Italian Style Mafia Thread: FSO wins!

[edocsil]

I was even blurring everywhere, edocsil and eagleblade into 1 along the way )

My heart bleeds. He has some fool trophy and I have this same sword I have had for years.

[everywhere116]

I was even blurring everywhere, edocsil and eagleblade into 1 along the way )

My heart bleeds. He has some fool trophy and I have this same sword I have had for years.

And I have the unmistakable Enterprise.

[jak111]

vote Codie for being suspicious earlier when I was away with a girl, then when I come back he lets a few pages go on so the pressure on him drops and begins speaking again like he know's who to lynch. Sorry but with the things I've seen so far of this game you seem to not like being pressured and I do believe you did a hate vote on someone earlier because they voted for you.

Now, that being said. Until I read the mod kill a few pages back I was thinking Eagle up to that. X3

[zimmah]

anyone else thinks it's not a smart move to NOT protect anyone night one?

i mean, what's the worst that can happen when you protect someone? the worst thing that can happen is when 2 mafia factions or sk/mafia target each other and you protect one of them.

in other words when you protect mafia while the sk choose the same mafia to kill and you protect him, or vice versa.

i think it's a stupid argument for not defending someone, as the chances are way better to protect someone good. since the ones who do nightkills are often the bad guys (especially on day 1) it's usually to your advantage to randomly defend someone.

i think you're just afraid someone watched you and he can counterclaim you if you said you protected someone while you didn't.

[safariguy5]

anyone else thinks it's not a smart move to NOT protect anyone night one?

i mean, what's the worst that can happen when you protect someone? the worst thing that can happen is when 2 mafia factions or sk/mafia target each other and you protect one of them.

in other words when you protect mafia while the sk choose the same mafia to kill and you protect him, or vice versa.

i think it's a stupid argument for not defending someone, as the chances are way better to protect someone good. since the ones who do nightkills are often the bad guys (especially on day 1) it's usually to your advantage to randomly defend someone.

i think you're just afraid someone watched you and he can counterclaim you if you said you protected someone while you didn't.

Oh absolutely, this works with the same logic as playing a cop. The "town" faction outnumbers "scum", especially in the beginning. You are statistically much more likely to protect a townie than a scum member, just like how the cop is statistically more likely to investigate a townie rather than scum Night 1.

[ghostly447]

I have never played as bodygaurd so I assumed find someone and defend them until I die.

[jgordon1111]

Hmmm MoB your going with safari guy on the not poster's, me being one of them, LOL safari is skimming and so are you, I posted on thursday, I am pretty sure that was yesterday, I dont think I have missed a day without posting. So adding me to that group kinda makes you and safari scummy, Because you know who scum is and therefore no real reason to follow the game except pick someone to vote for who isnt scum. Safari if you would please pay attention to the game a little better, MoB dont jump on a bandwagon that went the wrong way, it could get you stretched for not paying attention yourself. Unless of course this is saturday and I showed up at work for no reason. Damn I hope they pay Me.

[everywhere116]

Vote Count 3

ghostly: 1 (edocsil)
MoB Deadly: 1 (wildwilliam)
jgordon: 1 (safariguy)
wildwilliam: 2 (zimmah, codierose)
codierose: 1 (jak1111)
Not Voting: 8 (Sparticus, skillfusniper, jgordon, ghostly, Leehar, TheGeneral, MoB Deadly, dazza2008)

[MoB Deadly]

jgordon can you please explain this a little better? I don't even have a vote cast I dont think, how am I on a bandwagon? And I dont think I have even responded to any of safari's posts directly yet. Please enlighten me?

fastposted

[codierose]

vote Codie for being suspicious earlier when I was away with a girl, then when I come back he lets a few pages go on so the pressure on him drops and begins speaking again like he know's who to lynch. Sorry but with the things I've seen so far of this game you seem to not like being pressured and I do believe you did a hate vote on someone earlier because they voted for you.

