[Abandoned] - Dark Age Britain
Moderator: Cartographers
Forum rules
Please read the Community Guidelines before posting.
Please read the Community Guidelines before posting.
- gimil
- Posts: 8599
- Joined: Sat Mar 03, 2007 12:42 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: United Kingdom (Scotland)
Re: Dark Age Britian. Small V10 (pg 15), large V5 (pg 15)
Definetly the old 
What do you know about map making, bitch?
Top Score:2403natty_dread wrote:I was wrong
Re: Dark Age Britian. Small V10 (pg 15), large V5 (pg 15)
Do you mean old version, older looking version, or something else by that comment?gimil wrote:Definetly the old
Reposted for new page with poll!
No glow and normal text:

Slight glow with normal text:

No glow and reduced text:

- Balsiefen
- Posts: 2299
- Joined: Wed Aug 30, 2006 6:15 am
- Gender: Male
- Location: The Ford of the Aldar in the East of the Kingdom of Lindissi
- Contact:
Re: Dark Age Britian. New Poll (explained 1st post + 11th page)
Slight glow definatly there, Reduced text doesn't really work.
-
Ogrecrusher
- Posts: 250
- Joined: Thu Aug 16, 2007 2:55 pm
Re: Dark Age Britian. New Poll (explained 1st post + 11th page)
I think you should detatch the Isle Of Wight and Anglesey from the mainland. (Not as a new territory, just graphically).
Re: Dark Age Britian. New Poll (explained 1st post + 11th page)
finish this already 
[img]http://img801.imageshack.us/img801/9761/41922610151374166770386.jpg[/mg]
Re: Dark Age Britian. New Poll (explained 1st post + 11th page)
I dislike the Glow around the text in the "Castle Connections" box...
C.
C.

