Metsfanmax wrote:The argument I have consistently made, is that there's absolutely no basis for the claim that time did not exist prior to the creation of the universe. But this devolves into the multiverse discussion below, so let's keep it there.
How Could Time Exist Prior To Creation?
By Viceroy63
[updated and revised]
I also added an additional [Note] at the end.
The second most visible and obvious evidence for the existence of God is an expanding universe. The first is, how monstrously huge this universe really is. But the fact that this incredibly huge Universe is expanding and has been doing so for some 13 to 16 Billion Years is mind boggling. If you really consider this with an open mind, how can you not see the hand of God in creation.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hVApTLE7Csc
In the video they said that the Universe has been expanding from 10 to 20 Billion Years but more recent observations suggest 13 to 16 Billion Years. I don't know exactly how they come up with the number of years but it is safe to assume that if the galaxies are rushing away from each other that at one time they should have been closer to one another. Else how can you rush away?
I think that the the direction in which the galaxies are flying in can also be determined by the Doppler effect. So when you align all the directions together you get an idea of a more central location that the galaxies began their journey through time. But how does Time fit into all of this?
Einstein hypothesized that the universe must be related and work together some how. He was not the first to come up with this. If you've ever seen a Japanese Rock Garden and then ask the "Gardener" what it means he would explain to you that by moving one pebble in the Garden, you alter the destiny of the universe. That is what Einstein is basically saying with his special relativity theory and that idea was hundreds if not thousands of years before Einstein hit upon it. Everything is relative and related to everything else.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=fv ... iwq94&NR=1
But basically speaking, all three elements, Time, Space and Matter are related to each other so that by changing one you change the other. So if the Universe had a beginning some 14 Billion years ago, which of course implies a Beginner or Creator, then so also had all three of these elements their beginning at the same point in creation. To say that Time existed before Space and Matter, is to say that Time is not a part of our Universe and that simply is not the case. Either something is a part of the universe or it is not. And if the three are related then the three began when the Universe began. It's really just that simple.
Also it is safe to point out that if something is not a part of our universe, then it most likely can not be observed. Something outside of the universe, like a Creator God, can not be observed by the universe as the universe can only observe things inside of the universe. This is why we see and detect the presence of Time. Because Time is inside of and a part of this universe just as Matter and Space is also.
As a thought experiment I would like to suggest that when the Universe was only 5 Billion years old, that this part of Time and Space that we currently occupy did not exist. The universe at 5 Billion years old only had the stretch of space of 10 Billion Light Years in Diameter. So this Thirteenth Billion Light year that we call our home, our time and place, had not yet come to exist in a 5 Billion year old universe.
The Universe is constantly expanding in an outwardly direction from the epicenter of what we call the "Big Bang." So then at this point in time, the universe being 13 Billion Years old, the Time, Space and Matter of 20 Billion years from now does not yet exist. That is to say that the future has yet to be created. Along with the Space, Time and Matter that goes with it. [Tomorrow does not yet exist]
Currently our universe is 13 Billion years old so that means that it is safe to assume that our universe has a diameter of 26 Billion Light Years across. There is nothing that exist outside of the sphere of this 26 Billion Light Year Universe because everything outside of the sphere of this universe is yet to be created. Not Time nor Space nor Matter exist outside of the universe. If it does exist then it would be observational and a part of the universe and we could then say that the Universe is not 13 Billion years old but older.
We certainly can not detect light from the other side of this universe because of the distance and speed that light travels. If the other side of our universe is 26 Billion light years away then it takes light from the other side 26 billion light years to get to us. But if we are also moving at light speed or close to it away from the epicenter then the point will come when we will no longer be able to detect any light from the other side. We can how ever see and observe light in front of us and around us from surrounding galaxies, even if it is all also moving away from us as well, but we can observe it more easily then light from all the way on the other side of the universe, some 26 Billion light years away.
When scientist speak of empty space not being empty, they are referring to the space inside of our created universe. But beyond our Universe there is no empty space. There is simply nothing that exist outside of the sphere of this universe just as there is nothing that exist outside of the sphere of the Creator. The word universe means, all that there is. So outside of this universe there is no Time, Space or Matter. Not yet anyway!
