Conquer Club Newbie Mafia #1: Day 4 ends 9-4 1600

[Iron Butterfly]

You did not answer why you think YOU would be killed if I were the last mafia.

[grt]

Because I believe I am on the right track hunting down the mafia. The mafia will know I am not one of them as they know who each other are - therefore I would assume I would be a target. Now if I am completely wrong then they'll probably want to keep me alive to make more incorrect assumptions.

[Iron Butterfly]

Because I believe I am on the right track hunting down the mafia. The mafia will know I am not one of them as they know who each other are - therefore I would assume I would be a target. Now if I am completely wrong then they'll probably want to keep me alive to make more incorrect assumptions.

*grin*

Now here comes a question that is complete "wine in front of me"

You are no more a target then any other Town person but now that you have put that possibility out there if you do die tonight does that make me mafia or has mafia killed you to fulfill your theory to Make me look bad even though my only crime in your eyes was to not vote endgame? See where this is going?

Many times mafia can sit back as Town fight among themselves chasing shadows.

[grt]

As this is my first game there is a lot to learn - you make an interesting point

[StorrZerg]

Reminder day ends Tomorrow 16:00 cc time (around 16 hours)
op was updated. Mafia may chat has no day time restriction
If you have any questions about what this means, please pm your coach or send me a pm thanks.

[codierose]

Another day over and still only half voting is this a waste of time

[grt]

I count 6 alive and 6 votes?

4 for Endgame
1 for grt
1 for TeeGee

[StorrZerg]

bleh my bad. Was working on op for other game WIll tally the votes and lynch

[StorrZerg]

With 4 votes Endgame has been lynched

show

Night phase has started. You know the drill. Day 4 starts 16:00 tomorrow

[grt]

Well shows how wrong I can be - I was so sure he was mafia.

Sorry Endgame.

[Iron Butterfly]

Of course you were. Welcome to mafia.

[Iron Butterfly]

There are 5 of us left. One dies tonight that will make 4 players left...end of game if there are two mafia.

There is either a doc left or just one mafia as I would think Storr would say game over if that was the case.

[StorrZerg]

gesh so late today and i was on the whole time QQ


GRT you wake up dead
VT

[TeeGee]

Because I believe I am on the right track hunting down the mafia. The mafia will know I am not one of them as they know who each other are - therefore I would assume I would be a target. Now if I am completely wrong then they'll probably want to keep me alive to make more incorrect assumptions.

*grin*

Now here comes a question that is complete "wine in front of me"

You are no more a target then any other Town person but now that you have put that possibility out there if you do die tonight does that make me mafia or has mafia killed you to fulfill your theory to Make me look bad even though my only crime in your eyes was to not vote endgame? See where this is going?

Many times mafia can sit back as Town fight among themselves chasing shadows.

This leaves me with a real dilemma, now that grt has gone we have lost our best detective.


Is Iron Butterfly mafia? Or have mafia set him up to look like one of them..

[TeeGee]

as for laying low though.. where is jonty?

and codierose's contributions over the last 2 pages are also lacking.

i have to guess there is only 1 mafia here, but I can sniff a trace in you all.

We make a wrong call today though and with a night kill, it gives victory to the mafia

[TeeGee]

as for laying low though.. where is jonty?

and codierose's contributions over the last 2 pages are also lacking.

i have to guess there is only 1 mafia here, but I can sniff a trace in you all.

We make a wrong call today though and with a night kill, it gives victory to the mafia

So 3 of us have to choose very carefully

[Iron Butterfly]

The simple fact is that if I were mafia the easiest route would have been to vote Endgame. If Grt was our best detective he would not have voted GRT so spare us the best detective stuff.

As I stated earlier I have never understood the "Im to sick" to post. Unless one has Ebola I just don't see how it becomes a problem to post something.

But yes this game has been pretty lame as far as people contributing anything but the bare minimum. Not a great way to get beginner's involved or interested.

[jonty125]

as for laying low though.. where is jonty?

I haven't been laying low at all!

So 4 alive; hence one mafia; so we do have the option to no lynch today and then go LYLO (at the moment we're MYLO).

