Coaches Poll (Jan 1, 2014 Updated!)

[IcePack]

**** This has been handed off to icepack to handle. He was a big help when I started it, and it will be easier having all of the information in one place. I was considering stopping the poll due to lack of responses, but icepack should be able to keep it going.

show: 01.01.14

show: 09.01.13

show: 06.01.13

show: 03.01.13

show: Voters

Each voter ranks their top 20 clans
1st place vote is 20
2nd place is 19
so on and so on

Thats all I got, not enough votes to exclude any (highest/lowest ranking) so its just straight up votes received.

[Leehar]

No particularly huge discrepancies between this and the F400 (other than the slight fall for Fall ).

I suspect LoW's jump came just a trifle too late to be included

[Nicky15]

Nice work BG

[IcePack]

No particularly huge discrepancies between this and the F400 (other than the slight fall for Fall ).

I suspect LoW's jump came just a trifle too late to be included

It was a expected result, as a newer clan perceptions are slow to change.

[chapcrap]

Others Received votes: KOA (2)

I'm not sure KOA is even still active...

[BGtheBrain]

*****

[IcePack]

Others Received votes: KOA (2)

I'm not sure KOA is even still active...

Same for BOTFM

I think the poll was conducted just before the Atlantis split.

[BGtheBrain]

*****

[IcePack]

Several clans have, but usually there is some sort of roster changes as well? Most clans don't drop everything if their mantra / leadership hasn't changed at some point.

A carbon copy of the old clan doing the same thing will likely yield similar results

[Genoke]

Others Received votes: KOA (2)

I'm not sure KOA is even still active...

Same for BOTFM

I think the poll was conducted just before the Atlantis split.

The core from Atlantis came from the pirates, true. Most of those, have left BoTFM at the end of 2012. We were clanless before the idea came up to form our own clan.
Don't know what the purpose is with this poll....coaches...?
But i must admit i didn't read all the forum yet. Started to read when Atlantis was alive (and almost kicking).

[IcePack]

Others Received votes: KOA (2)

I'm not sure KOA is even still active...

Same for BOTFM

I think the poll was conducted just before the Atlantis split.

The core from Atlantis came from the pirates, true. Most of those, have left BoTFM at the end of 2012. We were clanless before the idea came up to form our own clan.
Don't know what the purpose is with this poll....coaches...?
But i must admit i didn't read all the forum yet. Started to read when Atlantis was alive (and almost kicking).

Basically a group of people who are involved / knowledgable on clans vote on the top 20. It's a perception polling similar to Chuuucks power rankings I believe, but restricted to people who are more involved in clans instead of a vote per clan etc

[Bruceswar]

How many voters did we have total? Seems pretty decent overall.

[IcePack]

OSA had a strong showing here. When CC3 started thy were 24th, and have made big strides in the last year in both F400 and perceptions (clearly).

I think it's safe to say BOTFM will drop out of top 20 and wonder where Atlantis will show up, or if a clan like TFFS will move to take the place.

[chapcrap]

OSA had a strong showing here. When CC3 started thy were 24th, and have made big strides in the last year in both F400 and perceptions (clearly).

I think it's safe to say BOTFM will drop out of top 20 and wonder where Atlantis will show up, or if a clan like TFFS will move to take the place.

I don't see Atlantis cracking the top 20 without a war played...

[IcePack]

OSA had a strong showing here. When CC3 started thy were 24th, and have made big strides in the last year in both F400 and perceptions (clearly).

I think it's safe to say BOTFM will drop out of top 20 and wonder where Atlantis will show up, or if a clan like TFFS will move to take the place.

I don't see Atlantis cracking the top 20 without a war played...

Well of course, but I'm theorizing about their future

[Genoke]

OSA had a strong showing here. When CC3 started thy were 24th, and have made big strides in the last year in both F400 and perceptions (clearly).

I think it's safe to say BOTFM will drop out of top 20 and wonder where Atlantis will show up, or if a clan like TFFS will move to take the place.