[Note]
When I say, "
Currently our universe is 13 Billion years old so that means that it is safe to assume that our universe has a diameter of 26 Billion Light Years across. There is nothing that exist outside of the sphere of this 26 Billion Light Year Universe because everything outside of the sphere of this universe is yet to be created...
First of all I am talking "Approximately." Secondly I would like to point out that it is the expanding Universe that is constantly creating and not that there is some "Room" in the "Universe" that is being filled up with time, space and matter.
As a thought experiment, if you could some how travel beyond the leading edge of our ever expanding universe; If you could some how go beyond the confines our our universe and go into tomorrow, Then you would simply cease to exist because Tomorrow does not yet exist as the past already does.
Einstein's theory of relativity states that if you could travel faster than light then you could end up in the past. But how does one go into tomorrow? It has to exist first and this alone is what makes time travel into the future, impossible. The fact that tomorrow does not yet exist for any of us because the Universe has not yet expanded into the realm of tomorrow.
But as we creep into the tomorrow, one second at a time, tomorrow is being created with every second that passes, even as I write these thoughts. This is why Time could not exist prior to the creation of the Universe because if time had existed prior to the creation of the Universe then the universe would not have had a beginning. And Astronomy and Astrophysics,
"Science," do show us that Yes, The Universe does have a beginning. So how could time exist prior to creation, when there is a Beginning to all of Creation?
The end of my article and my words.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=pl ... tSAvcslxag
Have you seen the January 11 issue of
New Scientist? There's a story by Lisa Grossman entitled, "Why Scientists Can't Avoid a Creation Event." It seems that at a conference in Cambridge in honor of Stephen Hawking's 70th birthday (truly an amazing achievement, it must be said), Alex Vilenkin showed up with the results of a new paper demonstrating the impossibility of yet another way of trying to escape the conclusion of an absolute cosmic beginning. Vilenkin concludes, ""All the evidence we have says that the universe had a beginning."
Grossman characterizes this news as "the worst birthday presesnt ever" for Hawking, who in a pre-recorded messaged to the conference declared, ""A point of creation would be a place where science broke down. One would have to appeal to religion and the hand of God."
-Reasonable Faith, Facebook.
Did the cosmos have a beginning? The Big Bang theory seems to suggest it did, but in recent decades, cosmologists have concocted elaborate theories - for example, an eternally inflating universe or a cyclic universe - which claim to avoid the need for a beginning of the cosmos. Now it appears that the universe really had a beginning after all, even if it wasn't necessarily the Big Bang.
At a meeting of scientists - titled "State of the Universe" - convened last week at Cambridge University to honor Stephen Hawking's 70th birthday, cosmologist Alexander Vilenkin of Tufts University in Boston presented evidence that the Universe is not eternal after all, leaving scientists at a loss to explain how the cosmos got started without a supernatural creator. The meeting was reported in New Scientist Magazine, 11 January 2012. I've quoted a few brief high lights below.
In his presentation, Professor Vilenkin discussed three theories which claim to avoid the need for a beginning of the cosmos.
One popular theory is the eternal inflation. Most readers will be familiar with the theory of inflation, which says that the universe increased in volume by a factor of at least 10^78 in its very early stages (from 10^-36 seconds), before settling into the slower rate of expansion that we see today. The Theory of
eternal infaltion goes further, and holds that the universe is constantly giving birth to smaller "bubble" universes withing an ever-expanding multiverse. Each bubble universe undergoes its own initial period of inflation. In some versions of the theory, the bubbles go both backwards and forward in time, allowing the possibilitly of an infinite past. Trouble is, the value of one particular cosmic parameter rules out that possibility:
But in 2003, a team including Vilenkin and Guth considered what eternal inflation would mean for the Hubble constant, which describes mathematically the expansion of the universe. They found that the equations didn't work (
http://prl.aps.org/abstract/PRL/v90/i15/e151301). "You can't construct a space-time with this property," says Vilenkin. It turns our that the constant has a lower limit that prevents inflation in both time directions. "It can't possibly be eternal in the past." says Vilenkin. "There must be some kind of boundary."
