Summer vs. Winter Mafia (6/13) Game Over. Mafia (Winter) Won

[StubbsKVM]

The game is Summer vs Winter. Winter did the killing so I assume they are mafia (red). Why would a Summer VT be orange?? Could it be that Summer has a cult leader that must recruit Summer VTs?

You are assuming Winter is red. You could say this because you know this is not true, to attempt to look like you really didn't know.

You are asking why Summer would be Orange, which is perfectly made clear by Hensow here:

summer

what color was your role PM?

Questions like that seem awfully close to violating (at least the intent of) rule 2.

show

well the backgrounds white most of the text is black (or possibly relay dark green) but the bit that says the name and role is pink well pinky gold well gold and not at all pink but what do you expect me to say.

And I have no idea why you suddenly assume there is a cult recruiter with an orange role PM(which is usually used for 3rd party).

So I think you did not get a Summer Role PM.

[gregwolf121]

Once again no one has been able to answer WHY I would do what i did. Theorize...give me a valid logical reason I would make such a play??

well i don't konw why you do what you do, i would guess you posted it cause it seemed right at the time but in hindsight you realized the error, and i think its very distracting to have us guess your reasons/intentions, if you don't know why you did it, then how would i know?

[Iron Butterfly]

If i am lynched you had best take a strong strong look at Stubbs.

Frankly go ahead and lynch me.

[kgb007]

it's not an official vote count but by my count, hensow is at L2 and IB is at L3

rereading the posts, i'm starting to think IB might be a 3rd party...i don't need to need to look at stubbs if IB flips town bc Stubbs was one of the first to affirm hensow's claim

so i'll unvote vote IB

what is it they always say when someone goes to L2? oh yeah...

CLAIM TIME IB

is there a run off if votes are tied at deadline?

[spiesr]

The game is Summer vs Winter. Winter did the killing so I assume they are mafia (red). Why would a Summer VT be orange?? Could it be that Summer has a cult leader that must recruit Summer VTs?

Ultimately Iron Butterfly, the issue is that it doesn't make much sense for you to say this if you are town. If you thought that the color Hensow posted for his town claim was strange wouldn't the first you do be compare it to the color of your own role pm? Unless you aren't town.

[thechuck51]

The game is Summer vs Winter. Winter did the killing so I assume they are mafia (red). Why would a Summer VT be orange?? Could it be that Summer has a cult leader that must recruit Summer VTs?

Ultimately Iron Butterfly, the issue is that it doesn't make much sense for you to say this if you are town. If you thought that the color Hensow posted for his town claim was strange wouldn't the first you do be compare it to the color of your own role pm? Unless you aren't town.

I agree with spiesr here. the color of hensow's post jumped out at me kinda like spiesr's confirmation did:

Confirm

More important no one has been able to explain how my initial statement/question would help my faction in any way.

it's called a scum-slip...

[jonty125]

FINAL Vote Count

Hensow (5) - safariguy5; new guy1; thechuck51; gregwolf121; ghostly447;
Iron Butterfly (4) - Hensow; dazza2008; StubbsKVM; skillfusniper;
gregwolf121 (2) - spiesr; kgb007;
safariguy5 (1) - TheForgivenOne;
skillfusniper (1) - Iron Butterfly;

A no lynch as been enforced, due to no lynch candidate having a majority.

Well the day started off with the traditional awful jokes. And then one man said he would wait for someone to provide a case, so a case was provided, with him based on the lynch. The wagon reached the precipice of a lynch but turned around. Another man was beginning to be pushed towards the rope based on colours but the sun set and he was saved.

Everyone returned to there tents, but who wold come out?

Night One has begun. Deadline for night actions is Wednesday 28 August @ 0900 BST.

[jonty125]

TheForgivenOne - Mia (Vanilla Townie) has been killed by an icicle.

With 12 alive it takes 7 to lynch. Deadline is Friday 6 September @ 0900 BST. With 12 alive it takes 7 to lynch.

[dazza2008]

Sucks that we lost 1 but at least no power role. Anyone got anything to go on?

