Stool Pigeon Mafia - Game Over! Mafia Win!!! MVP- Zimmah

[wildwilliam]

.

Normally it is best to lynch the inactives in my games, as I cannot always guarantee replacements.

???

inactives will make it harder to get a lynch because the inactives do count as 'alive'. so if 30% of the players is inactive, a lynch with the remaining 70% will be much harder. that's why lynching inactives before they become a problem is a viable idea.

on top of that are inactives sometimes just mafia that's scared of posting because they might actually accidently make a wrong post or make a post that might get someone's attention.

This makes sense only if you prod them and they respond. If you prod them and then they say nothing and get replaced, that just seems to me like they have a crap vanilla role.

Not to mention if you lynch a non acitve and they are vanilla, you lose 2 town roles (1 at night) and start d2 down 2. Seems odd to me.

and what if you can't find any replacements? then they're just dead meat.

which is why they should be mod killed. At least that way you are down 1 not 2.

[Victor Sullivan]

Whoa, whoa! Settle down, folks! Sully's been away from his computer for a few days is all. I've got a fair few things I still need to catch up on, but I don't suspect I'll be returning anytime late.

-Sully

[safariguy5]

Vote Count

hippo(3)- eldario, chap, shield

zimmah(3)- pancake, conozo, edoc

Sully (4)- hippo, zimmah, Mob, dazza


With 21 alive, it takes 11 to lynch.

[FoxMists]

Whoa, whoa! Settle down, folks! Sully's been away from his computer for a few days is all. I've got a fair few things I still need to catch up on, but I don't suspect I'll be returning anytime late.

-Sully

*sigh* This is hardly encouraging. Could you possibly be a bit more vague? Is "anytime late" in a the next week? The next month? I barely have time to make it here either. Suck it up, Princess...

[wildwilliam]

Whoa, whoa! Settle down, folks! Sully's been away from his computer for a few days is all. I've got a fair few things I still need to catch up on, but I don't suspect I'll be returning anytime late.

-Sully

*sigh* This is hardly encouraging. Could you possibly be a bit more vague? Is "anytime late" in a the next week? The next month? I barely have time to make it here either. Suck it up, Princess...

agreed

vote victor sullivan until I here from you.

[shieldgenerator7]

yay! Sully's back! hurrah!

I find his pop in and out scummy because he seems to be excusing his submarining, but I think he's really just busy IRL and needs a break. He's usually quite active.

Back in mah' day, when someone pops in to say 'hello' ever'one says 'hello' to 'em!

-SG7 ( )

[trinicardinal]

yay! Sully's back! hurrah!

I find his pop in and out scummy because he seems to be excusing his submarining, but I think he's really just busy IRL and needs a break. He's usually quite active.

Back in mah' day, when someone pops in to say 'hello' ever'one says 'hello' to 'em!

-SG7 ( )

lol... Sully has definitely been busy... we had a really long night in the mafia games that he's hosting for the mods... went way longer than it should have... his posts there matches the timing in the posts here I believe so i'd say its safe to accept busy in rl for the long time between posts. I'm still trying to figure out some of the studf from a few pages back... have to make some time for a solid read I guess

[terrafutan]

Is the speed of the mafia games in CC always like this ?

Seems a little slow to me.

Reading back, I think hippo is trying to hard to paint others as scummy, so

unvote vote hippo

[thehippo8]

Is the speed of the mafia games in CC always like this ?

Seems a little slow to me.

Reading back, I think hippo is trying to hard to paint others as scummy, so

unvote vote hippo

hooray and we are back on!

Sorry terra, just trying to find something useful to grasp onto. In a way you are right though, the point of the game is to find the scum. There are now three players in my sights, Jens, Sully and now you. I still say let's remove Jens as that will both help the town and I believe help unravel the mathematical puzzle posed by edoc. FOS terra.

[trinicardinal]

I still have to unravel that mathematical puzzle... time is the problem

[shieldgenerator7]

uh... I still want a claim from Hippo, but terrafutan that vote seemed very BandWagon. You didn't really support your case much. It was a nice try tho, but you seem scummy by the fact your post doesn't contain much contain on why or how he did, or why "painting others as scummy" is a scummy thing to do. FOS terrafutan. Try again.

Back in mah' day, no one accus'd anyone without a dosh garn good reason!

-SG7 ( )

[thehippo8]

uh... I still want a claim from Hippo, but terrafutan that vote seemed very BandWagon. You didn't really support your case much. It was a nice try tho, but you seem scummy by the fact your post doesn't contain much contain on why or how he did, or why "painting others as scummy" is a scummy thing to do. FOS terrafutan. Try again.

Back in mah' day, no one accus'd anyone without a dosh garn good reason!

-SG7 ( )

Hi again sg7 ... I claimed a while back ... but again for emphasis ... I an vanilla townie! Hence my concern on catching scum and suspicious on annyone who thinks otherwise!

On a lighter note ... COME ON you lot ... far too little chatter!

[MoB Deadly]

so you do not have any info you could give us?