I don't see Atlantis cracking the top 20 without a war played...

I agree with that!
Positive news is...our first war is about to begin in 2 weeks and we're participating in the newcomers cup aswell... hope to get a good result and become visible in the rankings. I have no doubt we can reach the top 20, but the question is..when? Hopefully it won't take to long.

[chapcrap]

OSA had a strong showing here. When CC3 started thy were 24th, and have made big strides in the last year in both F400 and perceptions (clearly).

I think it's safe to say BOTFM will drop out of top 20 and wonder where Atlantis will show up, or if a clan like TFFS will move to take the place.

I don't see Atlantis cracking the top 20 without a war played...

I agree with that!
Positive news is...our first war is about to begin in 2 weeks and we're participating in the newcomers cup aswell... hope to get a good result and become visible in the rankings. I have no doubt we can reach the top 20, but the question is..when? Hopefully it won't take to long.

I agree with you!! Maybe by the June vote!

[Genoke]

OSA had a strong showing here. When CC3 started thy were 24th, and have made big strides in the last year in both F400 and perceptions (clearly).

I think it's safe to say BOTFM will drop out of top 20 and wonder where Atlantis will show up, or if a clan like TFFS will move to take the place.

I don't see Atlantis cracking the top 20 without a war played...

I agree with that!
Positive news is...our first war is about to begin in 2 weeks and we're participating in the newcomers cup aswell... hope to get a good result and become visible in the rankings. I have no doubt we can reach the top 20, but the question is..when? Hopefully it won't take to long.

I agree with you!! Maybe by the June vote!

vote?

[Swifte]

vote?

yes. these rankings are the result of 15 or so people submitting their 'ballot' of rankings for clans 1-20. the ballots are submitted on a quarterly basis.

[Genoke]

vote?

yes. these rankings are the result of 15 or so people submitting their 'ballot' of rankings for clans 1-20. the ballots are submitted on a quarterly basis.

nice, that means we don't have to play 150 games like in F400...
How does the vote works, cause i think i misunderstand...about 15 people write down their vote and the cumule of this gives the results? (damn i feel so stupid now)

[Swifte]

vote?

yes. these rankings are the result of 15 or so people submitting their 'ballot' of rankings for clans 1-20. the ballots are submitted on a quarterly basis.

nice, that means we don't have to play 150 games like in F400...
How does the vote works, cause i think i misunderstand...about 15 people write down their vote and the cumule of this gives the results? (damn i feel so stupid now)

yes. 15 people rank 20 clans from 1-20. BG then assigns points to the votes in reverse order... so first place gets 20 points, a second place vote gets 19 points and so on down to 20th being assigned 1 points. BG then adds up the points, and the total points earned by each clan determines their ranking (most points is first, and so on).

[chapcrap]

vote?

yes. these rankings are the result of 15 or so people submitting their 'ballot' of rankings for clans 1-20. the ballots are submitted on a quarterly basis.

nice, that means we don't have to play 150 games like in F400...
How does the vote works, cause i think i misunderstand...about 15 people write down their vote and the cumule of this gives the results? (damn i feel so stupid now)

yes. 15 people rank 20 clans from 1-20. BG then assigns points to the votes in reverse order... so first place gets 20 points, a second place vote gets 19 points and so on down to 20th being assigned 1 points. BG then adds up the points, and the total points earned by each clan determines their ranking (most points is first, and so on).

Yeah, I probably misspoke mistyped when I said vote. I should have said ranking or something. But, if you do well and are playing wars, you might be able to make the top 20 in 3 months... But, you better get to work!

[Genoke]

But, if you do well and are playing wars, you might be able to make the top 20 in 3 months... But, you better get to work!

copy that!

[Swifte]

How many voters did we have total? Seems pretty decent overall.

Out of 22 requests, 15 responded.

[friendly1]

How many voters did we have total? Seems pretty decent overall.

Out of 22 requests, 15 responded.

Out of 22 requests, 15 gave rankings. More than 15 responded.