Now, that being said. Until I read the mod kill a few pages back I was thinking Eagle up to that. X3

hey jak nice for you to add something considering you let about 10 pages go before adding anthing skim then accuse me of missing a couple that happened in a 6 hour period whilst i as asleep time zones are a bitch i have posted what 10\15 times how many times have you hmm 2\3 go skim somemore and add something relevant to what's been going on

[codierose]

jak you Do know its day two 3 dead and 1 claim just thought i would give you the heads up any more info you need just let us know

[eagleblade]

. eagleblade (FBI Officer) Dumbassed Day 2

what just happened did I get lynched????

[edocsil]

. eagleblade (FBI Officer) Dumbassed Day 2

what just happened did I get lynched????

You got Modkilled retard.

[eagleblade]

for what?

[MoB Deadly]

Im going to Vote Codi until he addresses this post

yes but he did cheer that the good guy got lynched w00t! even though the role is up for interpretation

Have you reread the thread and realized what WW was cheering about? I made the same mistake, it should be clear now

So far he has ignored me and posted against Jak:

vote Codie for being suspicious earlier when I was away with a girl, then when I come back he lets a few pages go on so the pressure on him drops and begins speaking again like he know's who to lynch. Sorry but with the things I've seen so far of this game you seem to not like being pressured and I do believe you did a hate vote on someone earlier because they voted for you.

Now, that being said. Until I read the mod kill a few pages back I was thinking Eagle up to that. X3

hey jak nice for you to add something considering you let about 10 pages go before adding anthing skim then accuse me of missing a couple that happened in a 6 hour period whilst i as asleep time zones are a bitch i have posted what 10\15 times how many times have you hmm 2\3 go skim somemore and add something relevant to what's been going on

jak you Do know its day two 3 dead and 1 claim just thought i would give you the heads up any more info you need just let us know

______________________________________________

Also, I want jgordon to please clear this up.

Hmmm MoB your going with safari guy on the not poster's, me being one of them, LOL safari is skimming and so are you, I posted on thursday, I am pretty sure that was yesterday, I dont think I have missed a day without posting. So adding me to that group kinda makes you and safari scummy, Because you know who scum is and therefore no real reason to follow the game except pick someone to vote for who isnt scum. Safari if you would please pay attention to the game a little better, MoB dont jump on a bandwagon that went the wrong way, it could get you stretched for not paying attention yourself. Unless of course this is saturday and I showed up at work for no reason. Damn I hope they pay Me.

jgordon can you please explain this a little better? I don't even have a vote cast I dont think, how am I on a bandwagon? And I dont think I have even responded to any of safari's posts directly yet. Please enlighten me?

fastposted

[zimmah]

for what?

for copying your role pm

[wildwilliam]

unvote

I would like a few things cleared up. I asked a couple of questions that have been ignored, yet multiple posts have passed:

w00t!

his reaction to two mafia deaths, usurper and the don.

now his current claim is that he was happy because the usurper died. but since the godfather (Don) died with him, it doesn't matter to have the usurper around, because THE DON IS ALLREADY DEAD! so explain me once again your w00t!

i think he just made up his w00t reaction about being happy the usurper died and hoped noone would spot his lies, but i think he was in fact happy at first glance.

leading me to believe he is 3rd party or a really messed up mafia who didn't pay enough attention to his role pm.

vote WW

can you restate your reasons for voting for me please. Since the ones you stated here are false leading me to believe that you are not paying attention to the game.

and

yes but he did cheer that the good guy got lynched w00t! even though the role is up for interpretation

uhmmm up for interpretation? can you please explain?

[MoB Deadly]

WW isn't this game so randomly scattered dont you feel?

[eagleblade]

for what?

for copying your role pm

I didn't I forged it I was scum

[MoB Deadly]

Obviously you did something wrong or you wouldnt be dead right now. Ask the mod if you need clarification. He has the real reason

[wildwilliam]

WW isn't this game so randomly scattered dont you feel?

I think if you take a step back, you can see why it is so scattered. Some people genuinely have misread, and others I believe got caught off guard by the role reversals. Not to mention this game is going to fly by so short strict time limits + lots of posts = people scampering to read and may lead to some misjudgements..

