RememberMe - offensive and ratings abuse[Busted]TFO

by **talonz** on Sat Jul 13, 2013 10:18 pm

Accused:

RememberMe

The accused are suspected of:

Other: Player was verbally offensive and an ingame bully. All other players took efforts to knock this player out ingame while playing and did so. I ended up winning the game and yet somehow he leaves a 1 star rating in everything for me with the tags rude, secret diplomacy, cheap tactics, poor strategy. Im not sure what he considers cheap tactics, but having won the game while being polite and conducting all diplomacy in game, the other tags and the intentionally poor ratings are not warranted and an abuse of the rating system.

I would very much like to see that rating against me removed and the player warned for his abuse of other players and the rating system.

Game number(s):

Game 12779425

Comments:

by **Razorvich** on Sun Jul 14, 2013 8:03 am

I have seen worse mate...and you need 5 examples of ratings abuse to make a case.

FOE him.

by **talonz** on Sun Jul 14, 2013 10:16 am

Ah did not know that wrinkle. Look at his ratings left for other players, he tanked 2 other players from that game with single stars and multiple tags, all unwarranted as well. So its just a matter of time until he does hit 5 ratings abuse examples imo.

And of course I foed him.

by **gcwca_4_life** on Sun Jul 14, 2013 10:38 am

Do you really expect any different?

He has a completely terrible rating himself, and doesnt seem to care how me makes others look.

Foe him, let him fall for his mistakes, and do what ya gotta do.

by **Agent 86** on Sun Jul 14, 2013 12:02 pm

Actually I feel after looking into this..seems to maybe scream Multi. Hope I'm wrong as I want this site to grow in membership

by **clangfield** on Sun Jul 14, 2013 4:10 pm

gcwca_4_life wrote:Do you really expect any different?

He has a completely terrible rating himself, and doesnt seem to care how me makes others look.

Foe him, let him fall for his mistakes, and do what ya gotta do.

Seems a touch tough to slag off his rating when it's only based on 4 scores... :geek:

If he's not a multi then he's almost certainly a returning player; the game chat suggests rather more previous experience than might be expected...

by **gcwca_4_life** on Sun Jul 14, 2013 4:24 pm

clangfield wrote:
gcwca_4_life wrote:Do you really expect any different?

He has a completely terrible rating himself, and doesnt seem to care how me makes others look.

Foe him, let him fall for his mistakes, and do what ya gotta do.

Seems a touch tough to slag off his rating when it's only based on 4 scores...
If he's not a multi then he's almost certainly a returning player; the game chat suggests rather more previous experience than might be expected...

Im not gonna say it inst possible, as it really is.

But, when push comes to shove, if you foe him, you dont have to worry about him joining any new games you set up.

But, the mods can solve that with an IP check, just gotta give em time to do their jobs.

by **Larry46** on Sun Jul 14, 2013 9:55 pm

Smells like the infamous NodLoyalist!

by **turtleninja** on Mon Jul 15, 2013 9:28 pm

how would one go about someone posting some very mean a abusive language on someone wall and in game chat

by **betiko** on Tue Jul 16, 2013 3:49 am

That is sooo a multi! Why would you have an anonymous proxy and seem to know what you re doing with those settings & your first trench game with 10 games played? His first game a 4 men king s court 2 that he wins?
So basically if you can t ip check him correctly he s free to go?

by **Rock-** on Tue Jul 16, 2013 7:21 pm

I made this dude a foe because
1) he played like a vindictive jerk
2) he has no country flag, just a proxy, which is suspicious to me.
3) the name "Remember Me" tells me that perhaps he used to be a different person on this site and has returned to be a douche.

I honestly thought he may have created the account to "f" with me because he joined a few of my games as his 1st few here and then seemed to target me. I haven't been here long so this made it even more weird.
I received a nice rating from him too as have several others lately.

by **TheForgivenOne** on Wed Jul 17, 2013 9:53 am

Busted with eatthisubytch and streetcred

by **talonz** on Wed Jul 17, 2013 10:28 am

Does that mean he was a multi? And if so what actions were taken as a result? I see he has been kicked out of his games, what about the bad ratings left, can those be removed please?

by **TheForgivenOne** on Wed Jul 17, 2013 10:42 am

talonz wrote:Does that mean he was a multi? And if so what actions were taken as a result? I see he has been kicked out of his games, what about the bad ratings left, can those be removed please?

