Not too big, not too small
#GCCM The make a map time is upon us.
Moderator: Cartographers
Forum rules
Please read the Community Guidelines before posting.
Please read the Community Guidelines before posting.
- Armandolas
- Posts: 1761
- Joined: Fri Jun 06, 2008 6:32 am
- Gender: Male
- Location: Lisbon
Re: The Great Community Map Project. Competition Post 2 Week
I voted for medium, because the middle term is allways more consentual.
Not too big, not too small
Not too big, not too small
- koontz1973
- Posts: 6960
- Joined: Thu Jan 01, 2009 10:57 am
Re: The Great Community Map Project. Competition Post 2
Competitions are being run every week in post 2. The other way is to show support by using the avatar or sig I am showing. For the #Just For Fun, they are just that, for fun.mint-murray wrote:How many puzzles do I need to solve for a medal ?koontz1973 wrote:Well done mint-murry. You got it.
Thread locked for maintenance.

- koontz1973
- Posts: 6960
- Joined: Thu Jan 01, 2009 10:57 am
Re: The Great Community Map Project. Competition Post 2 Week

Tournament one is about to start. Good luck to all players.
AdamKeith
Gilligan
MoB Deadly
sempaispellcheck
mcshanester29
Iron Maid
iamkoolerthanu
Darin44
ender516
rjhankey
greenoaks
D4 Damager
General Bax
KingRat
Azuretsarts
rmjw10
keefie
Evil Semp

