MLP: Friendship is MAFIA! ENDGAME: DISCORD & PINKIE WIN!

[pmchugh]

OK guys we actually need to come to a conclusion on this. Although I am struggling to pick out exactly the right person. Lets review the evidence for and against each lynch:

Nagerous
For: No cop results. (blocked and investigated dead person)
Against: He claimed one of the main characters in the game.

Dazza
For: A town recruiting group sounds rather bizarre. He could be a cult or even a bizarre mafia claim.
Against: The vote clearing action does not seem likely in a cult

Sheep
For: Known to be part of a faction, his claim of being in a 3 man survivor faction that has no alterior motives is highly unlikely.
Against: Only member of the CMC died night 1, suggesting they don't have a kill. The claim by haggis of busdriver lessons the liklihood of my work around as well.

Pmchugh- Obviously hard to comment on myself but I will try be objective
For: The claim does not seem believable because he would have fake claimed.
Against: He got roleblocked last night.

/
For: Has managed to mainly avoid criticism so far and if I was to put my money on a 4th cmc member it would be applejack. (purely from reading the wiki)
Against: Confirmed roleblocker by nag night 1.

Haggis - Much the same as dazza

TFO
For: Is clearly not a member of the town. His claim is one of the least believable and sheep put forward a decent case against him.
Against: Doctors can be very useful.

Milkshake
For: Has acted the most scummy in game IMO and his claim is rather strange.
Against: His claim is so strange I doubt it was made up.

For me TFO sneaks it, but I really want to hear from everyone else at this point on what they think of others claims.

[/]

Nagerous
Against: He claimed one of the main characters in the game.

Most of us did, I think five of us still alive are main characters, which makes me think a mind screw is likely, so no point in playing the mod.

Dazza
For: A town recruiting group sounds rather bizarre. He could be a cult or even a bizarre mafia claim.
Against: The vote clearing action does not seem likely in a cult

I also blocked him N1, so he couldn't have killed anyone, directly, and he did note he was blocked, so he is likely truthful about the recruition, or at the very least has a role that would be apparent when blocked, ie: mafia cop or some such.

Sheep
For: Known to be part of a faction, his claim of being in a 3 man survivor faction that has no alterior motives is highly unlikely.
Against: Only member of the CMC died night 1, suggesting they don't have a kill. The claim by haggis of busdriver lessons the liklihood of my work around as well.

I'm not sure, if he is a mafia group then it's pretty dumb to come out in the open with just a bit of provocation, but that's WIFOM too, w/e, if nothing better can be done it seems as fine a place as any to get rid of a killing faction.

Pmchugh- Obviously hard to comment on myself but I will try be objective
For: The claim does not seem believable because he would have fake claimed.
Against: He got roleblocked last night.

indeed, knowing all the main chars are taken, it does seem the next logical thing to claim, and even if you are telling the truth about your name, it doesn't mean you can't be mafia with your apparent apprentice Nag/Twilight sparkle according to the wiki, Princess Celestia.

the against means you aren't a SK, if sheep was somehow the mafia I'd say you are fairly clear.

/
For: Has managed to mainly avoid criticism so far and if I was to put my money on a 4th cmc member it would be applejack. (purely from reading the wiki)
Against: Confirmed roleblocker by nag night 1.

I didn't block nag, I blocked dazza, also if I was CMC because sheep is my little sister, then Clever should have been too.

Haggis - Much the same as dazza

I don't know, he might be cult, might not, but with two ponies definitely lying about being killers, I would say a supposed cult is less likely of a priority, and I never really heard of cult successfully recruiting SKs.

TFO
For: Is clearly not a member of the town. His claim is one of the least believable and sheep put forward a decent case against him.
Against: Doctors can be very useful.

So if he's a doc or w/e what was victor? the heck is a "healer" anyways, can you heal a kidnapping? @ Shield can you provide what the dead list on the font page is supposed to look like proper? I'm starting to forget what the dead players roles/names were

Milkshake
For: Has acted the most scummy in game IMO and his claim is rather strange.
Against: His claim is so strange I doubt it was made up.

TFO and I can both confirm the existence of these muffins, and we both ate them, so it should be fine, as disturbing as those videos sheep put up are.

[pmchugh]

Haggis - Much the same as dazza

I don't know, he might be cult, might not, but with two ponies definitely lying about being killers, I would say a supposed cult is less likely of a priority, and I never really heard of cult successfully recruiting SKs.

Actually thinking of this now, has haggis been confirmed to be recruited? It seems like something fir would have told him?

