I always hope to get the conversation started before everyone can get their talking points.bedub1 wrote:I was going to come post about this, but I'm glad you guys are already on top of it. This is just proof that the US DOES have the BEST healthcare system in the world.Phatscotty wrote:Canadian Premier Williams is coming to the USA for his heart surgery. Isnt that the same guy who said in the past, repeatedly...
fastforward to 2010, Canadian Premier Williams, upon needing health care himself....Any Health Care available in the USA is available in Canada
I can't get the Health Care I need in Canada
ObamaCare - exchanges ,report your states options!
Moderator: Community Team
Forum rules
Please read the Community Guidelines before posting.
Please read the Community Guidelines before posting.
- Phatscotty
- Posts: 3693
- Joined: Mon Dec 10, 2007 5:50 pm
- Gender: Male
Re: Socialized Healthcare
Re: Socialized Healthcare
lol. she didn't say anything about emergency rooms. in fact, the discussion is about a highly specialized procedure on a heart. Everything you said is a myth.Phatscotty wrote:you CAN NOT be turned away from an emergency room....everything you said is a myth.PLAYER57832 wrote:For a reality check, try seeing how long an uninsured person has to wait here in the US...Phatscotty wrote:when you say "wait" it sounds like "oh that's just the way it is in Canada, ya know?" like you always have to wait.....for heart surgery? How long is that wait? holy shit is everything ok up there?Baron Von PWN wrote:Is that actually a quote from Danny Williams? As far as I know he hasn't spoken to the media about whatever is ailing him yet.
It's standard procedure in Canada that if a patient has a very specific problem requiring a specialist the gov will make sure you get access to that specialist even if it means going outside of the country. sometimes this means the US sometimes it means Europe all depends on the circumstances. In the Premier's case we don't know the details he and his staff have declined to give them. He might just not want to wait and so he bought the procedure in the US or it might be a rare case that needs a very specific kind of specialist.
he is a very popular politician it will be interesting to see how this will play out in Newfoundland & Labrador.
OR what it costs most people who only think they have enough insurance, here in the US. Things have changed in the past year with the bank issues, but the year before it was still true that roughly 75% of bankruptcies came within 2 years of a serious medical issue. Paying for the healthcare might not have been the direct and immediate cause of a person losing their home, etc. However, it often set off a cascading set of issues.
- Baron Von PWN
- Posts: 203
- Joined: Thu Oct 01, 2009 10:05 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: Capital region ,Canada
Re: Socialized Healthcare
Which of course is why Americans die sooner than most other developed nations.bedub1 wrote:I was going to come post about this, but I'm glad you guys are already on top of it. This is just proof that the US DOES have the BEST healthcare system in the world.Phatscotty wrote:Canadian Premier Williams is coming to the USA for his heart surgery. Isnt that the same guy who said in the past, repeatedly...
fastforward to 2010, Canadian Premier Williams, upon needing health care himself....Any Health Care available in the USA is available in Canada
I can't get the Health Care I need in Canada
- Phatscotty
- Posts: 3693
- Joined: Mon Dec 10, 2007 5:50 pm
- Gender: Male
Re: Socialized Healthcare
Sure, completely discount that we make our own life choices. For example, for some unknown reason, there is an abundance of red meat in the USA. People can go and choose to eat meat whenever they want. I could go on for a week why Canadians live 4 months longer on average than Americans. To say it's all because of Canadas health care system is absolutely naive.Baron Von PWN wrote:Which of course is why Americans die sooner than most other developed nations.bedub1 wrote:I was going to come post about this, but I'm glad you guys are already on top of it. This is just proof that the US DOES have the BEST healthcare system in the world.Phatscotty wrote:Canadian Premier Williams is coming to the USA for his heart surgery. Isnt that the same guy who said in the past, repeatedly...
