BigBallinStalin wrote:Phatscotty wrote:BigBallinStalin wrote:Phatscotty wrote:BigBallinStalin wrote:Phatscotty wrote:
Why am I the dictator who is calling the shots?
Is there really only one way to immigrate? no difference between legal/illegal, right/wrong, makes sense/doesn't make sense? Really? none at all? Because that's the way your questions keep laying it out as.
As in another gap; are you accusing me of denying the income of a person who is a 3 time convicted felon with gang tattoo all over their face? Or are you accusing me of denying the income a well mannered 16 year old virgin raised with a mother and a father with strong family values and a 4.0 GPA that had always dreamed of working at NASA and would like to inquire about furthering educational opportunities in America? Oh, so then it's about 'of course not the murderer, the 4.0 has a great shot tho' but then, back to my main point.....how do we know who is who?
And fourthly your questions tries to lame the blame on me for denying someone's income, as if it's not at all true that 10 million unskilled illegal immigrants with no social security number willing to work for less than minimum wage cash jobs has no impact on the 40 million unskilled Americans who are barely getting by on minimum wage because they actually fear the laws, like buying car insurance.
I aint denying foreigners anything, it's you who seems interested in misrepresenting what is in reality denied American citizens and keeping wages artificially low.
And in order for you to have a point in the first place, it would be a lot better if we actually helped people who needed it on a more consistent basis, like Christians in Iraq or homeschooling Christians from Germany, but we send them back. I don't buy that your compassion genuine when it's only given if the immigrant is more than 70% likely to vote Democrat.
The whole point of the question is to put a price on your position.
You see, let's say there's this guy, Bob. Bob likes the current immigration policy. So I ask Bob, "How much real income of the world are you willing to deny in order to maintain the current immigration policy?"
Let's say that Bob says that the current policy is fine unless EVERYONE in the world would have a 200% increase in their real income. So, if it was shown that if immigration restrictions were relaxed and that everyone in the world's income would increase by 200%, then Bob would have trouble defending the status quo.
That's the main point. You have to make tradeoffs, and if given the relevant information, you'd make a more informed decision in regard to current immigration policy.
People often refuse to answer the question because they don't want to KNOWN to deny people x-amount of foregone earnings. They'd rather dawdle about minor issues while consistently refraining from answering the question.
Main point: your stance on immigration restrictions affects millions of lives. Your opinion entails certain consequences for many people. Will you own up to the consequences? (No, which is why people don't like answering the question. They want a stance which is magically free of consequences).
Okay, I'll play along. Just one more thing in what I think is still a loaded question. The word 'deny' as in deny someone income..... I don't understand how an income can be someone's who has never had it before, not to mention who is not even currently a resident, and does not even have a social security number in order to work in the first place. My question, before I delve further, how can someone with no social security number be
denied something that requires them to have a social security number? And why would I be the one denying that income?
Is Player's beloved Obamacare 'denying' me a certain share of my take home income that used to go for the better kind of diapers that result in less rashes for my baby girl? Therefore the more often rashes my baby daughter gets are all Players fault?
I deal with the rest of your response separately
Basically, you're for immigration restrictions--even if the policy has negative consequences for poor people. Thanks for answering.
That wasn't my answer...nor was your response an answer to my question. Here we go again
Some restrictions, of course. I think we have the right to give the say on restrictions and not other countries, irrelevant to whether it's good or bad. Are you okay with the USA making it's own laws BBS? Cuz it sounds like you are saying our laws should be made by what's wrong with other countries. Seems counter to what I know you to believe, but have to check.
Primarily my concerns when it comes to restrictions are with our current open border policies for violent criminals and gang members, terrorists, and people with contagious diseases. Are those really 'restrictions that have negative consequences?' How in the world are those restrictions negative for poor people? How are those restrictions negative for the USA? Comment, please. I thought those were positive restrictions.....agree or disagree? Certainly you are able to differentiate between levels of restrictions, and not just lay 100% of any restriction under the sun in my lap like that. pfff
Never mind that you're unwilling to state a price that you find acceptable. With policy, there are costs, and no matter what you think, those costs will still exist. You can keep ignoring them as you please (or continue harping about a small portion of the costs a la criminals), but it isn't a convincing case. By denying people trade, you deprive them of opportunities. How many people you are willing to deny this opportunity is up to you.
