Dragon Age Mafia ~ Day 4 ~ Town Wins at L or L

[Mr. Squirrel]

In other news lets see some votes!

Pushing for rushing a lynch. Obvious scum. vote edocsil

[sensfan]

it is day 2, and i believe we can vote.. so

vote cena-rules

[cena-rules]

it is day 2, and i believe we can vote.. so

vote cena-rules

Care to give any reasoning behind that vote?

[cena-rules]

We have a bodyguard role lurking about somewhere who is very smart and protected sensfan. This bodyguard role means that if someone tries to kill the person the bodyguard is protecting then they die. So I figure that is what happened with sens

But the scene says nothing of a bodyguard. It says that duday saved him. And sensfan already admitted that he hit foxglove. I don't know where you get your ideas from.

Didn't read the scene properly, I saw wards and figured bodyguard role

[/facepalm]

[safariguy5]

it is day 2, and i believe we can vote.. so

vote cena-rules

Yeah man, you really need to give better reasoning behind that.

[duday53]

Edocsil - you need to mod more games.

Are you saying you like this or I need more experience?


Btw, this whole modding thing is fun, the game is so different from this perspective.

As in this game is great so far. I think you should keep modding!

[sensfan]

I just wanted to get the ball rolling. Don't see cena too suspicoiuos at all.

[safariguy5]

Well sens, you're basically the man in terms of known roles. It seems like you picked a target, why don't you come up with something?

[Mr. Squirrel]

Well sens, you're basically the man in terms of known roles. It seems like you picked a target, why don't you come up with something?

I second this. If we are gonna follow anyone's blind accusation, we might as well make it the confirmed town.

[edocsil]

Post or fear the modkill. Everyone must post in the next 72 hours.

[cena-rules]

Still waiting to know why I should be lynched

[naxus]

I have absolutely nothing to add or anything to lead me to vote so just posting while I think

[MeDeFe]

*post*

I'm a bit at a loss for what to do. I can discern no good leads, but voting no lynch two days in a row seems wrong.

But I would like to know why cena should be lynched.

[Mr. Squirrel]

But I would like to know why cena should be lynched.

I think this is a dead-end lead. We all know that sensfan is town and his actions are erratic. Asking him why he voted for cena lead to nothing.

If a no-lynch is necessary for the continuation of the game, although I don't like it, I will agree to it.

I looked back on all of duday's posting history and didn't turn up much. He didn't make any enemies on day 1. The only thing of interest I found was that he told everyone that he had been playing mafia for 2 years on this site. This may have intimidated some newbies and made him a target if one of them happens to be scum. I know this because in my very first game as scum, I remember always targeting the most experienced players.

In addition, The only lead I have found from today's posts is from jrl who said:

Yeah, sensfan's role might be confirmed but it doesn't help that he killed one of us.

Now, from the night scene it seems like sensfan killed foxglove, not duday. This could have been just a slip-up by jrl but perhaps not. Maybe the "one of us" was referring to "one of the scum". And I dislike it in general that it seems as if he is trying to discredit sensfan, the only confirmed townie, with his post. In addition, this is his first game, so he fits under the category of someone who wouldve been intimidated by duday's experience.

I know this is all very speculative, but since the day seems to have stalled I'm will to act on even the slightest bit of a scumtell.

[wercool]

well idk what we need to do. should we no lynch again or lynch just to get info?

[jrl332005]

In addition, The only lead I have found from today's posts is from jrl who said:

Yeah, sensfan's role might be confirmed but it doesn't help that he killed one of us.

Now, from the night scene it seems like sensfan killed foxglove, not duday. This could have been just a slip-up by jrl but perhaps not. Maybe the "one of us" was referring to "one of the scum". And I dislike it in general that it seems as if he is trying to discredit sensfan, the only confirmed townie, with his post. In addition, this is his first game, so he fits under the category of someone who wouldve been intimidated by duday's experience.

I know this is all very speculative, but since the day seems to have stalled I'm will to act on even the slightest bit of a scumtell.

I was just confused by the scene post. It said Duday had been killed by a fireball and we know that sensfan has such an ability. I just jumped the gun there.

[safariguy5]

I have absolutely nothing to add or anything to lead me to vote so just posting while I think

I don't like this post. Everyone should have an opinion here. Posting and adding no comment is damn near close to submarining. The proposal on the table is cena being voted. Surely you can say a yes or no and some reasoning why not.

[sensfan]

Ya. Naxus is hesitating alot. FoS.

[naxus]

I have absolutely nothing to add or anything to lead me to vote so just posting while I think

I don't like this post. Everyone should have an opinion here. Posting and adding no comment is damn near close to submarining. The proposal on the table is cena being voted. Surely you can say a yes or no and some reasoning why not.

