Blackpool Manor Dinner: D4! FRUITS WITH CHAMPAGNE

FOS: Dedicated those who can't get enough Mafia action. Ongoing Games located here!

Moderator: Community Team

Forum rules
Please read the Community Guidelines before posting.
katyssis
Posts: 5
Joined: Fri Mar 21, 2008 8:21 pm

Re: Blackpool Manor Dinner: D4! FRUITS WITH CHAMPAGNE

Post by katyssis »

hjelp wrote: Thu Nov 19, 2026 8:20 am Hm - I'm thinking.

annieh House
Charle House
I am House

so
- If Ragian flips Circle then Zulu flips Circle. And it makes sense to me that Zulu killed HottBunnie since visited HottBunnie. It also make sense that Circle sacrifies Ragian if Ragian flips Circle. That's why Zulu voted fast on Ragian so it doesn't look like a wagon vote. Moreover - Zulu was fast on saying that Katssis is Circle which is a way of saying look at Katyssis - don't look at me.

I cast my vote on Ragian. The annieh Circle is hard to accept, since sacrifying "The Patron" in the early gameplay. And I don't think we willl get any input from Katyssis.


Vote Ragian
sorry i have had to work extra days...just trying to get caught up on what's been going on..
katyssis
Posts: 5
Joined: Fri Mar 21, 2008 8:21 pm

Re: Blackpool Manor Dinner: D4! FRUITS WITH CHAMPAGNE

Post by katyssis »

now that i'm done reading.. finally...

vote annie
User avatar
SoN!c
Posts: 1125
Joined: Tue May 11, 2021 10:23 am

Re: Blackpool Manor Dinner: D4! FRUITS WITH CHAMPAGNE

Post by SoN!c »

official vote count

Ragian: 2 by Annie, Zulu
Annieh: 2 by Ragian, Katyssis


D4 - FRUITS WITH CHAMPAGNE ends MONDAY six o'clock ENGLAND DINNER TIME!


With 6 alive it takes 4 to LYNCH!!

ITS MYLO ENDGAME!
Image
User avatar
Charle
SoC Training Instructor
SoC Training Instructor
Posts: 1826
Joined: Fri Mar 05, 2010 9:11 am
Gender: Male
Location: South Africa

Re: Blackpool Manor Dinner: D4! FRUITS WITH CHAMPAGNE

Post by Charle »

@Hjelp, it looks like you and I are the two players who will have to make the final decision at the moment.
I have been going through the earlier posts again, and I am still not convinced by Annie's explanation about why she withheld her N2 investigation.

There is, however, a third possibility that I think we should seriously consider before deciding between Annie and Ragian.
What about Zulu? You investigated Zulu on N3 and your result was that he visited HottBunnie. That same night Bunny was murdered and that was the night after the day Bunny actually voted for Zulu. That is quite a coincidence and do you really think that Sonic would have two trackers on the same side?

Just one more thing I would want to understand, you had this information about Zulu, yet you decided to vote Ragian based on Annie's investigation. Why did you trust Annie's result more than your own investigation, especially when your result placed Zulu with the person who was murdered?

And @Annie, what do you think about this possibility? If Zulu was responsible for Bunny's death, would that change your view of who the remaining Circle members might be?

@Katy, you have now voted Annie after catching up with the game. I would really appreciate it if you could explain what convinced you. Did you find something in the earlier posts that we might have missed?

We have until Monday, I am not particularly active over weekends, but will have a look.

Damn, the lynch on Loose was a huge mistake putting us in this situation.
User avatar
Charle
SoC Training Instructor
SoC Training Instructor
Posts: 1826
Joined: Fri Mar 05, 2010 9:11 am
Gender: Male
Location: South Africa

Re: Blackpool Manor Dinner: D4! FRUITS WITH CHAMPAGNE

Post by Charle »

I have been thinking about our current situation, and there is another possibility I would like everyone to consider.

What if we vote No Lynch?

Circle would then have to make another night kill, and tomorrow we would have 3 House against 2 Circle, and still a miss lynch will loose the game, except we might have a little bit more info to work with? (who was killed, maybe some night actions, etc)

Circle could also use the night to manipulate us, but at least we would not be making a decision today based on two conflicting stories without enough evidence.

@Everybody, please let us know whether you think a No Lynch would help House or Circle, and why.

The choices of lynch we need to decide on before end of Monday IMHO are: Annie, Zulu, Ragian or No-Lynch.
User avatar
Zulu Warrior
Posts: 19
Joined: Fri Feb 03, 2023 1:17 pm
Gender: Male
Location: United Kingdom

Re: Blackpool Manor Dinner: D4! FRUITS WITH CHAMPAGNE

Post by Zulu Warrior »

Hang on, Charle, you are definitely House, but don't you think a No Lynch today is totally against us House members?