A second option explored by Vilenkin was that of a cyclic universe, where the universe goes through an infinite series of big bangs and crunches, with no specific beginning. It was even claimed that a cyclic universe could explain the low observed value of the cosmological constant. But as Vilenkin found, there's a problem if you look at the
disorder in the universe:
Disorder increases with time. So following each cycle, the universe must get more and more disordered. But if there has already been an infinite number of cycles, the universe we inhabit now should be in a state of maximum disorder. Such a universe would be uniformly lukewarm and featureless, and definitely lacking such complicated beings as stars, planets and physicists - nothing like the one we see around us.
One way around that is to propose that the universe just gets bigger with every cycle. Then the amount of disorder per volume doesn't increase, so needn't reach the maximum. But Vilenkin found that this scenario falls prey to the same mathematical argument as eternal inflation: if your universe keeps getting bigger, it must have started somewhere.
However, Vilenkin's options were not exhausted yet. There was another possibility: that the universe had sprung from an eternal cosmic egg:
Vilenkin's final strike is an attack on a third, lessor-known proposal that the cosmos existed eternally in a static state called the "Cosmic Egg." This finally "cracked" to create the big bang leading to the expanding universe we see today. Late last year Vilenkin and graduate student Audrey Mithani showed that the egg could not have existed forever after all, as quantum instabilities would force it to collapse after a finite amount of time (
http://arxiv.org/abs/1110.4096). If it cracked instead, leading to the big bang, then this must have happened before it collapsed - and therefore also after a finite amount of time.
"This is also not a good candidate for a beginningless universe," Vilenkin concludes.
So at the end of the day, what is Vilenkin's verdict?
"All the evidence we have says that the universe had a beginning."
A Supernatural Creator?
I've always been a bit leery of the
Kalam version of the cosmological argument which says that since (1) whatever begins to exist has a cause, and (2) the universe began to exist, therefore (3) the universe has a supernatural cause. Of course, I don't doubt the first premise, and as Professor William Lane Craig, who is a noted defender of the argument, points out, neither did the skeptical philosopher David Hume. Hume wrote in 1754: "I never asserted so absurd a proposition as that anything might arise without a cause" (The Letters of David Hume, Two Volumes, J. Y. T. Greig, editor: (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1932), 1:187; quoted in Craig, Reasonable Faith, Wheaton, Ill.: Crossway, revised edition, 1994,p.93).
And as philosopher Elizabeth Anscombe has pointed out, if you think about how you'd go about determining that an object which just appeared out of nowhere had actually come into existence or had just been very rapidly transported from some other place where it had existed previously, the only way you could settle the issue would be to identify something which was responsible for generating it, as opposed to merely transporting it. In other words, you'd need to identify a cause. (In the case of virtual particles which come into and go out of existence over very short time periods, that cause is the quantum vacuum, which, because it has a specific energy level and can be described by scientific laws, is a genuine entity in its own right, pervading the universe of space.) In short: methodologically, there seems to be no way in principle of showing that something which appeared out of the blue actually came into existence without a cause, and our ability to imagine it doesn't make it really possible (after all, I can imagine winged horses too).
But I've always been a bit doubtful about the second premise until now. Cosmologists themselves seemed to have lots of ideas as to how the universe might be eternal, and it seemed to me that as fast as one idea was refuted, another one sprang up.
So when I see a leading cosmologist such as Vilenkin admit that "All the evidence we have says that the universe had a beginning," I sit up and take notice.
Suppose Vilenkin is right. What follows then? The universe had some kind of cause - obviously not a natural cause, so you'd have to call it supernatural. But where does that take us?
A Personal Creator?
Professor William Lane Craig goes on to argue that this supernatural cause of the cosmos must be personal. According to Craig, every kind of explanation is either a logico-mathematical explanation (which, because it is abstract, is incapable of explaining the fact that something comes into existence), a
scientific explanation (which can explain events occurring within the universe, but not the coming-to-be of the universe itself) or a
personal explanation, involving an agent doing something for a reason. Personal explanation is the only schematic that can explain the coming-to-be of the cosmos, reasons Craig.
Professor Craig defends the notion of a personal Creator in a post entitled, "Is the Cause of the Universe an Uncaused, Personal Creator of the Universe, who spans the Universe Is Beginningless, Changeless, Immaterial, Timeless, Spaceless, and Enormously Powerful?
-Reasonable Faith, Facebook.
-Posted by vjtorley under Intelligent Design on January 12, 2012