There is also something mysterious going on that I completely forgot amongst haggis's post, I was expecting to claim to be an item giver of sorts. Last night I received an item, yet no one has owned up to giving it to me?

[/]

Haggis - Much the same as dazza

I don't know, he might be cult, might not, but with two ponies definitely lying about being killers, I would say a supposed cult is less likely of a priority, and I never really heard of cult successfully recruiting SKs.

Actually thinking of this now, has haggis been confirmed to be recruited? It seems like something fir would have told him?

There is also something mysterious going on that I completely forgot amongst haggis's post, I was expecting to claim to be an item giver of sorts. Last night I received an item, yet no one has owned up to giving it to me?

Clever was an inventor, so, there's that.
Vote count please?

[TheForgivenOne]

Not much I can say to defend myself that hasn't been said. I have my own WC, but I won't ditch my friends. And we aren't 100% certain that a "Healer" is a doctor. Maybe the "Healer" was intended to heal people (Why would a healer stop kidnappings)? Maybe the Muffins are poisoned and it takes 1 day phase for it to take effect.

Also, what is this item you have gotten pmc? And I do remember milkshake saying he wasn't sure if he was maf/town/third party earlier in the game.

[shieldgenerator7]

replying to requests... hold on a second

[shieldgenerator7]

Official Vote Count:

Pmchung (1) - Haggis
Dazza (1) - Pmchung
Haggis (1) - Sheep

With 8 alive it takes 5 to lynch

Deadlist coming soon

[shieldgenerator7]

Dead
5 Clever - (Rarity - Generous Fashion Giver (Inventor)/Lyncher) - Kidnapped Night 2
13 zimmah - (Spike - Tracker) - Kidnapped Night 2
4 Victor - (Fluttershy - Healer) - Lynched Day 2
3 Soundman - (Chicken - CMC Grunt) - Kidnapped Night 1
6 MeFeDe - (Sweetee Belle - CMC Roleblocker) - Kidnapped Night 1

[pmchugh]

Not much I can say to defend myself that hasn't been said. I have my own WC, but I won't ditch my friends. And we aren't 100% certain that a "Healer" is a doctor. Maybe the "Healer" was intended to heal people (Why would a healer stop kidnappings)? Maybe the Muffins are poisoned and it takes 1 day phase for it to take effect.

Also, what is this item you have gotten pmc? And I do remember milkshake saying he wasn't sure if he was maf/town/third party earlier in the game.

I'd rather not say what it is.

[sheepofdumb]

Not much I can say to defend myself that hasn't been said. I have my own WC, but I won't ditch my friends. And we aren't 100% certain that a "Healer" is a doctor. Maybe the "Healer" was intended to heal people (Why would a healer stop kidnappings)? Maybe the Muffins are poisoned and it takes 1 day phase for it to take effect.

Dead
4 Victor - (Fluttershy - Healer) - Lynched Day 2

Welp, that's all the evidence I need.
Unvote vote TFO

[nagerous]

TFO please divulge further on your role..

[/]

Not much I can say to defend myself that hasn't been said. I have my own WC, but I won't ditch my friends. And we aren't 100% certain that a "Healer" is a doctor. Maybe the "Healer" was intended to heal people (Why would a healer stop kidnappings)? Maybe the Muffins are poisoned and it takes 1 day phase for it to take effect.

Dead
4 Victor - (Fluttershy - Healer) - Lynched Day 2

Welp, that's all the evidence I need.
Unvote vote TFO

i'm sorry, did I miss something? what was the evidence provided by TFO speculating on Victor's role?

[sheepofdumb]

I think I jumped the gun again. I need to stop doing that. I still think TFO is one of the killers so my vote stays.

[/]

I noticed there are characters involved in all the scenes, can we tell who is or isn't in the game by going through them?

[pmchugh]

Not much I can say to defend myself that hasn't been said. I have my own WC, but I won't ditch my friends. And we aren't 100% certain that a "Healer" is a doctor. Maybe the "Healer" was intended to heal people (Why would a healer stop kidnappings)? Maybe the Muffins are poisoned and it takes 1 day phase for it to take effect.

Dead
4 Victor - (Fluttershy - Healer) - Lynched Day 2

Welp, that's all the evidence I need.
Unvote vote TFO

Wut

[TheForgivenOne]

TFO please divulge further on your role..

There isn't much further that I can say without getting modkilled. All it says, is that I am Rainbow Dash, [insert WC here]. However, you wont' ditch your friends so I can visit 1 ponies house per night to attempt to stop the kidnapping (If it was to happen).