Right now it's 4 House vs. 2 Circle. Surely, if No Lynch today, Circle gets a free kill tonight, almost certainly killing Annieh, our Archivist, or even worse, me lol :-). Leaving 3 House v 2 Circle tomorrow with one fewer power role alive. I know I am a newbie and I am looking at this whole game very simplistically, but that doesn't really make any sense to me, unless you can convince me otherwise.

Look at hjelps actual role; he is not a tracker like I am. His power was "Steward" with a 1-shot power that only worked once within the whole game. He also said if he picked a House Applicant, it wouldn't work, and yet it worked on me, meaning I have to be House. Meanwhile, my Tracker role continues to work, a major advantage to us House players, especially now I will be able to track any player tonight. Surely if I were the Circle killer who murdered HB last night, I couldn't have known that HB visited Annieh!

Also, Katyssis hasn't said very much and disappears for days. She then pops up saying she "finally finished reading everything". She immediately drops a vote on Annieh, right next to Ragian, without any explanation. In my opinion, both Circle members are clearly trying to pile onto Annieh, the Archivist who caught Devante AND Ragian to save Ragian today.

Please remember, Charle, Annieh caught Devante, Annieh caught Ragian, and Katyssis just walked straight onto Annieh's wagon with zero reasoning. Let's vote Ragian today and Katyssis tomorrow and win this for House.

Also, hjelp, am I correct in saying it looks like SoN!c missed your vote on the last count because Vote Ragian wasn't in bold?
User avatar
hjelp
Posts: 339
Joined: Thu Oct 06, 2011 2:50 pm

Re: Blackpool Manor Dinner: D4! FRUITS WITH CHAMPAGNE

Post by hjelp »

@ Charle

I don't think SoN!c will have two trackers (or similar) and I now have read HottBunnie's posts D3 and she was suspicious of Zulu and wanted to put pressure on Zulu.
So I think Zulu's claim is a fake.

I find it very risky for Circle to sacrify The Patron in the early game and that's why I have hold annieh as the House archivist . It would be a well planned game to sacrify The Patron as Loose elaborated. With that said - Ragian posts are fair and with Loose's arguments against annieh it can be that annieh is the recruited Circle,

Since annieh obviously isn't killed - It is an indication that annieh is recruited Circle which will have to be considered with the fact that annieh did reveal The Patron.
The only way to find out if annieh is the recruited Cirle archivist is the annieh lynch,

The reason why I voted on Ragian is if Ragian flips Circle, Zulu the tactical vote and sacrifiy Ragian and I have hold annieh as the House archivist as I wrote in my post.

A no vote is a loss for House I think, since it will be harder to do a 3vs2 than 4vs2. I mean that if 3vs2 and both Circles vote together then it's more likely to be a misslynch with only one more vote needed for a lynch. and it will still be you and I to be aligned unless one of us will be killed N4 which is very likely.

Now Katyssis has voted after my last post. Katyssis is kind of unbiased since haven't participated that much.
So now it's 50/50 between annieh and Ragian and it's a choice you and I will have to be aligned upon.
And Katyssis' vote actually might be the missing piece needed to decide if annieh Circle or not. Adding the argument that you or I likely will be killed N4 is the tipping point towards that annieh is the recruited Circle as I see it.

And by that the only way to find out if annieh is the recruited Circle (since annieh seems to surive all nights) is by a lynch. I'm prepared to cast my vote on annieh if you think that annieh is the recruited Circle. If so you and I are aligned.

User avatar
hjelp
Posts: 339
Joined: Thu Oct 06, 2011 2:50 pm

Re: Blackpool Manor Dinner: D4! FRUITS WITH CHAMPAGNE

Post by hjelp »

@ Zulu

My card says that my power is lost if I name an House applicant. If I named an House applicant I still would have got a result.
hjelp wrote: Wed Nov 18, 2026 2:45 pm ...
I'm the House - Steward - I can tell the footman to follow an named guest, revealing the undertaking of the guest during the night. It's a one action and I used it N3 and chosed Zulu to be followed (since I had Zulu as the flip option along with Loose). Moreover, If I was recruited then I would have lost my power and if I name a House applicant it's lost.
...
and now you are saying
Zulu Warrior wrote: Fri Nov 20, 2026 4:37 am ... He also said if he picked a House Applicant, it wouldn't work, and yet it worked on me, meaning I have to be House. Meanwhile, my Tracker role continues to work, a major advantage to us House players, especially now I will be able to track any player tonight. Surely if I were the Circle killer who murdered HB last night, I couldn't have known that HB visited Annieh!
...
that's why you claim is false. My power is one action disregarded if a player is House or Circle.