fastforward to 2010, Canadian Premier Williams, upon needing health care himself....Any Health Care available in the USA is available in Canada
I can't get the Health Care I need in Canada
- Baron Von PWN
- Posts: 203
- Joined: Thu Oct 01, 2009 10:05 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: Capital region ,Canada
Re: Socialized Healthcare
If only there were some kind of system that helped people stay healthy. Oh well we can only dream.Phatscotty wrote:Sure, completely discount that we make our own life choices. For example, for some unknown reason, there is an abundance of red meat in the USA. People can go and choose to eat meat whenever they want. I could go on for a week why Canadians live 4 months longer on average than Americans. To say it's all because of Canadas health care system is absolutely naive.Baron Von PWN wrote:Which of course is why Americans die sooner than most other developed nations.bedub1 wrote:I was going to come post about this, but I'm glad you guys are already on top of it. This is just proof that the US DOES have the BEST healthcare system in the world.Phatscotty wrote:Canadian Premier Williams is coming to the USA for his heart surgery. Isnt that the same guy who said in the past, repeatedly...
fastforward to 2010, Canadian Premier Williams, upon needing health care himself....Any Health Care available in the USA is available in Canada
I can't get the Health Care I need in Canada
- Phatscotty
- Posts: 3693
- Joined: Mon Dec 10, 2007 5:50 pm
- Gender: Male
Re: Socialized Healthcare
I think it's called "force"? no thank you, prefer freedomBaron Von PWN wrote:If only there were some kind of system that helped people stay healthy. Oh well we can only dream.Phatscotty wrote:Sure, completely discount that we make our own life choices. For example, for some unknown reason, there is an abundance of red meat in the USA. People can go and choose to eat meat whenever they want. I could go on for a week why Canadians live 4 months longer on average than Americans. To say it's all because of Canadas health care system is absolutely naive.Baron Von PWN wrote:Which of course is why Americans die sooner than most other developed nations.bedub1 wrote: I was going to come post about this, but I'm glad you guys are already on top of it. This is just proof that the US DOES have the BEST healthcare system in the world.
Baron-
You see, if we just lay inside a box, and never eat red meat, and never have any fun, and never fly on an airplane, never go out in the sun, never work more than 28 hours a week, or never drive on a highway, you can live a very long time! This is the best! Can't you see? here, I'll show you! now you don't even have the choice! This is the way everybody should be!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
- Baron Von PWN
- Posts: 203
- Joined: Thu Oct 01, 2009 10:05 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: Capital region ,Canada
Re: Socialized Healthcare
Not sure which Baron you're quoting there but they would be very wrong. Red meat in moderation is good for you, as is sunlight and flying is one of the safest means of travel.Phatscotty wrote:I think it's called "force"? no thank you, prefer freedomBaron Von PWN wrote:If only there were some kind of system that helped people stay healthy. Oh well we can only dream.Phatscotty wrote:Sure, completely discount that we make our own life choices. For example, for some unknown reason, there is an abundance of red meat in the USA. People can go and choose to eat meat whenever they want. I could go on for a week why Canadians live 4 months longer on average than Americans. To say it's all because of Canadas health care system is absolutely naive.Baron Von PWN wrote:Which of course is why Americans die sooner than most other developed nations.bedub1 wrote: I was going to come post about this, but I'm glad you guys are already on top of it. This is just proof that the US DOES have the BEST healthcare system in the world.
Baron-
You see, if we just lay inside a box, and never eat red meat, and never have any fun, and never fly on an airplane, never go out in the sun, never work more than 28 hours a week, or never drive on a highway, you can live a very long time! This is the best! Can't you see? here, I'll show you! now you don't even have the choice! This is the way everybody should be!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
- Phatscotty
- Posts: 3693
- Joined: Mon Dec 10, 2007 5:50 pm
- Gender: Male
Re: Socialized Healthcare
holy shit dude look up the word freedom...you just have not a clueBaron Von PWN wrote:Not sure which Baron you're quoting there but they would be very wrong. Red meat in moderation is good for you, as is sunlight and flying is one of the safest means of travel.Phatscotty wrote:I think it's called "force"? no thank you, prefer freedomBaron Von PWN wrote:If only there were some kind of system that helped people stay healthy. Oh well we can only dream.Phatscotty wrote:Sure, completely discount that we make our own life choices. For example, for some unknown reason, there is an abundance of red meat in the USA. People can go and choose to eat meat whenever they want. I could go on for a week why Canadians live 4 months longer on average than Americans. To say it's all because of Canadas health care system is absolutely naive.Baron Von PWN wrote:
Which of course is why Americans die sooner than most other developed nations.
