Batman Mafia~~~GOTHAM WINS!!!!!!!!

[gethine]

I was merely going on what the mod had written. He had said that Chad22342, Avron, Kernal_Kronic, Skittles!, and Skoffin would be prodded so I was merely stating that these people had been inactive and that if it came down to where there wasn't much to go on for a vote (on day 1 there normally isn't) then we might want to vote someone who hadn't said anything in the forum.

I am sorry if it came across like i was pushing for a premature vote.

P.S what is an OMGUS vote?

FOS CMCKINNEY - out of everyone you seem to be pushing for a vote more than anyone else.

[Kernal_Kronic]

I was merely going on what the mod had written. He had said that Chad22342, Avron, Kernal_Kronic, Skittles!, and Skoffin would be prodded so I was merely stating that these people had been inactive and that if it came down to where there wasn't much to go on for a vote (on day 1 there normally isn't) then we might want to vote someone who hadn't said anything in the forum.

I am sorry if it came across like i was pushing for a premature vote.

P.S what is an OMGUS vote?

FOS CMCKINNEY - out of everyone you seem to be pushing for a vote more than anyone else.

Ahh, yes...I knew i saw something that didn't seem kosher.

I'm leaving for the day, which means during the night (the next +/- 13 hours) i won't be able to post but i should be back before the vote deadline. So i'll have a look at what gets posted before i cast my final vote

[derfderf34]

I was merely going on what the mod had written. He had said that Chad22342, Avron, Kernal_Kronic, Skittles!, and Skoffin would be prodded so I was merely stating that these people had been inactive and that if it came down to where there wasn't much to go on for a vote (on day 1 there normally isn't) then we might want to vote someone who hadn't said anything in the forum.

I am sorry if it came across like i was pushing for a premature vote.

P.S what is an OMGUS vote?

FOS CMCKINNEY - out of everyone you seem to be pushing for a vote more than anyone else.

we need votes!

[gethine]

and now you are pushing this along :S
there isn't anything at all to go on really, is there?

[kwanton]

Lol Jnd did it again...

Anyway I'm all for Kernal's idea of having the 3 scummiest people defend themselves. Should be fun to watch

And I've said before I was gonna keep an eye on cmk. So until he shows up to defend hisself Vote:cmckinney

[Anarkistsdream]

Sorry everyone for being gone all weekend...

I will read through this and reply at some point today...

[Anarkistsdream]

It seems to me that you are all voting CMC for two reasons... Because you think he was being too defensive and because you are bandwagonning to get a lynch...

However, to me, MountainLion has come across as very quiet, helpful in that 'Wicked' sort of way... And basically just staying active enough to keep on the radar without showing his hand...

Unvote
Vote: MountainLion

[nagerous]

well you are around now Kernal and contributing so I will unvote

In regards to AD's observations on mountainlion its quite late in day 1 to start anything but its good to raise those observations.

It looks like a choice between kinney and no lynch at the moment. He hasn't responded yet so I will raise my Fos to a vote cmkiney

[MountainLion]

I'm being compared to wicked? I don't know if that's a good or bad thing

[spinwizard]

I'm being compared to wicked? I don't know if that's a good or bad thing

Its a very BAD thing

[MountainLion]

We could use a vote count and cmckinney should probably defend himself.

[pancakemix]

I'm being compared to wicked? I don't know if that's a good or bad thing

Its a very BAD thing

Not as bad as being compared to Mandy.

[kalishnikov]

Thats a fine idea kwanton, but who other then cmckinney really looks scummy at the moment? We are passed the point where he should have defended himself and gave us a reason as to why we should go another direction, and he has not.

If we're gonna have any hope of a lynch today, it's going to have to be cmckinney, less then 24 hours left and 14 to lynch...

There are plenty of players and I'd bet on multiple mafias, so even if we're wrong, it's not that big of a deal but we do need a lynch today or we'll get no info at all on day 1. Vote:cmckinney

Plus, from what I gathered from the first page, I'm also willing to bet on the fact that there's going to be quite a few independents and maybe even a cult, so I say lets go for it. We've got just as good a shot getting someone who's anti-gotham (scum, indie, cult, etc.) as a townie...

[cmckinney]

well, here i am to defend myself against.... whatever.

The only thing people have seriously voted me for is that...

A. I am being to defensive. Well, when you got quite a few votes from people who vote you, then give absolutely no reason and never bother to explain.

B. CAN U SAY BANDWAGON? About 3 or 4 votes i've been voted for are that people have just decided to hop on. U guys have been searching for scum, and now a textbook scum strategy comes up and your to busy attempting to lynch a guy that is to "defensive"

BTW, if it comes to it, I WILL ROLECLAIM.

[cmckinney]

We could use a vote count and cmckinney should probably defend himself.

And of course it's just my luck that the day that nobody is talking is the day i'm on hte computer all day. But the second I get off, everybody goes into hyper-lynch mode.

U GUYS DO NOT WANT TO BE KILLING ME!

[Anarkistsdream]

We could use a vote count and cmckinney should probably defend himself.

And of course it's just my luck that the day that nobody is talking is the day i'm on hte computer all day. But the second I get off, everybody goes into hyper-lynch mode.

U GUYS DO NOT WANT TO BE KILLING ME!

As opposed to repeating the comments I already wrote, how about you tell us who looks the most like mafia?

[cmckinney]

They had asked that I defend myself so i did.

AD, you are asking me who I think is mafia?

[MountainLion]

Even though cmckinney might appear somewhat scummy (hard to tell), I tend to believe him. Maybe we should vote on a player who's submarining.

Willis was the third player to post in this game and has never posted since then...his one and only post was the following:

Vote fircoal for being a 'chu

I don't think we've heard much from these three either: Alexwales93, XenCobra, n8freeman

Unvote

Vote willis

[Anarkistsdream]

They had asked that I defend myself so i did.

AD, you are asking me who I think is mafia?

Exactly my question, good sir.

[Koesen]

AlesWales has gone quiet in the Fishing Trip mafia game he is modding as well (allowing a ceryain mafia member to continue to cause confusion with his ludicrous stories), so I am inclined to think there's some sort of real life reason.

n8freeman was very quiet in other games due to comouter problems, but I believe he said those were solved.

XenCobra, I have no idea about.

Anarkistsdream wrote:

how about you tell us who looks the most like mafia?

to which cmckinney replied:

AD, you are asking me who I think is mafia?

This, in addition to the things already mentioned by other people, looks like an unconvincing attempt to evade the discussion. Seriously, what's not to understand about AD's question?

It's not exactly rock hard evidence, but since it's day one and we're not likely to get much more:

unvote
Vote cmckinney

[Koesen]

That should be 'certain' and 'computer'.

[MountainLion]

Who's played with cmckinney before? How does he look to you guys?

[cmckinney]

Anarkistsdream wrote:

how about you tell us who looks the most like mafia?

to which cmckinney replied:

AD, you are asking me who I think is mafia?

This, in addition to the things already mentioned by other people, looks like an unconvincing attempt to evade the discussion. Seriously, what's not to understand about AD's question?

Hey, listen, THAT WAS NOT ME ATTEMPTING TO EVADE THE QUESTION.
I wasn't sure if he was asking me for MY OPINION or if he was asking me who was in the lead to be lynched (which is the group's opinion on who is mafia) Just a little bit of confusion there. SORRY.

[cmckinney]

oh, and by the way, i have a feeling that koesen may be mafia.

1. He kind of submarined for a little bit.

2. He made a vote for me merely because I asked AD to restate his question so I would get the right idea.

3. He just jumped on the bandwagon, just like lots of u guys.

[cmckinney]

does that answer your question AD?