Conquer Club Bracket Tourny - Version 18 [abandoned]

[Coleman]

cairnswk: I think if you have either R or L you'll probably want to take the other much more then you'd want to take T or B. I might be removing T & B all together, a lot is still up in the air.

Edit: Actually, someone could attack the territories that border T and B from R or L, so the connection isn't that far off, but I still don't forsee people taking R or L and then ignoring the other half of the Final.

I GOT SERVED: Conquest always supercedes victory conditions. I know that victory conditions are new and not very widely used so I maybe should explain this on the map.

Conquer Final or All Other Players to Win?

[I GOT SERVED]

I GOT SERVED: Conquest always supercedes victory conditions. I know that victory conditions are new and not very widely used so I maybe should explain this on the map.

Conquer Final or All Other Players to Win?

Thanks for the clarification. Since this is thr first map I've seen a different win condition, I think some sort of explanation might be neccesary. Or maybe it's because I'm just stoopid.

[Coleman]

If you look at Age of Might it has a win condition as well, but DiM adds you can just eliminate everyone in text on the map. So I probably should too.

[WidowMakers]

-I really don't like the T or B.
-Plus I don't like the "Any box can attack prior box idea"

It is becoming less and less like a bracket with these changes.

If anything (to keep the flow going) make the R be able to attack every #1 (one way border) and the L be able to attack every #8 (one way border).

I know I said it is becoming less like a bracket but just a suggestion anyway.

WM

[spinwizard]

Now i know what a bracket tourny is, thanks m8

[cena-rules]

No offence to coleman and his mapmaking skills but to be honest I cannot stand this map right now. However I will probably grow to like it so continue

[bspride]

Coleman like what u did to my idea. T and B is gay takes away from a real "bracket". Enjoy idea about conquering final to win game but definetly think that if their is anyway to set it up to kill the other person, then it should be done, else it really isn't "Conquer" club. Awesome work man, awesome work

[Aerial Attack]

Excellent update.

My thoughts:

1) To do proper seeding for the tournament you would need to change several things (almost all of the labels). I've shown one half of the bracket (no graphics skills):

Code: Select all

Entry   Advancer     Quarters       Semis          Final
E1             
E8          A1
                           Q1
E5          A4
E4             
                                        SB<lue>                                         
E3
E6          A3
                           Q2
E7          A2
E2


E1             
E8          A1
                            Q1
E5          A4
E4             
                                        SG<reen>                                         
E3
E6          A3
                            Q2
E7          A2
E2



1) Once you add in connectors like T & B, it obfuscates true paths. Not horrible if you don't have the ability to attack backwards more than one level. Similarly it does the same if you put a connecting ring in the middle.

1a) You do unfortunately need a way to get to the other side without hitting the conquer condition. I don't think you should be able to make it to the other side without at least conquering SOME neutrals. Perhaps Q1s can attack Q1s and Q2s can attack Q2s. Maybe add a symbol/icon for this?

2) The text for backwards attacks should be something like "Boxes can attack back on any box in their advancement path." This is a bit wordy, but it explains somewhat better.

3) Take away T & B. Move your sig to where T was (maybe just a wee bit smaller?). Move the explanatory text to where B was and have it include the thing for Q1 to Q1 attacks.

[newline]

I like the map, but...
I don't like the "Control Final" to win idea. It takes away the stratagry and fighting against each other. I should be just a "Free for All" rather then a "Race to the Finish"

[Unit_2]

cole, the background is a little to light for the light colors you are useing, can you change/make a background?

[Coleman]

Wow, lots to get back to, I've been busy.

Let's get started.

-I really don't like the T or B.
-Plus I don't like the "Any box can attack prior box idea"

It is becoming less and less like a bracket with these changes.

I'll probably get rid of T & B.

The any box can attack any prior box idea doesn't break the bracket theme in my opinion though. If you have Blue 13 for example, it implies you have dominion over all the rounds it took to get there, which would be Blue 1, 2, 3, 4, 9 & 10.

If anything (to keep the flow going) make the R be able to attack every #1 (one way border) and the L be able to attack every #8 (one way border).

I'll consider that. That would be really late in the game though.

Coleman like what u did to my idea. T and B is gay takes away from a real "bracket". Enjoy idea about conquering final to win game but definetly think that if their is anyway to set it up to kill the other person, then it should be done, else it really isn't "Conquer" club. Awesome work man, awesome work

Thanks much, it will be hard to get a standard bracket through, so I've had to improvise, I don't like T & B either. I've decided they'll be gone when I update again.

1) To do proper seeding for the tournament you would need to change several things (almost all of the labels). I've shown one half of the bracket (no graphics skills):

I like all you did there, except with the E# part. I'd need 32, because there are 32 entrants right? But E32 would be hard to do because of the name length on the small map with the way I have the small map set up right now. I'll try it though.

1) Once you add in connectors like T & B, it obfuscates true paths. Not horrible if you don't have the ability to attack backwards more than one level. Similarly it does the same if you put a connecting ring in the middle.

I agree, both those ideas are scrapped, I have some others that spawned from the ones presented.

1a) You do unfortunately need a way to get to the other side without hitting the conquer condition. I don't think you should be able to make it to the other side without at least conquering SOME neutrals. Perhaps Q1s can attack Q1s and Q2s can attack Q2s. Maybe add a symbol/icon for this?

I like the icon and symbol part, but I'll definitely make people get to at least Quarter 3 before they can jump.

