MLP: Friendship is MAFIA! ENDGAME: DISCORD & PINKIE WIN!

[pmchugh]

I am Applejack, roleblocker, I was the one who blacked dazza N1, I figured the cop would investigate him, so if he turned up 3rd party rather than town; he would be cult and I might as well lessen the damage rather than have an unknown recruit running around.
Last night I blocked PMC, no reason really, I just targeted him at random.

Also I've been soft-hinting at my identity from the start, just do an advance search for the word "honest" or "honestly" with "/" as the author.

You bastard.. you stopped me from doing... nothing! What was your partial win condition achieved last night?

I hate fircoal, this game is screwing with my head. I wonder if fake claims were given to mafia or if the characters which are mafia are disguised as ordinary ponies. I think we need a review of claims.

1 Pmchung- Celestia, Beloved Princess
2 Nagerous- TWighlight, Cop
7 Dazza- Mayor, Town Recruiter
8 Sheep- CMC Protector
9 /- Applejack, Roleblocker
10 Haggis - Pinkie Pie, No role claim
11 TFO- Rainbow Dash, psuedoDoc
12 milkshake- Derp, Sends Letters and want muffins?

I think the most suspicious to me so far are sheep (i think its likely his faction had a kill), milkshake as I just don't understand his claim and I am still quite worried about dazza being a cult leader (game would be over by tomorrow) but we have at least two killers out there as well and identifying these should be a priority even if we do end up lynching daz.

[nagerous]

TFO, Haggis + /'s claims seem the most solid to me.

That was very crafty of you claiming last pmchugh - http://mlp.wikia.com/wiki/Characters

You had a whole list here to pick from and knew at that point you couldn't be counter-claimed. For fircoal to make a princess a beloved princess seems a bit lazy for him, I wouldn't necessarily have picked it. I also know, you would know that lynching a beloved princess would be a mistake and therefore it would not necessarily be the town's first choice in risk taking. Perhaps if you were really a beloved princess you may have fake claimed something else, like bulletproof townie, in order to avoid the bullet at night as now you have a big target on your back (if you are town) which quite possibly means this is our last day...

What do you have in your favour however is / blocked you and there were still two kills, this therefore gives me confidence that you are possibly in fact town.

Dazza and sheep are also good cases, but dazza was roleblocked night 1, and there were still two kills, which also adds credence to his defence.

Finally sheep, his faction having a kill, seems all well and good a possibility but... we know that the first night two of his team went down, would he really use the gun on his own men to bolster his own defence? Seems somewhat sadistic and dangerous.

That leaves me at milkshake, who is the character I am least confident with. On the character listing, he is counted as a miscellaneous character - now I am not sad as f*ck (no offence) so I have never seen this tv show and I am not going to bother in order to research for this game, although the temptation it seems there, but it seems odd to have a minor character in the game, when there are plenty it seems of other options.

[nagerous]

Also, haggis can you provide your thoughts besides a claim? Your unwillingness to contribute makes me suspicious and I'd like to know more about your role.

[pmchugh]

TFO, Haggis + /'s claims seem the most solid to me.

That was very crafty of you claiming last pmchugh - http://mlp.wikia.com/wiki/Characters

You had a whole list here to pick from and knew at that point you couldn't be counter-claimed. For fircoal to make a princess a beloved princess seems a bit lazy for him, I wouldn't necessarily have picked it. I also know, you would know that lynching a beloved princess would be a mistake and therefore it would not necessarily be the town's first choice in risk taking. Perhaps if you were really a beloved princess you may have fake claimed something else, like bulletproof townie, in order to avoid the bullet at night as now you have a big target on your back (if you are town) which quite possibly means this is our last day...

What do you have in your favour however is / blocked you and there were still two kills, this therefore gives me confidence that you are possibly in fact town.

Dazza and sheep are also good cases, but dazza was roleblocked night 1, and there were still two kills, which also adds credence to his defence.

Finally sheep, his faction having a kill, seems all well and good a possibility but... we know that the first night two of his team went down, would he really use the gun on his own men to bolster his own defence? Seems somewhat sadistic and dangerous.

That leaves me at milkshake, who is the character I am least confident with. On the character listing, he is counted as a miscellaneous character - now I am not sad as f*ck (no offence) so I have never seen this tv show and I am not going to bother in order to research for this game, although the temptation it seems there, but it seems odd to have a minor character in the game, when there are plenty it seems of other options.

I gave everyone plenty of encouragement to question the lists and say I should go first. Also you answered your own point in this post. I wasn't going to come out and claim, putting a large target on my own back when it was very likely we would catch someone else lying (i presume many mafia). I also thought my role was unfair on town given that we have two kills, although this could explain why we have 2 doctors. TFO please protect me tonight. Perhaps you were right about the fact I should have fake claimed though.

I want to know what win condition was met by /.

Also as you rightly point out I am cleared of last nights killings, and dazza of night 1's killings and unless I am missing something sheep is also cleared of night one killings. This leads me to believe that fir has either given mafia fake claims or there is a hidden faction amongst the towny named players. Well actually I have a better idea than that, if / would answer my question.

[/]

I apologize, but that rule 5 that crazy pointed out on the front page does say "win condition and death role (If there are in this game.) must be kept private", just look at the timing of when I said I won and you might be able to figure it out with a looser definition of known roles.

[pmchugh]

I apologize, but that rule 5 that crazy pointed out on the front page does say "win condition and death role (If there are in this game.) must be kept private", just look at the timing of when I said I won and you might be able to figure it out with a looser definition of known roles.

