me how stupid I am and find so many loopholes that they are force to blacklist me from all mafia games for being so inceredibly stupid.

So this is how it works. It would have to be a VERY large game. It would start with everyone being townie except for a few people that are all cult recruters for different cults. NO one knows that their are no mafia and only cults. Every first cult recruit gets a special power. It can be anything. A kill every night, a investsigation. i dont know. be creative. So town wins if they lynch all the cult recruiters. Cult win when they over power the town and when they have the largest cult. So blast away

PS. if it is as bad as I suspect it might be someone might want to move this to flame wars...

I like it, but I'm not going to mod any cult games after CP1.

Serbia · Post by **Serbia** » Mon Jun 11, 2007 8:41 pm

dominationnation wrote:hey I got an idea for a mafia game but I cant mod and will be leaving in about a week so I will put it out there for some other mod to grab/have everyone tell me how stupid I am and find so many loopholes that they are force to blacklist me from all mafia games for being so inceredibly stupid.

So this is how it works. It would have to be a VERY large game. It would start with everyone being townie except for a few people that are all cult recruters for different cults. NO one knows that their are no mafia and only cults. Every first cult recruit gets a special power. It can be anything. A kill every night, a investsigation. i dont know. be creative. So town wins if they lynch all the cult recruiters. Cult win when they over power the town and when they have the largest cult. So blast away

PS. if it is as bad as I suspect it might be someone might want to move this to flame wars...

I don't know, sounds good to me, but of course it couldn't be announced as this, the mod would have to keep these details under wraps of course.

dominationnation · Post by **dominationnation** » Mon Jun 11, 2007 8:41 pm

jnd94 wrote:
dominationnation wrote:hey I got an idea for a mafia game but I cant mod and will be leaving in about a week so I will put it out there for some other mod to grab/have everyone tell me how stupid I am and find so many loopholes that they are force to blacklist me from all mafia games for being so inceredibly stupid.

So this is how it works. It would have to be a VERY large game. It would start with everyone being townie except for a few people that are all cult recruters for different cults. NO one knows that their are no mafia and only cults. Every first cult recruit gets a special power. It can be anything. A kill every night, a investsigation. i dont know. be creative. So town wins if they lynch all the cult recruiters. Cult win when they over power the town and when they have the largest cult. So blast away

PS. if it is as bad as I suspect it might be someone might want to move this to flame wars...
now we do Well, I also came up with a good idea for a series of small games. Old kid stories, such as 3 little pigs, and Little red riding hood, etc. i can probably a few 10 player games, where it shows the other side of the story. Such as the 3 pigs as mafia, the wolf is the vig, etc.. just ideas though.

just dont tell people that you are using my idea. however I insist that you credit me with it after the game.

pancakemix · Post by **pancakemix** » Mon Jun 11, 2007 11:23 pm

Fircoal wrote:
dominationnation wrote:hey I got an idea for a mafia game but I cant mod and will be leaving in about a week so I will put it out there for some other mod to grab/have everyone tell me how stupid I am and find so many loopholes that they are force to blacklist me from all mafia games for being so inceredibly stupid.

So this is how it works. It would have to be a VERY large game. It would start with everyone being townie except for a few people that are all cult recruters for different cults. NO one knows that their are no mafia and only cults. Every first cult recruit gets a special power. It can be anything. A kill every night, a investsigation. i dont know. be creative. So town wins if they lynch all the cult recruiters. Cult win when they over power the town and when they have the largest cult. So blast away

PS. if it is as bad as I suspect it might be someone might want to move this to flame wars...
I like it, but I'm not going to mod any cult games after CP1.

That was ruined because I was totally overpowered by the end. Even in the beginning when I had a kill power and the rest didn't, I was overpowered.

Fircoal · Post by **Fircoal** » Tue Jun 12, 2007 1:43 am

pancakemix wrote:
Fircoal wrote:
dominationnation wrote:hey I got an idea for a mafia game but I cant mod and will be leaving in about a week so I will put it out there for some other mod to grab/have everyone tell me how stupid I am and find so many loopholes that they are force to blacklist me from all mafia games for being so inceredibly stupid.

So this is how it works. It would have to be a VERY large game. It would start with everyone being townie except for a few people that are all cult recruters for different cults. NO one knows that their are no mafia and only cults. Every first cult recruit gets a special power. It can be anything. A kill every night, a investsigation. i dont know. be creative. So town wins if they lynch all the cult recruiters. Cult win when they over power the town and when they have the largest cult. So blast away

PS. if it is as bad as I suspect it might be someone might want to move this to flame wars...
I like it, but I'm not going to mod any cult games after CP1.
That was ruined because I was totally overpowered by the end. Even in the beginning when I had a kill power and the rest didn't, I was overpowered.

