Streaker's F11 Game Over (4/9) MAFIA WIN (archive plz)

[madmitch]

My odds are on a player with some mafia experience, most likely.

I did have my eyes on Epi , and he is experience enough to pull this off. who should we vote for first Epi or Rizky ?

[rizky_biznezz]

Very quick to start talking about throwing votes around there Mitch its very early and we are still discussing... U haven't even tried to make an argument for or against anyone.. The only time I played the new card was in the beginning since then I have been trying to look at everyone.. You just seem to go for whoever is in the latest discussion

[rizky_biznezz]

to be honest i find it easier to make discussions now that tim is gone, i had a hard time trying to piece anything together before because i was so unsure of him and with everyone focussing on him not much was said about anyone else...

i have made cases on pt, subtle and epi, and i have said through the whole thing that i was unsure of mitch... so who is supposed to be my partner?

im still trying to figure out raz's death too pt it never really made sense.. all i got was:

*he was right about epi
*to set me or epi up to be targets
*his experience
*at the time there were suspicions on tim, mitch and I so didn't make sense to kill us... also as mentioned mitch and I hadn't spoken up much so smart to leave us to the end, less chance of us figuring it out

[Epitaph1]

I agree that with Tim gone we shouldn't be dealing with as much static. The problem with his play this game is that there were a lot of legitimate reasons to think he was scum. So, we can't just look at who was pushing for a Tim lynch.

Just a quick note since I don't have a ton of time atm, but risky strikes me as a lot more town today than the first two days. I need to re-read all of his posts again, and not just the one's ptolwe posted, to get an idea as a whole.

[madmitch]

WOW !!! that just what a good partner would say

[ptlowe]

Code: Select all

[color=#FF0000][b]vote rizky[/b][/color]

Im thinking rizky.

[ptlowe]

vote rizky

[madmitch]

vote rizky

[subtleknifewield]

vote: Rizky

[rizky_biznezz]

Bad move guys..

[rizky_biznezz]

Well done mafia.. Thanks everyone for the game it was interesting

[Streaker]

Rizky, Vanilla Townie has been lynched!

Game over, flawless victory for mafia! I do not understand why Mitch would ever cast his vote before hearing what Epi has to say... But ok.

Dead chat: http://www.quicktopic.com/51/H/L8fYrkdkycdb

Mafia chat: http://www.quicktopic.com/51/H/zptrJZfkfHzd

A lot has to be said about this game, but my part will have to wait until Monday.
I invite everyone to share their opinions (including those that watched this game without playing it.

Thank you all for playing, i hope you all had a fun experience and stick around to play the other games!

[madmitch]

well shit

[bosaardbeitje]

Holy Guacamoly! That was seriously bold play Ptlowe and Subtle. Very, very, very well done Your choices definitely taught me a lot about how this game is played. Kudos to both of you!!!

[madmitch]

Holy Guacamoly! That was seriously bold play Ptlowe and Subtle. Very, very, very well done Your choices definitely taught me a lot about how this game is played. Kudos to both of you!!!

the same from me well done

[aage]

Lol epi, on page 7-8 we were onto both of them but then got completely blindsided by each other

[the white rose]

after pt's opening vote it would be a simple matter to let it stand for a day or 2 and when the 2 scum did not support the vote it must mean that either pt or rizky were scum.

Any opening vote from town carries an enormous risk, as if incorrect surely a double hammer will come from scum. therefore it had to be scum that opened the vote. had one of the townies recognised that, just one vote for pt would have found him out. Another reason to suspect pt was the fact that he did not unvote as soon as mitch had voted, surely if he had been town he would have had to unvote for fear of a double hammer from scum.

Lynching tim on D2 was a bad move. Sure he was very suspect, but whether you lynch him on D2 or D3 makes no difference, except if lynched on D3 you would have had a N2 read from him, had he not get nightkilled. Even if he did get nightkilled you have a confirmed townie in boss who would still be alive in D3.

[subtleknifewield]

Thanks guys...I totally expected to die today because Epi suspected me the previous day.

In any case, kudos to those who actually suspected us of being partners, and good job on Tim for being the one to stick to me like glue. And I mean that in a caring way Seriously though, I thought Tim and Epi might actually convince enough people I was scum, that in part with his role as cop, was why I pushed for him so hard.

[bosaardbeitje]

after pt's opening vote it would be a simple matter to let it stand for a day or 2 and when the 2 scum did not support the vote it must mean that either pt or rizky were scum.

Agreed, also when Epi said this:

We have a 40% chance of getting this right today. No one bring anyone to L-1 until we are sure we want to pursue a lynch--the scum just need to quick hammer 1 person to end this whole thing.

I tried to yell through my screen hoping someone would hear me , because putting someone at L2 would already be a risk. So, basically no one should vote until later. If Mitch would have been the first one to vote, it would have been over as well.

[ptlowe]

I thought Mitch would follow based on his comments LOL and I thought the longer it went it would get to me or epi lol

[bosaardbeitje]

Very nicely timed as well, no one around to stop it

[ptlowe]

Thanks you and rizky did good jobs its my first time being mafia but I just Played normal town like I usually am and it workef

[bosaardbeitje]

Thanks, now I actually believe you, LOL. Near the end of day 2 I suspected you could be Epi's partner, but I was so set on Epi that it never occured to me that you and Subtle were a pair. I guess I tunneled there. Poor Rizky had way beter reads but didn't get the chance to use them.

[ptlowe]

I was down right scared of Epi so I tried to protect him hoping he would stay with me on scum till the end.

[subtleknifewield]

Before any of us forget...Thank you Streaker, for the fun game and the learning experience for all of us!