Unless Fircoal made some sort of bastard part to my role that he isn't including, that's all I know.

[pmchugh]

Did you just quote your role pm?

[pmchugh]

Please can we have a lynch/deadline or something, this game is moving slower than a day in the jail.

[/]

I noticed there are characters involved in all the scenes, can we tell who is or isn't in the game by going through them?

LAZY ASSES PONIES, Fine i'll do it

Players

show

Scenes

Names in red

opening scene

show

Day 1

show

Night 1

show

Day 2, not really a scene, skipped

Night 2

show

so in the end, Derpy, Mayor and Princess Celestia are not mentioned, the others are there by flavor, and sheep is probably scum, vote sheep

[TheForgivenOne]

One thing I noticed, is that of all the ponies listed in all the scenes, Bon-Bon is the only one that hasn't been used (Or, well, claimed).

But personally, I don't trust the Derpy for whatever reason. Vote: Crazy

[TheForgivenOne]

One thing I noticed, is that of all the ponies listed in all the scenes, Bon-Bon is the only one that hasn't been used (Or, well, claimed).

But personally, I don't trust the Derpy for whatever reason. Vote: Crazy

EBWOP; By whatever reason, I mean it's just a nagging feeling in the back of my ponybrain.

[crazymilkshake5]

One thing I noticed, is that of all the ponies listed in all the scenes, Bon-Bon is the only one that hasn't been used (Or, well, claimed).

But personally, I don't trust the Derpy for whatever reason. Vote: Crazy

EBWOP; By whatever reason, I mean it's just a nagging feeling in the back of my ponybrain.

Was it the muffins?

[crazymilkshake5]

That claim seems legit. Lietz is milkshake is he not? Milkshake claims next IMO.

oh thats right, lol i am Leitz, well, I am Derp, the mail pony, and i haz special letter, I dont know what it does, I can give it to one person each night.

That claim seems legit. Lietz is milkshake is he not? Milkshake claims next IMO.

oh thats right, lol i am Leitz, well, I am Derp, the mail pony, and i haz special letter, I dont know what it does, I can give it to one person each night.

So who have you given one to each night?

Its only 1 letter, I'm assuming that i get it back each night if the intended recipient doesnt receive it. Last night i gave it to TFO, and i dont remember who i gave it to N1. I think i might have given it to you or PMC N1

Um, it says I got a muffin

First off, I claim Derpy, mail pony, I say i gave it to TFO, then TFO says he got a muffin. IMO thats proof enough of my role being Legit.

[dazza2008]

That claim seems legit. Lietz is milkshake is he not? Milkshake claims next IMO.

oh thats right, lol i am Leitz, well, I am Derp, the mail pony, and i haz special letter, I dont know what it does, I can give it to one person each night.

That claim seems legit. Lietz is milkshake is he not? Milkshake claims next IMO.

oh thats right, lol i am Leitz, well, I am Derp, the mail pony, and i haz special letter, I dont know what it does, I can give it to one person each night.

So who have you given one to each night?

Its only 1 letter, I'm assuming that i get it back each night if the intended recipient doesnt receive it. Last night i gave it to TFO, and i dont remember who i gave it to N1. I think i might have given it to you or PMC N1

Um, it says I got a muffin

First off, I claim Derpy, mail pony, I say i gave it to TFO, then TFO says he got a muffin. IMO thats proof enough of my role being Legit.

Yeah but we still don't know what the muffins do.

[TheForgivenOne]

That claim seems legit. Lietz is milkshake is he not? Milkshake claims next IMO.

oh thats right, lol i am Leitz, well, I am Derp, the mail pony, and i haz special letter, I dont know what it does, I can give it to one person each night.

That claim seems legit. Lietz is milkshake is he not? Milkshake claims next IMO.

oh thats right, lol i am Leitz, well, I am Derp, the mail pony, and i haz special letter, I dont know what it does, I can give it to one person each night.

So who have you given one to each night?

Its only 1 letter, I'm assuming that i get it back each night if the intended recipient doesnt receive it. Last night i gave it to TFO, and i dont remember who i gave it to N1. I think i might have given it to you or PMC N1

Um, it says I got a muffin

First off, I claim Derpy, mail pony, I say i gave it to TFO, then TFO says he got a muffin. IMO thats proof enough of my role being Legit.

Doesn't mean you are with town. You said you have a special letter. Nothing about a muffin.