Moderator: Community Team
Remember; The name "HEIR" was already given out by the start..The (secret) role too. The name has a meaning. Why name it "Heir" otherwise? And for a good reason: only in the first days a voteless town member could work in a balanced set-up. It can't work (no balance) in the final days as town would have a negative number on reaching the needed votes (and it is by design supposed to be "knife-edge") meaning it could end up 2 townies vs 1 circle...annieh wrote: Sat Nov 14, 2026 8:33 pm I disagree that Sonic meant nothing at all by insisting we don't lynch Loose and nothing at all with his mod announcement-heir definition.
Maybe it isn't so simple as LC is house, Charle is circle, but no reason whatsoever?

Now you are being like me (hopefully past me but evidently not to those who would point understandably to my accusations of Annie), and for me I've in past games on good side, I've been notorious for exploring cul de sacs.
I have considered what you now wrote in hindsight regarding the D1 and D2.Loose Canon wrote: Thu Nov 12, 2026 5:23 pm That is a really good post Zulu and deserves a reply.
When Annie declared her "result" on Devante the other thing that was going on was Sonic indicating the dangers of a mislynch - at first I was questioning how dangerous it was. My initial joy/relief at the result changed overnight to fear when I was working it through in my mind. Having worked it through in my mind, I was in a mathematical and wary mindset. Working through the maths I realised that qunatitavely speaking to me the odds on an archivist having been recruited were high enough for me to not want to lynch Devante without a lot further consideration. Then when others just wanted to lynch Devante off the cuff and without listening to Devante the fear of a hasty and incorrect lynch intensified. I was tempted to argue for Devante (in his absence) but this would have been no substitute for anything Circle leaning that Devante might have inadvertently said. When the actual votes on Devante started on the Saturday - I was like FFS don't be so hasty. When Annie started trying to force the lynch and with the momentum for it already I asked Annie the questions that I thought should be asked of her at least - and I didn't like the answers I received CAPS ON ASKING YOU TO VOTE now, and the misquoting of Devante by Annie - taking an actual Devante quote and adding Bunny into it. My mathematical argument would have been invalidated by Devante's actual response (but there would still have been a debate to be had) , except your actual Lynch vote went through first.
...
Really good post deserved an extensive reply - for you to consider.
I asked myself why Charle voted himself this early- and I concluded that it could be a claim of "the Heir" - because Charle wasn't afraid of being lynched. And do that early with no other votes made sense for me. I could cast my vote on Charle - if wrong, then I was as wrong as the others voted on Charle.Loose Canon wrote: Wed Oct 28, 2026 3:11 am Oh Charle, you know I hate those self votes.
Why don't you do something original and make a claim on 1 vote instead?
Thanks for posting that Sonic. I think that means the actual House Applicant card settles it for me! Hjelp's claim matches the real Vanilla wording completely, whereas Loose Canon has spent all day twisting that around and fishing for a Doctor claim.
