Soundman's First Mafia [End] Arsonist Wins!!

[skillfusniper33]

a little confused about the Arsonist, please xplain more?

Basically a SK. So they have the option each night, to douse someone, or ignite the players doused. So basically they can try and line up several people for one night, then kill everyone off.

http://mafiascum.net/wiki/index.php?title=Arsonist

[thehippo8]

Frankly I should have guessed there was an arsonist, with two nights and no killings I should have guessed the mafia were expended. I simply didn't think to go back and look at the original set-up, my bad. Having said that, even if I had worked out that there was an arsonist there was nothing I could do. I didn't suspect Rodion at all, clever play and nothing scummy. My pick was Chap and I would have left Rodion to the last. Good game, lots of fun and I enjoyed the involvement by all. A chatty Mafia game is a good Mafia game!! Well done Soundman.

[isaiah40]

It was a good first day. Too bad the doc didn't protect me, but oh well maybe next time!! Good game!! Thanks soundman!! Whens your next one!?

[soundman]

Thanks guys, glad you liked it! I actually have another in the works. It'll be a themed game and hopefully even more fun than this one.

[TheGeneral2112]

Investigation proof Arsonist is a bit OP with 5 non town roles. Perhaps next time we will learn from this that follow the cop is not a good idea I had hoped with enough time with the "failing" kills you could all sort it out, I did not suspect an arsonist till too late. General, I share a large amount of responsibility for the town loss but take me killing you as a sign of respect. You, Rodion and I were the 3 people I suspected of being able to fool the town for long enough to win as a loner. I chose you because if I did not town was just going to go after you like the did for me. In retrospect perhaps it would have been better to kill another and let the cop (who I wrongly assumed naive) follow through with an investigation.

I'm still bitter. Give me time to get over my loss.

[thehippo8]

Thanks guys, glad you liked it! I actually have another in the works. It'll be a themed game and hopefully even more fun than this one.

If that is possible ... this was pretty darn good!!

[crazymilkshake5]

That it was! i will definitely join the next one! (or at least try!)

[Victor Sullivan]

I still can't believe TheGeneral somehow turned my simple comment(s) into a case against me! I was seriously not being scummy! Whenever I'm town, I always look scummy, but have rarely been lynched Day 1. This game I'm not and I'm lynched! I need to stick to third parties; I do far better playing those roles, haha.

-Sully

[TheGeneral2112]

I still can't believe TheGeneral somehow turned my simple comment(s) into a case against me! I was seriously not being scummy! Whenever I'm town, I always look scummy, but have rarely been lynched Day 1. This game I'm not and I'm lynched! I need to stick to third parties; I do far better playing those roles, haha.

-Sully

I have the gift of persuasion. I can convince others to vote with me. I lack the discretion necessary to pick a good lynch though. This game, I picked fairly well.

[thehippo8]

Crikey, there's more chatter after the game than during it ... lol ... no seriously this was a good chatty game!

[safariguy5]

Investigation proof Arsonist is a bit OP with 5 non town roles. Perhaps next time we will learn from this that follow the cop is not a good idea I had hoped with enough time with the "failing" kills you could all sort it out, I did not suspect an arsonist till too late. General, I share a large amount of responsibility for the town loss but take me killing you as a sign of respect. You, Rodion and I were the 3 people I suspected of being able to fool the town for long enough to win as a loner. I chose you because if I did not town was just going to go after you like the did for me. In retrospect perhaps it would have been better to kill another and let the cop (who I wrongly assumed naive) follow through with an investigation.

You know, I wondered about how to balance arsonist, but I figured it's basically a modified SKer because the kills are on delay. I figured people would have been able to suspect possible foul play with a few non death nights. Also, if a doused person is NKed or lynched, the arsonist is deprived of his kill.

If it was a bit OP for arsonist, then I admit to not really using it often, but I figured town had a decent chance to win at the end too. Mafia were a bit screwed by GF getting lynched Day 1 lol.

[TeeGee]

It was a good first day. Too bad the doc didn't protect me, but oh well maybe next time!! Good game!! Thanks soundman!! Whens your next one!?

That was a huge noob mistake by me, and it cost me big time..

But thanks for letting me play my 1st mafia game, I learnt lots and had fun at the same time

[soundman]

The only thing I didn't like about the game was the silencer. Originally I thought it would have more of an impact on the game (silencing select people to push the game in whatever direction they wanted) but all it really seemed to do was drop activity. Though it did keep suspicion off of Mr. S and CMS for a bit since everyone knew they couldn't talk much so didn't bother going after them. I'd leave it out of my future games.

Oh, and VTs... Don't like VTs...

[isaiah40]

It was a good first day. Too bad the doc didn't protect me, but oh well maybe next time!! Good game!! Thanks soundman!! Whens your next one!?

That was a huge noob mistake by me, and it cost me big time..

But thanks for letting me play my 1st mafia game, I learnt lots and had fun at the same time

Not a problem, we all make mistakes in our first game.