@ Charle, if you are prepared to start and trying to get four votes on Zulu I'm prepared to do that as well.
User avatar
hjelp
Posts: 339
Joined: Thu Oct 06, 2011 2:50 pm

Re: Blackpool Manor Dinner: D4! FRUITS WITH CHAMPAGNE

Post by hjelp »

Shall be

that's why you claim is false. My power is one action disregarded if a player named is House or Circle.
User avatar
hjelp
Posts: 339
Joined: Thu Oct 06, 2011 2:50 pm

Re: Blackpool Manor Dinner: D4! FRUITS WITH CHAMPAGNE

Post by hjelp »

@ Zulu - For a House applicant result I think that SoN!c simply would have given me the result - no result.
User avatar
Zulu Warrior
Posts: 19
Joined: Fri Feb 03, 2023 1:17 pm
Gender: Male
Location: United Kingdom

Re: Blackpool Manor Dinner: D4! FRUITS WITH CHAMPAGNE

Post by Zulu Warrior »

WOW — and right as I was typing this, hjelp just proved my point again by instantly switching from pushing Annieh to begging Charle to lynch ME instead!!
hjelp, you just exposed yourself as the second Circle member alongside Ragian! Look at the four smoking guns right in front of us:

1. Remember what CHARLE noticed at 8:20 am: hjelp ONLY claimed "Steward" after I had already told the thread I tracked HB. He didn't have a real Steward power; he just copied what I had already said to frame me for HB's murder.

2. Why hjelp didn't bold his vote on Ragian yesterday: He intentionally left Vote Ragian unbolded so SoN!c wouldn't count it, keeping his teammate Ragian safe at 2 votes—and he STILL hasn't cast a real vote today while shopping around for Annieh OR me to get lynched!

3. Look at hjelp changing his story 180 degrees: First he claimed he was "House" who trusted Annieh and voted Ragian; then he said "I don't think SoN!c will have two trackers... I'm prepared to cast my vote on annieh"—and now 30 minutes later he's trying to switch onto me because I'm a rookie who misunderstood his wording about House Applicants! Why would a real "House Steward" suddenly say "SoN!c wouldn't put two trackers in the game" against his own claim? Because he made his Steward claim up!

4. If Charle votes Annieh OR me with Ragian and hjelp, that hits 4 votes and Circle wins immediately!
Ragian and hjelp are the two Circle members! Katyssis is just a confused rookie (like me!) who got tricked into voting Annieh—@Katyssis and @Charle, please look at hjelp desperately trying to lynch Annieh AND me within 30 minutes!
Keep your vote off Annieh and me, Charle, and let's put the 3rd and 4th votes onto Ragian right now!
User avatar
hjelp
Posts: 339
Joined: Thu Oct 06, 2011 2:50 pm

Re: Blackpool Manor Dinner: D4! FRUITS WITH CHAMPAGNE

Post by hjelp »

@ Zulu

My replies regarding votes are answers to the questions Charle asked me.

And I did my vote in bold and unvote vote since Charle asked me to.
SoN!c wrote: Thu Nov 19, 2026 9:20 am official vote count

Ragian: 3 by Annie, Zulu and Hjelp
Annieh: 1 by Ragian


D4 - FRUITS WITH CHAMPAGNE ends MONDAY six o'clock ENGLAND DINNER TIME!


With 6 alive it takes 4 to LYNCH!!

ITS MYLO ENDGAME!
SoN!c wrote: Thu Nov 19, 2026 9:20 am official vote count

Ragian: 3 by Annie, Zulu and Hjelp
Annieh: 1 by Ragian


D4 - FRUITS WITH CHAMPAGNE ends MONDAY six o'clock ENGLAND DINNER TIME!


With 6 alive it takes 4 to LYNCH!!

ITS MYLO ENDGAME!
and
hjelp wrote: Fri Nov 20, 2026 4:55 am ...
I'm prepared to cast my vote on annieh if you think that annieh is the recruited Circle. If so you and I are aligned
...

Charle wrote: Fri Nov 20, 2026 3:04 am ...
The choices of lynch we need to decide on before end of Monday IMHO are: Annie, Zulu, Ragian or No-Lynch.
[/quote
hjelp wrote: Fri Nov 20, 2026 5:24 am ...
@ Charle, if you are prepared to start and trying to get four votes on Zulu I'm prepared to do that as well.
...
User avatar
hjelp
Posts: 339
Joined: Thu Oct 06, 2011 2:50 pm

Re: Blackpool Manor Dinner: D4! FRUITS WITH CHAMPAGNE

Post by hjelp »

and now it is
SoN!c wrote: Thu Nov 19, 2026 9:20 am official vote count

Ragian: 2 by Annie, Zulu
Annieh: 1 by Ragian


D4 - FRUITS WITH CHAMPAGNE ends MONDAY six o'clock ENGLAND DINNER TIME!


