Madagascar [Quenched]
Moderator: Cartographers
Forum rules
Please read the Community Guidelines before posting.
Please read the Community Guidelines before posting.
Re: Madagascar -UPDATE- Version5(s) Pages 1&4 PICK WHICH VERSION
Hey tom, looking good, and ill comment more later, but for now all i have to say is
5B
5B
Re: Madagascar -UPDATE- Version5(s) Pages 1&4 PICK WHICH VERSION
hmm - i dunnoKaplowitz wrote:I pretty sure that it is size 12...
hmm i will try that sometimeTaCktiX wrote:When in doubt you could drop by Foundry Discussion and download the Army Circle png that mibi posted. I took that and turned it into a layered PSD to show the armies on The Citadel. Very easy to do the Click, Drag, Ctrl+J (duplicate layer) deal.
i agree with ya tehrerocky mountain wrote:the lemur heads are greatand the mini-map looks better than the box key...
good job!
5 min job - just because Zeak wanted themlord voldemort wrote:also your 88 are not the correct size
actually i think its 630px X 500px - height by width - which is too big for a small maplord voldemort wrote:and i also think that this map is too small...
yea workin on thatlord voldemort wrote:and the rgaphical line for mountains could be a lil better to actually represent mountians...
thanks lollord voldemort wrote:the trees look cool
yea we'll work something outlord voldemort wrote:your bonus's are off....they are too many or not enough for the number of borders to defend....so id go by that
i think that 5C1 is just the best - it looks the bestjako wrote:u need to put up a poll for which version of ur map u should go with. u cant pick one based off of one person.![]()
ill look into other maps' mountains and look at their mountains - and perhaps hold a poll for the mountain style?jako wrote:u could try taking a look at the mountains on the WWII western front map or france map. both are different styles that could give u a good idea for mountains.
yea - i willl try some blurs and maybe stretch them a lil bit (upward)jako wrote:dont know how ur going to fix those forests, but they still need work.
i dont know if its thats straight forward - just doing the amount of defending terits - like what if you were holding the equivilant of asia with only one terit - it wouldnt just be a bonus og 1 or 2 - coz u got some more terits within - but i see your pointjako wrote:Antsiranana - 2 terts + 2 attacking points = 2.
Mahajanga - 4 terts + 3 attacking points = 3
Toamasina - 3 terts + 3 attacking points = 3
Antananarivo - 4 terts + 3 attacking points = 3
Fianarantsoa - 5 terts + 4 attacking points = 4
Toliara - 4 terts + 4 attacking points = 4
i will do some thinking
jako wrote:u need to put up a poll for which version of ur map u should go with. u cant pick one based off of one person.![]()
u could try taking a look at the mountains on the WWII western front map or france map. both are different styles that could give u a good idea for mountains.
dont know how ur going to fix those forests, but they still need work.
bonuses are a little off as lovo said. this i what i think they could be:
Antsiranana - 2 terts + 2 attacking points = 2.
Mahajanga - 4 terts + 3 attacking points = 3
Toamasina - 3 terts + 3 attacking points = 3
Antananarivo - 4 terts + 3 attacking points = 3
Fianarantsoa - 5 terts + 4 attacking points = 4
Toliara - 4 terts + 4 attacking points = 4
thanksand congratz on the adv idea.
cheers m8bryguy wrote:Hey tom, looking good, and ill comment more later, but for now all i have to say is
5B
---
ok next update soon,
i will play around with the trees (maybe) and the mounatins, also the bonuses, and the title background, anyone with anymore suggestions i am very open minded - so go ahead!
Re: Madagascar -UPDATE- Version5(s) Pages 1&4 PICK WHICH VERSION
I like the background for madagscar, it looks cool! Im not very keen on your impassables, i know you can do better 
[img]http://img801.imageshack.us/img801/9761/41922610151374166770386.jpg[/mg]
Re: Madagascar -UPDATE- Version5(s) Pages 1&4 PICK WHICH VERSION
ok here we go, version 6
---
Version 6: ive updated the mountains - not that they look any better lol (well maybe a lil bit), i changed the bevels on them and smudged them so they look rougher
trees un-altered
bonuses un-altered - i think theyre ok for now (thats probably a bad sign if i think theyre ok) - just that jako your method, well i dont think its quite right. you said that the pink/red cont had 3atacking terits so should have a 3 bonus - but its got 4 terits, and 5 terits availible to break the bonus - so 3 is too low i think.
i also altered the title background - which that doesnt really look much better either,
if anyone wants to see this with the 88's on - just say because its only a click of a button (litterally!)
anyway watcha think of this one??
p.s. yes i am aware that the mountains are all kinda different!