To throw my 2 cents around:
I still do not 100% trust ghostly, even though Eagle flipped. odd claim, but easily testable.
I am still wondering about zimmah. Made some serious statements that were completely false (I think he just misread, but have not heard an answer)
Codie as well. This post really throws me:

out of the 3 leads we had to go on one claimed bodyguard one mod killed fbi agent
one yet to be pressured so are we going to work on WW or look for other leads

You do not need the towns permission to follow your own leads, just seems like he is trying to coat tail someone.

Plus I believe we have a few stragglers who have not posted as much. That can kill in this game. We have till Monday so I would like to see people who have not said much to post a little more.

[wildwilliam]

for what?

for copying your role pm

I didn't I forged it I was scum

I would say it was this: you stated a win condition. Even if this is fake, you would still end up dieing because if you did not die from fake win condition claims, we would all know it was fake because you were not mod killed, and we would lynch you anyways.

[skillfusniper33]

vote Codi

Codi just seems to be adding a bunch of fluff. He is also getting on Jak for not posting much, and with very little added to the conversation, but IMO codi really isn't adding much either by always asking a few questions about cases available, and where everyone else is wanting to go with a case. If he were to build his own case it would help out some.

This is working from most recent backwards

jak you Do know its day two 3 dead and 1 claim just thought i would give you the heads up any more info you need just let us know

Jak should be able to easily look on his own, and find out, since all that info is on the 1st page.

vote Codie for being suspicious earlier when I was away with a girl, then when I come back he lets a few pages go on so the pressure on him drops and begins speaking again like he know's who to lynch. Sorry but with the things I've seen so far of this game you seem to not like being pressured and I do believe you did a hate vote on someone earlier because they voted for you.

Now, that being said. Until I read the mod kill a few pages back I was thinking Eagle up to that. X3

hey jak nice for you to add something considering you let about 10 pages go before adding anthing skim then accuse me of missing a couple that happened in a 6 hour period whilst i as asleep time zones are a bitch i have posted what 10\15 times how many times have you hmm 2\3 go skim somemore and add something relevant to what's been going on

This is codi's longest post, and is just trying to tell jak off because he hasn't posted as much as him, but then again this also has nothing to do with the game, and is more of an attack on jak.

so what do you think about the cases so far

Another fluff post, and doesn't really want to work on his own case. Not to sure why

hey ghost did you use your power last night
wOOt! wOOt! unvote vote WW

He asks a valid question, but also adds a bunch of fluff as well as a vote with very little explanation of why. But I am assuming that the reasoning was because he thought we only had 3 leads on the day. (See next quote for it to make a little more sense)

out of the 3 leads we had to go on one claimed bodyguard one mod killed fbi agent
one yet to be pressured so are we going to work on WW or look for other leads

I am not sure why he thinks we only had 3 leads today. The claim came from some random pressuring, and the mod-kill was just kind of dumb luck that worked in Town's favor.

And all of this came from just Day 2, and past 4 pages of text.

Fastposted X6

[eagleblade]

wait I can't state win condition then what is a claim?

[skillfusniper33]

WW isn't this game so randomly scattered dont you feel?

I think if you take a step back, you can see why it is so scattered. Some people genuinely have misread, and others I believe got caught off guard by the role reversals. Not to mention this game is going to fly by so short strict time limits + lots of posts = people scampering to read and may lead to some misjudgements..

To throw my 2 cents around:
I still do not 100% trust ghostly, even though Eagle flipped. odd claim, but easily testable.
I am still wondering about zimmah. Made some serious statements that were completely false (I think he just misread, but have not heard an answer)
Codie as well. This post really throws me:

out of the 3 leads we had to go on one claimed bodyguard one mod killed fbi agent
one yet to be pressured so are we going to work on WW or look for other leads

You do not need the towns permission to follow your own leads, just seems like he is trying to coat tail someone.


Plus I believe we have a few stragglers who have not posted as much. That can kill in this game. We have till Monday so I would like to see people who have not said much to post a little more.

Yes Mob (I know this wasn't directed at me) But I have to agree this game feels scattered, but I think it is because we have so much going on, and so many people posting either fluff, or other random stuff that doesn't really relate to the game.

Also thanks WW, you brought up a few points to help my case against codi out.