by Votanic on Fri Jan 26, 2024 12:41 pm
Addressing the Issues of the last 20+ Posts
1. Yes, do I agree. swang is not Confirmed as Town. His actions and reasoning read Town to me, but that could be famous last words.
In fact, I think Devante should Investigate Swang next...
2. Also, since nobody else has counter-claimed Cupid, Sonic is very likely Town.
3. Don't follow the reasoning that Pixar is Confirmed Town. DDS had to pick somebody to be Sheriff, but that doesn't mean he had Intel on Pixar's alignment.
4. Thor's minimal posting has become a problem, but it might not be a mod-kill job. We may have to demand a claim or lynch...
If he turns Wolf, his skulking might be decent strategy.
...and if he turns Town, all we can do is shake our head and once again wonder why people join a team game like Mafia and then play so selfishly.
5. Concerning Charle: even before he claimed as Scandalmonger, I doubted Charle was a Wolf.
My reasoning was the nature of the White Wolf role. To win, LC had to eliminate the Wolves and Town (talk about an unwinnable role!) so he had to pick off Town at a faster rate than the wolves so one side wouldn't be able to win. He was totally immune to the wolves (unless Swang is a wolf...) and so he could just kill a wolf on his wolf-kill nights. Btw, the fact that the White Wolf was also the almost unkillable Barkeep is too much of a coincidence. I strongly suspect the public roles were specifically linked to particular private roles by Traf to insure game balance, though I do still think those role pairings were randomly given out.
6.Yes, mass claims have risk, we should not go into that blindly and it should be planned, even choreographed, as much as possible.
Some FPing, but nothing that needs to be addressed.