EDIT:
oh yea i forgot, i used a faded gradient to blend the pic - hopefully it works
---
Version 6: ive updated the mountains - not that they look any better lol (well maybe a lil bit), i changed the bevels on them and smudged them so they look rougher
trees un-altered
bonuses un-altered - i think theyre ok for now (thats probably a bad sign if i think theyre ok) - just that jako your method, well i dont think its quite right. you said that the pink/red cont had 3atacking terits so should have a 3 bonus - but its got 4 terits, and 5 terits availible to break the bonus - so 3 is too low i think.
i also altered the title background - which that doesnt really look much better either,
if anyone wants to see this with the 88's on - just say because its only a click of a button (litterally!)
anyway watcha think of this one??
p.s. yes i am aware that the mountains are all kinda different!
EDIT:
oh yea i forgot, i used a faded gradient to blend the pic - hopefully it works
- cena-rules
- Posts: 9740
- Joined: Sat Apr 28, 2007 2:27 am
- Gender: Male
- Location: Chat
Re: Madagascar -UPDATE- Version6 Pages 1&6 MOUNTAINS UPDATED
they look better
lets see it with the 88's. The trees on the left need wotking on though
lets see it with the 88's. The trees on the left need wotking on though
19:41:22 ‹jakewilliams› I was a pedo
Re: Madagascar -UPDATE- Version6 Pages 1&6 MOUNTAINS UPDATED
lol i knew that if you came to the thread you'd ask lolcena-rules wrote:lets see it with the 88's. The trees on the left need wotking on though
here you go: i also tried out having a 3px stroke on the outside of the army cirlces (a darkish blue one) but it didnt look good
Last edited by t-o-m on Mon Apr 28, 2008 4:17 pm, edited 1 time in total.
- cena-rules
- Posts: 9740
- Joined: Sat Apr 28, 2007 2:27 am
- Gender: Male
- Location: Chat
Re: Madagascar -UPDATE- Version6 Pages 1&6 MOUNTAINS UPDATED
can you put a yellow 88 on the yellow cont
19:41:22 ‹jakewilliams› I was a pedo
Re: Madagascar -UPDATE- Version6 Pages 1&6 MOUNTAINS UPDATED
cena-rules wrote:can you put a yellow 88 on the yellow cont
lol you are awkward!
ok, i will IF you tell me which colours you want where
i.e orange on orange and so on lol
- cena-rules
- Posts: 9740
- Joined: Sat Apr 28, 2007 2:27 am
- Gender: Male
- Location: Chat
Re: Madagascar -UPDATE- Version6 Pages 1&6 MOUNTAINS UPDATED
umm army colours on cont of sam colour ie yellow on yellow etct-o-m wrote:cena-rules wrote:can you put a yellow 88 on the yellow cont![]()
lol you are awkward!
ok, i will IF you tell me which colours you want where
i.e orange on orange and so on lol
19:41:22 ‹jakewilliams› I was a pedo
Re: Madagascar -UPDATE- Version6 Pages 1&6 MOUNTAINS UPDATED
the brown cont though!!
lol - i did those brown cont #'s just for you
haha
EDIT:
i guessed at the colours
lol
lol - i did those brown cont #'s just for you
i guessed at the colours
lol
Re: Madagascar -UPDATE- Version6 Pages 1&6 MOUNTAINS UPDATED
All the colors are right here: http://www.conquerclub.com/mapmaker/index.php 
Re: Madagascar -UPDATE- Version6 Pages 1&6 MOUNTAINS UPDATED
thanks kap,Kaplowitz wrote:All the colors are right here: http://www.conquerclub.com/mapmaker/index.php
ill do that 2moro!
any other requests/suggestions for the next update - kap suggested lemur heads as army circles and look at the map now!
Re: Madagascar -UPDATE- Version6 Pages 1&6 MOUNTAINS UPDATED
Maybe a different color font for each continent to help differentiate?
Re: Madagascar -UPDATE- Version6 Pages 1&6 MOUNTAINS UPDATED
The black borders between continents look stronger in some places than in others. Compare the border between Sofia and Diana to the one between Anosy and Atsimo-Atsinanana. I think the darker ones look better, personally.
The new mountains are better, but still a bit too thin for my liking. Could you make them a bit thicker? Also, your source of light for the image seems to change as you move down the mountain chain. For example, between Analanjirofo and Sofia, you have illumination on the northwest and east sides of the mountain. Pick an angle and stick to it. I suggest the top right corner of the map for the light source.
The new mountains are better, but still a bit too thin for my liking. Could you make them a bit thicker? Also, your source of light for the image seems to change as you move down the mountain chain. For example, between Analanjirofo and Sofia, you have illumination on the northwest and east sides of the mountain. Pick an angle and stick to it. I suggest the top right corner of the map for the light source.