- iamkoolerthanu
- Posts: 4119
- Joined: Sun Dec 31, 2006 6:56 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: looking at my highest score: 2715, #170
Re: The Great Community Map Project. Competition Post 2 Week
small maps-27
Doodle Earth 18
Luxemburg 19
Egypt: Lower 20
Madagascar 24
Classic Cities: Madrid 24
Duck & Cover 24
USA West 24
Egypt: Upper 26
Eurasia Mini 27
Cyprus 28
Egypt:: Nubia 29
Greater China 29
Circus Maximus 30
Haiti 30
Indochina 31
Ireland 32
USA South West 32
Celtic Nations 33
St. Patrick's Day 33
London 33
Central America 33
Golfe Du St. Laurent 34
Netherlands 35
Austerlitz 35
Halloween Hollows 35
Greenland 35
USA New England 35
Luxemburg 19
Egypt: Lower 20
Madagascar 24
Classic Cities: Madrid 24
Duck & Cover 24
USA West 24
Egypt: Upper 26
Eurasia Mini 27
Cyprus 28
Egypt:: Nubia 29
Greater China 29
Circus Maximus 30
Haiti 30
Indochina 31
Ireland 32
USA South West 32
Celtic Nations 33
St. Patrick's Day 33
London 33
Central America 33
Golfe Du St. Laurent 34
Netherlands 35
Austerlitz 35
Halloween Hollows 35
Greenland 35
USA New England 35
medium maps-130
Portugal 36
WWII Operation Iwo Jima 36
Madness (our house) 36
Italy 36
Iceland 36
San Marino 36
Australia 36
Dustbowl 36
Draknor - Lv. 1 37
Mexico 37
France 1789 38
SteamWorks 39
WWII Western Front 39
Istanbul 39
Classic Cities: Jakarta 39
USA South East 40
USA Rockies 40
Flanders 1302 40
Mongol Empire 40
Ancient Greece 40
Berlin 1961 40
Scotland 40
Puget Sound 42
Indian Empire 42
Conquer 4 42
Germany 42
American Civil War 42
Malta 42
High Seas 42
Alexander's Empire 42
Hong Kong 42
Space 42
British Isles 42
Caribbean Islands 42
BeNeLux 42
USA 42
8 Thoughts 42
Middle East 42
Canada 42
Holy Roman Empire 42
San Francisco 42
Castle Lands 42
Classic 42
Macedonia 42
Cairns Metro 43
WWI Ottoman Empire 43
Discworld 43
England 43
Japan 43
Archipelago 43
Far East 43
Yugoslavia 43
CCU 44
Oceania 44
South America 44
Gilgamesh 44
France 44
New Jersey 44
WWII Poland 44
WWII Eastern Front 44
13 Colonies 44
Midkemdil 45
Brazil 45
King of the Mountains 45
USApocalypse 45
Africa 45
Good Morning Woodboro 46
Midgard 46
Extreme Global Warming 46
Portland 46
Three Kingdoms of Korea 47
Philadelphia 47
Unification italy 47
Unification Germany 47
Africa II 47
Europe 48
Wales 48
Great Lakes 48
Arctic 48
Montreal 48
Tamriel 48
North America 48
Route 66 48
Crossword 48
Philippines 48
The Citadel 50
South Africa 1885 50
Copenhagen 50
Thyseneal 51
Jamaica 52
Poker Club 52
Austro-Hungarian Empire 52
Magyarország 52
California 52
Triple Alliance 52
Land and Sea 53
First Nations of South America 53
Soviet Union 53
Egypt: Valley of the Kings 53
Balkan Peninsula 54
Europe 1914 55
2011 Women's World Cup 55
Siege! 56
Prohibition Chicago 56
Iberia 56
Chicago 56
Texan Wars 57
Dawn of Ages 57
Imperium Romanum 58
Age of Merchants 58
Sydney Metro 58
USA Great Lakes 58
Operation Drug War 59
Baltic Crusades 59
Thailand 60
Orient Express 1883 60
Cairns Coral Coast 60
Tribal War 60
Charleston 60
Chinese Checkers 60
Europa 61
Arms Race! 62
Kingdom Of Denmark 62
Nordic Countries 62
2010 South Africa World Cup 63
Poison Rome 63
Rail Australia 64
Knights 64
U.S. Senate 65
Transsiberian Rail 1914 65
WWII Operation Iwo Jima 36
Madness (our house) 36
Italy 36
Iceland 36
San Marino 36
Australia 36
Dustbowl 36
Draknor - Lv. 1 37
Mexico 37
France 1789 38
SteamWorks 39
WWII Western Front 39
Istanbul 39
Classic Cities: Jakarta 39
USA South East 40
USA Rockies 40
Flanders 1302 40
Mongol Empire 40
Ancient Greece 40
Berlin 1961 40
Scotland 40
Puget Sound 42
Indian Empire 42
Conquer 4 42
Germany 42
American Civil War 42
Malta 42
High Seas 42
Alexander's Empire 42
Hong Kong 42
Space 42
British Isles 42
Caribbean Islands 42
BeNeLux 42
USA 42
8 Thoughts 42
Middle East 42
Canada 42
Holy Roman Empire 42
San Francisco 42
Castle Lands 42
Classic 42
Macedonia 42
Cairns Metro 43
WWI Ottoman Empire 43
Discworld 43
England 43
Japan 43
Archipelago 43
Far East 43
Yugoslavia 43
CCU 44
Oceania 44
South America 44
Gilgamesh 44
France 44
New Jersey 44
WWII Poland 44
WWII Eastern Front 44
13 Colonies 44
Midkemdil 45
Brazil 45
King of the Mountains 45
USApocalypse 45
Africa 45
Good Morning Woodboro 46
Midgard 46
Extreme Global Warming 46
Portland 46
Three Kingdoms of Korea 47
Philadelphia 47
Unification italy 47
Unification Germany 47
Africa II 47
Europe 48
Wales 48
Great Lakes 48
Arctic 48
Montreal 48
Tamriel 48
North America 48
Route 66 48
Crossword 48
Philippines 48
The Citadel 50
South Africa 1885 50
Copenhagen 50
Thyseneal 51
Jamaica 52
Poker Club 52
Austro-Hungarian Empire 52
Magyarország 52
California 52
Triple Alliance 52
Land and Sea 53
First Nations of South America 53
Soviet Union 53
Egypt: Valley of the Kings 53
Balkan Peninsula 54
Europe 1914 55
2011 Women's World Cup 55
Siege! 56
Prohibition Chicago 56
Iberia 56
Chicago 56
Texan Wars 57
Dawn of Ages 57
Imperium Romanum 58
Age of Merchants 58
Sydney Metro 58
USA Great Lakes 58
Operation Drug War 59
Baltic Crusades 59
Thailand 60
Orient Express 1883 60
Cairns Coral Coast 60
Tribal War 60
Charleston 60
Chinese Checkers 60
Europa 61
Arms Race! 62
Kingdom Of Denmark 62
Nordic Countries 62
2010 South Africa World Cup 63
Poison Rome 63
Rail Australia 64
Knights 64
U.S. Senate 65
Transsiberian Rail 1914 65
large maps-50
WWII Battle for Australia 66
Rail USA 67
Vancouver 67
Solar System 67
Patch wars 68
New World 69
Northwest Passage 69
Fractured China 69
Eastern Hemisphere 70
Quad Cities 70
WWII Battle of Gazala 70
Christmas Map 71
Island of Doom 72
Pearl Harbor 72
Classic Cities: Sydney 72
New Zealand 72
First Nation of North America 72
D-Day Omaha Beach! 72
Treasures of Galapagos 73
Dark Continent 73
WWII Ardennes 73
Middle Ages 74
Cuban Missile Crisis 75
Lunar War 75
Rail Africa 78
NYC 80
Baseball: King of Diamonds 80
Forbidden City 81
Bamboo Jack 82
Napoleonic Europe 82
Feudal War 82
Third Crusade 82
Rail Europe 83
CC City Mogul 83
Rail Asia 84
1982 84
All Your Base are Belong To Us 86
Fractured America 86
Peloponnesian War 87
Battle for Iraq! 87
Monsters! 88
Rorke's Drift 89
Atlantis 89
Trench Warfare 92
Age of Realms : Might 93
Age of Realms : Magic 93
Easter Egg Hunt 94
Trafalgar 95
Battle of Actium 96
WWII Stalingrad 99
Rail USA 67
Vancouver 67
Solar System 67
Patch wars 68
New World 69
Northwest Passage 69
Fractured China 69
Eastern Hemisphere 70
Quad Cities 70
WWII Battle of Gazala 70
Christmas Map 71
Island of Doom 72
Pearl Harbor 72
Classic Cities: Sydney 72
New Zealand 72
First Nation of North America 72
D-Day Omaha Beach! 72
Treasures of Galapagos 73
Dark Continent 73
WWII Ardennes 73
Middle Ages 74
Cuban Missile Crisis 75
Lunar War 75
Rail Africa 78
NYC 80
Baseball: King of Diamonds 80
Forbidden City 81
Bamboo Jack 82
Napoleonic Europe 82
Feudal War 82
Third Crusade 82
Rail Europe 83
CC City Mogul 83
Rail Asia 84
1982 84
All Your Base are Belong To Us 86
Fractured America 86
Peloponnesian War 87
Battle for Iraq! 87
Monsters! 88
Rorke's Drift 89
Atlantis 89
Trench Warfare 92
Age of Realms : Might 93
Age of Realms : Magic 93
Easter Egg Hunt 94
Trafalgar 95
Battle of Actium 96
WWII Stalingrad 99
- koontz1973
- Posts: 6960
- Joined: Thu Jan 01, 2009 10:57 am
Re: The Great Community Map Project. Competition Post 2 Week