Baron-
You see, if we just lay inside a box, and never eat red meat, and never have any fun, and never fly on an airplane, never go out in the sun, never work more than 28 hours a week, or never drive on a highway, you can live a very long time! This is the best! Can't you see? here, I'll show you! now you don't even have the choice! This is the way everybody should be!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
-
PLAYER57832
- Posts: 3075
- Joined: Fri Sep 21, 2007 9:17 am
- Gender: Female
- Location: Pennsylvania
Re: Socialized Healthcare
Missed the point again. If you are able to walk around, etc. then you are no longer a true "emergency" in most cases. Suspected heart issues ARE emergencies, but only if the doctor believes you and doesn't think you are just looking for a warm place, on drugs, etc.Phatscotty wrote:PLAYER57832 wrote:you CAN NOT be turned away from an emergency room....everything you said is a myth.Phatscotty wrote: For a reality check, try seeing how long an uninsured person has to wait here in the US...
OR what it costs most people who only think they have enough insurance, here in the US. Things have changed in the past year with the bank issues, but the year before it was still true that roughly 75% of bankruptcies came within 2 years of a serious medical issue. Paying for the healthcare might not have been the direct and immediate cause of a person losing their home, etc. However, it often set off a cascading set of issues.
Besides, reliance upon emergency rooms is part of why our uninsured health bill (paid for by we taxpayers) is so very, very high and rising. That's part of the problem, not the solution. The solution is to get everyone REGULAR care.
But, hey, I only have family all over the US and in Europe, have multitudes of experiences (both good and bad) with several different insurance companies, and have been obtaining this for more than a few years on my own dime.
Re: Socialized Healthcare
Don't let this all fool you. Socialized or Privatized Healthcare = Someone is still getting rich, and it's not me.
Change the Government, they answer to us. If they don't listen, vote them ALL out!!!
Smile stickers for everyone!
Change the Government, they answer to us. If they don't listen, vote them ALL out!!!
Smile stickers for everyone!
- Phatscotty
- Posts: 3693
- Joined: Mon Dec 10, 2007 5:50 pm
- Gender: Male
Re: Socialized Healthcare
you are wrongPLAYER57832 wrote:Missed the point again. If you are able to walk around, etc. then you are no longer a true "emergency" in most cases. Suspected heart issues ARE emergencies, but only if the doctor believes you and doesn't think you are just looking for a warm place, on drugs, etc.Phatscotty wrote:PLAYER57832 wrote:you CAN NOT be turned away from an emergency room....everything you said is a myth.Phatscotty wrote: For a reality check, try seeing how long an uninsured person has to wait here in the US...
OR what it costs most people who only think they have enough insurance, here in the US. Things have changed in the past year with the bank issues, but the year before it was still true that roughly 75% of bankruptcies came within 2 years of a serious medical issue. Paying for the healthcare might not have been the direct and immediate cause of a person losing their home, etc. However, it often set off a cascading set of issues.
Besides, reliance upon emergency rooms is part of why our uninsured health bill (paid for by we taxpayers) is so very, very high and rising. That's part of the problem, not the solution. The solution is to get everyone REGULAR care.
But, hey, I only have family all over the US and in Europe, have multitudes of experiences (both good and bad) with several different insurance companies, and have been obtaining this for more than a few years on my own dime.
Re: Socialized Healthcare
Um, it's still an emergancy if the doctor's wrong and doesn't believe the person having heart "issues".Suspected heart issues ARE emergencies, but only if the doctor believes you and doesn't think you are just looking for a warm place, on drugs, etc.
