Memebase Mafia Game Over!

[strike wolf]

Well here is the list.

Admiral Ackbar (9)
Adventure! (5)
Advice Dog (4)
Age of Empires (15)
All the Things! (3)
Anti-Joke Chicken (44)
Art Student Owl (15)
Awww Yeah! (16)
Bad Pickup Line Panda (7)
Bear Grylls (74)
best-of-week (22)
Bill Nye The Science Guy (4)
Bill O'Reilly (18)
Bronies (28)
Business Cat (44)
Captcha (3)
Cereal Guy (34)
Challenge Accepted (40)
Charlie Sheen (19)
Chemistry Cat (8)
Close Enough (15)
Courage Wolf (33)
Creepy Scoutmaster (7)
Dat Ash (22)
Dating Site Murderer (18)
Depression Dog (11)
Derp (23)
Engineering Professor (2)
Forever Alone (173)
Foul Bachelor Frog (96)
Foul Bachelorette Frog (20)
Fry (78)
Good Guy Greg (47)
Gordon Freeman (10)
Happy Kitten (37)
he will never have a girlfriend (19)
High Expectations Asian Dad (38)
Hipster Disney & Friends (51)
Hipster Kitty (111)
Hood Dad (16)
How People View Me (11)
I Don't Want to Live on This Planet Anymore (6)
I've Seen Enough Hentai (16)
Inception (36)
Inglip (37)
Insanity Wolf (113)
Internet Husband (27)
Joseph Ducreux (75)
Karate Kid (5)
Ladies Love (28)
Lame Pun Coon (57)
Lenin Cat (9)
LOL Jesus (35)
Me Gusta (74)
Memes (1945)
Musically Oblivious 8th Grader (14)
Net Noob (5)
Not Even Once (21)
Nyan Cat (80)
Okay (12)
Paranoid Parrot (86)
Paula Deen Ya'll (9)
Pedobear (97)
Philosoraptor (149)
Picture Is Unrelated (27)
Pokémemes (162)
Poker Face (12)
PTSD Clarinet Kid (21)
QWOP (21)
Rage Comics (615)
Raisins (Super Fuuuu) (62)
Rasta Prof (10)
Rebecca Black (50)
Redneck Randal (3)
Sad Truck (8)
Scene Wolf (40)
Scumbag Brain (13)
Scumbag Steve (68)
Senior Freshman (6)
Sexy Sagan (1)
Sir Courage Wolf Esq. (7)
Socially Awkward Penguin (82)
Spiderman (27)
Stare Dad (39)
Success Kid (62)
Success Nun (12)
Superheroes (64)
Taxmaster (1)
Technologically Impaired Duck (43)
The Internet IRL (41)
The Most Interesting Man in the World (69)
The Shadowlurker (15)
The Sims (18)
Troll Dad (29)
Troll Face (126)
Troll God (17)
Troll Science (73)
Uber Frosh (6)
Very Demotivational (151)
Video (121)
voting-page (386)
Wrong Lyrics Christina (2)
Y U No Guy (174)
Yo Dawg (45)
zuckerberg (32)

Bolded the ones I would think to be scum if any. Duno why others haven't done this yet.

I forgot to talk about this one in my last post. This list is good but it doesn't i nclude the "why so serious" meme which I think could be a possible SK/mafia meme. I'm assuming the # refers to how many there are?

@rody: that seems like an over-simplication of what kwan was saying.

[safariguy5]

Wait, so Rodion, are you actually nameclaiming Pedobear as your meme? The tone sounded a bit like you were stating a hypothetical.

[Rodion]

Wait, so Rodion, are you actually nameclaiming Pedobear as your meme? The tone sounded a bit like you were stating a hypothetical.

I am Pedobear.

[Rodion]

Wait, so Rodion, are you actually nameclaiming Pedobear as your meme? The tone sounded a bit like you were stating a hypothetical.

I am Pedobear.

EBWOP: and I love little kids!

[MeDeFe]

Fasposted by Haggis: I did not say "I'm against it because it ruins the fun". I said "it would ruin the fun" and I said "we have experienced mods that would not allow such thing to happen because it would ruin the fun". This is not a VS experimental game.

By the way, has anyone seen Justin Bieber? I have unfinished businesses with him!

And I said this in my post last post.

The post you quoted for me had the "you're no fun" directed to Kwanton (and not to a particular "lack of game balance") as part of my "creative" decision of filling my PR requirement.