2) The text for backwards attacks should be something like "Boxes can attack back on any box in their advancement path." This is a bit wordy, but it explains somewhat better.

How about, Boxes can attack backwards to all connected Prior Boxes?

3) Take away T & B. Move your sig to where T was (maybe just a wee bit smaller?). Move the explanatory text to where B was and have it include the thing for Q1 to Q1 attacks.

Take away T&B is done, not sure if I like my signature being at the top though, I might make it smaller and keep it in the corner.

I don't like the "Control Final" to win idea. It takes away the stratagry and fighting against each other. I should be just a "Free for All" rather then a "Race to the Finish"

I'll be adding text to clarify that you can win without conquering the finish and some connections to make that possible. But I will not be removing the other potential objective.

cole, the background is a little to light for the light colors you are useing, can you change/make a background?

Maybe if more complaints show up about the white. I could try a large watermark if I could find something good that isn't copyrighted, but drawing up something myself isn't a skill I have. It would be fugly.

Thanks for everything. My current plan:

• Destroy T & B.
• Rename most of the map as AA suggested.
• Add a way for some of the Round 3's (Quarters) to attack each other with some sort of warp system or written rule.
• Add text to clarify you can still win by conquering all the other players.
• Reword prior boxes text.
• Shrink my signature.

I might also shrink all the bonuses text, decrease the spacing, and move the prior boxes text over there.

[Aerial Attack]

1) To do proper seeding for the tournament you would need to change several things (almost all of the labels). I've shown one half of the bracket (no graphics skills):

I like all you did there, except with the E# part. I'd need 32, because there are 32 entrants right? But E32 would be hard to do because of the name length on the small map with the way I have the small map set up right now. I'll try it though.

Thanks for everything. My current plan:

• Destroy T & B.
• Rename most of the map as AA suggested.
• Add a way for some of the Round 3's (Quarters) to attack each other with some sort of warp system or written rule.
• Add text to clarify you can still win by conquering all the other players.
• Reword prior boxes text.
• Shrink my signature.

I might also shrink all the bonuses text, decrease the spacing, and move the prior boxes text over there.

Coleman, sorry I wasn't clear before - That was only the left half of the draw. I purposely reused E1 through E8 (notice the same for A1 through A4). This way all names are two chars plus a background color. So, you would have Blue E1, Blue E2, ... Blue E8; Green E1, Green E2, ... Red E8 [on the other side].

[Coleman]

Okay, that makes sense. If it were a real tournament you could be "Entrant 3 in the Blue Division" for instance.

Sounds good to me. I'll try it out that way and see if people hate it or not.

I wouldn't expect the next version tonight. I have a party to go to and a tournament that needs badly to be updated. Plus this update may take some time since I'll be changing most of the text on the map.

[mibi]

Okay, that makes sense. If it were a real tournament you could be "Entrant 3 in the Blue Division" for instance.

Sounds good to me. I'll try it out that way and see if people hate it or not.

I wouldn't expect the next version tonight. I have a party to go to and a tournament that needs badly to be updated. Plus this update may take some time since I'll be changing most of the text on the map.

Party on coleman.

[cazmart]

I know you are familiar with bracket names...
1st round,Sweet 16, elite 8 and final 4...

Anyway if you were to rename your tabs this way and maybe make the elite 8 column have a unique shading and state elite 8's can attack other elite 8's it might make the use of conecting lines obsolete for those attacks. Anyway I am a big fan of the map and keep up the work.


Question on another subject: Still working on my C-City Map - I am slow because I am learning gimp on the fly. anyway do you use Gimp or are you using a different program. I am making progress but there are things I can not figure out like once I insert an image how can I put a border on it. Also I maybe screwing the pooch...I may have started with to large of a map...do not know if I was to just scale if that would work....thanks for the help..

Can email you the rough copy if you want just pm me

[Coleman]

Version 5

Changes:

• Got rid of T & B.
• Renamed most of the map as AA suggested.
• Introduced a glow effect to some quarters so they can attack each other.
• Added text to clarify you can still win by conquering all the other players.
• Reworded prior boxes text.
• Made my signature smaller.
• Other minor things

I don't like the spacing at the top with the names changed... I'll probably work on that next.

[cairnswk]

5 updates....good discussion and support....Good work Coleman....but i would ask if you could save some room on the map and bring it down to 800 px wide....i think there is plenty of savable room in it without damaging the overall appearance. Would you mind please?

[I GOT SERVED]

If you're adding the glow, you should make it more prominent. I can see it, but just barely.

And I've gots one question. I'm still confused by the prior wording boxes. Does this mean that Q1 can attack E1? Or can it only attack A1/A4?

[Coleman]

It means Q1 can attack E1. I'll need to word it better still.

I'll see about boosting the glow, could you recommend something more specific. Should it be another color perhaps? I was trying to pick the star trek color.

[Coleman]

Version 6

I made it smaller. 800x740 now.

[cairnswk]

Thanks for that downsize Coleman. I believe this qualifies to be...

Moved to the Foundry now...

[GreecePwns]

So wait. You can conquer the final 2 spaces to win? Just making sure, because that would be awesome!

[gimil]

i thought of an idea for connecting the two sides for assain and terminator. Have a winners box, and a second place box, teh second place box can connect both t sides throught te middle.

[Coleman]

So wait. You can conquer the final 2 spaces to win? Just making sure, because that would be awesome!

Yes.

[Telvannia]

hate to tell you this, you moved the text up saying 'glowing boxes...' and left some of the glow behind:
the tip of the last r
and most of the bottom area