Jonty125's Mad Mafia Game Over

by **benga** on Thu Mar 13, 2014 2:09 am

vote crasp

by **NoSurvivors** on Thu Mar 13, 2014 2:14 am

benga wrote:vote crasp

....... Lol of all the people...

by **Lootifer** on Thu Mar 13, 2014 3:37 am

Urrgh... really?

nagerous wrote:There has only been one night phase, he said his read was NoS and he got told he was a roleblocker - no alignment?

Yeah but at least trying to force a reads list is worth it: it tells us a lot, regardless of his alignment.

by **new guy1** on Thu Mar 13, 2014 11:31 am

Benga, I got that your reasoning was probably that someone said the day should just end, but would it kill you to give a reason with your vote? It doesnt look good when you come in and hammer someone with a one liner. Anyways, Ill wait for the scene I suppose. I guess I cant really blame you, he has had long enough to post and hasnt, but the one liner is something to work on.

by **NoSurvivors** on Thu Mar 13, 2014 12:16 pm

new guy1 wrote:Benga, I got that your reasoning was probably that someone said the day should just end, but would it kill you to give a reason with your vote? It doesnt look good when you come in and hammer someone with a one liner. Anyways, Ill wait for the scene I suppose. I guess I cant really blame you, he has had long enough to post and hasnt, but the one liner is something to work on.

Basically +1. And if he turns up town... Look out scout.

by **jonty125** on Thu Mar 13, 2014 12:20 pm

Vote Count

crasp (8) - Iron Butterfly; safariguy5; Nebuchadnezer; Metsfanmax; Anarkistsdream; virus90; new guy1; benga
new guy1 (1) - kgb007;
Hotshot51 (1) - crasp;

CRASP HAS BEEN LYNCHED

So after talking amongst themselves the town by the power of democracy they strung up crasp and hung him. crasp - Dunja – Town Role Cop has been lynched. Night action deadline is Monday 17 March @ 1800 GMT.

by **benga** on Thu Mar 13, 2014 4:11 pm

new guy1 wrote:Benga, I got that your reasoning was probably that someone said the day should just end, but would it kill you to give a reason with your vote? It doesnt look good when you come in and hammer someone with a one liner. Anyways, Ill wait for the scene I suppose. I guess I cant really blame you, he has had long enough to post and hasnt, but the one liner is something to work on.

I gave my reasoning in earlier post, just hammered so we can continue, he was dead anyway

by **new guy1** on Thu Mar 13, 2014 5:51 pm

benga wrote:
new guy1 wrote:Benga, I got that your reasoning was probably that someone said the day should just end, but would it kill you to give a reason with your vote? It doesnt look good when you come in and hammer someone with a one liner. Anyways, Ill wait for the scene I suppose. I guess I cant really blame you, he has had long enough to post and hasnt, but the one liner is something to work on.

I gave my reasoning in earlier post, just hammered so we can continue, he was dead anyway

K, was meant mostly as a warning anyways, I must have missed the post so Ill go read it. lol

by **Anarkistsdream** on Thu Mar 13, 2014 5:52 pm

Shhhhhhhhh... Zzzzzzzz

by **crasp** on Fri Mar 14, 2014 7:36 am

Thanks for the experience guys. Good luck town.

by **jonty125** on Mon Mar 17, 2014 2:44 pm

The town had a lost a 3rd man, and some people didn't understand the prospect of going to sleep (or at least pretending to) at night.

Early in the night Metsfanmax, made his gamble and went on sat on benga's doorstep, with his musket. One man got to the gate, pushed the gate open

Hotshot53 - Eurig - Town Jailkeeper lay dead at the gate. In quick succession another man came around the corner, he saw the dead man on the floor and then

NoSurvivors - Klemens – Town Roleblocker his body falling on top of the other.

In another part of town, a mafia member, was walking downing the street, unaware of what was happening elsewhere, he came across his target's house. Slipped in through an open window, and threw a knife in the back of Iron Butterfly - Funske - Town JOAT who lay dead on the floor of his own home.

Back to Metsfanmax, dawn was coming soon, and Mets decided no-one else was coming and benga wasn't going anywhere and with that, he broke down benga's door and shot him with the musket, with a large ...

Click image to enlarge.

benga - Alexander – Town Vengeful lay dead, and was most likely was deaf, after not hearing two muskets shots or his door been broke down.

And with that Metsfanmax disappeared, satisfied, never to been seen again. Metsfanmax - Villem - Kamikaze has fulfilled their victory conditon and been endgamed.

THE GAME CONTINUES with 8 alive it takes 4 to lynch, deadline Monday 31 March @ 1800 GMT.

by **nagerous** on Mon Mar 17, 2014 2:50 pm

Holy batman!

by **HotShot53** on Mon Mar 17, 2014 3:03 pm

Wow, that was a lot of deaths... good luck town, looks like you'll need some of it now to pull this one off.

by **virus90** on Mon Mar 17, 2014 3:05 pm

ok i have to read this again. WTF !its almost an achievement to not get a single maffia killed.

ok i read it again.
not that it matters much but i got the feeling everyone who visited benga got killed by metsfanmax. the way the scene is written makes me think that.was he that suspicious? that both NoS and Hotshot visited him? and what was metsfanmax victory he had to kill 3 at once? it doesnt matter much for the game i guess to discuss this. but what the hell..

IB got maffia killed as i read it, i guess maffia just took an experienced member afraid of being picked out by IB.

ok flabbergasted by this... havent seen this before..

by **Iron Butterfly** on Mon Mar 17, 2014 3:19 pm

Holy Game Balance Batman.

by **Lootifer** on Mon Mar 17, 2014 3:47 pm

Wow congrats Mets, I would love to know what your VC is, but I guess I will have to wait. Presumably its based on taking down X number of people. Good call on benga either way.

