Stool Pigeon Mafia - Game Over! Mafia Win!!! MVP- Zimmah

[wildwilliam]

are we still needing 2 replacements?

[thehippo8]

Unvote since it was just a random day 1 vote. I do give this for you to think about and discuss on a serious matter, but the last line is very important.

We have 3 players who's game numbers equal 41. Who they are, I cannot say by rule, but one of them will surely cause a death each day by choosing to make a dead dude. The numbers are not all even or all odd, but the person surely is odd. Heed my advice town because once I state this, I cannot interpret any answers.

Okay so let's get serious ... the starting roles have provided some small snippets of information which a player knows but cannot directly say ... if I get what your saying. This information though is just too weird. If its based on starting position numbers then I am afraid that really doesn't help right now2 ... although it will be very valuable information later as the days go on and the three remain. For now here is an example of numbers (no intent to be exhaustive) ...

22 18 1
22 17 2
22 16 3
22 15 4
22 14 5
22 13 6
22 17 2
22 16 3
22 15 4
22 14 5
22 13 6
22 12 7
22 11 8
22 10 9
21 18 2
21 16 4
21 14 6
21 12 8
20 19 2
20 18 3
20 17 4
20 16 5
20 15 6
20 14 7
20 13 8
20 12 9
20 11 10
19 18 4
19 16 6
19 14 8
19 12 10
18 17 6
18 16 7
18 15 8
18 14 9
18 13 10
18 12 11
17 22 2

For now, I am still of the view that those who have been silent are probably being silent because they have something to hide. My vote doesn't change at this stage and I focus on the silent ones for now.

[zimmah]

it's a jokevote stage, what's there to hide?

[trinicardinal]

it's a jokevote stage, what's there to hide?

I'm sure I have no idea... that you can't joke maybe?

[sensfan]

(a little birdie told me that you are looking for replacement, so im in.)

[chapcrap]

Unvote since it was just a random day 1 vote. I do give this for you to think about and discuss on a serious matter, but the last line is very important.

We have 3 players who's game numbers equal 41. Who they are, I cannot say by rule, but one of them will surely cause a death each day by choosing to make a dead dude. The numbers are not all even or all odd, but the person surely is odd. Heed my advice town because once I state this, I cannot interpret any answers.

Okay so let's get serious ... the starting roles have provided some small snippets of information which a player knows but cannot directly say ... if I get what your saying. This information though is just too weird. If its based on starting position numbers then I am afraid that really doesn't help right now2 ... although it will be very valuable information later as the days go on and the three remain. For now here is an example of numbers (no intent to be exhaustive) ...

22 18 1
22 17 2
22 16 3
22 15 4
22 14 5
22 13 6
22 17 2
22 16 3
22 15 4
22 14 5
22 13 6
22 12 7
22 11 8
22 10 9
21 18 2
21 16 4
21 14 6
21 12 8
20 19 2
20 18 3
20 17 4
20 16 5
20 15 6
20 14 7
20 13 8
20 12 9
20 11 10
19 18 4
19 16 6
19 14 8
19 12 10
18 17 6
18 16 7
18 15 8
18 14 9
18 13 10
18 12 11
17 22 2

For now, I am still of the view that those who have been silent are probably being silent because they have something to hide. My vote doesn't change at this stage and I focus on the silent ones for now.

I also don't think there is anything to hide at this stage. Secondly, can you explain to me the significance of 41? I really don't understand what you guys are trying to say here.

[edocsil]

Unvote since it was just a random day 1 vote. I do give this for you to think about and discuss on a serious matter, but the last line is very important.

We have 3 players who's game numbers equal 41. Who they are, I cannot say by rule, but one of them will surely cause a death each day by choosing to make a dead dude. The numbers are not all even or all odd, but the person surely is odd. Heed my advice town because once I state this, I cannot interpret any answers.

I made a little program that calculated every possible combination of player numbers totaling 41. There are 46 unique combinations (hippo's method had duplicates) Here they are for reference as well as the player list I used.

