Puff's Dead Man's Gulch Mafia Game, The White Bandits Win!

UCAbears · Post by **UCAbears** » Mon Feb 12, 2007 10:34 pm

guys guys guys I have other things I have to get done during my time on the comp and just about everytime I come its night and I dont have the time to read the pages to see whats suspicious and whats not. So that may be y u think I am bandwagoning.

Lord Canti · Post by **Lord Canti** » Mon Feb 12, 2007 11:25 pm

UCAbears wrote:guys guys guys I have other things I have to get done during my time on the comp and just about everytime I come its night and I dont have the time to read the pages to see whats suspicious and whats not. So that may be y u think I am bandwagoning.

Yeah... so you decide to vote to lynch me when you don't even know what the heck is going on...what's that about?

Minkish · Post by **Minkish** » Mon Feb 12, 2007 11:29 pm

alright, f*ck this. You're right Canti, that it's been a pretty damn long day for me, and I was getting tired of not having any activity in this thread.

When we killed Anarkist yesterday, it was because of a dumb reason that a mafia member was able to get everyone to believe. The same damn thing could be happening today.

Unvote Lord Canti

FOS Rodger Dodger

We've all read the rules. We all know that theres not any clues given in the story. I'd love to hear some reasonings from Dodger as to why Canti is guilty just off of what the sotry says.

And if I remember correctly, Dodger and XenHu had a little confrontation on Day 1. If Dodger is mafia, then that could have just been a big bluff by XenHu to protect both of their identities. I thought XenHu was just trying to cover for himself, but it's very possible he was trying to cover for an accomplice as well.

Kernal_Kronic · Post by **Kernal_Kronic** » Tue Feb 13, 2007 5:35 am

If you go by the story, why would Lord Canti put 2 bodies into a pinyata, that he made, and allow it to get broken open in public?

SO...I'm not gonna vote lynching Lord Canti based purely on the story.

VOTE: everywhere116

Reason: The early bandwagonning with the mafia scum. You sleep with dogs, you wake up with fleas

Roger Dodger · Post by **Roger Dodger** » Tue Feb 13, 2007 6:21 am

first of all Xenhu & i always argue but, it has never been personal.

just go back & read everything and you'll see i'm right. He made the pinata. he filled it. you can believe what you want to but, the good Lord Canti protest too much.

my vote will not change.. i was right before, i am right now.

you guys do what you want. that's all i have to say.

frodobaggins994 · Post by **frodobaggins994** » Tue Feb 13, 2007 7:57 am

Lord Canti wrote:FOS frodobaggins994

Not ready to vote lynch yet, but this guy was just too willing to agree a vote to lynch me, and left no reason, just his vote

i just voted that cuz every1 else did

Minkish · Post by **Minkish** » Tue Feb 13, 2007 8:17 am

Kernal_Kronic wrote:If you go by the story, why would Lord Canti put 2 bodies into a pinyata, that he made, and allow it to get broken open in public?

That's a good point. Killer's don't tend to advertise their handy-work. If Lord Canti did kill them, he wouldn't hide the bodies there because people would get suspicious of him, just like we're dong now.

And regardless of all that, we aren't supposed to look that far into the story. Period. Puff makes the day stories to be funny, not to get into huge debates over who stuffed the friggin pinata.

I'm sticking with my gut instinct on this one, and saying VOTE everywhere116
The other two people who stuck together to get Anarkist lynched were both mafia, and I think that everywhere116 belongs in that same boat

Roger Dodger · Post by **Roger Dodger** » Tue Feb 13, 2007 9:25 am

it may be a good point but, i think a better point is that, i was right last time and, maybe i am reading too much into it but, it was just to blatent not to dismiss.

why r u defending this individual so much Minski??

i may be the lone person here that thinks this way.

tell ya what vote the way you want then see what happens. you're gonna get another townie and then, you are giving more leverage to the bad guys.

we are doing their work for them every time we choose wrong.

my vote stays.

Roger Dodger · Post by **Roger Dodger** » Tue Feb 13, 2007 9:27 am

last post for me. just count my vote and, let's see what happens.

i have work to do today so, no time to play.

Puff · Post by **Puff** » Tue Feb 13, 2007 9:33 am

UCAbears wrote:
I am confirmed man he just never changed it. Puff will u change me to confirmed please?

