Battle of Attrition WWI (FINISHED)Winners in 1st post

[nebsmith]

Winners - nolefan5311 & Egel

One year Premium to each member of the surviving team

1. 11 Round limit on the games.
2. Each team will start with 60,001 troops
3. The winners are the last team to have any troops left.

Settings
Auto
Sequential
Flat Rate & Escalating
Chained
Foggy & Sunny

show: teams

show: maps in order of play

show: format

show: troop losses

show: the final battle

show: extra rules

An up to date troop count will be kept in the next post

[nebsmith]

show

Troop Counts
Link to all First Campaign Games

show: the first campaign

Link to all Second Campaign Games

show: the second campaign

Link to all Final Campaign Games

show: the final campaign

[nolefan5311]

nolefan5311
Egel

Thanks!

[Serbia]

Sorry, but with the point system drawn up the way it is, this tourney will not work. In Round 6, the winning team is still losing fewer troops than the losing team is, but in Round 7, you're actually PUNISHING the team that wins, by causing them to lose armies. Which completely removes the incentive to win the game. In fact, you're better off losing the game in 12 rounds than you are winning in 5.

The "troop losses" will have to be re-worked, to eliminate the advantage given to the loser.

[nebsmith]

Responding to Serbia has made me realise that it is actually an 11 round limit on games.
I think the scoring system is ok and have added in an extra table to make the troops lost by both teams clearer.

Waiting to hear back from Serbia to see if I have answered his concerns.

[nebsmith]

All ok - open for sign-ups

[Serbia]

My answer to nebsmith (from pm conversation)

I think the updated score looks fine now. This way, you still get a benefit for winning the game. I wouldn't even mind if the scoring was closer in later rounds, I just don't think it was right to give the advantage to the team that loses.

Short story - looks good to me, thanks!

[giannikas]

giannikas and Liveoak, thanks

[TheMoge]

In please!

TheMoge
Markus Oralius

[chapcrap]

me and happyfeet

[blonderic]

in please, blonderic,alexlau

[Viskehesteren]

In plz

Struer + Viskehesteren

[aaronvollrath]

in please:
aaronvollrath
patrickaa317

[General Bax]

psychosos & general bax

[silversun6]

in plz

silversun6 & benga

[bcoop]

in please
pajarito and bcoop

[nebsmith]

Sorry about the delay on this one but I had stopped checking it as there were no sign-ups for a couple of weeks.

All in except the last 2 teams, I will use you as reserves if we get any first round dissapearences.

Now Full and awaiting privs.

[TheMoge]

Hey I don't think you're doing your math quite right here, we won in Round 6, so shouldn't we have only lost 1200 troops? You have us listed as having lost 2000 troops.

[nebsmith]

Sorry about that - I did have you down as losing 1200 but typed a 0 instead of an 8. I will be more careful in future.

[mcshanester29]

Still Active

[nebsmith]

Thank you mcshanester29

[mcshanester29]

This Tournament is Still Active

[mcshanester29]

This Tournament is Still Active

[nebsmith]

Ok - the second campaign is ready to go.

[nebsmith]

still active