Yes, he was a multi. He has been kicked off the site. Ratings aren't removed, as 1 bad rating among thousands won't affect your overall rating.

by **Rock-** on Wed Jul 17, 2013 12:11 pm

TheForgivenOne wrote: Ratings aren't removed, as 1 bad rating among thousands won't affect your overall rating.

that's really not a good policy you know.
sure, they may not impact an overall rating when you have thousands but it certainly will when you don't have thousands.
I'm not that worried about my overall score as I've had quite a few negative ones so far but this guys poor rating did make me drop one tenth of a point.

the site should absolutely remove ratings left by a person like this.

no matter how you look at it, rule abiding members are being penalized and permanently marked by rule breakers.

by **talonz** on Wed Jul 17, 2013 1:50 pm

I have to agree. I'm glad there is a comprehensive response and policy in place to deal with abusers and I thank you for your work in busting him, but to not clean up the mess left behind them at all is disapointing.

How hard is it to delete those comments? Heck why not code this in when dealing with multis, so that their profile and all their comments are automatically deleted, as they are not legitimate players anyways?

And yes it may be buried eventually, but right now his comment is at the top of my ratings for all to see and that annoys me greatly.

by **greenoaks** on Wed Jul 17, 2013 4:47 pm

Rock- wrote:
TheForgivenOne wrote: Ratings aren't removed, as 1 bad rating among thousands won't affect your overall rating.

that's really not a good policy you know.
sure, they may not impact an overall rating when you have thousands but it certainly will when you don't have thousands.
I'm not that worried about my overall score as I've had quite a few negative ones so far but this guys poor rating did make me drop one tenth of a point.

the site should absolutely remove ratings left by a person like this.

no matter how you look at it, rule abiding members are being penalized and permanently marked by rule breakers.

send me an invite to a game. any map, any setting. i'll then give you a rating.

repeat with other members thousands minus one times.

by **Rock-** on Wed Jul 17, 2013 5:42 pm

greenoaks wrote:
Rock- wrote:
TheForgivenOne wrote: Ratings aren't removed, as 1 bad rating among thousands won't affect your overall rating.

that's really not a good policy you know.
sure, they may not impact an overall rating when you have thousands but it certainly will when you don't have thousands.
I'm not that worried about my overall score as I've had quite a few negative ones so far but this guys poor rating did make me drop one tenth of a point.

the site should absolutely remove ratings left by a person like this.

no matter how you look at it, rule abiding members are being penalized and permanently marked by rule breakers.

send me an invite to a game. any map, any setting. i'll then give you a rating.

repeat with other members thousands minus one times.

OK, I'll take a chance on you.
Heck, according to the site moderators, bad ratings don't affect your overall score anyway, right?

by **greenoaks** on Wed Jul 17, 2013 7:42 pm

Rock- wrote:
greenoaks wrote:
Rock- wrote:
TheForgivenOne wrote: Ratings aren't removed, as 1 bad rating among thousands won't affect your overall rating.

that's really not a good policy you know.
sure, they may not impact an overall rating when you have thousands but it certainly will when you don't have thousands.
I'm not that worried about my overall score as I've had quite a few negative ones so far but this guys poor rating did make me drop one tenth of a point.

the site should absolutely remove ratings left by a person like this.

no matter how you look at it, rule abiding members are being penalized and permanently marked by rule breakers.

send me an invite to a game. any map, any setting. i'll then give you a rating.

repeat with other members thousands minus one times.

OK, I'll take a chance on you.
Heck, according to the site moderators, bad ratings don't affect your overall score anyway, right?

not after 1600+ ratings, maybe a little less than that.

by **Bradley Bomber** on Sun Aug 25, 2013 2:08 pm

Rock- wrote:
TheForgivenOne wrote: Ratings aren't removed, as 1 bad rating among thousands won't affect your overall rating.

that's really not a good policy you know.
sure, they may not impact an overall rating when you have thousands but it certainly will when you don't have thousands.
I'm not that worried about my overall score as I've had quite a few negative ones so far but this guys poor rating did make me drop one tenth of a point.

the site should absolutely remove ratings left by a person like this.

no matter how you look at it, rule abiding members are being penalized and permanently marked by rule breakers.

I agree.