[Official] Choose Your Own Mafia - TOWN WINS

[*Pixar*]

so if we do vote madmitch, he won't have a good claim(VT already) so are we lynching him?

[subtleknifewield]

Ugh, I suppose I should do a re-read of the thread to see if I can find anything suspicious an get some more comprehensive reads. So many pages...

[madmitch]

unvote I am so stupid , sorry guys

[madmitch]

the draft location sure seems to me to have bearing on alinement,ten,eleven and twelve were all vts and I am thirteen and also vt,.Aage you are scum, you are an great player and had all of us chasing our tales ,but enough is enough VOTE AAGE

ebwop VOTE AOG HOPE i got this right this time

[benga]

Well f*ck me, I'm dead. You guys have no option but to lynch me.

Here's my last thoughts and reads, you might need them:

-HS likely scum
-Mitch town
-Whatsausage town, based on his last few posts
-Pixar probably scum (quick to end the day)
-subtleknifewield possible scum, trying to direct the vig
-endgame town

I am indeed the Town Double Voter. That's why I was comfortable switching my vote to ensure the lynch, they were closer to lynch then you guys could see.
Don't lynch mets tomorrow, and don't vig him. A few things could have happened to give the skewed result.

Good luck!

well its either Pixar or SBK.STREAKERS OTHER READS WERE RIGHT

guess streaker went here with reverse psychology
all his reads are wrong
will read some of Whatsausage posts, before voting

[Endgame422]

Mind laying it out clearly benga?
Who do you think are the 3 scum?
Who are the other 3 townies(assuming your town)?

[Marashu]

DAILY VOTE COUNT
madmitch: AoG, Mets
AoG: madmitch

Not Voting: pixar, endgame, skw, benga

With 7 alive, it takes 4 to lynch. Deadline is Wednesday, October 14, 1600CCT.

[*Pixar*]

we got 6 days, I might have switched my scum as midmitch, just not sure who isnt scum on my early list. I would vote but it looks like it takes 4 to lynch and don't want to put him at L1 without any discussion

[Army of GOD]

we got 6 days, I might have switched my scum as midmitch, just not sure who isnt scum on my early list. I would vote but it looks like it takes 4 to lynch and don't want to put him at L1 without any discussion

I don't know how much there is to discuss really. D4 will be better but mitch has been scummy since D1. He claimed vt with no pressure to do so whatsoever, asked the "can the mafia factions talk to each other?" question, OMGUS'd me twice and then voted aage (?).

with Mets not getting any (relevant) information, we don't have much more to go off of.

[*Pixar*]

so you suggest we lynch him?

[Army of GOD]

what are our alternatives?

[*Pixar*]

I guess lynch madmitch, or mass claim, I dont like the idea of mass claims though, I can never tell who's lying

[Army of GOD]

I guess lynch madmitch, or mass claim, I dont like the idea of mass claims though, I can never tell who's lying

massclaim doesn't mean anything though. Roles have no impact on alignment.

[Endgame422]

Id rather hold the mass claim for tomorrow honestly.
Last ditch effort sort of thing.
But we have lots of options for who to lynch.
Benga is an option,he is muddying the waters with his straker went reverse psychology statement.
Im still ok to lynch pix as well.

[*Pixar*]

Id rather hold the mass claim for tomorrow honestly.
Last ditch effort sort of thing.
But we have lots of options for who to lynch.
Benga is an option,he is muddying the waters with his straker went reverse psychology statement.
Im still ok to lynch pix as well.

you are okay with lynching everyone except yourself lol

[Endgame422]

Like i said before AoG,scum may try to lie and we could catch them there.
Or they could be honest and by telling us all of their previous NAs we might see a pattern that suggests scum.
Its not as illuminating as usual but a mass claim at Lylo could help us out.
If scum remains tomorrow i think it will be worth it for a mass claim.
FPd by Pix
Notice how mets/Aog/skw arent mentioned pix?
Thats because i dont want to lynch those 3 today.
So anyone but myself is totally incorrect.
Vote Pix

[*Pixar*]

well you can think I'm scum all you want, I'll claim if it gets to that point no problem. anyways I'm voting mitch

[madmitch]

VOTE ME OUT-LOSE THE GAME

[Marashu]

DAILY VOTE COUNT
madmitch: AoG, Mets, Pixar
AoG: madmitch
Pixar: Endgame

Not Voting: skw, benga

With 7 alive, it takes 4 to lynch. Deadline is Wednesday, October 14, 1600CCT.

[Metsfanmax]

subtle and benga, where do you stand? There's no excuse for not voting at this point.

[subtleknifewield]

Personally I am finding Mitch...not very helpful at all. I don't know if that is indicative of town or scum, or just poor play, but his defense is rather...lacking.

Like i said before AoG,scum may try to lie and we could catch them there.
Or they could be honest and by telling us all of their previous NAs we might see a pattern that suggests scum.
Its not as illuminating as usual but a mass claim at Lylo could help us out.
If scum remains tomorrow i think it will be worth it for a mass claim.
FPd by Pix
Notice how mets/Aog/skw arent mentioned pix?
Thats because i dont want to lynch those 3 today.
So anyone but myself is totally incorrect.
Vote Pix

Not complaining, of course, but I am wondering why you don't want to lynch me today. I haven't exactly been super-active in the last couple days, unlike AoG, and one could easily make the case for me lurking to avoid suspicion, which I believe you guys call Scumarining, or something like that?

[Endgame422]

Subtle,Yes youve been guilty of lurking today but the game has been dragging and I've looked a few times and just had very little to say,so i can't blame you for that.
But honestly i have almost zero feeling about you either way so your not on my list for today.
So who are you voting subtle?
Thats what I'm interested in.

[Metsfanmax]

I confess to having very little of an opinion on subtle as well, because he hasn't posted that often and it's been pretty vanilla when he has. So I agree with Endgame that subtle needs to actually take a stand. Unless you want us to lynch you, subtle?

[subtleknifewield]

Alright, fair enough, endgame. And very funny, Mets.

Hmmm...honestly, having just checked the roles listed out, that kinda negates a theory I had. If they had not been listed out, I would have suspected we had a jester-type role (someone who wins by getting themselves lynched) in the game in the form of Mitch. As it is, I can see why he has already garnered three of the four necessary votes.

Before I decide, I have two things to say...

@Mitch. Please try and put up some kind of meaningful defense, or I may feel I have no choice but to be the hammering vote on you based on the lack of it. As it is with my jester theory out the window, your early D1 roleclaim and your lack of a defense today are now actually raising a few red flags in my book.

@Endgame Could I get the reasoning of your vote on Pixar? I could make an educated guess based on what you did say, but I would like to hear it explicitly in your own words if possible.

[subtleknifewield]

EBWODP

Also @ Madmitch: Could I get a reasoning behind your vote today on AoG? I would go look myself, but I don't even know which page to start digging on.