Ok well my theory was that you had to kill the lyncher, who was targetting you. This would explain away one of the kills, did you have a night kill?

[/]

I apologize, but that rule 5 that crazy pointed out on the front page does say "win condition and death role (If there are in this game.) must be kept private", just look at the timing of when I said I won and you might be able to figure it out with a looser definition of known roles.

Ok well my theory was that you had to kill the lyncher, who was targetting you. This would explain away one of the kills, did you have a night kill?

I have no night kill, roleblock is my only action and I am not aware of who kidnapped the lyncher, weather or not I would thank them for it.

[pmchugh]

Mk well there goes that idea. I'm getting impatient. Based on the two kills we are getting I can come to no conclusion other than that pancake must have a kill. Otherwise the numbers just seem shallow. Other than that my money would be on milkshake as an SK and I still don't trust dazza, who did you recruit?

[crazymilkshake5]

Lol bro, all i ask for is one night.

[TheForgivenOne]

Lol bro, all i ask for is one night.

If I turn into a cow because of this...

[crazymilkshake5]

im going to target myself, have a tracker track me.

[dazza2008]

im going to target myself, have a tracker track me.

Is there a tracker?

Mk well there goes that idea. I'm getting impatient. Based on the two kills we are getting I can come to no conclusion other than that pancake must have a kill. Otherwise the numbers just seem shallow. Other than that my money would be on milkshake as an SK and I still don't trust dazza, who did you recruit?

I recruited Haggis.

[pmchugh]

OK So apparently we have:

Some weird third party:
Milkshake- BTW what happens when you win, are you removed from the game? I am still not sure I buy your "one night" thing but I am not sure we have much choice to believe it or not at this stage.

Ordinary townies:
pmc
nag
TFO
/

Cult, I mean Town mason group:
Dazza
Haggis

CMC:
pancake

I don't know if we can actually win now. Our only hope is the roleblocker I think. I reckon pancake is scum in the very least and dazza is probably a cult- I very much doubt a town recruiter. If I am right and we lynch pancake and roleblock dazza then tomorrow we will wake up with: 2 Culties, 1 Killer, 2 Townies. Its likely that mafia/SK will kill TFO and give us only one day remaining. From there we have to lynch dazza and block the killer and on the next day we then lynch the correctly blocked killer. Finally if the game isn't over we lynch haggis on the last day.

Does that all make sense as a plan?

[pmchugh]

Actually that wont work if milkshake wins tomorrow. My head hurts trying to think about this.

[dazza2008]

I am confused. Why are you talking about pancake?

Anyway, there have been 2 kils every night. Are we any closer to working that out?

[crazymilkshake5]

False, I'm town, not weird third party. and it does not say what happens when i get my muffins...

[pmchugh]

I am confused. Why are you talking about pancake?

Anyway, there have been 2 kils every night. Are we any closer to working that out?

Sorry I meant sheep

I reckon sheep is responsible for one, the other I am not sure of atm. I was suspicious of milkshake but he is sounding more legit now, his fake claim is a little too bizarre to be made up. I think we are pretty fucked from whatever direction we go at it. We need a lot of things to go our way. Haggis might be a decent lynch, he has the potential both to be a killer and a cult member.

[nagerous]

I still think we should lynch milkshake, his claim does not seem genuine at all.

Also, no reason to lynch haggis - if we were to lynch a cult member for being cult we would have to go for the leader (Dazza).

[nagerous]

I still think we should lynch milkshake, his claim does not seem genuine at all.

Also, no reason to lynch haggis - if we were to lynch a cult member for being cult we would have to go for the leader (Dazza).

Sorry I just saw the block comment, I am coming around to lynching dazza.

[pmchugh]

I still think we should lynch milkshake, his claim does not seem genuine at all.

Also, no reason to lynch haggis - if we were to lynch a cult member for being cult we would have to go for the leader (Dazza).

The idea was that haggis might be a killer and in a cult. It would tell us whether dazza should be killed and it could also remove a killer. It's a high risk move but I think we need something high risk with 2 killers and a cult, why the f*ck didn't we just lynch dazza day 1

Admittedly the chacnes of Haggis being a killer aren't high.

[pmchugh]

Screw it unvote vote dazza. We need rid of the cult tonight and with roleblocker, cop and doctor we have a decent chance of getting the killers tomorrow.

[crazymilkshake5]

I also dont like the fact that there is a cult, but I will restrain my vote until dazza speaks.

[sheepofdumb]

I'm going to call bull on Pmc. First off he claims last. That claim being beloved princess. Now that's a role you don't want dead. That claim puts doubt in the towns mind and buys him some time. While he wasn't the first to suggest the mass claim he certainly made it happen. Now the whole town is laid bare for the killers the take out. The killers only need two nights to take out the cop. Finally, he's been leading discussion and laying out a lynch plan. This is peaking my scumdar.

Unvote Vote PMC

[dazza2008]

I also dont like the fact that there is a cult, but I will restrain my vote until dazza speaks.

There is not a cult. There is someone accusing me of being a cult leader but he is paranoid and wrong or he is the scumbag we are looking for. I think he is scum.

Vote pmc

[TheForgivenOne]

I also dont like the fact that there is a cult, but I will restrain my vote until dazza speaks.

There is not a cult. There is someone accusing me of being a cult leader but he is paranoid and wrong or he is the scumbag we are looking for. I think he is scum.

Vote pmc

Yeah, but isn't that exactly what a Cult group would say?

And yes, I find it hard to believe the claim of Beloved Princess. And holy tits Haggis needs to put in some input.