Soundman's First Mafia [End] Arsonist Wins!!

[chapcrap]

Sorry that you had to claim that role Sully. If no one counter claims, it's mostly believable in a game this size. There aren't always Town Watchers, so if he were mafia, it would be a safer claim than other things, but I would bet we have a watcher. We can verify it with who he watches.

And I wouldn't be surprised if I turn up dead tomorrow, assuming you guys don't lynch me anyway.

Thanks, General. 'Preciate it.

-Sully

Time to switch it round then ...

Unvote vote General ... asside from bluster what else are you giving us?

unvote vote TheGeneral2112

I agree with hippo. Unless we get multiple town claims, a day 1 lynch is needed.

[TeeGee]

Sorry that you had to claim that role Sully. If no one counter claims, it's mostly believable in a game this size. There aren't always Town Watchers, so if he were mafia, it would be a safer claim than other things, but I would bet we have a watcher. We can verify it with who he watches.

And I wouldn't be surprised if I turn up dead tomorrow, assuming you guys don't lynch me anyway.

Thanks, General. 'Preciate it.

-Sully

Time to switch it round then ...

Unvote vote General ... asside from bluster what else are you giving us?

unvote vote TheGeneral2112

I agree with hippo. Unless we get multiple town claims, a day 1 lynch is needed.

Have to agree, even though I am very much a noob, slowly starting to sort this game

unvote vote TheGeneral2112

[isaiah40]

I don't believe sully is the town watcher. I have a hunch that Sully is using that as a fake claim - and I hate to do this on Day1 - because I am the Town Watcher.

[zimmah]

I don't believe sully is the town watcher. I have a hunch that Sully is using that as a fake claim - and I hate to do this on Day1 - because I am the Town Watcher.

unvote vote sully if i haven't allready.

[chapcrap]

I don't believe sully is the town watcher. I have a hunch that Sully is using that as a fake claim - and I hate to do this on Day1 - because I am the Town Watcher.

Well!! In that case, unvote vote Sully. Can't do much against a counter claim.

For noobs, this basically requires a lynch and when Sully is lynched, if he is town watcher, then isaiah40 is in trouble tomorrow. Looks like we caught a scum though.

[maximumbandit]

I can get behind that as well. Isaiah40 would be completely screwed if he says "I'm the town watcher," and then the town watcher gets lynched.

Though - do the mafia know everyone's roles? I mean - wouldn't they want to off the people who can best identify them? (Asking this may be to my detriment, but this is indeed my first mafia game.)

unvote vote Sully

[MoB Deadly]

unvote vote VS - because of counterclaim

[thehippo8]

I don't believe sully is the town watcher. I have a hunch that Sully is using that as a fake claim - and I hate to do this on Day1 - because I am the Town Watcher.

Before I follow blindly; can you please explain to me what you mean when you say

I have a hunch.

Are you saying that there could be more than on Town Watcher, in which case crikey that's a new one, or are you really saying

ooh look, here's a chance to bamboozle, I will do a fake claim myself and see if that get's sully lynched.

Give me a good response to that and I will vote sully again, otherwise you have some quick explaining to do!!

Click image to enlarge.

[chapcrap]

I can get behind that as well. Isaiah40 would be completely screwed if he says "I'm the town watcher," and then the town watcher gets lynched.

Though - do the mafia know everyone's roles? I mean - wouldn't they want to off the people who can best identify them? (Asking this may be to my detriment, but this is indeed my first mafia game.)

unvote vote Sully

Mafia only know each other. And they don't always know each other's roles. They have to tell each other what their roles are. They aren't allowed to talk until the night.

Also, nice to see you all of a sudden. Don't think I have forgotten that your last post was almost a week ago.

FASTPOSTED twice

[chapcrap]

I don't believe sully is the town watcher. I have a hunch that Sully is using that as a fake claim - and I hate to do this on Day1 - because I am the Town Watcher.

Before I follow blindly; can you please explain to me what you mean when you say

I have a hunch.

Are you saying that there could be more than on Town Watcher, in which case crikey that's a new one, or are you really saying

ooh look, here's a chance to bamboozle, I will do a fake claim myself and see if that get's sully lynched.

Give me a good response to that and I will vote sully again, otherwise you have some quick explaining to do!!

Click image to enlarge.

He may be lying, but it's highly unlikely. It is a very bad idea to lie like this. If he isn't lying, we're probably lynching scum. If he is lying, then he is probably scum and we lycnch him tomorrow. That's a win-win for the town. Trading one town for one mafia is something I would do every day of the week. And twice on Sundays.

[maximumbandit]

Mafia only know each other. And they don't always know each other's roles. They have to tell each other what their roles are. They aren't allowed to talk until the night.

Also, nice to see you all of a sudden. Don't think I have forgotten that your last post was almost a week ago.

FASTPOSTED twice

Nice to see you too, Chapcrap.

[zimmah]

doubt there's two watchers in a 14 man game, so yes, either VS or isaiah is scum.

[Victor Sullivan]

Whoa whoa whoa! No no, I am the Town Watcher!

