Shannon Apple wrote:Yeah, my problem is your lack of tact when addressing others work. Your icons would not work for front page. No offense, but they're not that well done at all. They are very quickly cut out of their backgrounds and are not "designed" at all. These ones are much cleaner. If one was to make proper icons, they would need a large scale version of the image used that they can then cut out properly using the pen tool. That takes a long time to do for 40 images. You would have to give credit to anyone who spent the time to do that alone... and do it properly AND apply them to a design template.
As I was saying, you don't have to like something, but you can be constructive in your criticism, not destructive. That means telling someone what you don't like about what they've done in a civil manner, and then telling them how you think they can improve it. Don't be so quick to dismiss the creator of set 2 as not deserving to win because you think yours are better.
Forgive me for having an issue with the way you've conducted yourself in this thread. You obviously cannot see the error of your ways, so I'll just leave it at that. I'm done. >.>
you are very funny,, where you find that mine icons need to win here? Its look that i need to repeat again, because you dont understand,, mine icons are not created for any contest, its created for CL5 purposes.
Option what won are much better then option who have shields and silouetes, because this option take into consideration Clan avatars.
And you realy need to go into map foundry and to try to create map, then you will see what are real destructive criticism .
