Feedback by rank

[kc-jake]

I don't think that privates should be able to leave negative feedback on someone ranked higher than them. In fact, I suggest that no one be allowed to leave negative feedback who is more than 2 ranks ahead of them. Also, anyone with a rank that involves bent lines should not be allowed to leave negative feedback for anyone who's rank looks like time and effort were put into the rank, rather than just drawing another bent line.

That is how it should be. Especially all these crappy-ass privates.

[P Gizzle]

ok, first of all, i know privates that i bet would beat you! second, the feedback system is to allow critism (constructive) to players. Good players actually can get better.



Idiot!

By the Power Invested in Me by the Unofficial Gods of CC, I declare this thread DEAD!!!

[AK_iceman]

This is the dumbest suggestion ever.

Heres a better one... Dont make suggestions until you think about what they are.

[P Gizzle]

thanks AK!



ok, now i declare it DEAD

[spring1]

here's another one... open mouth, insert foot kc. dumbest suggestion ever. are your brain cells even firing today? I suggest putting your wet finger in an electrical socket to jumpstart your mind back up before posting anymore mindless drivel.

[KoolBak]

*love it when sproing is having a bad day - gets the posts really creative! I think it's the new avatar (gag)* ;o)

[Fireside Poet]

spring1's avatar followed by your dobie with teeth = funny mind images.

[wcaclimbing]

does that just mean that you have been an a$$ so some privates and you dont want them to give you bad feedback?

[kc-jake]

does that just mean that you have been an a$$ so some privates and you dont want them to give you bad feedback?

No, privates give the dumbest feedback for the dumbest things. I'm just saying that in order to give feedback, someone should at least have to be somewhat respectable at this game in order to say something negative about someone. They are generally new players who don't understand strategy and will deride your strategy because they are stupid and don't understand it. After 10 matches, if they have a clue, they can be a sergeant and say whatever.

And of course you would disagree, you're a private.

[sully800]

This is a terrible idea.

When you joined this site kc you acted and talked like you knew everything. "Just call me prodigy" comes to mind, even though a player like xBMKx advanced up the scoreboard much more quickly and consistantly than you did. All you ever do is deride people who have a lower rank than you and obsess about the fact that you are higher than them. That does not mean that someone lower than you cannot have something valuable to say, or that they cannot criticize your playing style.

There are currently 231 people higher than you on the scoreboard. Perhaps you shouldn't be able to criticize any of them because you clearly aren't as good?

Sorry for the flame- I think you can and have contributed some valuable things to this site. However this is just a pompous attitude to take toward people of a lower rank and I don't think it belongs here.

[AK_iceman]

Very well said Sully, I agree.

[P Gizzle]

yeah, im a good contributor to the site, but im not a captain, or whatever

[KoolBak]

Ok....I will play......since I spend most of my time as a "Bent Liner" (according to his mightyness), my post probably will not show up here, but I shall try anyhow.

Having completed 10 times more games than you, Jake, I think I should decide how YOU get to interact...isnt that what we are doing here? Applying inductive logic or perhaps even prejudice? When you started at CC, Jake, did you start as a colonel? There is a thing called freedom where I live...one takes the good with the bad.....(thus my post).

Finally, I am also unclear as to how I should vote, dress, worship and think - could you please clarify these issues for me?

*listens for the telltale "click" of being added to Jake's Ignore List* ;o)

[P Gizzle]

Ok....I will play......since I spend most of my time as a "Bent Liner" (according to his mightyness), my post probably will not show up here, but I shall try anyhow.

Having completed 10 times more games than you, Jake, I think I should decide how YOU get to interact...isnt that what we are doing here? Applying inductive logic or perhaps even prejudice? When you started at CC, Jake, did you start as a colonel? There is a thing called freedom where I live...one takes the good with the bad.....(thus my post).

Finally, I am also unclear as to how I should vote, dress, worship and think - could you please clarify these issues for me?

*listens for the telltale "click" of being added to Jake's Ignore List* ;o)

i think Jake's going to create his own communist CC usergroup where he is the Risk God and since everyone below him sucks they cannont speak to him

[KoolBak]

LOL @ PG! I'll wait for him to tell me to join!

[Fireside Poet]

i think Jake's going to create his own communist CC usergroup where he is the Risk God and since everyone below him sucks they cannont speak to him

Now THAT is funny!

[P Gizzle]

thanks.

[Knight of Orient]

this is dumb. privates can be some of the best players around. many make it to the end and barely lose. this thread is senseless,

1)seeing that no one agrees, and 2) no one cares for it

jus close this thread

[P Gizzle]

but one of my best flames is in here

[dugcarr1]

i agree,,,,,,but then again, i dont think anyone would give a shit after looking at the feed back all the newbei crybabies left for me

[sully800]

this is dumb. privates can be some of the best players around.

I wouldn't go THAT far...unless its just a new great player. But I agree they aren't necessarily bad....and they might understand some good strategies despite the low score.

[P Gizzle]

this is dumb. privates can be some of the best players around.

I wouldn't go THAT far...unless its just a new great player. But I agree they aren't necessarily bad....and they might understand some good strategies despite the low score.

like me?

[KoolBak]

LOL! Always enjoy seeing Duggy post....

[reverend_kyle]

I think maybe sorting feedback by rank would be a good idea.

[Pedronicus]

I'm not going to be playing any games for a day or two.

For the next 48 hours - I will mostly be leaving negative feedback for any private I've ever played.

KC has shown me the light.