I did

SirSebstar · Post by **SirSebstar** » Tue Feb 13, 2007 1:38 pm

i know, but it was there.....

anyways what is the votecount now. i see some surprising swings and not everybody is participating.. why is that anyways.

i read that can be a mafia tactic too, but it appears so is 'jumping the bandwagon'...arg

talk to me people, tell me who i should vote for, who you think is mafia, and lets win this for us townsies

Minkish · Post by **Minkish** » Tue Feb 13, 2007 2:43 pm

SirSebstar wrote:i know, but it was there.....

anyways what is the votecount now. i see some surprising swings and not everybody is participating.. why is that anyways.

i read that can be a mafia tactic too, but it appears so is 'jumping the bandwagon'...arg

talk to me people, tell me who i should vote for, who you think is mafia, and lets win this for us townsies

Personally, I think you should take a good hard look at the events of yesterday. People got into a frenzy about lynching Anarkist. The mob was led by XenHu, cmkiney, and everywhere116 from what I read. Two of those three are already dead, and from everything that happened yesterday, I would say that it's very possible that everywhere116 was in on it too

Lord Canti · Post by **Lord Canti** » Tue Feb 13, 2007 2:55 pm

frodobaggins994 wrote:
Lord Canti wrote:FOS frodobaggins994

Not ready to vote lynch yet, but this guy was just too willing to agree a vote to lynch me, and left no reason, just his vote
i just voted that cuz every1 else did

Vote lynch: frodobaggins994

I don't think hes mafia, but his behavior of blindly following other peoples words, with out any reasoning, makes him just as dangerous to us citizens. He can be too easily used by the mafia as an extra vote against us.

everywhere116 · Post by **everywhere116** » Tue Feb 13, 2007 3:32 pm

Minkish wrote:
Kernal_Kronic wrote:If you go by the story, why would Lord Canti put 2 bodies into a pinyata, that he made, and allow it to get broken open in public?
That's a good point. Killer's don't tend to advertise their handy-work. If Lord Canti did kill them, he wouldn't hide the bodies there because people would get suspicious of him, just like we're dong now.

And regardless of all that, we aren't supposed to look that far into the story. Period. Puff makes the day stories to be funny, not to get into huge debates over who stuffed the friggin pinata.

I'm sticking with my gut instinct on this one, and saying VOTE everywhere116
The other two people who stuck together to get Anarkist lynched were both mafia, and I think that everywhere116 belongs in that same boat

I'm sorry to everyone on the town side for lynching Anarkist. Xenhu seemed to make a good arguement against him so I voted with him. I am innocent! Please dont make the same mistake I did! I will give a FOS Rodger Dodger for trying to get someone lynched based on the story, which means diddly squat.

Minkish · Post by **Minkish** » Tue Feb 13, 2007 5:44 pm

Lord Canti wrote:
frodobaggins994 wrote:
Lord Canti wrote:FOS frodobaggins994

Not ready to vote lynch yet, but this guy was just too willing to agree a vote to lynch me, and left no reason, just his vote
i just voted that cuz every1 else did

Vote lynch: frodobaggins994

I don't think hes mafia, but his behavior of blindly following other peoples words, with out any reasoning, makes him just as dangerous to us citizens. He can be too easily used by the mafia as an extra vote against us.

well then thats why it's important that all the non mafia talk and bring up some good arguements about people. We need to all come to a group concencus on the lynch today, otherwise the outcome could be really bad.

Right now, there's FOS's on Roger Dodger, everywhere116, and UCAbears

I personally don't buy into Bears being mafia just because of the timing, he could have sent his confirmation in really early, we don't really know.

As far as the other two, I'm suspicious of both.

Roger has a very, very weak reason to lynch Canti, and he's standing by his guns. The vote is close to lynching Canti, and he knows it. So if he is mafia, he's going to try to push that extra little bit to get the attention off of himself.

everywhere116 was one of the 3 main accusers of Anarkist. Maybe what he says is true about believing XenHu, but I think most of us were very suspicious of what XenHu was doing from the beginning.

I think that one of the two of them was working with XenHu. If there are two familys, they could both be guilty. I'm still deciding which one seems mroe scum to me, and I really hope that everyone considers a vote against one of these two.

Since I'm still making up my mind on which one is guilty UNVOTE everywhere116

DIRESTRAITS · Post by **DIRESTRAITS** » Tue Feb 13, 2007 9:42 pm

Unvote Bears

Vote: everywhere116

Minkish · Post by **Minkish** » Wed Feb 14, 2007 12:18 am

DIRESTRAITS wrote:Unvote Bears

Vote: everywhere116

care to elaborate on your change of vote?