The only reason that cena is on the table for being voted is because sensfan randomly voted him in the last page or two. If he would give the reason why instead of pointing fingers then i might have something useful to add. Besides that cena hasnt really done anything to warrant my vote

[aage]

Guys, the known towny got nothing. I think it's even worse to follow him into an accusation based on nothing, than vote half-blind with an eye on what people have posted so far... The last option at least gives better results. We ought to be really lucky for a BW lead by Sensfan to get a scum kill.

Safari and Squirrel should know that. FoS on both. Don't know which one is scummier, but I'll find out.

[safariguy5]

Guys, the known towny got nothing. I think it's even worse to follow him into an accusation based on nothing, than vote half-blind with an eye on what people have posted so far... The last option at least gives better results. We ought to be really lucky for a BW lead by Sensfan to get a scum kill.

Safari and Squirrel should know that. FoS on both. Don't know which one is scummier, but I'll find out.

Well what do you suggest then? Your rationale for being suspicious about me and Squirrel seems to rest on the fact that we have posted the most. Maybe if we had more input from the rest of the people before the mod had to prod, then we would have caught someone. As it stands, the only confirmed townie is sens, and unless you want to declare something, I'll side with the known over the unknown.

[edocsil]

I have absolutely nothing to add or anything to lead me to vote so just posting while I think

Just a heads up, this wasn't the kind of post I had in mind. Lets keep on seeing the activity.
Whatever happens this game will not be allowed to die, I will happily set the end of the day and modkill to keep things moving.

[Mr. Squirrel]

Guys, the known towny got nothing. I think it's even worse to follow him into an accusation based on nothing, than vote half-blind with an eye on what people have posted so far... The last option at least gives better results. We ought to be really lucky for a BW lead by Sensfan to get a scum kill.

Safari and Squirrel should know that. FoS on both. Don't know which one is scummier, but I'll find out.

HAve you even read my posts? didn't I say that cena was a dead end? and wasn't I the only one to post anything of substance? Quit skimming the thread and actually read why don't you.

Proof:

But I would like to know why cena should be lynched.

I think this is a dead-end lead. We all know that sensfan is town and his actions are erratic. Asking him why he voted for cena lead to nothing.

I looked back on all of duday's posting history and didn't turn up much. He didn't make any enemies on day 1. The only thing of interest I found was that he told everyone that he had been playing mafia for 2 years on this site. This may have intimidated some newbies and made him a target if one of them happens to be scum. I know this because in my very first game as scum, I remember always targeting the most experienced players.

In addition, The only lead I have found from today's posts is from jrl who said:

Yeah, sensfan's role might be confirmed but it doesn't help that he killed one of us.

Now, from the night scene it seems like sensfan killed foxglove, not duday. This could have been just a slip-up by jrl but perhaps not. Maybe the "one of us" was referring to "one of the scum". And I dislike it in general that it seems as if he is trying to discredit sensfan, the only confirmed townie, with his post. In addition, this is his first game, so he fits under the category of someone who wouldve been intimidated by duday's experience.

I know this is all very speculative, but since the day seems to have stalled I'm will to act on even the slightest bit of a scumtell.

[aage]

Well sens, you're basically the man in terms of known roles. It seems like you picked a target, why don't you come up with something?

I second this. If we are gonna follow anyone's blind accusation, we might as well make it the confirmed town.

Here the reason why I am FoS'ing both of you. Your first response to the fact that the firmed towny votes for someone is that we all should follow his accusation blindly. Please notify me if I read this wrong here, but I think especially Mr. Squirrel's post almost literally says we should.

The reason I FoS'ed you both is because I have the impression you both already played various mafia games and thus should know that a random BW is not getting us anywhere.

[aage]

Well sens, you're basically the man in terms of known roles. It seems like you picked a target, why don't you come up with something?

I second this. If we are gonna follow anyone's blind accusation, we might as well make it the confirmed town.

Here the reason why I am FoS'ing both of you. Your first response to the fact that the firmed towny votes for someone is that we all should follow his accusation blindly. Please notify me if I read this wrong here, but I think especially Mr. Squirrel's post almost literally says we should.

The reason I FoS'ed you both is because I have the impression you both already played various mafia games and thus should know that a random BW is not getting us anywhere.

As on what you said later, that's not what I'm aiming at.

If you are interested in my opinion on what you said later, I would like you to know that the argument you give against jrl only counts if jrl is a complete idiot and did not know he shouldn't tell us he is scum. Since I believe he is not a complete idiot, your argument is gone and there is only an empty suspicion pointing at jrl. I don't like that. I mean, if you want to help the firmed towny get a scum BW, you really should give reasons for it. This is not reasons. This is just bullcrap. I don't like it.