Re: Socialized Healthcare
Its simply proof that you have some of the best specialists in the world. I know several Canadian doctors that work in the states simply because the pay is better. If your health system is so great, why do Canadians, and many other nationalities, live longer? I haven't checked, but I bet you Cubans have a longer life span.bedub1 wrote:I was going to come post about this, but I'm glad you guys are already on top of it. This is just proof that the US DOES have the BEST healthcare system in the world.Phatscotty wrote:Canadian Premier Williams is coming to the USA for his heart surgery. Isnt that the same guy who said in the past, repeatedly...
fastforward to 2010, Canadian Premier Williams, upon needing health care himself....Any Health Care available in the USA is available in Canada
I can't get the Health Care I need in Canada
- Baron Von PWN
- Posts: 203
- Joined: Thu Oct 01, 2009 10:05 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: Capital region ,Canada
Re: Socialized Healthcare
They do, just barely.notyou2 wrote:Its simply proof that you have some of the best specialists in the world. I know several Canadian doctors that work in the states simply because the pay is better. If your health system is so great, why do Canadians, and many other nationalities, live longer? I haven't checked, but I bet you Cubans have a longer life span.bedub1 wrote:I was going to come post about this, but I'm glad you guys are already on top of it. This is just proof that the US DOES have the BEST healthcare system in the world.Phatscotty wrote:Canadian Premier Williams is coming to the USA for his heart surgery. Isnt that the same guy who said in the past, repeatedly...
fastforward to 2010, Canadian Premier Williams, upon needing health care himself....Any Health Care available in the USA is available in Canada
I can't get the Health Care I need in Canada
Re: Socialized Healthcare
Brilliant counter Scotty....Fuckin brilliant!!!! Mind if I use that one?Phatscotty wrote:you are wrongPLAYER57832 wrote:Missed the point again. If you are able to walk around, etc. then you are no longer a true "emergency" in most cases. Suspected heart issues ARE emergencies, but only if the doctor believes you and doesn't think you are just looking for a warm place, on drugs, etc.Phatscotty wrote:PLAYER57832 wrote:you CAN NOT be turned away from an emergency room....everything you said is a myth.Phatscotty wrote: For a reality check, try seeing how long an uninsured person has to wait here in the US...
OR what it costs most people who only think they have enough insurance, here in the US. Things have changed in the past year with the bank issues, but the year before it was still true that roughly 75% of bankruptcies came within 2 years of a serious medical issue. Paying for the healthcare might not have been the direct and immediate cause of a person losing their home, etc. However, it often set off a cascading set of issues.
Besides, reliance upon emergency rooms is part of why our uninsured health bill (paid for by we taxpayers) is so very, very high and rising. That's part of the problem, not the solution. The solution is to get everyone REGULAR care.
But, hey, I only have family all over the US and in Europe, have multitudes of experiences (both good and bad) with several different insurance companies, and have been obtaining this for more than a few years on my own dime.
- Phatscotty
- Posts: 3693
- Joined: Mon Dec 10, 2007 5:50 pm
- Gender: Male
Re: Socialized Healthcare
I'm sure it's ALL socialized healthcare, with no single other contributing factor.notyou2 wrote:Its simply proof that you have some of the best specialists in the world. I know several Canadian doctors that work in the states simply because the pay is better. If your health system is so great, why do Canadians, and many other nationalities, live longer? I haven't checked, but I bet you Cubans have a longer life span.bedub1 wrote:I was going to come post about this, but I'm glad you guys are already on top of it. This is just proof that the US DOES have the BEST healthcare system in the world.Phatscotty wrote:Canadian Premier Williams is coming to the USA for his heart surgery. Isnt that the same guy who said in the past, repeatedly...
