Moderator: Cartographers
Your intimacy with his work is quite tellingoaktown wrote:Personally I'm surprised by the voting - H is far from that mapmaker's best work, in my humble opinion. Looks to me like he threw it together in about three hours using a flatbed scanner, a library book, and elements from his other maps.
im shocked also. I couldnt decide between A B or H, and I narrowed it down to B and H, and I decided to go ahead and vote for H, thinking B probably had a ton of votes...multiplayertim wrote:I was undecided between B and H went for H in the end i'm shocked B has no votes thoughoaktown wrote:what, no votes for B? Not even the mapmaker? It's a clean look - it deserves some love.
There's something about A I also like. Kinda of a night time feeling. But it certainly looks like we already have a winner. Not much hope of catching up now. I'm not even sure if we need a second round "face-off" when the lead is that big.Natewolfman wrote:I like both A and H alot, they are both unique, but it dosnt look like A will make this cut, but H is going great!
1. votes don't carry over and everyone who didn't vote for H could vote for the #2 one.RjBeals wrote:There's something about A I also like. Kinda of a night time feeling. But it certainly looks like we already have a winner. Not much hope of catching up now. I'm not even sure if we need a second round "face-off" when the lead is that big.Natewolfman wrote:I like both A and H alot, they are both unique, but it dosnt look like A will make this cut, but H is going great!
ZeakCytho wrote:No offense to you, Marv, but it must really suck for the creator of B to not have got a vote when even the old version did. I'm tempted to change my vote just so whoever made it doesn't get suicidal or something.
I knew you wouldnt!hulmey wrote:To be honest none of them stand out apart from F, which i really really like but from a playing point of view the prespective view doesnt look right....
Maybe if the prespective looked more like H it would be a winner
Top Score:2403natty_dread wrote:I was wrong
yeah, maybe im not good for changegimil wrote:I knew you wouldnt!hulmey wrote:To be honest none of them stand out apart from F, which i really really like but from a playing point of view the prespective view doesnt look right....
Maybe if the prespective looked more like H it would be a winner
call it womans interwishin!
Try being optimistic! Maybe you will suprise mehulmey wrote:yeah, maybe im not good for changegimil wrote:I knew you wouldnt!hulmey wrote:To be honest none of them stand out apart from F, which i really really like but from a playing point of view the prespective view doesnt look right....
Maybe if the prespective looked more like H it would be a winner
call it womans interwishin!
But again F is great but the prespective seems to be unappealing
Top Score:2403natty_dread wrote:I was wrong
this runs for a week, so people can come back and change their votes based on the way its shaking down. Anything can happen, and hopefully we'll be in for some surprises in round 2, especially if gimil does indeed let three maps go through.yeti_c wrote:Methinks this round is over?
C.
Maybe they can give some comments without revealing their identity.oaktown wrote:...Will the mapmakers be unveiled after round 1, or do we have to wait until the entire thing is over? I say open it up and let the mapmakers talk about their maps in round 2. I would like to hear what the mapmakers have to say before casting a final vote...
Top Score:2403natty_dread wrote:I was wrong
i think you can tell most of the makers from the style of the map.InkL0sed wrote:Anybody wanna take any bets?