Highest score : 2297
Re: Dark Age Britian. New Poll (explained 1st post + 11th page)
Ok, i have 2 weeks of holiday at the moment, i will need to do revision for exams, but i cant do that all day so i need something to distract me, and DAB looks like a good cause. So could you bring all the graphic concerns to the table during this 2 weeks and by the end of it i will try to have a nearly finished version of the large and small map. Though i need to wait on Balsiefen return to get the XML started.
I can try, but im not sure how successful it will be though.Ogrecrusher wrote:I think you should detatch the Isle Of Wight and Anglesey from the mainland. (Not as a new territory, just graphically).
I am trying to finish it, but it takes time, the major hold up is the XML.hulmey wrote:finish this already
That will be changed to fit in with the other fonts/golws on the map when the final style is decided on.yeti_c wrote:I dislike the Glow around the text in the "Castle Connections" box...
C.
Re: Dark Age Britian. New Poll (explained 1st post + 11th page)
i dont know why, but i dislike the blue text without the slight glow, with the slight glow it looks ok/good.
^in my opinion
^in my opinion
Re: Dark Age Britian. New Poll (explained 1st post + 11th page)
the font is my only issue with the map. I voted for the slight glow btw
Is it possible to increase the size of the text by one point or two? That might help a lot.
On the map the territory seems to say Brega. On the castle connections legend it looks like Broga. I suppose the e just looks like an o when the font is that small. Maybe there's a different font that could be used that still fits the style but is more readable?
Is it possible to increase the size of the text by one point or two? That might help a lot.
On the map the territory seems to say Brega. On the castle connections legend it looks like Broga. I suppose the e just looks like an o when the font is that small. Maybe there's a different font that could be used that still fits the style but is more readable?
Re: Dark Age Britian. New Poll (explained 1st post + 11th page)
Graphics wise 'ey ...
The most obvious thing is that the graphics of the castle floor plans/insets do not come close to meeting the standard of the rest of the map ... they still seem in thier rudimentary form of development ...
- they look very "boxy" and pixelated,
colours are too bright ... or else they need to be smothed over a bit, hehe, given a bit of a smudge to lose thier hard edge, but really, maybe they just need to be tied into the map alittle more (i.e., they look a little out thier place)
- can't read the name of the town where london is now ... infact, most of the names (and the glows certainly don't make it easier ... it's a beautiful font, but for these purposes it seems like it needs to be spaced out a bit (i.e. between letters), or something like that).
But a beautiful map in general.
The most obvious thing is that the graphics of the castle floor plans/insets do not come close to meeting the standard of the rest of the map ... they still seem in thier rudimentary form of development ...
- they look very "boxy" and pixelated,
colours are too bright ... or else they need to be smothed over a bit, hehe, given a bit of a smudge to lose thier hard edge, but really, maybe they just need to be tied into the map alittle more (i.e., they look a little out thier place)
- can't read the name of the town where london is now ... infact, most of the names (and the glows certainly don't make it easier ... it's a beautiful font, but for these purposes it seems like it needs to be spaced out a bit (i.e. between letters), or something like that).
But a beautiful map in general.
Re: Dark Age Britian. New Poll (explained 1st post + 11th page)
I think the text is too intense, more obvious in the blue, i might try using a greyer type font.t-o-m wrote:i dont know why, but i dislike the blue text without the slight glow, with the slight glow it looks ok/good.
^in my opinion
It is possible, but i dont know if it will fit the territories as easily.edbeard wrote:Is it possible to increase the size of the text by one point or two? That might help a lot.
The castle connection box was added in a hurry, i really need to redo some of it.edbeard wrote:On the map the territory seems to say Brega. On the castle connections legend it looks like Broga. I suppose the e just looks like an o when the font is that small. Maybe there's a different font that could be used that still fits the style but is more readable?
The colours only became too bright recently, but i can tone it down. As for the borders, they need to be crisp, so that you can see that every room cant attack every other room in the castle. THe boxes used to have a drop shadow, which made them fit better, i dont know where it has gone, i will have to check on that.asl80 wrote:The most obvious thing is that the graphics of the castle floor plans/insets do not come close to meeting the standard of the rest of the map ... they still seem in thier rudimentary form of development ...
- they look very "boxy" and pixelated,
colours are too bright ... or else they need to be smothed over a bit, hehe, given a bit of a smudge to lose thier hard edge, but really, maybe they just need to be tied into the map alittle more (i.e., they look a little out thier place)
It seems that the font could do with a change, i will have a look around and see what i can find to fill the need of the font...asl80 wrote:- can't read the name of the town where london is now ... infact, most of the names (and the glows certainly don't make it easier ... it's a beautiful font, but for these purposes it seems like it needs to be spaced out a bit (i.e. between letters), or something like that).
Re: Dark Age Britian. New Poll (explained 1st post + 11th page)
yes!Telvannia wrote:I think the text is too intense, more obvious in the blue, i might try using a greyer type font.t-o-m wrote:i dont know why, but i dislike the blue text without the slight glow, with the slight glow it looks ok/good.
^in my opinion
- sam_levi_11
- Posts: 2872
- Joined: Mon Dec 11, 2006 2:48 pm
- Gender: Male
Re: Dark Age Britian. New Poll (explained 1st post + 11th page)
i said seoncd one, buyt can someone explain the castles to me
- lighteningbrain
- Posts: 14
- Joined: Mon Mar 17, 2008 3:12 pm
Re: Dark Age Britian. New Poll (explained 1st post + 11th page)
I think the territory names need to be made bigger or a clearer font, but I like the glow.
Also, if you made the caslte plan borders a bit thicker then I think that would be clearer and you could also get away with sftening the edges a bit.
Great map btw, I like the way it's coming along
Also, if you made the caslte plan borders a bit thicker then I think that would be clearer and you could also get away with sftening the edges a bit.
Great map btw, I like the way it's coming along
Re: Dark Age Britian. New Poll (explained 1st post + 11th page)
Glad to see this is alive and kicking again!
I'm still unhappy with the castle plans - they don't work with the rest of the image, with the right angles and crisp lines. An old diagram of a castle wouldn't have different colors and crisp angles. And I'd like to see the territory names on/closer to the appropriate territories in the castle diagrams.
Army circles, or no?
I'd agree on both points - glow is a must, text could be a bit bigger since you're losing parts of the letters (look at the "t" in Gate). The text on the water could stand out a bit more as well.lighteningbrain wrote:I think the territory names need to be made bigger or a clearer font, but I like the glow.
Also, if you made the caslte plan borders a bit thicker then I think that would be clearer and you could also get away with sftening the edges a bit.
I'm still unhappy with the castle plans - they don't work with the rest of the image, with the right angles and crisp lines. An old diagram of a castle wouldn't have different colors and crisp angles. And I'd like to see the territory names on/closer to the appropriate territories in the castle diagrams.
Army circles, or no?