DIRESTRAITS · Post by **DIRESTRAITS** » Wed Feb 14, 2007 12:23 am

sorry, I had a date and only had time to post that. It seems like the whole timing thing on Bears is flawed cause it may just be that Puff forgot to post it. The not posting thing isnt enogh in my mind to lynch someone, but I still have my eye on him. Everywhere was the number two guy supporting the Lynching if AD. Theres your explanation

Kernal_Kronic · Post by **Kernal_Kronic** » Wed Feb 14, 2007 2:46 am

I just had a look back & XenHu & cmckinney were not in the same group of mafia (cmckinney was a Desparado(serial killer)) so maybe everywhere116 was just bandwagonning...but i agree that Roger Dodger is acting very suspicious, i don't like the way she's pushing so hard for a lynch based on the story...Could be trying to confuse any noobs

unvote = everywhere116

FOS = Roger Dodger

Roger Dodger · Post by **Roger Dodger** » Wed Feb 14, 2007 7:52 am

like i said i'm not playing the defense game cause i have nothing to hide but, on this new day of another stalemate. do what u must. I'm just waiting around to see what you guys are gonna do.

remember, i am the only one that stood up for Anark. and, i was right.

Kernal_Kronic · Post by **Kernal_Kronic** » Wed Feb 14, 2007 8:06 am

When does the day officially end & what is the vote count?

Minkish · Post by **Minkish** » Wed Feb 14, 2007 10:41 am

Kernal_Kronic wrote:I just had a look back & XenHu & cmckinney were not in the same group of mafia (cmckinney was a Desparado(serial killer)) so maybe everywhere116 was just bandwagonning...but i agree that Roger Dodger is acting very suspicious, i don't like the way she's pushing so hard for a lynch based on the story...Could be trying to confuse any noobs

unvote = everywhere116

FOS = Roger Dodger

XenHu and cmckinney both had reasons to want to be killing people, regardless of if they were in the same mafia or not. It was easy for cmckinney to jump on the lynching train since he wanted people dead just as much as XenHu did.
Now it's possible that everywhere116 just got convinced of XenHu's story, but I think it could be because he already knew that he would be working together with XenHu since they already had a night kill together. everywhere116 was just all too willing to follow everyword that XenHu said blindly.

As for Roger Dodger though, he could have just as easily been in XenHu's gang. On day one, he could have been "covering his tracks" if you will, by making it known that he and XenHu didn't get along. Then his actions today, trying to get people to lynch based off of something he inferred from the story, it's all very very suspicious.

SirSebstar · Post by **SirSebstar** » Wed Feb 14, 2007 10:55 am

Minkish wrote: edited.....
Right now, there's FOS's on Roger Dodger, everywhere116, and UCAbears

I personally don't buy into Bears being mafia just because of the timing, he could have sent his confirmation in really early, we don't really know.

...................

well that is a real posibility. I have doubts still but i dont trust my doubts alone to vote for lynch. There has to be some more plausible reasoning. Well ill keep it in mind anyways. I am not off the UCAbears, but for now it will do. After all we need to catch, (i think) 3 more mafia gangster types.

UNVOTE UCAbears, VOTE NO Lynch

i have not made up my vote to lynch, becaus outside of bears, i dont have any clue yet. Normally i would go with the the majority on a vote to lynch, but not in this game. I think there are 3 non-communicating groups killing people. A lynch is not what we need right now. More baddies have died through night action then we killed so i am going to do the only thing i can do.
hence the no lynch vote.

as always, imput appreciated.

Puff · Post by **Puff** » Wed Feb 14, 2007 11:03 am

Vote Count

[3] Lord Canti (Roger Dodger, fordobaggins994, UCAbears,)

[1] everywhere116 (DIRESTRAITS)

[1] frodobaggins994 (Lord Canti)

[1] No Lynch (Sir Sebstar)

[3] Not Voting (everyone else)

with 9 left its 5 to lynch

Roger Dodger · Post by **Roger Dodger** » Wed Feb 14, 2007 11:29 am

i'm stuborn that's what i am. i normally look at everything but, i think i have been good at picking who is good & who is bad. maybe i'm wrong but, i really do believe that he is guilty.