hoytdwow[warned]SN

by **rhp 1** on Fri Jul 06, 2012 3:01 pm

BGtheBrain wrote:ok.
Out of the latest list, I found 2 instances.

The others were justified OR they are merely the accused not understanding that "deadbeating" requires 3 missed turns. In the past, when someone doesnt understand the deadbeat tag, they often get noted and a PM from the mod

I do like how RHP is able to question his case, but when I show him where he was wrong, him and jltile both have a problem with that.

hmm... so that's 4, and in my opinion it's clearly more than that, but at what point does it become abuse? I'm thinking if someone other than me reported this guy, it would have been a warning fairly quickly... but whatever... It's mods letting their personal opinions dictate their judgement.. not the first, won't be the last...

and I have no problem being wrong BG... I just don't like that you have issues with being objective... that's all..

by **rhp 1** on Fri Jul 06, 2012 3:03 pm

BGtheBrain wrote:ok.
Out of the latest list, I found 2 instances.

The others were justified OR they are merely the accused not understanding that "deadbeating" requires 3 missed turns. In the past, when someone doesnt understand the deadbeat tag, they often get noted and a PM from the mod

I do like how RHP is able to question his case, but when I show him where he was wrong, him and jltile both have a problem with that.

and which 2 from the latest list are abuse in your opinion?

by **BGtheBrain** on Fri Jul 06, 2012 3:06 pm

12302 games completed

Youve given 4 examples of ratings abuse.

Clearly you have no problem being wrong....

by **BGtheBrain** on Fri Jul 06, 2012 3:07 pm

Culs and Ivan

by **sniffie** on Fri Jul 06, 2012 3:17 pm

I also found 4 ratings that where unjustified.

This thread is going out of hand.
I'll lock this and RHP1 can PM me with a more detailed list of his accusations, I am confident we can debate about this as adults.

sniffie

by **sniffie** on Sun Jul 08, 2012 3:52 pm

the accused has been warned for Rating abuse.

snifie

by **jltile1** on Sun Jul 08, 2012 3:54 pm

sniffie wrote:the accused has been warned for Rating abuse.

snifie

nice job !!

by **hoytdwow** on Sun Jul 08, 2012 4:43 pm

this is hilarious...all the research to prove that I "abused" the rating system, but in my disciplinary warning I was not told which rating(s) are considered abusive so that I can verify it.

I've certainly left my last rating. What a joke.

by **rhp 1** on Sun Jul 08, 2012 9:29 pm

hoytdwow wrote:this is hilarious...all the research to prove that I "abused" the rating system, but in my disciplinary warning I was not told which rating(s) are considered abusive so that I can verify it.

I've certainly left my last rating. What a joke.

glad to hear it!!!

by **shanksdigs** on Sun Jul 08, 2012 11:14 pm

BGtheBrain wrote:@JL: Rather than blindly commenting here, why dont you acknowledge that I actually did something. I looked at ratings, and found them to be justified.

I looked at 11 ratings. 9 were justified, 2 were abuse.

I'm glad the C&A Mods are finally using their voices. Kudos!

by **Jdsizzleslice** on Sun Jul 08, 2012 11:39 pm

rhp 1 wrote:
hoytdwow wrote:this is hilarious...all the research to prove that I "abused" the rating system, but in my disciplinary warning I was not told which rating(s) are considered abusive so that I can verify it.

I've certainly left my last rating. What a joke.

glad to hear it!!!

Agreed.