1. NO you weren't.

2. That part was ok, I'm talking about the one thing I regret about that game, and who caused it starts with a M and ends with Andy.

pancakemix · Post by **pancakemix** » Tue Jun 12, 2007 9:22 am

Fircoal wrote:
pancakemix wrote:
Fircoal wrote:
dominationnation wrote:hey I got an idea for a mafia game but I cant mod and will be leaving in about a week so I will put it out there for some other mod to grab/have everyone tell me how stupid I am and find so many loopholes that they are force to blacklist me from all mafia games for being so inceredibly stupid.

So this is how it works. It would have to be a VERY large game. It would start with everyone being townie except for a few people that are all cult recruters for different cults. NO one knows that their are no mafia and only cults. Every first cult recruit gets a special power. It can be anything. A kill every night, a investsigation. i dont know. be creative. So town wins if they lynch all the cult recruiters. Cult win when they over power the town and when they have the largest cult. So blast away

PS. if it is as bad as I suspect it might be someone might want to move this to flame wars...
I like it, but I'm not going to mod any cult games after CP1.
That was ruined because I was totally overpowered by the end. Even in the beginning when I had a kill power and the rest didn't, I was overpowered.
1. NO you weren't.

2. That part was ok, I'm talking about the one thing I regret about that game, and who caused it starts with a M and ends with Andy.

That too. From what he posted, he didn't break any rules. You aso messed up my kill on Night 1.

Fircoal · Post by **Fircoal** » Tue Jun 12, 2007 9:33 am

pancakemix wrote:
Fircoal wrote:
pancakemix wrote:
Fircoal wrote:
dominationnation wrote:hey I got an idea for a mafia game but I cant mod and will be leaving in about a week so I will put it out there for some other mod to grab/have everyone tell me how stupid I am and find so many loopholes that they are force to blacklist me from all mafia games for being so inceredibly stupid.

So this is how it works. It would have to be a VERY large game. It would start with everyone being townie except for a few people that are all cult recruters for different cults. NO one knows that their are no mafia and only cults. Every first cult recruit gets a special power. It can be anything. A kill every night, a investsigation. i dont know. be creative. So town wins if they lynch all the cult recruiters. Cult win when they over power the town and when they have the largest cult. So blast away

PS. if it is as bad as I suspect it might be someone might want to move this to flame wars...
I like it, but I'm not going to mod any cult games after CP1.
That was ruined because I was totally overpowered by the end. Even in the beginning when I had a kill power and the rest didn't, I was overpowered.
1. NO you weren't.

2. That part was ok, I'm talking about the one thing I regret about that game, and who caused it starts with a M and ends with Andy.
That too. From what he posted, he didn't break any rules. You aso messed up my kill on Night 1.

1) TO me he did, and it's the mod's decision. But the controversy on the modkill is part of why I'm not doing it again.

2) I didn't.

MountainLion · Post by **MountainLion** » Tue Jun 12, 2007 2:17 pm

I was wondering what is the most common way of modding a mafia game. Mainly I have one question: if a cop investigates someone, do you tell them "innocent" or "mafia" or do you tell them everything (like the character's name and if they have any powers or not)?

If there's some kind of modding guide somewhere, let me know.

The1exile · Post by **The1exile** » Tue Jun 12, 2007 2:27 pm

Tell them the full role if it's a smaller game.

tell them only the alignment if there are cops of varying sanity.

nagerous · Post by **nagerous** » Wed Jun 13, 2007 12:47 pm

Who is up for a scrubs RT mafia this weekend? I thought it would be a nice idea to play around with a few of the various doc roles (weak doc etc.) .

pancakemix · Post by **pancakemix** » Wed Jun 13, 2007 12:49 pm

I'm game. I've used the paranoid doc and it worked extraordinarily well.

spinwizard · Post by **spinwizard** » Wed Jun 13, 2007 12:50 pm

jnd94 wrote:
dominationnation wrote:hey I got an idea for a mafia game but I cant mod and will be leaving in about a week so I will put it out there for some other mod to grab/have everyone tell me how stupid I am and find so many loopholes that they are force to blacklist me from all mafia games for being so inceredibly stupid.

So this is how it works. It would have to be a VERY large game. It would start with everyone being townie except for a few people that are all cult recruters for different cults. NO one knows that their are no mafia and only cults. Every first cult recruit gets a special power. It can be anything. A kill every night, a investsigation. i dont know. be creative. So town wins if they lynch all the cult recruiters. Cult win when they over power the town and when they have the largest cult. So blast away

PS. if it is as bad as I suspect it might be someone might want to move this to flame wars...
now we do Well, I also came up with a good idea for a series of small games. Old kid stories, such as 3 little pigs, and Little red riding hood, etc. i can probably a few 10 player games, where it shows the other side of the story. Such as the 3 pigs as mafia, the wolf is the vig, etc.. just ideas though.

Any chance of me nicking this idea?

jnd94 · Post by **jnd94** » Thu Jun 14, 2007 9:18 am

spinwizard wrote:
jnd94 wrote:
dominationnation wrote:hey I got an idea for a mafia game but I cant mod and will be leaving in about a week so I will put it out there for some other mod to grab/have everyone tell me how stupid I am and find so many loopholes that they are force to blacklist me from all mafia games for being so inceredibly stupid.

