King and the Dr. [noted]

[King_Shmegmito]

Innocent until proven guilty. I love America, Freedom, and justice. And no we have never ever ever not once said hey you don't attack me and i wont attack you or hey whats happening Dr.? Oh that's cool! Say, don't attack me here and I won't there. No. Sorry. Conquer Club is war. And just like America does, I love war and attack whoever whenever. I do like to attack more, however, players who like to talk crap in the game chat (ex General Stoneham) so i may not worry about my borders or other players bonuses at that time, but it's that other players choice whether they attack you or not. That's what makes this game fun and mostly luck.

[c12ax7]

and ur opinions are nice and all but i have quantitative evidence supporting the theory that you and your friends are throwing games towards each other even if unintentional

Yeah too bad your numbers are completely out of whack. The king has only completed 1 game without someone we play with locally. Yes he did lose that 1 game, but since your so good with numbers you would realize that one game is statistically insignificant. If he played more games with only randoms his numbers would even out much more.

Of the 14 games he won, 8 were filled with only local payers and therefore no one was at this disadvantage of playing with a group of friends.

9 of these 29 games (31%) played with friends and randoms were won by a random person or team. This number is huge considering that random players made up less then 20% of the players in these games. If anything we have increased the ramdom players chance of winning by over 50%. This "secret diplomacy" is actually putting us at a disadvantage.

Shmegmito has won less games with random players in them then with local players. This simple fact makes the secret diplomacy claim a little hard to swallow, especially when only one player has accused us of it.

(edit: We know exactly what we are being accused of, and yes we know exactly what secret diplomacy means (which isnt the only thing we were accused of by the General)

[king achilles]

Granted that King_Shmegmito, c12ax7 and DrGrabowski are indeed friends in real life, we would need more than one game of strong evidence of malicious plays involving the same players to warrant a block. Even the reasoning in this report that they have played numerous games together lacks the needed information for us to move forward. Just because someone did not break someone else's bonus does not always constitute cheating.

[DrGrabowski]

Thank you king achilles.
I'd just like to reassure you that all of my friends, myself included, are well aware of the rules of CC and have been since the day we signed up. I hope that you don't need to hear from us again.

[a.sub]

fair is fair
my apology for falsely accusing you
please realize it was nothing personal

[c12ax7]

Thanks Achilles, at least someone has a level head in here.