fastforward to 2010, Canadian Premier Williams, upon needing health care himself....Any Health Care available in the USA is available in Canada
I can't get the Health Care I need in Canada
- Phatscotty
- Posts: 3693
- Joined: Mon Dec 10, 2007 5:50 pm
- Gender: Male
Re: Socialized Healthcare
I have a close relative that works at numerous hospitals as head ER. I'm just not even going to adress that point. it's wrong on so many levels. I don't have to educate him on how it really works. I would rather stand back and watch him slit his own throat with demands for socialized medicine, so America can throw the progressives out once and for all.notyou2 wrote:Brilliant counter Scotty....Fuckin brilliant!!!! Mind if I use that one?Phatscotty wrote:you are wrongPLAYER57832 wrote:Missed the point again. If you are able to walk around, etc. then you are no longer a true "emergency" in most cases. Suspected heart issues ARE emergencies, but only if the doctor believes you and doesn't think you are just looking for a warm place, on drugs, etc.Phatscotty wrote:PLAYER57832 wrote: you CAN NOT be turned away from an emergency room....everything you said is a myth.
Besides, reliance upon emergency rooms is part of why our uninsured health bill (paid for by we taxpayers) is so very, very high and rising. That's part of the problem, not the solution. The solution is to get everyone REGULAR care.
But, hey, I only have family all over the US and in Europe, have multitudes of experiences (both good and bad) with several different insurance companies, and have been obtaining this for more than a few years on my own dime.
Re: Socialized Healthcare
Mega dittos Scotty!
- Baron Von PWN
- Posts: 203
- Joined: Thu Oct 01, 2009 10:05 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: Capital region ,Canada
Re: Socialized Healthcare
Ok I will. Freedom is the human value, or situation, to act according to one's will without being held up by the power of others.Phatscotty wrote: holy shit dude look up the word freedom...you just have not a clue![]()
Hmm sounds pretty subjective. There are many situations in the USA which are not "free" according to the criteria you seem to place on public healthcare. For example: Americans are not free to shoot whomever they please. Americans are forced to drive under certain speeds. they are forced to go school. Americans are prohibited from buying certain things or going to certain countries.
Oh my, how do you Americans live in such an oppressive system.
- Snorri1234
- Posts: 3438
- Joined: Wed Sep 12, 2007 11:52 am
- Location: Right in the middle of a fucking reptile zoo.
- Contact:
Re: Socialized Healthcare
bedub1 wrote:I was going to come post about this, but I'm glad you guys are already on top of it. This is just proof that the US DOES have the BEST healthcare system in the world.Phatscotty wrote:Canadian Premier Williams is coming to the USA for his heart surgery. Isnt that the same guy who said in the past, repeatedly...
fastforward to 2010, Canadian Premier Williams, upon needing health care himself....Any Health Care available in the USA is available in Canada
I can't get the Health Care I need in Canada
STOP BEING SO UNBELIEVABLY DUMB YOU GUYS! SERIOUSLY!
"Some motherfuckers are always trying to ice skate uphill."
Duane: You know what they say about love and war.
Tim: Yes, one involves a lot of physical and psychological pain, and the other one's war.
Duane: You know what they say about love and war.
Tim: Yes, one involves a lot of physical and psychological pain, and the other one's war.
- Snorri1234
- Posts: 3438
- Joined: Wed Sep 12, 2007 11:52 am
- Location: Right in the middle of a fucking reptile zoo.
- Contact:
Re: Socialized Healthcare
http://www.denverpost.com/ci_13530098
Why does the greatest health care system in the world ban healthy babies from insurance?
Why does the greatest health care system in the world ban healthy babies from insurance?
"Some motherfuckers are always trying to ice skate uphill."
Duane: You know what they say about love and war.
Tim: Yes, one involves a lot of physical and psychological pain, and the other one's war.
Duane: You know what they say about love and war.
Tim: Yes, one involves a lot of physical and psychological pain, and the other one's war.
- Snorri1234
- Posts: 3438
- Joined: Wed Sep 12, 2007 11:52 am
- Location: Right in the middle of a fucking reptile zoo.
- Contact:
Re: Socialized Healthcare
"Some motherfuckers are always trying to ice skate uphill."
Duane: You know what they say about love and war.
Tim: Yes, one involves a lot of physical and psychological pain, and the other one's war.
Duane: You know what they say about love and war.
Tim: Yes, one involves a lot of physical and psychological pain, and the other one's war.