For our second competition, we are going to look into the future.
...............................What Can I Say?
Every map that gets made, a small description needs to be written. This is what was written for Rorke's Drift.
Below, you will find 4 descriptions for 4 different maps at different stages of map making.Map Description wrote:January 1879, around 4500 Zulu warriors attacked the tiny outpost of Rorke's Drift. Under the command of Chard and Bromhead, around 130 British and 20 Natal regulars defended the outpost for 2 whole days before relief.
You will find the maps in the drafting room, main foundry and beta map forums. All you need to do is go hunting for which map is being described. Then when you have the four maps, send the names of them to me (koontz1973) via PM.
Map 1
Battle for HIGH GROUND! Auto-deploy bonuses which increase as players conquer higher ground; higher levels bombard lower levels. The summit is the only territory that can kill starting spots.
Map 2
Set of on your travels, exploring the furthest regions. Explore unknown lands with famous explorers. But watch out for monsters swim in the waters.
Map 3
This is a simple map, in some ways similar to route 66, where the win objective is to hold the route. Its based on real life, but I have added a few stations and connections that would/could be built in the future.
Map 4
This map incorporates resource collection (4 weapons), build-a-bonus (Capitals), auto-deploy territories, gameplay from standard CC maps, and continues the series style including two "free-for-all" regions.
rules
Please read through all rules.
- No posting answers into the thread.
- Send all answers to me koontz1973 via PM.
- Answers to me by this time
- At the end of the competition, all correct answers will be entered into a random draw (Random.org) to determine the winner of the GA medal.

-
mint-murray
- Posts: 452
- Joined: Sat Oct 08, 2011 7:26 am
- Gender: Male
- Location: Scotland
Re: The Great Community Map Project. Competition Post 2 Week
Medium Map. Small maps leave little room for inventive game play, theyre lux or doodle no matter how you dress them up. Medium gives nice balance, and avoids trench games lasting 4 months and 6 days.
- iamkoolerthanu
- Posts: 4119
- Joined: Sun Dec 31, 2006 6:56 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: looking at my highest score: 2715, #170
Re: The Great Community Map Project. Competition Post 2 Week
I disagree. Circus Maximus, Egypt: Upper, Ireland, Greenland, Halloween Hollows, all are slightly unique.mint-murray wrote:Medium Map. Small maps leave little room for inventive game play, theyre lux or doodle no matter how you dress them up. Medium gives nice balance, and avoids trench games lasting 4 months and 6 days.
Maybe with a mid-size map there is a little more room to play with, but you can add bombards, one way attacks, killer neutrals, etc to any sized map to significantly change the gameplay
Re: The Great Community Map Project. Competition Post 2 Week
THREE KINGDOMS OF CHINA! GOT IT!
This image is a sofilorry.