- wcaclimbing
- Posts: 5598
- Joined: Fri May 12, 2006 10:09 pm
- Location: In your quantum box....Maybe.
- Contact:
Re: Madagascar -UPDATE- Version6 Pages 1&6 MOUNTAINS UPDATED
New mountains are better.
No more comments from me for a while.
No more comments from me for a while.

- rocky mountain
- Posts: 415
- Joined: Thu Jul 12, 2007 7:08 pm
Re: Madagascar -UPDATE- Version6 Pages 1&6 MOUNTAINS UPDATED
how come you have an ! beside your thread instead of a regular conquer club star?
- wcaclimbing
- Posts: 5598
- Joined: Fri May 12, 2006 10:09 pm
- Location: In your quantum box....Maybe.
- Contact:
Re: Madagascar -UPDATE- Version6 Pages 1&6 MOUNTAINS UPDATED
sticky (or announcement.... i don't know which....)rocky mountain wrote:how come you have an ! beside your thread instead of a regular conquer club star?

Re: Madagascar -UPDATE- Version6 Pages 1&6 MOUNTAINS UPDATED
It's Stickied as an Advanced Idea.
Re: Madagascar -UPDATE- Version6 Pages 1&6 MOUNTAINS UPDATED
i dont think that you could get those colours mixed up very easily - other views?Kaplowitz wrote:Maybe a different color font for each continent to help differentiate?
maybe ill have a poll
--
yea - for some reason i have 2 layers of conts - (when i was making it i probably wanted to make it look darker and harder at the sides) - and they both have different ocpacities, but its just a duplicated layer so i dont know why some have turned out diferent to others, - i will look into itZeakCytho wrote:The black borders between continents look stronger in some places than in others. Compare the border between Sofia and Diana to the one between Anosy and Atsimo-Atsinanana. I think the darker ones look better, personally.
--
ill try make 'em thickerZeakCytho wrote:The new mountains are better, but still a bit too thin for my liking.
--
yea - i am trying to make the mountains on the top-rightish more like the others (which you cant see the light source so well) but i used different light sources to get the same effect on the other mountainsZeakCytho wrote:Also, your source of light for the image seems to change as you move down the mountain chain.
--
sticky yeawcaclimbing wrote:sticky (or announcement.... i don't know which....)rocky mountain wrote: how come you have an ! beside your thread instead of a regular conquer club star?
yupTaCktiX wrote:It's Stickied as an Advanced Idea.
-----
anyway - i will update it soon
thanks for the suggs.
Re: Madagascar -UPDATE- Version6 Pages 1&6 MOUNTAINS UPDATED
But its a little hard to tell which name goes where.t-o-m wrote:i dont think that you could get those colours mixed up very easily - other views?Kaplowitz wrote:Maybe a different color font for each continent to help differentiate?
maybe ill have a poll
--
Re: Madagascar -UPDATE- Version6 Pages 1&6 MOUNTAINS UPDATED
the terit names or the cont names?Kaplowitz wrote:But its a little hard to tell which name goes where.t-o-m wrote:i dont think that you could get those colours mixed up very easily - other views?Kaplowitz wrote:Maybe a different color font for each continent to help differentiate?
maybe ill have a poll
--
EDIT:
475px X 600px is ok right?
(width X height)
- sam_levi_11
- Posts: 2872
- Joined: Mon Dec 11, 2006 2:48 pm
- Gender: Male
Re: Madagascar -UPDATE- Version6 Pages 1&6 MOUNTAINS UPDATED
i think the gs is one too small, while the southern most bonus is one too big
Re: Madagascar -UPDATE- Version6 Pages 1&6 MOUNTAINS UPDATED
ill put together a few bonus options and maybe hold a pollsam_levi_11 wrote:i think the gs is one too small, while the southern most bonus is one too big
version 6A is coming out in like 5mins
EDIT:
here it is,
Zeak i think the mountains are too big on this one, and you wouldnt beleive it but i turned the pixel number down 5px's on this update lol
(but changed it to "Emboss" rather than the outer bevel)
Last edited by t-o-m on Tue Apr 29, 2008 3:15 pm, edited 1 time in total.
- sam_levi_11
- Posts: 2872
- Joined: Mon Dec 11, 2006 2:48 pm
- Gender: Male
Re: Madagascar -UPDATE- Version6 Pages 1&6 MOUNTAINS UPDATED
ill be here......waiting

- sam_levi_11
- Posts: 2872
- Joined: Mon Dec 11, 2006 2:48 pm
- Gender: Male
Re: Madagascar -UPDATE- Version6 Pages 1&6 MOUNTAINS UPDATED
i stick by what i said about the bonus' also the mountains look fine...looks less cartoony and more geographical