-
PLAYER57832
- Posts: 3075
- Joined: Fri Sep 21, 2007 9:17 am
- Gender: Female
- Location: Pennsylvania
Re: Socialized Healthcare
Phatscotty wrote: I have a close relative that works at numerous hospitals as head ER.
So do I, and while I have not run an ER, I have been an EMT in 4 states.
Educate me? Try educating yourself. I not only have relatives in emergency care, I was an EMT in 5 states, have literally grilled local doctors and administrators on these issues, partially to solve these issues here (they are well beyond local means of solutions, though) and partially because our whole hospital/medical care systems have been in huge flux.Phatscotty wrote:I'm just not even going to adress that point. it's wrong on so many levels. I don't have to educate him on how it really works. I would rather stand back and watch him slit his own throat with demands for socialized medicine, so America can throw the progressives out once and for all.
Among other issues, you might get admitted, get treatment, but the bill collectors WILL come calling unless you are homeless or can prove you are indigent. Even then, relatives can be hit up for payment. In our case, when my husband' insurance changed, leaving us with a $1000 deductable, we told the hospital we would pay 1/2. Their answer? We got sent to collections and I had to field 2 weeks of daily harrassing phone calls until I finally put the charges on our credit card.
Second, definitions of emergencies vary a great deal. You might get care, but the If you are a woman, are poor, are a minority person, you are far less likely to be taken seriously by doctors. If a doctor does not feel your issue is "life threatening", then you have to provide proof you can pay. If you don't, they can generally turn you away. If a doctor does not feel your issue is "life threatening", then they can generally turn you away.
The biggest issue is that when you say "emergency rooms have to treat people" you ignore the fact that emergency is not supposed to be the first line of care. People who can regularly see doctors, get the tests they need are far less likely to need the emergency room. But that care is rarely available for free. Currently, in my community, many of those who have insurance cannot afford to go. And, though I have said it before, I will say it again, those who can are WORKING people -- people working 40 hours plus -- who's kids qualify for Medicaid either because they make less than $39,000 (for a family of 4 in PA) or have a child with a disability.
This uninsured and underinsured group includes a good many small business owners as well as those who work for them.
So .. please explain exactly what it is that you feel "I just have wrong" ?
Oh .. one more thing .... I am not "a guy".
- Snorri1234
- Posts: 3438
- Joined: Wed Sep 12, 2007 11:52 am
- Location: Right in the middle of a fucking reptile zoo.
- Contact:
Re: Socialized Healthcare
I still don't understand why ER's not being able to deny you care is considered a good argument for your system being awesome.
"Some motherfuckers are always trying to ice skate uphill."
Duane: You know what they say about love and war.
Tim: Yes, one involves a lot of physical and psychological pain, and the other one's war.
Duane: You know what they say about love and war.
Tim: Yes, one involves a lot of physical and psychological pain, and the other one's war.
- Snorri1234
- Posts: 3438
- Joined: Wed Sep 12, 2007 11:52 am
- Location: Right in the middle of a fucking reptile zoo.
- Contact:
Re: Socialized Healthcare
Snorri1234 wrote:bedub1 wrote:I was going to come post about this, but I'm glad you guys are already on top of it. This is just proof that the US DOES have the BEST healthcare system in the world.Phatscotty wrote:Canadian Premier Williams is coming to the USA for his heart surgery. Isnt that the same guy who said in the past, repeatedly...
fastforward to 2010, Canadian Premier Williams, upon needing health care himself....Any Health Care available in the USA is available in Canada
I can't get the Health Care I need in Canada
STOP BEING SO UNBELIEVABLY DUMB YOU GUYS! SERIOUSLY!
Seriously guys. This is not proof of anything.
"Some motherfuckers are always trying to ice skate uphill."
Duane: You know what they say about love and war.
Tim: Yes, one involves a lot of physical and psychological pain, and the other one's war.
Duane: You know what they say about love and war.
Tim: Yes, one involves a lot of physical and psychological pain, and the other one's war.