- AndyDufresne
- Posts: 24919
- Joined: Fri Mar 03, 2006 8:22 pm
- Location: A Banana Palm in Zihuatanejo
- Contact:
Re: Dark Age Britian. New Poll (explained 1st post + 11th page)
I agree with Oaktown on the crisp angles and lines...it is something I think (or at least I thought) I mentioned early on in this thread...those seem out of place with the general rough feeling of the map.
--Andy
--Andy
Re: Dark Age Britian. New Poll (explained 1st post + 11th page)
hmm, i see what you mean oak! It would be better, if the lines werent so crisp!
[img]http://img801.imageshack.us/img801/9761/41922610151374166770386.jpg[/mg]
Re: Dark Age Britian. New Poll (explained 1st post + 11th page)
A couple of different text styles, each continent has their own, so which continent has the best text style?

Im putting a poll up now about it.

Im putting a poll up now about it.
Re: Dark Age Britian. Even Newer Poll (1st post + 12th page)
wessex is the best I'd say
north umbria is second
wales third
I don't get the vote for Mercia. That one doesn't seem that readable to me.
north umbria is second
wales third
I don't get the vote for Mercia. That one doesn't seem that readable to me.
Re: Dark Age Britian. Even Newer Poll (1st post + 12th page)
I went for Northumbria... But wessex is also good... I really like the Pictland one theme wise - but it's just not legible.edbeard wrote:wessex is the best I'd say
north umbria is second
wales third
I don't get the vote for Mercia. That one doesn't seem that readable to me.
C.

Highest score : 2297
Re: Dark Age Britian. Even Newer Poll (1st post + 12th page)
EDIT: I see that a lot of text has been removed to show the beta fonts.
As for fonts, I think the Strathclyde and Pictland fonts are way too hard to read, but the rest of them are great.
As for fonts, I think the Strathclyde and Pictland fonts are way too hard to read, but the rest of them are great.
Re: Dark Age Britian. Even Newer Poll (1st post + 12th page)
With only 10 votes in the poll. im going to have to post a interest poll. Because i really dont want to be spending time try to work on a map going nowhere, i might as well try to fix the titanic with selotape.
I will need a word with Balsiefen whatever the result of the poll, he might yet want to try and save this...
I will need a word with Balsiefen whatever the result of the poll, he might yet want to try and save this...
- gimil
- Posts: 8599
- Joined: Sat Mar 03, 2007 12:42 pm
- Gender: Male
- Location: United Kingdom (Scotland)
Re: Dark Age Britian. Even Newer Poll (1st post + 12th page)
Mate just go with wessex 
What do you know about map making, bitch?
Top Score:2403natty_dread wrote:I was wrong
Re: Dark Age Britian. Interest Poll
It is not a matter of which text to use, (i was going to use wessex), it is more a matter of whether people are actually interested in this map, and whether it is worth continuing...
Re: Dark Age Britian. Interest Poll
yes continue it, i really like this map!! Half the maps made in the foundry have not had interest in them!!
[img]http://img801.imageshack.us/img801/9761/41922610151374166770386.jpg[/mg]