Clan League: Season 2 (2009-2010) - Info, Discussion, Q&A

by **reptile** on Mon Jun 21, 2010 9:47 am

lordnex wrote:Someone please post game links

by **josko.ri** on Mon Jul 05, 2010 9:05 am

I know it is too late for change format of season 3, but maybe you can make better season 4 format. from my sight, it is league, not cup, so it is not good that winner is decided in only 17 games playoff. I think league champion must be the clan which played the best during ALL season, not the one who win only 9 from 17 games in semifinal and final games.
as format for season 3 (relegated and promoted teams) is already decided, I suggest to make season 4 really league, not cup(as we already have conqueror's cup). it can be make, for example, if Division 1 has 12 (or 10, it may be discussed) clans who will play each other home and away (22 clan wars if 12 teams). also, Division 2 may have 12 teams, and all other teams may play in new formed Division 3 (or Division 4 if lot of new clans will be then), so every clan will have optional league level to play in.
if my suggestion will be implemented, we will avoid that winner of Clan League be the team who was 2 times (semis and finals) in ONLY 17 games better than the other Clan. 17 games is too low for League that last almost a year.
playoff is not necessary in League, because we already have conqueror's cup.

by **jpcloet** on Mon Jul 05, 2010 11:43 am

Season 3 is not decided. People wanted the playoffs.

by **josko.ri** on Mon Jul 05, 2010 1:39 pm

jpcloet wrote:[*]The bottom 2 Clans in each division will be relegated automatically (where applicable)
[*]The 6th place (3rd last) will have a Relegation Playoff against the next lower Division's 3rd place team. Winner will get to play in the higher Division the next Season.

because of that qouted above I thought that season 3 is decided. I mean equal number of teams like this season (16) will play in Division 1, and 30 Clan wars is I think too much. I joined clan when clan league was in semifinal so didnt know that players decided for playoffs. but from my opinion, playing well 112 games, and then be elminated in only 17 games is not good. if it is league then let s play league. if it is cup then let s play cup.

maybe the reason why players chose playoff format is because 16 teams is in Division 1. they didnt wanted to play 30 clan wars because it would be too exhausting. if you reduce number of teams in Division 1 to 12 or 10 then I think more players would choose completely league format because it would then be 22 or 18 clan wars, which I think is optimal.

anyway, I think that you may put new pool when starting season 3, so players may again choose if want playoff or not.

by **Chariot of Fire** on Wed Jul 14, 2010 1:12 am

I don't mind the Playoffs but I agree that best-of-17 is too small a sample to decide such an important contest.

by **hiddendragon** on Fri Jul 16, 2010 8:29 pm

damn, missed this thread earlier. You know the BSS are always in jp

by **Qwert** on Thu Aug 05, 2010 2:14 pm

Im also for League format,withouth Playoffs. think that will be great that create 3 division with equal clan strengt, with same number of team(lets say 10 teams),and in first round play home and away, and best 3 from each division form superleague,and play again home and away games. These can give to all clans equal chance to be winner-no playoffs. If someon need more info abouth these concept,i can give you visual view.