[CC2] Semi Finals THOTA vs.TSM [TIE-BREAK 3-4] TSM wins

[jackal31]

This rule is irritating, and causes problems like this. CC should look at implementing some sort of automatic snapshot for both sides as soon as the game starts. Or allow teams to take snapshots for eachother, although that would still mean that the team that goes first would have to remember to snap before playing.

BTW, this is a great suggestion. If there is a way to offer a public snap for both teams upon the start of non-FoW games and teams snaps of regular FoW games, then that would be way better than having to try and sort this out.

[jackal31]

lc and I have gotten together and we have determined for the better of the match, this game should continue. THOTA team will be providing all missing information.

Thank you for your understanding and once again, sorry for the foul up.

[firstholliday]

i trust lc

carry on

[laughingcavalier]

We are NOT remaking the bamboo jack game.
Some monkis asked for it to be re-made. Thota did not want to & the monkis in the game said they are happy with notes from commander, so we are sticking with the original rule.
Play on.

[firstholliday]

cool if we loose by 1.

[codeblue1018]

Thats fine, I didn't realize that it had happened a coupla times in the last war between you guys as well, which I guess could make this a trifle irritating.
But if both sides do agree on making a new game for it, then it shouldn't be a problem, and I'm glad you guys are able to resolve it so easily.

ps. I just pm'd you cause I wanted the Pack to know how these things are done

Who are the pack? Are they a clan or something?

[codeblue1018]

Things happen; I'm glad we came to a fast solution regarding this matter. Battle on people. Jackel, thanks for the expedient response.

[Commander62890]

It's kind of ridiculous that this was even an issue... a game should never have to be remade if all of the pertinent info is given. What's the point of remaking it? In other words, how can we have an unfair advantage?

In any case, this type of thing should have a solution that is agreed to before the challenge and cannot be broken. What was the official rule, again?

Because the only way for a team to gain an unfair advantage in a situation like this is if the rule was not set in stone beforehand.

[skillfull]

have fun everyone

[nikola_milicki]

It's kind of ridiculous that this was even an issue... a game should never have to be remade if all of the pertinent info is given. What's the point of remaking it? In other words, how can we have an unfair advantage?

In any case, this type of thing should have a solution that is agreed to before the challenge and cannot be broken. What was the official rule, again?

Because the only way for a team to gain an unfair advantage in a situation like this is if the rule was not set in stone beforehand.

makes sense

[nikola_milicki]

I'd be much obliged if u'd give my address to clappy and tisha

thnx for setting girls up with my address, I already have them back against my wall

[Georgerx7di]

It's kind of ridiculous that this was even an issue... a game should never have to be remade if all of the pertinent info is given. What's the point of remaking it? In other words, how can we have an unfair advantage?

In any case, this type of thing should have a solution that is agreed to before the challenge and cannot be broken. What was the official rule, again?

Because the only way for a team to gain an unfair advantage in a situation like this is if the rule was not set in stone beforehand.

The rule should be that if you take your turn before 12 hours, then you automatically forfeit 31 of the 60 games. I'll lobby for that next game.

Also, we have women in our clan, how come thota doesn't bring any women to the table?

[jackal31]

we dont share

[kratos644]

I'd be much obliged if u'd give my address to clappy and tisha

thnx for setting girls up with my address, I already have them back against my wall

Be careful nik we sent them over with herpes to ruin things for you

[Tisha]

I'd be much obliged if u'd give my address to clappy and tisha

thnx for setting girls up with my address, I already have them back against my wall

Be careful nik we sent them over with herpes to ruin things for you

f*ck off?

[firstholliday]

[jackal31]

THOTA team will be providing all missing information.

This was in regard to the Bamboo game.....I have learned all information is visible by the Monkey team. There are no other changes on the board that need to be accounted for.

Good luck in the rest of the game.

[Commander62890]

THOTA team will be providing all missing information.

This was in regard to the Bamboo game.....I have learned all information is visible by the Monkey team. There are no other changes on the board that need to be accounted for.

Good luck in the rest of the game.

I provided all of the necessary information in the game chat just 3 hours after taking my turn (after being notified of my error by LC). I'm sorry for the slip-up, everyone. An honest mistake, quickly rectified.

Was the solution decided upon (to continue and count the game) agreed to before the challenge began? What was the original rule? There must have been a rule, as this mistake happens often enough.
If THOTA agreed to an original rule that said we have to remake the game... then we ought to do that.

And, if that is not the case, I am truly stumped as to why anyone (especially FirstH) was calling for a remake. In my mind, that's inexcusable.

Any details?

[Leehar]

THOTA team will be providing all missing information.

This was in regard to the Bamboo game.....I have learned all information is visible by the Monkey team. There are no other changes on the board that need to be accounted for.

Good luck in the rest of the game.

I provided all of the necessary information in the game chat just 3 hours after taking my turn (after being notified of my error by LC). I'm sorry for the slip-up, everyone. An honest mistake, quickly rectified.

Was the solution decided upon (to continue and count the game) agreed to before the challenge began? What was the original rule? There must have been a rule, as this mistake happens often enough.
If THOTA agreed to an original rule that said we have to remake the game... then we ought to do that.

And, if that is not the case, I am truly stumped as to why anyone (especially FirstH) was calling for a remake. In my mind, that's inexcusable.

Any details?

Because in the last war it was two incidents like that with breaking the fog rule was what could be said to have caused the 1 game win by thota and which probably caused a lot of tension.
You, jackal, lc (and obviously me) weren't involved in that, but it obviously caused a lot of angst between both sides. So it does seem understandable that some of the guys would hope that there could be a better way to resolve it then going through the whole shebang again which ended up causing a whole lot of heat in the last encounter?

[jackal31]

I never looked it up, but zips and I were new to THOTA at that time and I think I may have broken the rule being a newbie.

We are beyond this though now. There's no reason to worry about it anymore.

edit: And for your entertainment, I did find it in Game 6215903. I was one of the culprits at that time, and it was my 1st game playing with this rule in place. I'm sure that didnt help the already fiesty-ness of the challenge either.

[skillfull]

No problem guys, keep playing...have fun

[firstholliday]

No problem guys, keep playing...have fun

[Incandenza]

Also, we have women in our clan, how come thota doesn't bring any women to the table?

We leave the toilet seat up.

[kratos644]

Also, we have women in our clan, how come thota doesn't bring any women to the table?

We leave the toilet seat up.

[Georgerx7di]

Also, we have women in our clan, how come thota doesn't bring any women to the table?

We leave the toilet seat up.

Me too, I lol'd when I read this : P