As in you're no fun because you are an old douche and Fircoal is fun because he is only 17! Where are you, Fir?!

I am disappoint. 17 is too old and you know it.

Other than that I agree with you dawg, trying to find scum by speculating on whether someone is playing a "good" or a "bad" meme is likely to backfire, extremely hard. We're far more likely to find scum by putting pressure on people who cum up with half-baked ideas and speculate about flavour, practically trying to set us up the bomb.

vote kwanton

Deal with it.

[kwanton]

UMAD?

I still think that speculating on roles and possible alignment won't hurt us as long as we're not dumb about it. This is a game of information-gathering so I don't understand why people are voting me for trying to gather information. I'm sticking by my guns on this one.

[safariguy5]

UMAD?

I still think that speculating on roles and possible alignment won't hurt us as long as we're not dumb about it. This is a game of information-gathering so I don't understand why people are voting me for trying to gather information. I'm sticking by my guns on this one.

I agree. Just because a PR isn't gamebreaking in and of itself doesn't mean it isn't relevant. Tal basically hid in plain sight with a self imposed PR in Resort and Evil Chef's M.O. in South Park was imposing the soup PR. So I'm with kwan on this one, we can't discount PR's. No doubt some are town, some are mafia. Still relevant.

[strike wolf]

UMAD?

I still think that speculating on roles and possible alignment won't hurt us as long as we're not dumb about it. This is a game of information-gathering so I don't understand why people are voting me for trying to gather information. I'm sticking by my guns on this one.

I agree. Just because a PR isn't gamebreaking in and of itself doesn't mean it isn't relevant. Tal basically hid in plain sight with a self imposed PR in Resort and Evil Chef's M.O. in South Park was imposing the soup PR. So I'm with kwan on this one, we can't discount PR's. No doubt some are town, some are mafia. Still relevant.

This.

[JenBroness]

Well here is the list.

Admiral Ackbar (9)
Adventure! (5)
Advice Dog (4)
Age of Empires (15)
All the Things! (3)
Anti-Joke Chicken (44)
Art Student Owl (15)
Awww Yeah! (16)
Bad Pickup Line Panda (7)
Bear Grylls (74)
best-of-week (22)
Bill Nye The Science Guy (4)
Bill O'Reilly (18)
Bronies (28)
Business Cat (44)
Captcha (3)
Cereal Guy (34)
Challenge Accepted (40)
Charlie Sheen (19)
Chemistry Cat (8)
Close Enough (15)
Courage Wolf (33)
Creepy Scoutmaster (7)
Dat Ash (22)
Dating Site Murderer (18)
Depression Dog (11)
Derp (23)
Engineering Professor (2)
Forever Alone (173)
Foul Bachelor Frog (96)
Foul Bachelorette Frog (20)
Fry (78)
Good Guy Greg (47)
Gordon Freeman (10)
Happy Kitten (37)
he will never have a girlfriend (19)
High Expectations Asian Dad (38)
Hipster Disney & Friends (51)
Hipster Kitty (111)
Hood Dad (16)
How People View Me (11)
I Don't Want to Live on This Planet Anymore (6)
I've Seen Enough Hentai (16)
Inception (36)
Inglip (37)
Insanity Wolf (113)
Internet Husband (27)
Joseph Ducreux (75)
Karate Kid (5)
Ladies Love (28)
Lame Pun Coon (57)
Lenin Cat (9)
LOL Jesus (35)
Me Gusta (74)
Memes (1945)
Musically Oblivious 8th Grader (14)
Net Noob (5)
Not Even Once (21)
Nyan Cat (80)
Okay (12)
Paranoid Parrot (86)
Paula Deen Ya'll (9)
Pedobear (97)
Philosoraptor (149)
Picture Is Unrelated (27)
Pokémemes (162)
Poker Face (12)
PTSD Clarinet Kid (21)
QWOP (21)
Rage Comics (615)
Raisins (Super Fuuuu) (62)
Rasta Prof (10)
Rebecca Black (50)
Redneck Randal (3)
Sad Truck (8)
Scene Wolf (40)
Scumbag Brain (13)
Scumbag Steve (68)
Senior Freshman (6)
Sexy Sagan (1)
Sir Courage Wolf Esq. (7)
Socially Awkward Penguin (82)
Spiderman (27)
Stare Dad (39)
Success Kid (62)
Success Nun (12)
Superheroes (64)
Taxmaster (1)
Technologically Impaired Duck (43)
The Internet IRL (41)
The Most Interesting Man in the World (69)
The Shadowlurker (15)
The Sims (18)
Troll Dad (29)
Troll Face (126)
Troll God (17)
Troll Science (73)
Uber Frosh (6)
Very Demotivational (151)
Video (121)
voting-page (386)
Wrong Lyrics Christina (2)
Y U No Guy (174)
Yo Dawg (45)
zuckerberg (32)

Bolded the ones I would think to be scum if any. Duno why others haven't done this yet.