The players I believe are alive are: codie; IB; TeeGee and myself.

According to the rules I must vote, so ##vote TeeGee for the reasons I provided on D3.

[TeeGee]

The simple fact is that if I were mafia the easiest route would have been to vote Endgame. If Grt was our best detective he would not have voted GRT so spare us the best detective stuff.

As I stated earlier I have never understood the "Im to sick" to post. Unless one has Ebola I just don't see how it becomes a problem to post something.

But yes this game has been pretty lame as far as people contributing anything but the bare minimum. Not a great way to get beginner's involved or interested.

I never said I was too sick to post, I can't read the forums on a phone.. I'm no spring chicken... Not hard to look up a users post history
Anyways, this game has shown me I don't have time to play mafia (or real interest) and work as head global, as well as playing risk type games. Maybe it needed a better mix of newbies and playing coaches who have some idea of what goes on..

since this is the last day, and mafia kill tonight will likely give the game to them

##Vote codierose He has posted a fair bit, but read his posts, what is he saying? not much.. so for now that is my vote..

[TeeGee]

The simple fact is that if I were mafia the easiest route would have been to vote Endgame. If Grt was our best detective he would not have voted GRT so spare us the best detective stuff.

As I stated earlier I have never understood the "Im to sick" to post. Unless one has Ebola I just don't see how it becomes a problem to post something.

But yes this game has been pretty lame as far as people contributing anything but the bare minimum. Not a great way to get beginner's involved or interested.

I never said I was too sick to post, I can't read the forums on a phone.. I'm no spring chicken... Not hard to look up a users post history
Anyways, this game has shown me I don't have time to play mafia (or real interest) and work as head global, as well as playing risk type games. Maybe it needed a better mix of newbies and playing coaches who have some idea of what goes on..

since this is the last day, and mafia kill tonight will likely give the game to them

##Vote codierose He has posted a fair bit, but read his posts, what is he saying? not much.. so for now that is my vote..

Actually, after looking back on D3, jonty cast the deciding vote to lynch endgame.. my vote being the 4th was irrelevant.

##unvote codierose
##vote jonty125

[grt]

Well my last post. I enjoyed it and look forward to another one. There are some comments about this game not being so good - but it is a game for newbies and to be honest I hadn't a clue what was going on for the first few days. In my opinion I think you get a taster and can decide from this if it is for you or not.

Thanks to all the participants, the coaches and the host.

[Iron Butterfly]

This is a game that you can only learn by playing. It is also not for everyone as the debate/argument can get heated. This game has been tame compared to some of the blow outs I have participated in. I would suggest not to judge mafia by this game. I suggest looking at some of the game archives.

I am holding my vote for now.

[Iron Butterfly]

The simple fact is that if I were mafia the easiest route would have been to vote Endgame. If Grt was our best detective he would not have voted GRT so spare us the best detective stuff.

As I stated earlier I have never understood the "Im to sick" to post. Unless one has Ebola I just don't see how it becomes a problem to post something.

But yes this game has been pretty lame as far as people contributing anything but the bare minimum. Not a great way to get beginner's involved or interested.

I never said I was too sick to post, I can't read the forums on a phone.. I'm no spring chicken... Not hard to look up a users post history
Anyways, this game has shown me I don't have time to play mafia (or real interest) and work as head global, as well as playing risk type games. Maybe it needed a better mix of newbies and playing coaches who have some idea of what goes on..

since this is the last day, and mafia kill tonight will likely give the game to them

##Vote codierose He has posted a fair bit, but read his posts, what is he saying? not much.. so for now that is my vote..

Actually, after looking back on D3, jonty cast the deciding vote to lynch endgame.. my vote being the 4th was irrelevant.

##unvote codierose
##vote jonty125

A majority lynch would be 50% of players plus one. Yesterday YOUR vote would have been the hammer. However endgame would have been lynched with out your vote anyways if things stayed the same.

[jonty125]

Actually, after looking back on D3, jonty cast the deciding vote to lynch endgame.. my vote being the 4th was irrelevant.]

No vote on the wagon is irrelevant.

[Iron Butterfly]

I want to hear from Codierosa.