Code: Select all

22   18   1
22   17   2
22   16   3
22   15   4
22   14   5
22   13   6
22   12   7
22   11   8
22   10   9
21   18   2
21   17   3
21   16   4
21   15   5
21   14   6
21   13   7
21   12   8
21   11   9
20   18   3
20   17   4
20   16   5
20   15   6
20   14   7
20   13   8
20   12   9
20   11   10
19   18   4
19   17   5
19   16   6
19   15   7
19   14   8
19   13   9
19   12   10
18   17   6
18   16   7
18   15   8
18   14   9
18   13   10
18   12   11
17   16   8
17   15   9
17   14   10
17   13   11
16   15   10
16   14   11
16   13   12
15   14   12

And here is my list, as they are on the first page, counting replacements

1   edocsil
2   Nag
3   Victor
4   PCM
5   Fox
6   LSU Tiger
7   Irish Tiger
8   Trinicardinal
9   terrafutan
10   chapcrap
11   skillfusion
12   WildWill
13   dazza
14   conzocool
15   mob deadly
16   SG7
17   JenBroness
18   Zimmah
19   ShaggyDan
20   DazeRazer
21   thehippo
22   eldario



At the moment it does us little, besides indication that low player numbers are statistically less likely to be scum then then high numbers. Even this assumption is invalid if the roles were assigned in a non random fashion. If we find out that player (pick a number randomly here) 17 was scum that would leave us with 18 possible scum but if we know that player 17 was scum and player 4 was scum, following the pattern would explicitly claim that player 20 was the 3rd scum member.

The major caveat to this is the whole thing is completely useless if there are more then 3 scum, but it still will work if there are multiple factions and we can distinguish between scum. Factions are a possibility, otherwise we could easily have a 10 day game with only one kill a night. It could go on even longer if we cannot come to conclusions as to who to lynch.

[FoxMists]

Unvote since it was just a random day 1 vote. I do give this for you to think about and discuss on a serious matter, but the last line is very important.

We have 3 players who's game numbers equal 41. Who they are, I cannot say by rule, but one of them will surely cause a death each day by choosing to make a dead dude. The numbers are not all even or all odd, but the person surely is odd. Heed my advice town because once I state this, I cannot interpret any answers.

I made a little program that calculated every possible combination of player numbers totaling 41. There are 46 unique combinations (hippo's method had duplicates) Here they are for reference as well as the player list I used.

Code: Select all

22   18   1
22   17   2
22   16   3
22   15   4
22   14   5
22   13   6
22   12   7
22   11   8
22   10   9
21   18   2
21   17   3
21   16   4
21   15   5
21   14   6
21   13   7
21   12   8
21   11   9
20   18   3
20   17   4
20   16   5
20   15   6
20   14   7
20   13   8
20   12   9
20   11   10
19   18   4
19   17   5
19   16   6
19   15   7
19   14   8
19   13   9
19   12   10
18   17   6
18   16   7
18   15   8
18   14   9
18   13   10
18   12   11
17   16   8
17   15   9
17   14   10
17   13   11
16   15   10
16   14   11
16   13   12
15   14   12

And here is my list, as they are on the first page, counting replacements

1   edocsil
2   Nag
3   Victor
4   PCM
5   Fox
6   LSU Tiger
7   Irish Tiger
8   Trinicardinal
9   terrafutan
10   chapcrap
11   skillfusion
12   WildWill
13   dazza
14   conzocool
15   mob deadly
16   SG7
17   JenBroness
18   Zimmah
19   ShaggyDan
20   DazeRazer
21   thehippo
22   eldario



At the moment it does us little, besides indication that low player numbers are statistically less likely to be scum then then high numbers. Even this assumption is invalid if the roles were assigned in a non random fashion. If we find out that player (pick a number randomly here) 17 was scum that would leave us with 18 possible scum but if we know that player 17 was scum and player 4 was scum, following the pattern would explicitly claim that player 20 was the 3rd scum member.

The major caveat to this is the whole thing is completely useless if there are more then 3 scum, but it still will work if there are multiple factions and we can distinguish between scum. Factions are a possibility, otherwise we could easily have a 10 day game with only one kill a night. It could go on even longer if we cannot come to conclusions as to who to lynch.

Must be fun to have us all wracking our brains on numbers while the instigator kills off people, hmm? I really doubt there are only 3 scum in a game with 22 players. This IS useless. And a great way to throw off suspicion.

unvote VOTE LSU

[thehippo8]

Whilst I agree with you FoxMists, I am still not convinced that LSU was trying to be unhelpful. I suspect he was only working with the clues given to him. I am more convinced that those who are not responding have FOS as they are really just trying to keep their head low. Again, FOS terrafutan and JenBroness for saying nothing.

My vote remains with terrafutan ... aren't futon's made of feathers?