I forgot to talk about this one in my last post. This list is good but it doesn't i nclude the "why so serious" meme which I think could be a possible SK/mafia meme. I'm assuming the # refers to how many there are?

@rody: that seems like an over-simplication of what kwan was saying.

Are we trying to make this le comprehensive list?

That's quite le task... You should add le Tiger Mom ("Facebook? Why don't you face BOOK and STUDY?").

You're also missing my role. Honestly, we're going nowhere with this!

Although ... up till now everything's gone better than expected...

[Mr. Squirrel]

I'm on the list, bro, but the list won't help much. Rather, we should make a list of all memes that each poster has made obvious so far. This is what I've been able to piece together so far:

1. Kwanton


2. BG


3. Jonty


4. /


5. chapcrap


6. Rodion


7. medefe


Feel free to add, if any of you figure out more.

[kwanton]

Hit it right on the nose squirrel.

Obvious troll is obvious.

Problem?

[safariguy5]

Fasposted by Haggis: I did not say "I'm against it because it ruins the fun". I said "it would ruin the fun" and I said "we have experienced mods that would not allow such thing to happen because it would ruin the fun". This is not a VS experimental game.

By the way, has anyone seen Justin Bieber? I have unfinished businesses with him!

And I said this in my post last post.

The post you quoted for me had the "you're no fun" directed to Kwanton (and not to a particular "lack of game balance") as part of my "creative" decision of filling my PR requirement.

As in you're no fun because you are an old douche and Fircoal is fun because he is only 17! Where are you, Fir?!

I am disappoint. 17 is too old and you know it.

Other than that I agree with you dawg, trying to find scum by speculating on whether someone is playing a "good" or a "bad" meme is likely to backfire, extremely hard. We're far more likely to find scum by putting pressure on people who cum up with half-baked ideas and speculate about flavour, practically trying to set us up the bomb.

vote kwanton

Deal with it.

Not sure about your list there Mr. Squirrel, this quote from MeDeFe makes it look like he's the All Your Base meme.

[jonty125]

I'm on the list, bro, but the list won't help much. Rather, we should make a list of all memes that each poster has made obvious so far. This is what I've been able to piece together so far:

3. Jonty

Am I really that obvious x OVER 9000 TIMES!

[Mr. Squirrel]

Fasposted by Haggis: I did not say "I'm against it because it ruins the fun". I said "it would ruin the fun" and I said "we have experienced mods that would not allow such thing to happen because it would ruin the fun". This is not a VS experimental game.

By the way, has anyone seen Justin Bieber? I have unfinished businesses with him!

And I said this in my post last post.

The post you quoted for me had the "you're no fun" directed to Kwanton (and not to a particular "lack of game balance") as part of my "creative" decision of filling my PR requirement.

As in you're no fun because you are an old douche and Fircoal is fun because he is only 17! Where are you, Fir?!

I am disappoint. 17 is too old and you know it.

Other than that I agree with you dawg, trying to find scum by speculating on whether someone is playing a "good" or a "bad" meme is likely to backfire, extremely hard. We're far more likely to find scum by putting pressure on people who cum up with half-baked ideas and speculate about flavour, practically trying to set us up the bomb.

vote kwanton

Deal with it.

Not sure about your list there Mr. Squirrel, this quote from MeDeFe makes it look like he's the All Your Base meme.

He starts that quote out with "I am dissapoint." And I don't see how 'All your base' is in his quote at all.

[sensfan]

I don't think that we should be looking up meme's and playing a guessing game. It is not cool, and me, being a very fun person, (and hoping that you guys are having fun too) I think we should just play like normal mafia rolls out. Accuse when someone is being suspicious.

Just my two cents.

[naxus]

Well since Sens is dropping the ball, unvote vote sens

[safariguy5]

Fasposted by Haggis: I did not say "I'm against it because it ruins the fun". I said "it would ruin the fun" and I said "we have experienced mods that would not allow such thing to happen because it would ruin the fun". This is not a VS experimental game.