That was a stupid move, isaiah, even if the town lynches me and finds out who the real Watcher is.

unvote vote isaiah40

-Sully

[zimmah]

Whoa whoa whoa! No no, I am the Town Watcher!

That was a stupid move, isaiah, even if the town lynches me and finds out who the real Watcher is.

unvote vote isaiah40

-Sully

i begin to doubt if we shouldn't do a no lynch today and see who claims to have watched who, based on their claims we can lynch one of them. maybe that way we'll even get more information, and may possibly avoid a misslynch too.

[chapcrap]

Whoa whoa whoa! No no, I am the Town Watcher!

That was a stupid move, isaiah, even if the town lynches me and finds out who the real Watcher is.

unvote vote isaiah40

-Sully

i begin to doubt if we shouldn't do a no lynch today and see who claims to have watched who, based on their claims we can lynch one of them. maybe that way we'll even get more information, and may possibly avoid a misslynch too.

That is a bad idea. Mafia and busdrive someone, can switch people so that when watched or investigated, they show up differently. There are too many ways for the town to lose out.

[thehippo8]

Whoa whoa whoa! No no, I am the Town Watcher!

That was a stupid move, isaiah, even if the town lynches me and finds out who the real Watcher is.

unvote vote isaiah40

-Sully

i begin to doubt if we shouldn't do a no lynch today and see who claims to have watched who, based on their claims we can lynch one of them. maybe that way we'll even get more information, and may possibly avoid a misslynch too.

smart idea zimmah ... the VS / 2112 drama has been fun but frankly unhelpful. This new issue is definitely far more relevant. It is interesting that Isaiah has not responded yet but I am also leaning towards the no lynch idea unless we can have something more concrete to go on.

Looking back at the log, Isaiah has been anti sully from day one (first vote by isiah was against sully), Isaiah then inexplicably said

I am _____________

Then Isaiah dallied about the TeeGee thing before landing straight back on sully again. Definitely FOS Isaiah but is that enough information for anything more. Sully on the other hand has been under constant attack and has squirmed like a squirmy thing. Is that enough to FOS? Certainly a tricky one!!

Click image to enlarge.

[thehippo8]

Mind you, I should add that Sully said

EVEN IF the town lynches me and finds out who the real Watcher is

So I'll put my money where my mouth is and stick tounvote vote VS

[MoB Deadly]

I am ____________.

Let's see, 12 spaces...

Town cop? nope, thats 8

Town doctor? nope, thats 11

mafia doctor? *Gasp* 12! unvote vote isaiah40

Thanks for the confession

*Ahem* Town Watcher - thats 12 characters people. My vote stays on Sully.

[Rodion]

Victor was counterclaimed, the decision can't get any easier.

Unvote, vote VS.

If Victor flips town watcher, just lynch Isaiah D2 (if he makes it that far).

[soundman]

Vote Count:

Rodion -
Zimmah -
Mob Deadly -
Victor Sullivan - General, isaiah, Zimmah, Chapcrap, maximumbandit, Mob, thehippo, Rodion - (Lynch)
Mr. Squirrel -
Shieldgenerator7 -
Chapcrap - usAir - (L7)
Crazymilkshake5 -
usAir -
isaiah40 - Mr. Squirrel, Victor - (L6)
TeeGee -
thehippo8 -
maximumbandit -
TheGeneral2112 - TeeGee - (L7)

With 14 alive it takes 8 to lynch.

[soundman]

The sound of an argument slowly attracted the townspeople like flies to ointment. "You're too aggressive and are trying to get a townie lynched!" yelled the one named Sully. "Am not! You're the one with no real evidence!" replied General.
A few of the townspeople jumped in with the General thinking Victor's crusade against him was a little scummy. A few others agreed with Victor. However with the day almost at its end they where starting to get nervous. "We need to get some information and quick. Let's just add some pressure and get a claim."

"Fine, fine. I'm the town watcher. Satisfied?" said Victor as he sat on a horse, hangman's noose around his neck. "Can you get me down now?"

"Liar!" shouted isaiah, "I'm the real watcher!" This caused a flurry of activity among the townsfolk. Could isaiah be lying? "If he is then we'll get him tomorrow." said Rodion as he stepped forward and slapped the horse.

Victor Sullivan Mafia Godfather has been lynched.

It is now Night 1. Night will last 48 hours unless I receive all the night actions sooner than that.

[isaiah40]

*Watches the mafia godfather dangle at the end of the rope and thinks to himself, it's been a long day, time to get some sleep*

[Victor Sullivan]

The funny part is I forgot I was Mafia Godfather up until the time I had to claim, then I was like, "SHIT!"

-Sully

[MoB Deadly]

The funny part is I forgot I was Mafia Godfather up until the time I had to claim, then I was like, "SHIT!"

-Sully

[TheGeneral2112]

The funny part is I forgot I was Mafia Godfather up until the time I had to claim, then I was like, "SHIT!"

-Sully

Sorry, Sully. How's that coffin tasting?