Dexsting wrote:I had a few comments, but it seems the newest version is on the last page, and the first page image hasn't been updated, so oops, they don't apply! lol. I am curious as to where the pirate was...
I love this map and its idea with resources and such.
Excellent
thanks
I think it was a good idea to remove the Baccy as it was hard to see it sometimes.
Yes that became redundant as a most unused-resource.
Do you think the All Maroons should be higher? Maybe +4?
they could be, but please convince me.
Maybe to even London out a little get rid of the Bumbo on the Morgan line?
OK, i could do that but...
the territory Morgan Line has Bumbo (rum) on it because this is where Captain Henry Morgan had his rum wahehouses.
So i think it is quite apt given the flavour of the map. But i could be convinced otherwise with a good reason...
I really like the needing 2 food for a bonus, but maybe 2 food and ships gives +2 bonus?
Done, next version.
Do you need the Ports in the legend? I don't think of a port as a "resource".
Proably not, unless we want to attack a bonus to them (come to think of that)?
Having all the slaves seems extremely difficult and giving a bonus to holding them all seems like its more of a win-more resource (IE, the person who gets that bonus is probably going to win anyways to have spread out and be able to hold all the slaves). Especially since each slave and sugar gets +1 anyways.
OK, good reasoning. Removed next version.
It seems that Calico Jack has a raw deal and not easily get any bonuses...maybe put a Bumbo or a Gold Cob on the Black River?
Not of the ports have any resources (unless as asked above you want to give them all a bonus such as a gold cob). C. Jack has only to attack Bluefields and Savannah le Mar and he has a bonus of +1 for sugar and slaves.
Henry Morgan is proably going to have a harder deal unless there is a a bonus for +1 for gold cobs.
They can then both battle over the slaves the and sugar.
Sorry if this is nit-picky, but on the big map its called Kingston Port Royal, but on the zoomed-map its called Port Royal & Kingston...maybe change that to be consistent? Not that its confusing, I just think nit-picky it'd be nicer that way.
Sorry, but i read left to right and that is how i read the big map also, Port Royal first and then Kingston. So the parallel is the same on the title for the insert small map. Does that make sense?
I'm glad you brought this map outta vacation and hope you can use my suggestions. Thanks Cairns!
Cheers.
And thanks for your positive input.