If you can't understand that trade is mutually beneficial, then I really can't explain to you how opening up labor markets provides gains for both sides. If you're still digging in your heels, imagine that your State prevents 95% of people from entering. Does that sound like a prosperous policy?
re: underlined, If that's really your primary concern, then you'd support looser immigration restrictions. Those who have higher chances of legally entering the country are those who aren't criminals, diseased (?, how many Americans who are diseased should be kicked out?), or militants. If you open the legal window, then more decent folk enter while consequently the diseased criminals compose a larger percent of the illegals. There, we just increased the chances of capturing teh bad guise by supporting looser immigration restrictions. Do you agree with loosening immigration restrictions now?
With policies there are costs? And....without policies, there are still costs. So...???
All of my questions remain unanswered. You don't even attempt to address them. With full knowledge you will not address any of these questions, I simply cannot resist pointing out your flawed logic and your loaded questions.
I have nothing wrong with legal immigration. Obviously, this is about illegal immigration. Let's get the current crisis under control, then let's talk about loosening legal immigration. But that doesn't change your point that the needs of the rest of the world trump America's right to make our own laws. And because of the political aspect of the situation, we aren't going to be talking about anything or making any deals until we deal with the current problem. We've already been down that road of making deals and passing laws, only to have those deals fall through and those laws laughed at. Politicians can't be trusted or counted on to get serious about the crisis. I think this one is gonna be handled personally by the people.
I'm not unwilling to state a price at all. The simple fact of the matter is, I asked you to state a price long ago in this thread, and as usual, you don't like the answer you'd have to give if you were being honest, so you do not give one. I asked you to to state whether restricting murderers and rapists and violent criminals and gang members and those with contagious diseases was a good restriction or bad, and you can't even handle that. And then you think you're gonna badger me about not stating a cost?? Go back and look it up, I asked you to tell us the cost of all the American's who have been murdered by illegal immigrants in that video which documented some of the crime's committed by illegals in 2013. Then tell me the cost of all the DWI's and all the property damaged caused by the illegals who don't give a damn about our laws or our people or our way of life. Then tell me the cost of all the men and women, and children who have been raped, kidnapped, sold into prostitution, and enslaved. Why don't you start with the cost of the 14 year old girl in Texas that was raped by 2 illegal aliens on the 4th of July last month.
I don't ignore the costs at all, you are just barking up the wrong tree. I could come right back at you with your own flawed logic, and I could ask 'Do you understand there are costs for us to have a court system? Since you ignore those costs, we should not have a court system?" As I've said time and time again, there are fundamental basic legitimate functions of our government, and while it doesn't excuse waste and overcharging taxpayers to load their crony buddy's pockets which in turn get filtered back to them, there is a point when it comes to courts and police and defense and protecting our borders where those costs are justified. Without those basic fundamental primary duties, we do not have a country, we do not have a government, we are unable to enforce our laws.
If you cannot understand that there is a legitimate reason to not take a child with a contagious diseases, then put them in the same classroom as your child, if you cannot understand there is a legitimate reason not to let violent criminals in or that we should at least try to protect our people and laws and way of life, then let that violent criminal move into your basement. If you cannot understand there is a legitimate reason to do what we can to turn away gang members, then let them move into the drug trade on your street corner.
You try to reflect my concerns back on me with a ridiculous point that sick Americans should be kicked out of the USA? HA! 0/10. Let's again take your pretend logic and go with violent criminals, not violent as you and I know them from the TV or first hand experience, but violent as in born and raised in the 3rd world all they know is violence....so let's apply your method. 'Why should we lock Americans up for murder? You just want to deny them income and opportunity by locking them up! Can't you understand this will build up the economy?' Hey, just like you said, the % of people locked up for murder and rape is a statistically small %, and 95% of people will still not rape and murder, so just get rid of the laws against rape and murder, and we will all benefit!
It sounds to me like you are making the barbarian argument, that is if America does not do what the rest of the hemisphere wants us to do, then more murderers and rapists and thugs are going to pour across out border. Perhaps loosening our legal policies will stem the tide of these kinds of illegals. Just curious why you think all of a sudden our laws will be respected with such a long history of treating our laws like a joke and wiping their asses with what Americans think?