Black Whole Mafia - Closed because of inactivity

[max is gr8]

I should have been Dr X. as I truely am phycic and in a wheelchair

[dagreatbroomhead]

i choose all my roles out of a hat, i tore pieces of paper and went down the list in order of names, if people wanted to try again(I'd have to be sure everyone actually wanted to play) we could try Upick, where you get to pick your flavor and the mod gets to decide your role, so if your angling to be a mob boss, you might try "the don"

[Machiavelli]

And BTW, well played Mach, you had me worried for a lot of the time.

Thanks, you played well also.

I would like to say that I had 4 people written down on a note card, two of which I thought were mafia. I choose these four people because they had bandwagoned max. These people were hoff, fishfleas, kingwaffles, and cutlah. The only other two who bandwagoned max were cahoots and painbrian, both were already killed. It turns out that 3 of the 4 living people who bandwagoned max were mafia. Go figure.

As for roles and things, it was kinda hard to deteremine balance seeing as neither the doc nor the cop were particularly active....

It is a common move for the cop and doctor to remain inactive, so as not to draw attention to themselves.

I had two other people written down on another notecard. These two people were axelius and Sprcobra. They were two of the people who posted the least. I figured that one of them was the mafia and one of them was the cop/doctor. I figured that axelius was the mafia because, although sprcobra didnt help, I could tell that he wanted others to be more active by bumping the thread with a post that said "post".


And I think that I could have gotten hoff lynched tomorrow but the mafia still would have won.

[dagreatbroomhead]

It is a common move for the cop and doctor to remain inactive, so as not to draw attention to themselves.

yes common for them to remain silent, not common for them not to send in choices without me dogging them, and your lucky that i was on the doc's back to choose someone cause he choose you and saved you.

[Machiavelli]

Oh, I didnt realize they werent sending in night choices.

And sprcobra isnt very good at mafia any way. I played against him, as mafia, in my first game on mafia scum and I killed him Night one and went on to win the game.

[kingwaffles]

Yeah, I know sometimes docs/cops will stay low to avoid lots of attention, but they are barely ever on the forums at all...
Also, once we had killed Banana there would be 6... with 3 of us as mafia I don't think you could pull a lynch on Hoff.

[dagreatbroomhead]

well he did have two votes... normally the win condition for mafia is 50% but i thought just in case a situation like this one arises... and it was funny, that you left, the double voter, a cop and a doc left alive, you hit everyone else.

[kingwaffles]

Right... I forgot about that. Hmm.... I think you probably could have convinced em to vote for Hoff, knowing you....

[Machiavelli]

Right... I forgot about that. Hmm.... I think you probably could have convinced em to vote for Hoff, knowing you....

And once I did that then you and cutlah would obviously stand out for defending hoff.

The doctor would save me, you would kill either the doc or the cop and it would be three pro town votes to two mafia votes. We would lynch one of you two, the doctor would save me again at night and then it would be me w/ 2 votes against the other mafia w/ only one vote.

Victory!:D



This is all very optimistic thinking of course...

[Hoff]

Yes you figured me out mach, nice job.

[dagreatbroomhead]

this all works execpt one thing, NEITHER OF THEM WERE ACTIVE!

[DRoZ]

Is there any chance of starting another one ... I'd enjoy joining and I've always got a CC web page up from 7-5 EST all through the week and 9-12 EST on saturday ... I rarely get on sundays.

[dagreatbroomhead]

well i'd love to, but i just don't know if i have the support yet. i'll keep you in mind if i hear of more people interested

[Hoff]

I'll be up for another game if people actually play and post

[Darkfire001]

I'd like to join in when the next one starts

[PainBrain]

I'll join the next one.

[dagreatbroomhead]

hmm intriguing, 4 people who readily want to play...hmmm and i'd assume mach would want to play, but thats what i want to avoid, to make people join and then not be active. so if i get one more person who says they want in, i'll start sign ups.

[Machiavelli]

Does that one more person include me or not, because you know Im in.

[kingwaffles]

you know I'm in Broomy, though I'll be outta town till the 18th....

[Darkfire001]

K cool thats easily Six, 8 or 10 would be nice though. I'm game for all of june basically (playwise).

[dagreatbroomhead]

yeah, okay, i give, ANOTHER GAME!

this time it will be quite active! and the screening process will be very rigorous... if you can find the thread to sign up, you may play. (hint: this isn't a trick, its in the off topics...)

and while we are all discussing the mafia game here... i'd like some ideas for a new theme. last time i did black whole so i could include whatever i wanted, this time i want it to be more like "Monty python and the holy grail theme" orrrr "literary Mafia" orrrrrr "reality show mafia" basically i need ideas.

[Machiavelli]

I never was quite sure, did you mean to spell "hole" wrong?

[dagreatbroomhead]

i meant to spell it that way, its a pun, black hole, black Whole meaning anything and everything

so suggestions for theme, i am thinking mario bros.

[Machiavelli]

I think that would work nicely.