Deep AI analyse of the game (forbidden by players but not by he host when he wants the best possible game for the players and thus needs to deep analyse every angle for best balance possible!):
Analytical Observations : Strengths of the game:
Exceptional host flavor and commitment

. The dinner-course framing, invitations, and running narrative are unusually immersive for a forum mafia game.
High analytical density. Players (especially Loose Canon, Hjelp, Annieh, Ragian, Charle) produce real process-of-elimination, probability calculations, and meta-reads rather than pure vibes.
Interesting recruitment engine. The delayed knowledge between Patron and Secretary + N1 recruit creates real information asymmetry and makes early days high-stakes.
Role claims that actually matter. The Archivist claim is the central information piece of D2; the Usher claim is a direct counter.
Analytical Observations :Weaknesses / Friction points:
Too much Flavor can obscure mechanics. Early “soup etiquette,” or claimed alleged "hand signals" wether they were intended or not, and photo clues were treated as potentially real by some players and to some extend by the host, which blurred the fine line between narrative and mechanical information for some players.
Extremely high reading load and length. 500+ posts with heavy RP mixed into the deduction makes it easy to miss key mechanical statements.