Re: The Great Community Map Project. Competition Post 2 Week
i voted for medium size map. although a community map should be epic i think it should be able to used in all kinds of games. medium size maps are suitable for that


- sempaispellcheck
- Posts: 2852
- Joined: Fri Sep 10, 2010 10:31 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: Among the clouds and the skyscrapers, saving the world.
Re: The Great Community Map Project. Competition Post 2 Week
I voted for a large map because I like this idea:
betiko wrote:if we make a community map; let's use members as territories and the more the merrier!
Re: The Great Community Map Project. Competition Post 2 Week
That does sound pretty fun.sempaispellcheck wrote:I voted for a large map because I like this idea:betiko wrote:if we make a community map; let's use members as territories and the more the merrier!

- koontz1973
- Posts: 6960
- Joined: Thu Jan 01, 2009 10:57 am
Re: The Great Community Map Project. Competition Post 2 Week
A poll can be added to graphics sweeps week for this. But it would depend on the name I guess. koontz and gilligan sound OK, but sempaispellchack or thebasterd do not have a nice ring to it.Gilligan wrote:That does sound pretty fun.sempaispellcheck wrote:I voted for a large map because I like this idea:betiko wrote:if we make a community map; let's use members as territories and the more the merrier!

- sempaispellcheck
- Posts: 2852
- Joined: Fri Sep 10, 2010 10:31 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: Among the clouds and the skyscrapers, saving the world.
Re: The Great Community Map Project. Competition Post 2 Week
I'm fine with mine being shortened to sempai - that's how I sign my posts and PMs, anyway. Observe:koontz1973 wrote:A poll can be added to graphics sweeps week for this. But it would depend on the name I guess. koontz and gilligan sound OK, but sempaispellchack or thebasterd do not have a nice ring to it.Gilligan wrote:That does sound pretty fun.sempaispellcheck wrote:I voted for a large map because I like this idea:betiko wrote:if we make a community map; let's use members as territories and the more the merrier!
sempai
- koontz1973
- Posts: 6960
- Joined: Thu Jan 01, 2009 10:57 am
Re: The Great Community Map Project. Competition Post 2 Week
#Just For Fun
OK, lets have some fun.
Name this map and the map maker.

OK, lets have some fun.
Name this map and the map maker.


- koontz1973
- Posts: 6960
- Joined: Thu Jan 01, 2009 10:57 am
Re: The Great Community Map Project. Competition Post 2 Week
Ok, another one then.
#Just For Fun
Map and maker.

Give me a minute to get another one set up.
#Just For Fun
Map and maker.

Give me a minute to get another one set up.

Re: The Great Community Map Project. Competition Post 2 Week
Krazy Kingdoms/Dolomite!
Time for class
Time for class

- koontz1973
- Posts: 6960
- Joined: Thu Jan 01, 2009 10:57 am
Re: The Great Community Map Project. Competition Post 2 Week
Two more for tonight, then I am out of here.
#Just For fun
Maps and map makers.


#Just For fun
Maps and map makers.



Re: The Great Community Map Project. Competition Post 2 Week
For me, map size doesn't matter as long as it is a creative concept.
In this project, I would rather see a large map then a small map. It's a big project, so a bigger map should come out of it.
Thus, I voted for large.
In this project, I would rather see a large map then a small map. It's a big project, so a bigger map should come out of it.
Thus, I voted for large.
- sempaispellcheck
- Posts: 2852
- Joined: Fri Sep 10, 2010 10:31 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: Among the clouds and the skyscrapers, saving the world.
Re: The Great Community Map Project. Competition Post 2 Week
I'm gonna guess...
Madness - cairnswk
France 2.1 - Lancelot du Lac
Madness - cairnswk
France 2.1 - Lancelot du Lac
Re: The Great Community Map Project. Competition Post 2 Week
Large map, of course. I don't think another Hive-style map (I like the map, hey) is currently needed, but I think it would be quite interesting to have a big map to play with 8 people (or once the suggestion gets implemented, 12)
This image is a sofilorry.


Re: The Great Community Map Project. Competition Post 2 Week
I prefer a small map. Small maps tend to produce shorter games. You could run an enormous tournament on a small map and get it finished before your premium runs out.
- koontz1973
- Posts: 6960
- Joined: Thu Jan 01, 2009 10:57 am
Re: The Great Community Map Project. Competition Post 2 Week
One is correct, the other not. You also got only one of the three map makers.sempaispellcheck wrote:I'm gonna guess...
Madness - cairnswk
France 2.1 - Lancelot du Lac

- koontz1973
- Posts: 6960
- Joined: Thu Jan 01, 2009 10:57 am
Re: The Great Community Map Project. Competition Post 2 Week
I also voted large on this one. Out of all the great maps we have on this site, all are large maps. Very rare that a medium map can rise above the ordinary. Another reason for large is it allows more game play options.

Re: The Great Community Map Project. Competition Post 2 Week
The other is Escape, mapmaker koontz
Last mapmaker of France 2.1 is Mishalex
Last mapmaker of France 2.1 is Mishalex


