Dysonsphere - Secret Diplomacy[CLEARED]ES

[NeilLock]

Accused:

dysonshpere


The accused are suspected of:

Conducting Secret Diplomacy





Game number(s):

Game 6961557

Comments:

In the game chat Dysonsphere offers to use a PM to setup playing times that will give the other player and advantage over me. This seems to be a pretty clear cut case of SD and I asked that Dysonsphere be removed from CC. My understanding is that anything related to strategy should be discussed openly in GC. Please administer justice.

[gundiesalvo]

Accused:

dysonsphere


The accused are suspected of:

Conducting Secret Diplomacy





Game number(s):

Game 6961557

Comments:

In the game chat Dysonsphere offers to use a PM to setup playing times that will give the other player and advantage over me. This seems to be a pretty clear cut case of SD and I asked that Dysonsphere be removed from CC. My understanding is that anything related to strategy should be discussed openly in GC. Please administer justice.

Fixed a typo on the Player Name

[theherkman]

The worst he will get is a warning, fyi.

[NeilLock]

He may only get a warning, and if that's what the mods decide is fair I'll have to live with it. This is not the guy's first appearance in a C&A post though. He is a clear menace to the community.

[gundiesalvo]

It looks like he always talks his diplo openly on game chat, dunno why he offered PM on that game. I agree with theherkman, a warning should be enough. And I don´t think Dysonsphere is a clear menace to the community, if he bothers you so much just foe him.

[eddie2]

ok here is the game chat in question


2010-05-16 16:25:00 - dysonsphere: he forgot me in UK
2010-05-16 16:25:16 - dysonsphere: he now has 12 hours in which we can restart and get back in
2010-05-16 16:25:47 - dysonsphere: and he has no spoils too
2010-05-16 16:26:19 - dysonsphere: message me if you like and we can come to an agreement on timed restart
2010-05-16 16:26:38 - dysonsphere: or that of course
2010-05-16 16:26:40 - dysonsphere: lol gg

now this is tricky because by the sounds of the chat there has been no pms this will be good to watch.

[eddie2]

He may only get a warning, and if that's what the mods decide is fair I'll have to live with it. This is not the guy's first appearance in a C&A post though. He is a clear menace to the community.

neal he has had 1 apperance in c and a for game chat in this game

Game 5071893

its a funny read and he reported himself i dont think its a menace to the site also maybe he was trying to get the other player a warning as he did not send a message he asked the other player 2

[Evil Semp]

Without any evidence of secret diplomacy there isn't anything we can do. There was no PM reported, as far as I can see all discussion was done in game chat. So Dysonsphere is CLEARED.