[safariguy5]

Vote Count

hippo(4)- eldario, chap, shield, terrafutan

zimmah(3)- pancake, conozo, edoc

Sully (5)- hippo, zimmah, Mob, dazza, wildwilliam


With 21 alive, it takes 11 to lynch.

[shieldgenerator7]

uh... I still want a claim from Hippo, but terrafutan that vote seemed very BandWagon. You didn't really support your case much. It was a nice try tho, but you seem scummy by the fact your post doesn't contain much contain on why or how he did, or why "painting others as scummy" is a scummy thing to do. FOS terrafutan. Try again.

Back in mah' day, no one accus'd anyone without a dosh garn good reason!

-SG7 ( )

Hi again sg7 ... I claimed a while back ... but again for emphasis ... I an vanilla townie! Hence my concern on catching scum and suspicious on annyone who thinks otherwise!

On a lighter note ... COME ON you lot ... far too little chatter!

oops... I forgot. sorry hippo. Me ole' noggin' ain't what it used ta' be.

-SG7 ( )

[thehippo8]

uh... I still want a claim from Hippo, but terrafutan that vote seemed very BandWagon. You didn't really support your case much. It was a nice try tho, but you seem scummy by the fact your post doesn't contain much contain on why or how he did, or why "painting others as scummy" is a scummy thing to do. FOS terrafutan. Try again.

Back in mah' day, no one accus'd anyone without a dosh garn good reason!

-SG7 ( )

Hi again sg7 ... I claimed a while back ... but again for emphasis ... I an vanilla townie! Hence my concern on catching scum and suspicious on annyone who thinks otherwise!

On a lighter note ... COME ON you lot ... far too little chatter!

oops... I forgot. sorry hippo. Me ole' noggin' ain't what it used ta' be.

-SG7 ( )

No problems.

I am going to go out on a limb here and FOS eldario, chap, shield, terrafutan also as being scummy (they have no reason to pick on me but seem to me to be birds of a feather) - I think pancake, conozo, edoc are town but attacking Zimmah weirdly who I think is also town. So that leaves you sg7, I think your town also but all this fence sitting is becoming odd. Make a decision and vote! I am undecided on alliegences of Jens and Sully but I reckon we should remove Jens because I am convinced that submarining is scummy and ultimately not in our interests.

[chapcrap]

uh... I still want a claim from Hippo, but terrafutan that vote seemed very BandWagon. You didn't really support your case much. It was a nice try tho, but you seem scummy by the fact your post doesn't contain much contain on why or how he did, or why "painting others as scummy" is a scummy thing to do. FOS terrafutan. Try again.

Back in mah' day, no one accus'd anyone without a dosh garn good reason!

-SG7 ( )

Hi again sg7 ... I claimed a while back ... but again for emphasis ... I an vanilla townie! Hence my concern on catching scum and suspicious on annyone who thinks otherwise!

On a lighter note ... COME ON you lot ... far too little chatter!

oops... I forgot. sorry hippo. Me ole' noggin' ain't what it used ta' be.

-SG7 ( )

No problems.

I am going to go out on a limb here and FOS eldario, chap, shield, terrafutan also as being scummy (they have no reason to pick on me but seem to me to be birds of a feather) - I think pancake, conozo, edoc are town but attacking Zimmah weirdly who I think is also town. So that leaves you sg7, I think your town also but all this fence sitting is becoming odd. Make a decision and vote! I am undecided on alliegences of Jens and Sully but I reckon we should remove Jens because I am convinced that submarining is scummy and ultimately not in our interests.

Oh my goodness! Are you really gonna FOS me? I would have never guessed that. Since you did the same thing to zimmah when he went after you. And the same thing to terrafutan when he voted a few posts ago. That's all you have been doing is a bunch of OMGUS FOS. You have done nothing that is not scummy. My vote will stay on you.

[skillfusniper33]

uh... I still want a claim from Hippo, but terrafutan that vote seemed very BandWagon. You didn't really support your case much. It was a nice try tho, but you seem scummy by the fact your post doesn't contain much contain on why or how he did, or why "painting others as scummy" is a scummy thing to do. FOS terrafutan. Try again.

Back in mah' day, no one accus'd anyone without a dosh garn good reason!

-SG7 ( )

Hi again sg7 ... I claimed a while back ... but again for emphasis ... I an vanilla townie! Hence my concern on catching scum and suspicious on annyone who thinks otherwise!

On a lighter note ... COME ON you lot ... far too little chatter!

I don't really buy your claim as a Vanilla hippo. You guys need to do better looking because it was LSU tigers mathematical puzzle, edoc just put it into an actual format where he went through and found all the possible numbers for a solution (and factored out the repeats).

Yes Jen is dead weight right now hippo, but he hasn't poked his head in at all, not even to confirm, so him being scum seems pretty low on my part, I just beileve he is extremely busy and hasn't had time to play mafia right now. So finding a replacement would be better action right now I think.

[thehippo8]

uh... I still want a claim from Hippo, but terrafutan that vote seemed very BandWagon. You didn't really support your case much. It was a nice try tho, but you seem scummy by the fact your post doesn't contain much contain on why or how he did, or why "painting others as scummy" is a scummy thing to do. FOS terrafutan. Try again.