[TheForgivenOne]

Sucks i'm out! But glad I was only a VT Go Summer!

[StubbsKVM]

vote IB

[new guy1]

vote IB

Vote stubbs

Do you see how this vote with no reasoning can cause someone to question motive? Whats your reasoning? unvote (sorry jonty )

[StubbsKVM]

The game is Summer vs Winter. Winter did the killing so I assume they are mafia (red). Why would a Summer VT be orange?? Could it be that Summer has a cult leader that must recruit Summer VTs?

You are assuming Winter is red. You could say this because you know this is not true, to attempt to look like you really didn't know.

You are asking why Summer would be Orange, which is perfectly made clear by Hensow here:

summer

what color was your role PM?

Questions like that seem awfully close to violating (at least the intent of) rule 2.

show

well the backgrounds white most of the text is black (or possibly relay dark green) but the bit that says the name and role is pink well pinky gold well gold and not at all pink but what do you expect me to say.

And I have no idea why you suddenly assume there is a cult recruiter with an orange role PM(which is usually used for 3rd party).

So I think you did not get a Summer Role PM.

a new day doesn't mean I forget what happened.

[jonty125]

vote IB

Vote stubbs

Do you see how this vote with no reasoning can cause someone to question motive? Whats your reasoning? unvote (sorry jonty )

No problem.

[Hensow]

The night kill, TheForgivenOne, didn't say a lot in day one and so posed no threat to anyone particular so there little to gleam there probably why he was picked thought they might just have well run a submarinning case on him so for now that leaves us with

Vote IB from day one
IB seem confused as to weather summer was Town or 3rd party it's hard to conceive how someone would be unsure if they were town so I propose he is not town.
he of course claims that he did notice the color in his role pm but that it struck him as odd only toward the end of day 1.

[skillfusniper33]

Why are you guys rushing into a case that was from yesterday? We could have some new developments from night actions. And the day is still very fresh.

[safariguy5]

Why are you guys rushing into a case that was from yesterday? We could have some new developments from night actions. And the day is still very fresh.

True, but unless someone comes forward with some particularly useful night action, I doubt we will see something.

I do think stubbs should be a little more careful about voting first and then providing the reason later. Happened yesterday, and again today. I could easily see a situation later on where stubbs votes first to lynch someone, then never provides his reasoning later if we allow his posting style to continue.

FOS stubbs

One more vote from you with no reason (even if the reason is nothing new) and I will upgrade to a vote.

[spiesr]

Why are you guys rushing into a case that was from yesterday? We could have some new developments from night actions. And the day is still very fresh.

Well, what exactly happen last night. One person who wasn't critical to anything from yesterday died and was VT. Unless somebody found something that is worth revealing theirself for I don't think we have anything new.

[jonty125]

Vote Count
Iron Butterfly (2) - StubbsKVM; Hensow;
StubbsKVM (1) - new guy1;

Deadline is Friday 6 September @ 0900 BST. With 12 alive it takes 7 to lynch.

[dazza2008]

I agree we should wait a bit to see if there is anything solid but if not Iron is the strongest case I see from what he said day 1.

[gregwolf121]

did anyone get anything worthwhile from their night actions? cause i got nothing

[StubbsKVM]

I figured my reasons would be obvious.

[new guy1]

Vote Count
Iron Butterfly (2) - StubbsKVM; Hensow;
StubbsKVM (1) - new guy1;

Deadline is Friday 6 September @ 0900 BST. With 12 alive it takes 7 to lynch.

I unvoted in the same post, sorry for that

[jonty125]

Vote Count
Iron Butterfly (2) - StubbsKVM; Hensow;
StubbsKVM (1) - new guy1;

Deadline is Friday 6 September @ 0900 BST. With 12 alive it takes 7 to lynch.

I unvoted in the same post, sorry for that

I even acknowledged it

[kgb007]

not much to glean from the N1 scene, nor do I have any useful to add in respect to anyone's N1 actions...

i'll refrain from voting at the moment to see if anyone comes forward with new info but saf brings up a good point

I figured my reasons would be obvious.

of course it's obvious to you but the rest of us aren't in your head