So this is how it works. It would have to be a VERY large game. It would start with everyone being townie except for a few people that are all cult recruters for different cults. NO one knows that their are no mafia and only cults. Every first cult recruit gets a special power. It can be anything. A kill every night, a investsigation. i dont know. be creative. So town wins if they lynch all the cult recruiters. Cult win when they over power the town and when they have the largest cult. So blast away

PS. if it is as bad as I suspect it might be someone might want to move this to flame wars...
now we do Well, I also came up with a good idea for a series of small games. Old kid stories, such as 3 little pigs, and Little red riding hood, etc. i can probably a few 10 player games, where it shows the other side of the story. Such as the 3 pigs as mafia, the wolf is the vig, etc.. just ideas though.
Any chance of me nicking this idea?

Um, I have some ideas that I can pm you. You can mod it, because Im through with modding for a while, but if you let me give you some guidelines, then sure.

spinwizard · Post by **spinwizard** » Thu Jun 14, 2007 9:55 am

jnd94 wrote:
spinwizard wrote:
jnd94 wrote:
dominationnation wrote:hey I got an idea for a mafia game but I cant mod and will be leaving in about a week so I will put it out there for some other mod to grab/have everyone tell me how stupid I am and find so many loopholes that they are force to blacklist me from all mafia games for being so inceredibly stupid.

So this is how it works. It would have to be a VERY large game. It would start with everyone being townie except for a few people that are all cult recruters for different cults. NO one knows that their are no mafia and only cults. Every first cult recruit gets a special power. It can be anything. A kill every night, a investsigation. i dont know. be creative. So town wins if they lynch all the cult recruiters. Cult win when they over power the town and when they have the largest cult. So blast away

PS. if it is as bad as I suspect it might be someone might want to move this to flame wars...
now we do Well, I also came up with a good idea for a series of small games. Old kid stories, such as 3 little pigs, and Little red riding hood, etc. i can probably a few 10 player games, where it shows the other side of the story. Such as the 3 pigs as mafia, the wolf is the vig, etc.. just ideas though.
Any chance of me nicking this idea?
Um, I have some ideas that I can pm you. You can mod it, because Im through with modding for a while, but if you let me give you some guidelines, then sure.

Yeah sure, i was just brainstorming

Minister Masket · Post by **Minister Masket** » Thu Jun 14, 2007 10:19 am

Add me...
ADD ME!!!!
*launches into screaming and running off-satge*

jnd94 · Post by **jnd94** » Thu Jun 14, 2007 10:22 am

Minister Masket wrote:Add me...
ADD ME!!!!
*launches into screaming and running off-satge*

have you ever played a game?

AK_iceman · Post by **AK_iceman** » Thu Jun 14, 2007 11:12 am

I unstickied the page because it turned into something else. It was supposed to be a helpful resource for the mafia gamers, but now it just seems like you're trying to control other moderators from making games, which isn't good.

That and spin really isn't keeping it updated.

If you would like to edit it Spin I'll be happy to re-sticky it.
Or if someone else thinks they can keep it updated better, I'd be happy to let you try.

I GOT SERVED · Post by **I GOT SERVED** » Thu Jun 14, 2007 11:29 am

I'd be willing to give it a try.

spinwizard · Post by **spinwizard** » Thu Jun 14, 2007 2:21 pm

AK_iceman wrote:I unstickied the page because it turned into something else. It was supposed to be a helpful resource for the mafia gamers, but now it just seems like you're trying to control other moderators from making games, which isn't good.That and spin really isn't keeping it updated.

If you would like to edit it Spin I'll be happy to re-sticky it.
Or if someone else thinks they can keep it updated better, I'd be happy to let you try.

how do u work this 1 out!!! there are way too many games going on atm and u know it, at first it was good, now it is just out of hand.

This is fair enough, tyhe ammount of games atm is silly

What did it turn into?

Also AK, i have to agree with Spamalot supporters here, you abuse your powers and I think i am not the one bossing ppl around here.

dustn64 · Post by **dustn64** » Thu Jun 14, 2007 2:24 pm

from now on you should have mods PM you before they start a game. And why am I not on the players list?

autoload · Post by **autoload** » Thu Jun 14, 2007 2:25 pm

It would take another full time mod to keep track of all the current mafia games. Way too many... Diluting the quality of the games if you ask me.

spinwizard · Post by **spinwizard** » Thu Jun 14, 2007 2:26 pm

dustn64 wrote:from now on you should have mods PM you before they start a game. And why am I not on the players list?

You will be added now.

I bet AK says i would be controling the mafia mods if i try to sujest this, like every other community organisation idea i have posted!

Fircoal · Post by **Fircoal** » Thu Jun 14, 2007 2:26 pm

pancakemix wrote:I'm game. I've used the paranoid doc and it worked extraordinarily well.

I USED IT BEFORE ALL OF YOU!

NV1.

Also I remember the insane vig, that was so funny. It was a doc that was called a vig. It had a funny death scene too.