By the way, has anyone seen Justin Bieber? I have unfinished businesses with him!

And I said this in my post last post.

The post you quoted for me had the "you're no fun" directed to Kwanton (and not to a particular "lack of game balance") as part of my "creative" decision of filling my PR requirement.

As in you're no fun because you are an old douche and Fircoal is fun because he is only 17! Where are you, Fir?!

I am disappoint. 17 is too old and you know it.

Other than that I agree with you dawg, trying to find scum by speculating on whether someone is playing a "good" or a "bad" meme is likely to backfire, extremely hard. We're far more likely to find scum by putting pressure on people who cum up with half-baked ideas and speculate about flavour, practically trying to set us up the bomb.

vote kwanton

Deal with it.

Not sure about your list there Mr. Squirrel, this quote from MeDeFe makes it look like he's the All Your Base meme.

He starts that quote out with "I am dissapoint." And I don't see how 'All your base' is in his quote at all.

If you go back and rewatch the original cinematic, it goes something like

"What Happen"
"Somebody Set us up the bomb!"
Katz: "Hello Gentlemen, all your base are belong to us"
"What you say??!!"

etc.

I don't think that we should be looking up meme's and playing a guessing game. It is not cool, and me, being a very fun person, (and hoping that you guys are having fun too) I think we should just play like normal mafia rolls out. Accuse when someone is being suspicious.

Just my two cents.

So accuse someone when they start looking suspicious? Basically you're saying we should noob hunt then because experienced mafia players won't make careless slipups in the early game? Or is this a sneaky way of saying you support a no lynch? We have to actively be trying to find leads, and trying to establish known memes cuts down on possible mafia fakeclaims later on.

[strike wolf]

Ok at the risk of sounding like an idiot on a possibly minor detail, is there a meme that goes along the lines of combining other memes randomly?

[Mr. Squirrel]

Ok at the risk of sounding like an idiot on a possibly minor detail, is there a meme that goes along the lines of combining other memes randomly?

What?

[strike wolf]

Ok at the risk of sounding like an idiot on a possibly minor detail, is there a meme that goes along the lines of combining other memes randomly?

What?

*internal: OmG why doesn't anyone get me! This could be game breaking!*

External: it's not really important but you know maybe a meme that spoofs other memes by combining two random memes. Does anything like that exist?

[strike wolf]

Ok at the risk of sounding like an idiot on a possibly minor detail, is there a meme that goes along the lines of combining other memes randomly?

What?

*internal: OmG why doesn't anyone get me! This could be game breaking!*

External: it's not really important but you know maybe a meme that spoofs other memes by combining two random memes. Does anything like that exist?

Ebwop: for instance: over 9000! + O RLY?

[JenBroness]

Ok at the risk of sounding like an idiot on a possibly minor detail, is there a meme that goes along the lines of combining other memes randomly?

What?

*internal: OmG why doesn't anyone get me! This could be game breaking!*

External: it's not really important but you know maybe a meme that spoofs other memes by combining two random memes. Does anything like that exist?

When a mommy meme and a daddy meme love each other very much...

...everything goes better than expected.

[/]

Ok at the risk of sounding like an idiot on a possibly minor detail, is there a meme that goes along the lines of combining other memes randomly?

What?

*internal: OmG why doesn't anyone get me! This could be game breaking!*

External: it's not really important but you know maybe a meme that spoofs other memes by combining two random memes. Does anything like that exist?

When a mommy meme and a daddy meme love each other very much...

...everything goes better than expected.

Sounds exciting, me gusta

I agree we should be on the lookout for the scummier memes and should point them out as necessary, but I'm not sure a list is the best way to go about it, if roles correspond to scum, it probably goes both ways, it could give scum a hint to power-roles if we present everything in handy list form.

[kwanton]

I agree / but I think some are fairly obvious anyway (chargin ma lazer= probable vig/sk).

I don't remember seeing that PR yet, but I don't think everyone has posted .

[safariguy5]

Well since Rodion nameclaimed Pedobear, I think we have a convenient test case here. Now whether or not claiming your real name as mafia is what he's doing is WIFOM. That said, it could be considered a good way try and gauge what sort of memes would be mafia. Inherently, I don't see pedobear as malicious. Disturbing at times yes, but anyone who's browsed the 4chan boards has seen much worse. I don't think it warrants a vote at this point from me, but it does fall into the so called "mafia" aligned memes outlined in the list, though it's not as clear as say the troll memes.