Back in mah' day, no one accus'd anyone without a dosh garn good reason!

-SG7 ( )

Hi again sg7 ... I claimed a while back ... but again for emphasis ... I an vanilla townie! Hence my concern on catching scum and suspicious on annyone who thinks otherwise!

On a lighter note ... COME ON you lot ... far too little chatter!

oops... I forgot. sorry hippo. Me ole' noggin' ain't what it used ta' be.

-SG7 ( )

No problems.

I am going to go out on a limb here and FOS eldario, chap, shield, terrafutan also as being scummy (they have no reason to pick on me but seem to me to be birds of a feather) - I think pancake, conozo, edoc are town but attacking Zimmah weirdly who I think is also town. So that leaves you sg7, I think your town also but all this fence sitting is becoming odd. Make a decision and vote! I am undecided on alliegences of Jens and Sully but I reckon we should remove Jens because I am convinced that submarining is scummy and ultimately not in our interests.

Oh my goodness! Are you really gonna FOS me? I would have never guessed that. Since you did the same thing to zimmah when he went after you. And the same thing to terrafutan when he voted a few posts ago. That's all you have been doing is a bunch of OMGUS FOS. You have done nothing that is not scummy. My vote will stay on you.

Interesting take on it Chap. You may need to read the posts a bit more closely. I was the first to work out that the mathematical puzzle was very complex and posted a general stab at the combinations. I am pleased that I have rattled your cage but it's all very good pointing the blame away from yourself. I have genuienly declared, rather than attack me perhaps you would be so kind as to declare also.

[thehippo8]

uh... I still want a claim from Hippo, but terrafutan that vote seemed very BandWagon. You didn't really support your case much. It was a nice try tho, but you seem scummy by the fact your post doesn't contain much contain on why or how he did, or why "painting others as scummy" is a scummy thing to do. FOS terrafutan. Try again.

Back in mah' day, no one accus'd anyone without a dosh garn good reason!

-SG7 ( )

Hi again sg7 ... I claimed a while back ... but again for emphasis ... I an vanilla townie! Hence my concern on catching scum and suspicious on annyone who thinks otherwise!

On a lighter note ... COME ON you lot ... far too little chatter!

I don't really buy your claim as a Vanilla hippo. You guys need to do better looking because it was LSU tigers mathematical puzzle, edoc just put it into an actual format where he went through and found all the possible numbers for a solution (and factored out the repeats).

Yes Jen is dead weight right now hippo, but he hasn't poked his head in at all, not even to confirm, so him being scum seems pretty low on my part, I just beileve he is extremely busy and hasn't had time to play mafia right now. So finding a replacement would be better action right now I think.

You are right, edoc is one smart cookie setting out the full combinations. That's why I believe edoc is a townie like me. Vio has explained why she doesn't like to replace Jens so that leaves it for us to make a call on that. I see no reason to suggest that Jens is just busy - we are all busy. Unless there is a better candidate then Jens should go now.

[dazza2008]

What do you mean by declare Hippo? Do you really want people to roleclaim? I thought we had been through all this.

[thehippo8]

Incidentally, there are a number of other players which are also keeping their head down! It's good that we have got the forum going again, would be nice if the others joined in. Dazza ... what's up?

[thehippo8]

What do you mean by declare Hippo? Do you really want people to roleclaim? I thought we had been through all this.

Actually ... I agree Dazza ... in this game all you can do is say whether you are townie or scum. I would prefer it if we could focus on something useful. The puzzle is great but we need to remove people to make it useful. There are so few people coming up with theories. I am just trying to get the discussion going! Maybe that strategy is wrong but I tried being silent for a few days and absolutely nothing happened ... lol. Any suggestions Dazza?

[dazza2008]

What do you mean by declare Hippo? Do you really want people to roleclaim? I thought we had been through all this.

Actually ... I agree Dazza ... in this game all you can do is say whether you are townie or scum. I would prefer it if we could focus on something useful. The puzzle is great but we need to remove people to make it useful. There are so few people coming up with theories. I am just trying to get the discussion going! Maybe that strategy is wrong but I tried being silent for a few days and absolutely nothing happened ... lol. Any suggestions Dazza?

I really don't know how to play this. Even when we lynch someone we will not know there role. The puzzle will help I am sure but it just confuses me

[zimmah]

What do you mean by declare Hippo? Do you really want people to roleclaim? I thought we had been through all this.

Actually ... I agree Dazza ... in this game all you can do is say whether you are townie or scum. I would prefer it if we could focus on something useful. The puzzle is great but we need to remove people to make it useful. There are so few people coming up with theories. I am just trying to get the discussion going! Maybe that strategy is wrong but I tried being silent for a few days and absolutely nothing happened ... lol. Any suggestions Dazza?

it's not wrong and i beleive you for now. it's dangerous though, because the one that brings up too much discussion often gets a lot of attention. and that can be a bad thing.

it's quite hard because there's indeed nothing to claim other then vanilla or scum. and even when someone died there's not much information revealed. we need to make some really good decisions based on players actions i think. does anyone here have experience with this type of mafia?