With 6 alive it takes 4 to LYNCH!!

ITS MYLO ENDGAME!


LOL - FP
User avatar
hjelp
Posts: 339
Joined: Thu Oct 06, 2011 2:50 pm

Re: Blackpool Manor Dinner: D4! FRUITS WITH CHAMPAGNE

Post by hjelp »

Now I'm out for the snow.
User avatar
Zulu Warrior
Posts: 19
Joined: Fri Feb 03, 2023 1:17 pm
Gender: Male
Location: United Kingdom

Re: Blackpool Manor Dinner: D4! FRUITS WITH CHAMPAGNE

Post by Zulu Warrior »

Fair play, hjelp. Again, my rookie mistake! I missed the earlier post where you unvoted at Charle's request, so Ragian wouldn't sit at L-1 before Katyssis weighed in. Happy to own that,
and honestly, if you really are the House Steward who watched me visit HottBunnie last night, then look back at my earlier breakdown; That puts you, me, Annieh, and Charle all on House, which leaves Ragian and Katyssis as the only two Circle members left out of the 6 of us, which was my first analysis. It's too easy for a beginner to assume so much without fully analysing the facts, sorry.

Notice though how Katyssis is the only person who dropped a zero-explanation vote on Annie alongside Ragian and then vanished again without answering Charle's question about why she voted Annieh!
Let's stick together as House (Charle, hjelp, Annieh, and me)—let's put the 3rd and 4th votes on Ragian today and vote out Katyssis tomorrow!"
User avatar
annieh
Posts: 4
Joined: Mon Jul 28, 2014 12:36 pm
Gender: Female

Re: Blackpool Manor Dinner: D4! FRUITS WITH CHAMPAGNE

Post by annieh »

Yeah, I think it is sus Zulu was at HB's the night she was killed. It's very possible she used her medicine bag, if she did it's very possible she used it before last night and if she had she wouldn't have gone anywhere at all. His story relies on a couple unlikely things happening. In the meantime, he has well articulated points on Ragian's guilt and a vote on a circle member. Which means I don't have a problem.

The day house votes for the archivist who has identified the patron and brought all this other conversation starting, clue digging, and commentary over the guy who is making up anything he can is the day house deserves to lose. Ragian put in almost no effort until he had to come for me and now that he has it's not even consistent. Not consistent with the way I play, not consistent with reasonable strategy, not internally consistent...just a wild shifting mishmash of bad and unlikely theories.

I don't think I could have done anything better for house other than wait longer into champagne for Ragian to dig his own grave to reveal my findings. I put too much faith in my own reputation as Patron killer. That and 100 fresh bad arguments can look convincing against 1 that's old news as the days go on.

I am also the one still trying to play by trying to find out if the circle can kill per person or one per night and if the knife is a separate thing.

Remember, we are looking for a player Devante would have selected and it's DEV + RAGS 4EVA.
User avatar
Ragian
Posts: 123
Joined: Wed Apr 15, 2009 7:39 am

Re: Blackpool Manor Dinner: D4! FRUITS WITH CHAMPAGNE

Post by Ragian »

For crying out loud. I agree. We are looking for a player that Devante would have selected. Which is you! Then you sacrificed him in order to bring us in the mess that we're in now. Why on earth pick me? You don't go for (one of) the most experienced players in here. I'm bound to be under scrutiny. No. You go for someone who's played enough to carry themselves and pull this off. And look how far you've come. While it's obviously very frustrating to be the fall guy, Annie, I do applaud you for your scum play this game.

@Charle & hjelp, I need all House votes on Annie for us to win this. Hjelp has already toyed with fire but was wisely cautioned by Charle. Good man, Charle!
- Annie sacrificed her Patron (I presume due to him being busy and because it allowed her to coast the rest of the game)
- As the Archivist, she did not clear up the Loose mess. I mean...I cannot stress that choice enough. Such an anti House move!
- She has openly guided Zulu on voting. I presume day chat is not available for scum.

Now she wants you to believe that Devante picked a high profile player (sorry to toot my own horn here...I'm merely going by site reputation) rather than someone who is low profile and still plays one hell of a game (as Annie has proved in earlier games). Don't buy into it. Don't fall for it. Let's get this right. I don't care how much time you need, but we need all House votes on Annie.
Image
Post Reply

Return to “Mafia Games”