This has reset eveything. With the crasp town-flip (which now seems so long ago) Benga and IB were going to be my two targets for pressure and probing today, with Hotshot also pinging a few things on my scumdar. With all three being killed and flipping town I am now at a loss... looks like its time for a re-read :S

Heres a repost of the alive player list FYI:

1. virus90
2. Anarkistsdream
4. new guy1
5. Nebuchadnezer
9. safariguy5
10. Lootifer
13. kgb007
14. nagerous

I am trying to work out how many scum we have to kill, and initially I would have said 4. But Jonty said 4 are required for a lynch (is this correct?) so maybe 3..?

Either way its this kind of circumstance that a no-lynch is a good option right?

by **Anarkistsdream** on Mon Mar 17, 2014 4:09 pm

....... Well... I wanna accuse virus and nag, because they are two I KNOW have the smarts to pull all of this crap off.

by **virus90** on Mon Mar 17, 2014 4:24 pm

@ anarkist, well i gues i take that as a compliment

@ lootifier... that is pretty coincidental... you had 3 leads and all of them are killed... maybe you should add NoS he got killed to.. (sarcasm/irony or something like that). You are performing pretty poorly for a towny if all of your reads flip town, that makes me question your townliness.
FOS lootifier

by **virus90** on Mon Mar 17, 2014 4:27 pm

oh and i did not even read the no lynch part. thats not making it better in my opinion. you presume 3 maffia and want to no lynch? that would leave 7 alive tomorrow and if only 1 someone votes a not maffia and the presumed 3 maffia hop on.. GAME OVER...

by **Metsfanmax** on Mon Mar 17, 2014 4:53 pm

Lootifer wrote:Wow congrats Mets, I would love to know what your VC is, but I guess I will have to wait.

Thanks

Good luck all.

by **Lootifer** on Mon Mar 17, 2014 5:00 pm

virus90 wrote:@ lootifier... that is pretty coincidental... you had 3 leads and all of them are killed... maybe you should add NoS he got killed to.. (sarcasm/irony or something like that). You are performing pretty poorly for a towny if all of your reads flip town, that makes me question your townliness.
FOS lootifier

This doesnt even make sense. Why would I add NoS? I was 90% sure he was town (and said as much at the time), IB lead the crasp pressure, and benga quick hammered. If you would so kindly point out the bad reasoning in there... poorly indeed

I will admit, however, that the hotshot thing is mostly gut (though he also pushed crasp, and has been posting a lot of information rather than analysis).

oh and i did not even read the no lynch part. thats not making it better in my opinion. you presume 3 maffia and want to no lynch? that would leave 7 alive tomorrow and if only 1 someone votes a not maffia and the presumed 3 maffia hop on.. GAME OVER...

Interesting, veerrrry interesting. I have some thoughts on this post but want to see others' thoughts first.

by **virus90** on Mon Mar 17, 2014 5:09 pm

as pointed out the "maybe you should add nos" was meant sarcastic, see the (sarcams/irony) part just after i said that.
I was sarcastic because you point out all dead people as you possible scum. (well except for NoS, hence the sarcasitic comment)
not meant to offend you if i did.
i tend to use a lot of sarcasm, it is in the Dutch language/culture and well i tend to use it in english aswell. but to be sure i generally add the (sarcasm) sign (makes me think of the big bang theory) to be sure not to cause confusion, since sarcasm is culture derived and thus since i assume none of you is Dutch, might be harder to read.

by **Nebuchadnezer** on Mon Mar 17, 2014 10:58 pm

Okay, this sucks, but...That. Was. Awesome. I'm a sucker for the big multi-kill scenes, and Mets saw a great opportunity.

Why? Aw, hell, Benga hammered the lynch. Plus NoSurvivors said he blocked Benga N1 and there was only one kill...it made sense to go back to him again and see what happened, especially considering the chance that Edoc killed himself on N1 by hiding behind mafia. Obviously, Hotshot picked up on that as well and was going to jailkeep him. It all makes sense for Mets to make his move whatever his VC was, he needed to kill some people).

Congrats to Mets, however, he really effed over town for us big time.

I have no information at this point to give us a lead.

by **benga** on Tue Mar 18, 2014 2:57 am

good luck rest of the way townies

by **safariguy5** on Tue Mar 18, 2014 11:34 am

Lootifer wrote:Wow congrats Mets, I would love to know what your VC is, but I guess I will have to wait. Presumably its based on taking down X number of people. Good call on benga either way.

This has reset eveything. With the crasp town-flip (which now seems so long ago) Benga and IB were going to be my two targets for pressure and probing today, with Hotshot also pinging a few things on my scumdar. With all three being killed and flipping town I am now at a loss... looks like its time for a re-read :S

Heres a repost of the alive player list FYI:

1. virus90
2. Anarkistsdream
4. new guy1
5. Nebuchadnezer
9. safariguy5
10. Lootifer
13. kgb007
14. nagerous

I am trying to work out how many scum we have to kill, and initially I would have said 4. But Jonty said 4 are required for a lynch (is this correct?) so maybe 3..?

Either way its this kind of circumstance that a no-lynch is a good option right?

I disagree with the no lynch option, mainly because I don't know if there are any other killing roles out there. If there is some other sort of vig or what have you, an incorrect read could lead to endgame. I'm also kind of hoping that we have at least one protective role left, and that even if we do mislynch, we still have a small chance of protecting the nk target.