Black Metal Mafia - D3

[Loose Canon]

So just to be clear max, given the following a,b,c options regarding you personally

A. I am not a detective
B. I am a detective
C. I am not saying whether I'm a detective or not

You would currently choose C???

Even though evidence of a detective or not, would evidence a recruit or not, and if not which players would more likely opt for no recruit.

Also max, given your FOS on me and Charle, does this signify you would NOT be on board with a lynching of Ew or sonic, if neither are lynched today???

lynching of Ew or sonic tomorrow, if neither are lynched today???

Max, you haven't answered the above 2 questions.
It's not impossible that votes might start landing on you.
I don't have confidence you would do the right things for town D4.
If votes were to start landing on you, I'd hang a sword above your head and threaten a vote on you.
You could be zealously guarding a detective role so I'd be hesitant about swinging it. But then again I might. Best you answer the 2 above questions now I think.
(Whether or not any detective should claim now is an open question, any detective surviving into d4 should for sure claim then)

[Charle]

Guys, if Max was cop, he would have investigated me on N1 already as he was on my case since then. He would have seen I am not guilty and stopped wasting votes on me. The fact that he cannot see that I am town and constantly voting me (hoping to get a confirmed townie lynched so that they can focus on finding jailkeeper), makes him No. 1 suspect in my books.

Unless Max comes up with good reasoning for his actions, he reads the most scum of all at the moment.

[SoN!c]

Kong asked me a valid a question re Ew.

I had microsuspicions of ew to end of d2 and I believe you will find I may not have called them out loud and clear, but I did post regarding them.
To balance these microsuspicions Ew has been asking valid questions - what if I'm wrong, am I still suspicious of him. Of course Ew is a clever player so my microsuspicions and his asking the right questions of me probably each amount to very little.
You are right that the no recruit theory forms the main basis of my suspicion on Ew.
But there is also Sonic's distraction strategy that makes me think he's distracting for a reason, and he started this once I went for Ew d3 and not sonic.

Kong you also ask why not Traf.
I think you will find beginning of d3 I had suspicion of Traf too, it's just sonic has gone so 1 dimensionally on loose is scum that I can't work out what sonic is up to if he's town. Ew made what I think was that argument on sonic too.

Don't be silly Loose. You sound like an exact copy from the Charle game. Pretty funny you mentioned that. Everytime you were 3P serial killer you could (looking back) notice the difference. So nobody is gonna vote you. Unless you start wild loose chases

First of all I looked exactly like I looked in Charles game when I was town mason, now I'm obvious scum. Ok a town sonic can change his mind - just pointing that out for starters sonic.

Thing is maybe at the point you posted the above , scum sonic thought I might be detective so worth backing off D2.
But then d3 I kick off with the no recruit theory and scum sonic figures I'm not, so that removes his reticence to go hard at me.

These comments are sheer humbug. At least you make me laugh.

If you take the time to read this thoroughly and think it thru it's again more of the same "it's Sonic +...".

Ive been at you since halfway D1 Loose. And pretty hard on D2 aswell. I never tought you were the cop like you suggest. You claimed to be vanilla super fast.

And Think about it: i (as scum) think your the cop since D1 (like you say here) but you are still alive? Man, do i suck that hard as scum that you think that? Scum would not kill the cop first?
----

I liked your search activity D1, you were taking point and doing good untill it got bizarre and a pattern started to develop. Too many faults (voting Charle, placing big FoS on Pixar when everybody was thinking they are "lock town"). And just going at whoever dares to question you or Max. Like you did with Pixar and Strike before. So yes one needs to wonder: is Max your scumpartner or do you just wanna trick him on your side. As town there is no way you can be sure Max is not scum but you have him "lock town without even one question" and while Charle has valid arguments..you just ignored them all game long.

Only today the first glimpse of any critical view of you towards Max emerges. "Hey Max do this because if you do not do what i say i might start to think voting you"

(I'd hang a sword above your head and threaten a vote on you.)

Also You never once went along with Kong and his concerns about Traf. A town Loose would be in full support of Kong going after Traf, just to check it out and be sure, but you are only worried about self-defence. Only OMGUS in this game. And you cannot explain why, you cannot explain your reasoning behind your "100% sure cases" because you cannot admit it's just self defense OMGUS. So you fabricate stupid reasoning (aka smoke) like you did today on EW (the no recruit theory) or like you did on Strike (the "well elabore post" with 16 minutes time gap versus "the call-out post")...

So that is why i think you are scum Loose. Not dumb town moves but smart scum moves. Like not joining the bandwagon on JFM but voting Max seconds before deadline. Put yourself into my shoes and reread the thread. You will come to the same conclusion if your honest.

[Loose Canon]

Charle, I can't fault your logic for max not being any town detective.

However I think max should answer the 2 questions I asked of him.

And Charle I asked you some time back for insight as to Max's mo as scum. You have voted for max. Care to give your insights?

[Charle]

Charle, I can't fault your logic for max not being any town detective.

However I think max should answer the 2 questions I asked of him.

And Charle I asked you some time back for insight as to Max's mo as scum. You have voted for max. Care to give your insights?

Max as scum was pretty much the same way he plays as town as well, not very active. I had to prod him myself a few times just to post something.

[Loose Canon]

When masons together with me he was more engaged.
I went down the alternative wrong hypothesis route, he got the feel that with what he was saying and me going down that route too it was probably correct.
There was what goes for debate between us.
I changed back to the correct hypothesis.
Max stuck on the alternative hypothesis.