[LSU Tiger Josh]

Glad we're getting some discussion going. No where did I state how many "bad" guys total in this game. I used the info that I've seen and was allowed to post it to give out some info that IS beneficial for the townies to use and hopefully the smarties in the group will be able to figure out what is meant by what I stated since I am not allowed to clarify stuff that yall have interpreted from my riddle. I am still in favor of the bandwagon that was started on zimmah to come down to face their judge and jury on why they should not be our day 1 lynch. Fox if I really wanted to tie your head up in a logics twist why would I do it on day 1 when it's just a bunch of random crap. I would do it on a day when town was closer to discovering someone that I wanted to "protect" instead of using my eye of the tiger to see what is happening out here.

For what it is worth Jens is getting replaced currently in another game I'm in so I would leave that one up for the mod to handle.

[chapcrap]

Glad we're getting some discussion going. No where did I state how many "bad" guys total in this game. I used the info that I've seen and was allowed to post it to give out some info that IS beneficial for the townies to use and hopefully the smarties in the group will be able to figure out what is meant by what I stated since I am not allowed to clarify stuff that yall have interpreted from my riddle. I am still in favor of the bandwagon that was started on zimmah to come down to face their judge and jury on why they should not be our day 1 lynch. Fox if I really wanted to tie your head up in a logics twist why would I do it on day 1 when it's just a bunch of random crap. I would do it on a day when town was closer to discovering someone that I wanted to "protect" instead of using my eye of the tiger to see what is happening out here.

For what it is worth Jens is getting replaced currently in another game I'm in so I would leave that one up for the mod to handle.

Maybe I'm just thick, but I don't understand what he's talking about. If someone does understand, can they clarify for me? I'm going to go re-read what was said, but I don't get it.

[Victor Sullivan]

Oopsie! I believe I forgot about this one I'll read up soon...

-Sully

[edocsil]

Glad we're getting some discussion going. No where did I state how many "bad" guys total in this game. I used the info that I've seen and was allowed to post it to give out some info that IS beneficial for the townies to use and hopefully the smarties in the group will be able to figure out what is meant by what I stated since I am not allowed to clarify stuff that yall have interpreted from my riddle. I am still in favor of the bandwagon that was started on zimmah to come down to face their judge and jury on why they should not be our day 1 lynch. Fox if I really wanted to tie your head up in a logics twist why would I do it on day 1 when it's just a bunch of random crap. I would do it on a day when town was closer to discovering someone that I wanted to "protect" instead of using my eye of the tiger to see what is happening out here.

For what it is worth Jens is getting replaced currently in another game I'm in so I would leave that one up for the mod to handle.

Maybe I'm just thick, but I don't understand what he's talking about. If someone does understand, can they clarify for me? I'm going to go re-read what was said, but I don't get it.

Go take a look at my post a little ways up, I attempt to dissect the riddle, and I have the riddle quoted.

[thehippo8]

Glad we're getting some discussion going. No where did I state how many "bad" guys total in this game. I used the info that I've seen and was allowed to post it to give out some info that IS beneficial for the townies to use and hopefully the smarties in the group will be able to figure out what is meant by what I stated since I am not allowed to clarify stuff that yall have interpreted from my riddle. I am still in favor of the bandwagon that was started on zimmah to come down to face their judge and jury on why they should not be our day 1 lynch. Fox if I really wanted to tie your head up in a logics twist why would I do it on day 1 when it's just a bunch of random crap. I would do it on a day when town was closer to discovering someone that I wanted to "protect" instead of using my eye of the tiger to see what is happening out here.

For what it is worth Jens is getting replaced currently in another game I'm in so I would leave that one up for the mod to handle.

Hmmmm ... I think not only havee you redeemed yourself but you have a convincing argument.

unvote vote zimmah

[safariguy5]

Vote Count

Foxxie(2)- edoc, chapcrap

eldario- dazza

mob deadly(2)- zimmah, terrafutan

trini- shield

zimmah(5)- pancake, conozo, sniper, LSU, hippo

wildwilliam- trini

LSU(3)- wildwilliam, MoB, Foxxie

hippo- eldario


With 21 alive, it takes 11 to lynch.

Quick clarification, the rules state that only bold votes will be counted. Whether or not you color the bold is irrelevant, but just colored text is not considered voting. So no change in vote edoc.

[edocsil]

Quick clarification, the rules state that only bold votes will be counted. Whether or not you color the bold is irrelevant, but just colored text is not considered voting. So no change in vote edoc.

So it is on record UNVOTE VOTE ZIMMAH

[VioIet]

are we still needing 2 replacements?

Well, there are some who have yet to post in this game. I am undecided about jenbronnes, I think I should give him/her some more time.

I will add sens to the replacement list in the meanwhile. I'm going to keep the 2 replacements sign up, just in case I need more.

[zimmah]

Vote Count

Foxxie(2)- edoc, chapcrap

eldario- dazza

mob deadly(2)- zimmah, terrafutan

trini- shield

zimmah(5)- pancake, conozo, sniper, LSU, hippo

wildwilliam- trini

LSU(3)- wildwilliam, MoB, Foxxie

hippo- eldario


With 21 alive, it takes 11 to lynch.

Quick clarification, the rules state that only bold votes will be counted. Whether or not you color the bold is irrelevant, but just colored text is not considered voting. So no change in vote edoc.

that's why i always color and bold it, so i'm sure it gets voted.

[terrafutan]

okay FOS terrafutan and JenBroness for saying nothing

And to add some pressure vote terrafutan ... are they your feathers?

Newb to CC Mafia, so haven't much to say at this point. I at least RV'd.

What feathers are you on about mate ?

So your FOS plan is to target the inactives and noobs ? Little bit scummy that.

[thehippo8]

okay FOS terrafutan and JenBroness for saying nothing

And to add some pressure vote terrafutan ... are they your feathers?

Newb to CC Mafia, so haven't much to say at this point. I at least RV'd.

What feathers are you on about mate ?

So your FOS plan is to target the inactives and noobs ? Little bit scummy that.

Ah ... I was simply trying to get you to play. You will note that I am not voting for you any more. Unusual you would be so sensitive though. You remain under suspicion for now, but I am NOT voting against you unless I have further good reason to do so.

As to feathers it was simply a play on words - we are looking for a pigeon of sorts!

[zimmah]

okay FOS terrafutan and JenBroness for saying nothing

And to add some pressure vote terrafutan ... are they your feathers?

Newb to CC Mafia, so haven't much to say at this point. I at least RV'd.

What feathers are you on about mate ?

So your FOS plan is to target the inactives and noobs ? Little bit scummy that.

Ah ... I was simply trying to get you to play. You will note that I am not voting for you any more. Unusual you would be so sensitive though. You remain under suspicion for now, but I am NOT voting against you unless I have further good reason to do so.

As to feathers it was simply a play on words - we are looking for a pigeon of sorts!

well, if you're looking for pigeons, try looking at my roof, they are poluting the whole place with their poop.

[dazza2008]

okay FOS terrafutan and JenBroness for saying nothing

And to add some pressure vote terrafutan ... are they your feathers?

Newb to CC Mafia, so haven't much to say at this point. I at least RV'd.

What feathers are you on about mate ?

So your FOS plan is to target the inactives and noobs ? Little bit scummy that.

Ah ... I was simply trying to get you to play. You will note that I am not voting for you any more. Unusual you would be so sensitive though. You remain under suspicion for now, but I am NOT voting against you unless I have further good reason to do so.

As to feathers it was simply a play on words - we are looking for a pigeon of sorts!

If you are looking for pidgeons then you must be scummy. They are townies. I would rather we did not know who they are.

[terrafutan]

Ah ... I was simply trying to get you to play. You will note that I am not voting for you any more. Unusual you would be so sensitive though. You remain under suspicion for now, but I am NOT voting against you unless I have further good reason to do so.

As to feathers it was simply a play on words - we are looking for a pigeon of sorts!

Nothing sensitive about my reply, simply stated my position.

Trying to gauge my first D1 on a new site, so it's not like I'm going to jump in guns blazing.

[wildwilliam]

Ah ... I was simply trying to get you to play. You will note that I am not voting for you any more. Unusual you would be so sensitive though. You remain under suspicion for now, but I am NOT voting against you unless I have further good reason to do so.

As to feathers it was simply a play on words - we are looking for a pigeon of sorts!

Nothing sensitive about my reply, simply stated my position.

Trying to gauge my first D1 on a new site, so it's not like I'm going to jump in guns blazing.

I did, was the cop, and was killed N-1 in the other game...... good times.

[edocsil]

As to feathers it was simply a play on words - we are looking for a pigeon of sorts!

If you are looking for pidgeons then you must be scummy. They are townies. I would rather we did not know who they are.[/quote]

Yeah second that.

Nothing sensitive about my reply, simply stated my position.

Trying to gauge my first D1 on a new site, so it's not like I'm going to jump in guns blazing.

No worries, sit back a bit learn the game and come out swing once you get the feel. Just don't wait too long